Pumpkin Pie Cake
intro
A cozy layered hybrid of silky spiced pumpkin pie and buttery golden cake, topped with crisp cinnamon streusel—ideal for autumn holiday tables and casual gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Preheat and Prep Pan
Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C). Grease the 9x9 inch matte light gray ceramic baking dish lightly with softened butter, making sure to coat the bottom and 1/2 inch up the sides to prevent sticking. Set the prepared dish in the center of the counter work area.
Mix Cake Base
Measure out 1 cup of the dry yellow cake mix, setting the remaining mix aside for the streusel topping. In the small stainless steel mixing bowl, combine the 1 cup cake mix, 1/2 cup melted unsalted butter, and 1 large egg. Stir with the matte black handled silicone spatula until a thick, smooth, evenly moist dough forms, with no pockets of dry cake mix remaining.
Press Base Evenly
Transfer the mixed cake dough to the prepared greased baking dish. Use clean fingers or the flat bottom of a stainless steel measuring cup to press the dough into an even, flat layer across the entire bottom of the dish, ensuring no thin spots or gaps. The finished base layer should be roughly 1/4 inch thick across the entire pan.
Mix Pumpkin Filling
In the medium stainless steel mixing bowl, combine the full 15oz can of pumpkin puree, 2 remaining large eggs, 12oz evaporated milk, 1/2 cup granulated sugar, 2 tsp ground cinnamon, 1/2 tsp ground ginger, 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg, 1/8 tsp ground cloves, 1 tsp vanilla extract, and 1/4 tsp fine sea salt. Whisk with the stainless steel wire whisk for 1 minute until completely smooth, with no streaks of egg or unblended spice clumps remaining.
Pour Filling Over Base
Slowly pour the entire bowl of smooth pumpkin filling directly over the pressed cake base in the baking dish. Pour gently to avoid disturbing or breaking through the soft cake layer; the filling will spread evenly across the base on its own to form a uniform 1-inch thick custard layer.
Make Streusel Topping
Place the remaining reserved dry yellow cake mix (approximately 2 1/2 cups) into the now-empty, wiped-clean small stainless steel mixing bowl. Add 1/4 cup cold, cubed unsalted butter, and cut the butter into the dry mix using the metal dough blender, working until the mixture forms coarse, pea-sized crumbs with no large butter chunks remaining.
Top and Bake Cake
Sprinkle the streusel crumbs evenly over the entire surface of the pumpkin filling, covering it completely with no large bare patches. Place the baking dish on the middle rack of the preheated 350°F oven, and bake for 50-55 minutes, until the streusel is deep golden brown and the center of the cake jiggles only slightly when the pan is nudged (a toothpick inserted 1 inch from the edge should come out clean, with no wet filling attached).
Cool Cake Completely
Once baked, carefully remove the dish from the oven using oven mitts, and set it on the matte black wire cooling rack placed on the counter. Let the cake cool fully at room temperature for 1 full hour before slicing, to allow the pumpkin custard layer to set completely; slicing warm will cause layers to slide and result in runny slices.
Tips
2.Use very cold butter for the streusel topping: cold butter melts slowly during baking, creating crisp, distinct crumbs instead of a soggy, dense top layer that sinks into the pumpkin custard.
3.Allow the full 1-hour cooling time before slicing: the pumpkin custard layer continues to set as it cools, and cutting warm cake will cause layers to slide apart and result in runny, messy slices.

Y’all, I made this last night for my kid’s fall soccer team potluck and it was GONE in 10 minutes. I was worried it would be too fussy since I’m not a big baker, but it was so easy! The texture is like if pumpkin pie and fluffy spice cake had a perfect baby. 10/10 will make every week from now until Christmas.
This was SO good! My whole family loved it at Sunday dinner, I only knocked off a star because my cake came out a little soggier than I expected in the middle. Did I do something wrong? I followed the bake time exactly at 55 mins but my oven runs a little hot, weirdly enough.
Game changer for meal prep! I baked this Sunday night, cut it into squares, and have been having a piece with my coffee every morning this week. Way better than the overpriced pumpkin loaf at the coffee shop by my apartment. Will be making this on repeat all fall.
I’ve literally never baked anything from scratch before in my life and this turned out perfect!!! I was so nervous I’d mess it up but the steps were so straightforward, and my roommate said it’s the best pumpkin dessert she’s ever had. OMG I’m so proud of myself lmao
Test ran this for our family Thanksgiving this year and wow, it’s dethroned my grandma’s classic pumpkin pie as the new favorite. Don’t tell her I said that though 😂 The crumb topping with the cinnamon and nutmeg is absolutely insane, and the cake layer is so light but still has that rich pumpkin flavor. No notes!
The flavor is incredible, but I tried making this with a 1:1 gluten free flour blend and it came out really dense. Did anyone else try this gluten free? I want to love it so bad because the smell while it was baking had my whole house smelling like fall.
Really yummy! I added an extra teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice because I love that warm, spicy flavor, and swapped half the oil for applesauce to make it a little lighter. It turned out so moist, my husband ate three slices as soon as it cooled down enough to eat. Will make again for sure.
I threw this together in 15 minutes before work yesterday for our office fall party, and I can’t believe how well it turned out! My 7 year old helped me dump the ingredients in the bowl and even he could follow most of the steps. My boss asked for the recipe before I even left the party, that’s how you know it’s good.
Full transparency: I hate pumpkin pie. Like, hate it. I only made this because my partner begged me for something pumpkin for his birthday, and I was fully prepared to not eat a single bite. Y’all…I ate half the pan. It’s not cloyingly sweet like regular pumpkin pie, the cake texture is so much better, and the crumb top is chef’s kiss. I’m a convert.
If you’re on the fence about making this, do it! It freezes so well — I wrapped individual slices in plastic wrap and tossed them in the freezer, and they thaw perfectly in 30 seconds in the microwave. Perfect for quick fall treats when you don’t have time to bake.
Flavor is 10/10, but my crumb topping melted into the cake instead of staying crumbly! Any idea what I did wrong? I used cold butter like I do for all my crumb toppings, so I’m confused. Even with that, it was still delicious, my book club gobbled it up.
Brought this to our Ohio State tailgate last weekend and it was the most popular dish at the whole tailgate, even beating out the chili! Everyone kept saying it tastes like fall in a pan, and I loved that I didn’t have to mess with a finicky pie crust. 5 stars, will be a tailgate staple from now on.
I found this recipe 2 hours before friends were coming over for dinner and thought there’s no way it turns out, since most cake recipes take forever. It was done in 55 minutes exactly, smelled incredible, and my friends thought I spent hours on it. Total lifesaver for lazy hosts like me!
This recipe is perfect as is, but I added a quick cream cheese swirl (8 oz cream cheese, 1/4 cup sugar, 1 egg) dolloped on top before baking and it took it to a whole other level. Tastes like pumpkin cheesecake met pumpkin pie cake, I’m obsessed. My kids asked for seconds before they even finished their first slice!
This was really tasty! I cut the sugar by 1/3 cup because I don’t like super sweet desserts, and it was perfect for my taste. My in-laws loved it when we had them over for dinner, even my father-in-law who swears he doesn’t like pumpkin anything ate two slices. Great recipe, just adjust sugar to your preference!
It’s finally 60 degrees here in Colorado so I baked this today to celebrate, and my whole house smells like cinnamon and pumpkin. It’s so warm and cozy, perfect with a mug of apple cider after a hike. This is going to be on repeat every weekend until spring, no exceptions.
I take a dessert to our church potluck every single Sunday, and this is the first recipe in months where people came back for thirds. The ladies in my choir all begged for the recipe, and one of them even said it’s better than the pumpkin cake she’s been making for 40 years. That’s the highest compliment you can get, honestly.
Full transparency: I accidentally used a 9 inch round cake pan instead of a 9x13 and it still turned out perfect! It baked a little taller, took an extra 10 minutes in the oven, but the texture was still so moist and flavorful. Even my mistake didn’t ruin this, which is how you know it’s a foolproof easy recipe.
Made this in my tiny dorm oven (yes, it only fits a 9x9 pan so I adjusted the bake time a little) and my whole floor smelled like it for hours. All my neighbors knocked asking for a piece, and I’m now the most popular guy on my floor. Worth every penny of the $10 I spent on ingredients lmao