pumpkin pudding mix
intro
This warm, spiced homemade pumpkin pudding mix makes silky, rich pumpkin pudding in minutes, with no artificial fillers—perfect for cozy autumn and Thanksgiving meals.
Ingredients
Steps
Sift Dry Base Ingredients
Set the light acacia wood mixing bowl in the center of the counter. Rest the matte stainless steel fine-mesh sieve across the bowl’s rim. Measure 3/4 cup packed light brown sugar, 1/2 cup cornstarch, and 3/4 cup nonfat dry milk powder into the sieve. Gently tap the sieve’s edge with the polished stainless steel whisk to sift all ingredients into the bowl below, pressing any soft brown sugar lumps through the mesh with the back of the whisk as you work. Stop when only hard, unbreakable lumps remain in the sieve, which can be discarded. The sifted base should be a fine, pale tan powder with no large clumps.
Add Warm Spices
Lift the sieve from the bowl rim and set it in its resting position to the right of the mixing bowl. Measure 2 tablespoons ground cinnamon, 1 teaspoon ground ginger, 1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg, 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves, and 1 teaspoon fine sea salt into the bowl with the sifted dry base. Level each spice measure with the flat edge of the whisk for consistent, balanced flavor, as over-measuring cloves will create a harsh, bitter taste in the finished pudding.
Whisk to Combine
Hold the stainless steel whisk at a slight angle, and stir all ingredients together thoroughly for 45 to 60 seconds, scraping the bottom and inner sides of the bowl regularly to incorporate any hidden pockets of cornstarch or spice. Stop mixing when the powder is a consistent warm golden-tan color, with dark spice flecks evenly distributed throughout and no streaks of white cornstarch or dark spice visible.
Re-sift for Smoothness
Place the fine-mesh sieve back over the mixing bowl. Pour the fully combined spiced mix through the sieve a second time, pressing any soft lumps through the mesh with the back of the whisk. Discard any hard, dry spice or sugar lumps that will not press through the sieve. This second sift eliminates grainy clumps that would cause uneven texture in cooked pudding.
Transfer to Storage Jar
Pick up the clear glass storage jar from its resting position, and hold it at a slight angle next to the mixing bowl. Use the whisk to gently guide the sifted pumpkin pudding mix into the jar, taking care not to spill powder over the counter edge. Halfway through filling, tap the base of the jar firmly on the soapstone counter 2 to 3 times to settle the powder and eliminate air gaps, so the full 2-cup batch fits easily without overflow.
Seal for Pantry Storage
Wipe any stray powder from the outside of the glass jar using a corner of the burnt orange linen towel, then press the bamboo lid firmly into place to create an airtight seal. Stored in a cool, dark pantry, the mix will stay fresh for up to 6 months. To prepare finished pudding, combine the full batch of mix with one 15-oz can of unsweetened pumpkin puree, 2 cups whole milk, 2 large beaten eggs, 2 tablespoons melted unsalted butter, and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract. Cook over medium heat for 8 to 10 minutes, stirring constantly, until the pudding thickens enough to coat the back of a spoon, then chill for 2 hours before serving.
Tips
2.Use packed light brown sugar, not dark brown sugar, for this mix: dark brown sugar has a stronger molasses flavor that will overpower the delicate pumpkin and warm spice notes, while light brown sugar adds a soft caramel note that complements the spices perfectly.
3.If gifting this mix, wait to add preparation notes after photography (to avoid text in images), and be sure to tell recipients not to boil the pudding after combining with wet ingredients: high heat will break down the cornstarch thickener and result in a runny, watery texture.

OMG this homemade spiced pumpkin pudding mix is a total game changer! I made a big batch last Sunday to stash in my pantry for quick fall desserts, and I’ve already used half of it. Whipping up the actual pudding takes literally 10 minutes on the stove, no weird artificial aftertaste like the store-bought stuff. Brought a batch to my office potluck yesterday and everyone was begging for the recipe!
My kids went crazy for this! I’ve been struggling to find easy after-school snacks that don’t have a million unpronounceable ingredients, and this fits the bill. I let the kids help measure the spices for the dry mix on Sunday meal prep day, and they felt so proud when we cooked up a batch after soccer practice on Tuesday. 10/10, will be making this on repeat all pumpkin season.
Was looking for a simple dessert to add to our weekend cookout spread, and this did not disappoint. I’ll admit I was skeptical a no-cook dry mix would turn into good pudding, but 10 minutes on the stovetop and it was perfectly thick, spiced just right. Even my brother-in-law who swears he ‘hates pumpkin anything’ went back for seconds. Only knock is I wish it had a little more cinnamon kick, but that’s an easy fix next time I mix up a batch.
This is going to be my go-to hostess gift this fall! I poured the dry mix into cute mason jars, tied them with little gingham ribbons, and attached a tag with the cooking instructions. So much more thoughtful than a random candle, and everyone who’s gotten one so far has texted me raving about how good the pudding turned out.
As a broke college student with basically zero cooking skills, this is perfect. The dry mix is so cheap to throw together, I don’t need any fancy equipment, and cooking the actual pudding takes way less time than waiting for delivery. I meal prepped four jars of the mix to keep in my dorm closet for late-night study snack attacks.
I’ve been making pumpkin pudding from scratch for 40+ years, and this dry mix version tastes just like the one my own mom used to make. The spice blend is spot on—no overdoing it on the clove like so many modern pumpkin recipes. I made a batch for our Sunday family dinner last week, and my grandkids asked for it again before they even left the table.
I brought the finished pudding to my neighborhood fall block party and it was the first dessert gone! People were hovering over the table waiting for seconds. I topped it with crushed gingersnap cookies and a little whipped cream, chef’s kiss. So easy to make the mix ahead of time so I didn’t have to stress about cooking the day of the party.
Wait, has anyone tried using this mix for pumpkin bread? I was thinking if I added a little flour and oil it might work, but I don’t want to waste a batch if it’s terrible. The pudding itself is amazing, for the record—perfect post-hike cozy snack when the weather gets cold.
I swapped the regular dairy milk for oat milk when cooking the pudding, and used a little extra cornstarch to make up for skipping the milk powder in the mix to keep it vegan, and it turned out perfectly creamy! Such a great base recipe to adjust for different dietary needs. My vegan roomie was obsessed.
Y’all, this is so good. I keep a jar of the mix on my kitchen counter right next to the coffee maker, so I can whip up a quick warm bowl of pudding on cold ranch mornings when I’m done with chores. Beats the sugary cereal I used to grab on busy days by a mile.
Tiny NYC apartment kitchen hack: this dry mix takes up barely any pantry space, which is a premium over here. I don’t have room to store 10 different pre-made dessert mixes, so being able to make this from bulk spices and pantry staples is a total lifesaver. Tastes way better than the fancy gourmet pudding they sell at the market down the street for 8 bucks a cup.
Made this for our weekly Sunday dinner with the extended family, and my 82-year-old dad said it tasted exactly like the pumpkin pudding his mom made when he was a kid. That’s the highest possible praise if you ask me. Super easy to throw together the mix while I was watching football on Saturday, no fuss at all.
So happy this mix is naturally gluten free as long as you use gluten free cornstarch! I’ve been buying overpriced gluten free pumpkin pudding mix online for years, and this tastes better, is cheaper, and I know exactly what’s going into it. Game changer for my fall dessert rotation.
I’m a super new cook, like, I burned toast last week level new, and this was so easy! I was nervous I’d mess up the dry mix, but you just measure the spices and powder and stir them together—zero cooking for the mix, like the recipe says. The finished pudding came out perfectly smooth on my first try, I was so proud of myself.
I made the finished pudding for our fall book club meeting, and we spent 20 minutes just talking about how good it was instead of discussing the book (oops). I added a little extra ginger to my spice blend because I love that warm kick, and it was chef’s kiss. Will absolutely be making this for our Thanksgiving dinner this year.
Made a batch of the pudding last night after a long walk with my pup when it was 50 degrees out, and it was the coziest fall snack ever. I didn’t have any whipped cream, so I topped it with a handful of mini marshmallows and it was perfect. So nice to have the mix on hand for quick little treats like that without running to the store.
I keep a giant jar of this mix in the office kitchen now, so anyone can whip up a quick bowl when that 3pm slump hits. It’s way better than the stale candy bars we used to keep in the snack drawer, and everyone keeps thanking me for bringing it in. Total office win.
I’m the worst at remembering to plan desserts ahead of time, so having this dry mix in my pantry means I never have to panic when friends pop over unannounced. 10 minutes on the stove and I’ve got a fancy-tasting dessert to serve, no grocery run required. I’ve already recommended this to literally everyone I know.
I was in charge of bringing a dessert to my kid’s fall soccer team potluck, and this pudding was a massive hit with all the 8-year-olds. I served it in little plastic cups with a tiny candy pumpkin on top, and the kids went crazy for it. Even the other parents were asking for the recipe. Super easy, zero stress, will be making this for every team event from now on.