Protein Shake
intro
A thick, creamy, macro-balanced protein shake ideal for post-workout recovery or fast on-the-go fuel, with no refined sugar and 30g of protein per serving.
Ingredients
Steps
Gather and prep ingredients
First, set out all pre-measured ingredients: confirm your frozen banana slices are fully solid (frozen for at least 4 hours prior), and arrange 60g vanilla whey protein, 150g non-fat Greek yogurt, 360ml unsweetened almond milk, 32g no-added-sugar peanut butter, 15g chia seeds, 1/4 tsp ground cinnamon, and 120g ice cubes within reach. Ensure your countertop blender is plugged in and its carafe is clean and completely dry.
Add liquid base first
Pour the full 360ml of cold, refrigerated unsweetened almond milk into the bottom of the blender carafe first. Adding liquid before any thick or dry ingredients prevents protein powder and dense add-ins from getting trapped under the blender blades, which causes lumpy, unevenly blended shakes. Do not add thick or frozen ingredients before the liquid.
Layer soft, dry ingredients
Next, add the 150g non-fat plain Greek yogurt, 32g no-added-sugar peanut butter, 15g chia seeds, and 1/4 tsp ground cinnamon on top of the almond milk. Scoop the full 60g of vanilla whey protein powder directly into the center of the liquid pool to avoid powder sticking to the dry upper sides of the carafe, which causes unblended dry clumps.
Top with frozen ingredients
Place all 118g of frozen pre-sliced banana and 120g of large ice cubes on the very top of the ingredient stack. The weight of the frozen ingredients will gently push softer ingredients down toward the spinning blades as the blender runs, creating a smoother, more even texture without requiring long over-blending.
Blend in staged intervals
Secure the blender lid tightly, holding it down with a folded cotton kitchen towel to prevent cold shake splatters. Run the blender on low speed for 10 seconds to initially break up ice and banana chunks, then increase to medium-high speed for 30 seconds. Stop the blender, scrape down the sides of the carafe with a rubber spatula to dislodge any stuck protein powder, then blend for another 20 seconds on high speed until completely smooth, with no visible lumps or ice chunks.
Check consistency and serve
Remove the blender lid, and dip a metal spoon into the shake to check thickness: it should coat the back of the spoon evenly without running off too quickly. If too thick, stir in 30ml extra cold almond milk and blend for 5 seconds; if too thin, add 1 extra large ice cube and blend for 5 seconds. Pour immediately into two tall 16-oz glasses, and serve cold, as the shake will thicken and separate if left to sit for more than 10 minutes.
Tips
2.Avoid over-blending for more than 1 minute total, as excessive blending breaks down whey protein and chia seeds, leading to a thin, watery texture instead of the desired thick, creamy consistency.
3.For a vegan version, swap whey protein for vanilla pea protein, replace Greek yogurt with unsweetened coconut yogurt, and use oat milk for an equally creamy, plant-based result.

OMG this shake is a total game changer for my post-workout routine! I was so sick of chalky vanilla protein drinks that taste like artificial sweetener, but this is SO creamy, even my 8 year old asked for a sip when I made it this morning. Threw in a handful of frozen strawberries on a whim and *chef’s kiss*. 10/10 will be making this weekly for meal prep!
Solid recipe, super easy to whip up in 5 minutes flat before I head to the gym. Only note is that my first batch was a little thinner than I like – anyone else have that issue? I used regular unsweetened almond milk like the recipe said.
I add a shot of cold brew to this every morning and it’s replaced my fancy $7 coffee shop vanilla latte. Saves me so much money and keeps me full until lunch! No mid-morning slump at all. Obsessed.
Bro, this is way better than the fast food vanilla shakes I used to chug after late night study sessions. Way more protein, less sugar, and it takes literally no time to make in my dorm blender. 10/10 no notes.
Made this for my kids before soccer practice yesterday and they went crazy for it! They kept asking for refills, which never happens with the “healthy” stuff I make. Win for dad.
Is there a way to make this vegan? I don’t do dairy, so I swapped the Greek yogurt for coconut yogurt but it had a weird coconut aftertaste that overpowered the vanilla. Would love tips!
I was a little skeptical how “creamy” a protein shake could be without a ton of heavy cream, but wow, the combination of vanilla extract and a tiny bit of cinnamon (I added that on a whim) makes this taste like a vanilla cupcake in a glass. So good.
Made these for my daughter’s soccer team potluck this weekend, served them in little disposable cups with straws, and every single kid asked for seconds. Even the other parents were asking for the recipe! Total home run.
Wait, can I prep these ahead for the week? I usually make my shakes fresh every morning but I’m swamped with work this month and would love to batch make them on Sundays.
My husband and I have been making this every Saturday after our morning walk and it’s become our new little weekend ritual. We top ours with a tiny bit of whipped cream and sprinkles for fun, feels like a treat without the guilt.
I’ve been looking for a high protein snack that’s easy on my sensitive stomach and this fits the bill perfectly! No weird aftertaste, no bloating, and it’s sweet enough that I don’t feel like I’m drinking something “healthy”. Will be making this often.
Tried this after my 6am CrossFit class today and it hit so different. 32g of protein when I use my regular protein powder, kept me full all the way through my work meetings until lunch. No random sugar crash either. 10/10.
Pro tip: add a tablespoon of sugar-free vanilla pudding mix to this, it tastes EXACTLY like a vanilla milkshake from the old diner down the street. I know it sounds wild but trust me, game changer.
As a remote worker who forgets to eat lunch half the time, this is a lifesaver. I keep all the ingredients portioned out in freezer bags so I can just dump everything in the blender in 2 minutes and get back to my desk. No cooking, no cleanup, perfect.
I was worried this would be too bland because I don’t love super plain vanilla flavors, but it’s perfectly sweet! I added a tiny pinch of sea salt on top like I do with my regular milkshakes and it makes the vanilla flavor pop so much more. So easy too.