Pumpkin Pie Milkshake
intro
Creamy, spice-kissed frozen treat that blends nostalgic pumpkin pie flavor with rich vanilla ice cream, perfect for cool fall days and holiday gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Crumb Rims
Measure 1 tablespoon of maple syrup from the total amount, and use a clean finger to spread it in a thin, even layer across the outer 1cm edge of each tall clear milkshake tumbler rim. Pour the finely crushed graham cracker crumbs across the surface of the small matte cream ceramic plate. Hold each glass at a 45-degree angle, and twist the rim gently through the crumbs until the syrup-coated edge is fully covered in an even, textured crumb layer. Place the rimmed glasses in the freezer to chill for 5 minutes to set the crumbs and keep the milkshake cold longer.
Load Blender Jar
Remove the clear blender jar from its silver base, and use the metal spring-loaded ice cream scoop to add all 2 cups of slightly softened vanilla ice cream to the jar. Use the clear glass measuring cup to pour in the chilled 1/2 cup unsweetened pumpkin puree, remaining 2 tablespoons of maple syrup, and 1/3 cup cold whole milk. Use the 1 tsp measuring spoon to add pumpkin pie spice, and the 1/8 tsp spoon to add flaky sea salt. Do not overfill the jar; ingredients should sit no higher than the 1.5L mark to avoid overflow when blending.
Blend Until Smooth
Secure the matte black lid tightly on the blender jar, return the jar to the brushed silver blender base, and blend on medium speed for 20-30 seconds. Pause once halfway through blending to scrape down the sides of the jar with the burnt orange silicone spatula to ensure no clumps of pumpkin or ice cream get stuck above the blade line. The finished mixture should be thick, smooth, and uniform pale orange, with no visible streaks of spice or lumps of ice cream, and should coat the back of a spoon thickly when lifted. Stop blending immediately once smooth—over-blending will melt the ice cream too much and result in a runny, watery shake.
Pour Into Chilled Glasses
Remove the prepped crumb-rimmed glasses from the freezer and set them on the central counter. Remove the blender lid, and pour the thick milkshake mixture evenly between the two glasses, filling each to 2cm below the rim to leave space for toppings. If the mixture is too thick to pour easily, use the silicone spatula to gently guide it out of the jar, taking care not to smudge the graham cracker rims. The milkshake should pour slowly in a thick stream; if it runs thinly, add one extra small scoop of ice cream and blend for 5 seconds to thicken.
Add Whipped Cream Topping
Shake the can of chilled whipped cream vigorously for 10 seconds, then dispense a generous 5cm tall swirled mound on top of each milkshake, starting at the outer edge of the glass and working inward to create a soft, rounded peak. The cream should sit just above the rim of the glass without spilling over the sides.
Finish With Garnishes
Pinch a small amount of extra pumpkin pie spice between your fingers and dust a light, even layer over the whipped cream tops. Tuck a small 2cm piece of graham cracker into the side of each whipped cream mound, then slide a long matte stainless steel milkshake straw into the center of each shake, angled slightly outward for easy sipping. Serve immediately before the ice cream softens and melts.
Tips
2.Always chill rimmed glasses in the freezer for a minimum of 5 minutes: Warm room-temperature glasses will cause the cold milkshake to melt rapidly on contact, turning your treat soupy before you can add toppings. The cold glass also helps the maple syrup and graham cracker rim set firmly, so crumbs don’t fall off onto your hands as you drink.
3.Use unsweetened canned pumpkin puree, not pre-made pumpkin pie filling: Pie filling is pre-sweetened and pre-spiced, which often leads to an overly sweet, unbalanced shake with muted spice flavor. Unsweetened puree lets you adjust sweetness with maple syrup and tweak spice levels to match your taste.

OMG this is SO good! I whipped this up last night for our family movie night and everyone went back for seconds. Tastes exactly like pumpkin pie but cold and creamy, total game changer for fall. I added a little extra whipped cream on top with cinnamon sprinkles, chef’s kiss.
My kids loved it! I was looking for a quick after-school snack that wasn’t just chips or cookies, and this took literally 5 minutes to throw together. No cooking required? Sign me up. The only swap I made was using oat milk instead of regular because that’s what we had in the fridge.
I make protein shakes every morning for meal prep and decided to tweak this to add a scoop of vanilla protein powder. Tastes like a fall dessert without all the guilt, which is exactly what I was looking for! Only knocked a star off because it came out a little thinner than I like, but I’ll add extra ice next time to fix that. Will be making this at least twice a week through November.
Brought a big batch of this to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! I served it in small mason jars with a tiny pie crust crumble on top and it looked so cute. Everyone thought I spent hours on it, lmao.
Wait, cook time is 0 minutes? That’s wild to me, I thought anything pumpkin flavored required baking for an hour. This is perfect for those random fall pregnancy cravings when I need something pumpkin STAT. Only thing is, would it work with canned pumpkin that’s already been spiced?
Tried this last night and it was good, but I felt like it was a little too sweet for my taste. Next time I’ll cut back on the maple syrup a little. Otherwise, the texture is perfect and the pumpkin flavor is spot on.
Made this after a long fall hike last weekend and it hit the spot. I added a handful of frozen banana to make it extra thick, and it was so refreshing after being out in the still-warm Arizona fall weather. Will be making this post-hike all season.
My granddaughter is obsessed with all things pumpkin, so I made this for her when she visited last Sunday. She said it was better than the actual pumpkin pie I make for Thanksgiving! Can’t wait to make it again when the whole family is here for the holiday.
Dude this is so easy to make in my tiny dorm blender! No fancy equipment, no cooking, I don’t even have to turn on my oven (which is good because my dorm smoke alarm goes off if I look at it wrong). My roommate and I have made it three nights in a row now.
I made this for our fall book club meeting and everyone raved! I topped each glass with a tiny piece of pie crust stick and a dash of nutmeg, and it felt so fancy for how little effort it took. 10/10, will be making on repeat.
I was skeptical about pumpkin in a milkshake but wow, this converted me. It’s creamy, perfectly spiced, not overpowering at all. I added a dash of caramel syrup on top and it was chef’s kiss. Don’t knock it till you try it!
This looks so amazing, I can already tell it’s going to be a hit! Quick question — can I make this ahead of time and store it in the freezer for a couple days? I want to prep it for my kid’s Halloween party but I don’t want to be blending milkshakes while 10 eight-year-olds run around my house.
I’m not a huge pumpkin pie fan but my husband is, so I made this for him as a little weekend treat. Even I loved it! The spice level is perfect, not too heavy, it just tastes like fall in a cup. We had it with grilled cheese and tomato soup for our cozy Saturday dinner, random combo but it worked.
Used vegan vanilla ice cream and coconut whipped cream to make this dairy free, and it turned out incredible. My vegan roommate couldn’t believe how close it tasted to the regular pumpkin milkshakes we get at the local diner. Great base recipe that’s super easy to customize.
It’s still 85 degrees here in Florida in October, so I’m not ready to turn on the oven for pumpkin pie yet. This is the perfect workaround! Cold, creamy, pumpkin-y, no hot kitchen required. I drank mine while sitting on the porch watching the sunset, 10/10 vibe.
I added a shot of cold brew to mine this morning for a little pumpkin pick-me-up, and it was the best breakfast I’ve had all month. Tastes like a pumpkin spice latte but creamy and thick, so much better than the coffee shop version. Saved me $6 too, lmao.
Took my kid to the pumpkin patch yesterday and came home with a giant sugar pumpkin, so I roasted my own pumpkin puree to use in this. It was so fresh and flavorful, way better than canned in my opinion. Worth the extra little bit of effort if you have fresh pumpkin on hand!
I brought this on our fall camping trip last weekend, pre-blended it and stored it in a stainless steel thermos. It stayed cold for 4 hours! We drank it around the campfire after our hike and it was such a fun treat. Everyone kept asking where I bought it, lmao.