pumpkin spice cocktail
intro
Cozy, warmly spiced creamy pumpkin cocktail balanced with smooth bourbon, vanilla, and a cinnamon-sugar rim, perfect for crisp autumn holiday gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Cinnamon Sugar Rim
In the 4-inch clear glass ramekin on the cutting board, mix 2 tablespoons granulated sugar with 1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon until evenly combined, with no streaks of separate spice or sugar. Cut a 1/4-inch thick slice from the end of the navel orange, and run the juicy cut edge around the full outer rim of each rocks glass to moisten it evenly. Dip each moistened rim into the cinnamon-sugar mixture, twisting gently to coat the outer 1/4 inch of the glass in an even, not clumpy, layer. Set coated glasses aside in their fixed position on the counter.
Measure Cocktail Ingredients
Using the double-sided stainless steel jigger for accuracy, measure 8oz bourbon, 4 tablespoons pumpkin puree, 2 tablespoons pure maple syrup, 4oz unsweetened oat milk, and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract directly into the base of the brushed stainless steel cocktail shaker. Add the remaining 3/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon, 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg, and 1/8 teaspoon ground cloves to the shaker, taking care not to spill spice on the counter.
Muddle to Combine Flavors
Insert the maple-handled muddler into the cocktail shaker, and press gently 4-5 times to mix the thick pumpkin puree evenly with the liquid ingredients and break up any dry clumps of spice. Do not over-muddle or churn aggressively, as this will create unwanted foam. Stop when the mixture is a uniform pale orange with no visible lumps of pumpkin or undissolved spice visible on the surface.
Shake Cocktail Vigorously
Add 2 cups of crushed ice to the cocktail shaker, press the shaker lid on tightly to create a watertight seal, and shake vigorously up and down for 15-20 seconds. Stop when the entire outside surface of the metal shaker feels frosty and uncomfortably cold to the touch, which indicates the drink is perfectly chilled and diluted.
Strain Into Glasses
Rest the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer over the opening of the shaker. Fill each cinnamon-sugar rimmed rocks glass with 1/2 cup fresh crushed ice, mounding it slightly above the glass rim. Pour the shaken cocktail mixture through the strainer into each glass, dividing the liquid evenly between the four 10oz servings. The strainer will catch any small fibrous pumpkin clumps or undissolved spice for a smooth texture.
Add Final Garnishes
Use the citrus zester to scrape a thin strip of orange peel (avoiding the bitter white pith) for each drink, hold the peel 2 inches above the drink surface, and squeeze gently to release citrus oils over the cocktail. Curl each peel strip and rest one on the rim of each glass, tuck one whole cinnamon stick into the ice of each glass as a stirrer, then grate a light, even dusting of whole nutmeg over the top of each drink before serving immediately.
Tips
2.Shake for the full 15-20 seconds until the shaker is frosty: this creates ideal dilution (roughly 20% water from melted ice) to soften bourbon’s alcoholic heat and let warm pumpkin and spice flavors come forward, rather than tasting harsh and unbalanced.
3.Always pour through the fine-mesh strainer: canned pumpkin has small stringy fibrous bits that will create an unpleasant gritty mouthfeel if left in the drink, and the strainer ensures every sip is silky and smooth.

I was skeptical about creamy cocktails usually being too cloying, but this is perfect! The pumpkin spice isn’t overpowering, the bourbon shines through, and that little creamy kick? *Chef’s kiss.* Brought a batch to my office fall potluck last week and everyone was hounding me for the recipe, even made it again for my wife’s fall birthday dinner and she said it’s better than the fancy cocktail bar version downtown.
OMG SO good!!! I swapped the regular heavy cream for oat milk creamer because I’m dairy free and it still turned out insanely delicious. Will be making this every weekend from now until Thanksgiving tbh.
Solid cocktail! I added an extra half shot of bourbon because I like mine a little stronger, and it went over great at our Sunday football watch party. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish it had a little more cinnamon punch for my taste, but easy to fix with an extra sprinkle on top.
First cocktail I’ve ever made from scratch and it was so easy! No fancy tools needed, just shook everything up in a mason jar like the recipe said and it came out perfect. My roommates were obsessed.
Made these for my girls’ night in last night and we all agreed this tastes like fall in a glass! I garnished each with a little cinnamon stick and a dollop of whipped cream, it looked so fancy for how little effort it took. 10/10 will make again.
Perfect post-hike fall treat! Came home from a chilly morning hike in Rocky Mountain National Park, whipped this up in 5 minutes, and sat on the porch watching the leaves change. Absolute vibe. The bourbon gives the perfect warm kick that hits just right when it’s 40 degrees outside.
Taste was great, but mine came out a little thinner than I expected? I followed the measurements exactly, not sure if I shook it long enough or what. Still drinkable, just not as creamy as the photos look.
Added this to my Thanksgiving dinner menu immediately after testing it last weekend! My husband who swears he ‘hates pumpkin everything’ drank two glasses and asked when I’d make it again. Total win. I’m even going to make a non-alcoholic version for the kids and my sober sister by swapping the bourbon for extra cream and a splash of vanilla.
Just made this to test before my fall house party next month and WOW. I’m not even a big bourbon drinker but this is so smooth, the pumpkin and warm spices make it feel so cozy. I might have already had a second glass while writing this oops. 100% making a giant punch bowl of this for the party.
Great cocktail for our fall bonfire last weekend! Only note is I’d recommend skipping the nutmeg garnish if you’re not a super strong spice fan, it was a little much for a couple of my friends. We added a caramel rim to half the glasses and that was a huge hit.
Even in 75 degree SoCal fall weather this hits! I thought a creamy cocktail would be too heavy for our warm Octobers but it’s light enough that it doesn’t feel weird when it’s still sunny out. So excited to bring this to my neighborhood block party next weekend.
Game changer! I make a batch of this every Sunday to have a little after-dinner treat throughout the week, it stores great in a mason jar in the fridge for up to 3 days. Saves me from having to mix a drink every night after the kids go to bed, total mom win.