Reindeer Cookies
intro
Adorable chewy peanut butter reindeer cookies with pretzel antlers, candy eyes, and bright red noses, perfect for festive Christmas baking with kids and holiday cookie swaps.
Ingredients
Steps
Cream Butter and Sugars
Place the softened 1/2 cup unsalted butter, 3/4 cup packed brown sugar, and 1/4 cup granulated sugar into the large matte beige mixing bowl. Using the matte white electric hand mixer on medium speed, beat the mixture for 2 full minutes until it is light, fluffy, and pale caramel in color, stopping to scrape down the sides of the bowl with the pale red silicone spatula halfway through. The mixture should hold soft peaks when the mixer is lifted.
Mix in Wet Ingredients
Add the 1 cup creamy peanut butter, room temperature large egg, and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract to the creamed butter and sugar in the mixing bowl. Beat on low speed for 30 seconds until fully combined, scraping down the bowl sides once with the spatula. Do not overmix, as this will make baked cookies tough.
Fold in Dry Ingredients
Whisk together the 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour, 1/2 teaspoon baking soda, and 1/4 teaspoon salt in a measuring cup to combine. Gradually add the dry mixture to the wet dough in the mixing bowl, folding with the red silicone spatula just until no streaks of flour remain. Stop mixing as soon as the last flour streak disappears to avoid tough cookies; the finished dough will be thick and slightly sticky.
Portion and Bake Dough
Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C) while you finish mixing the dough. Line the light gray non-stick baking sheet with the cut unbleached parchment paper. Use the spring-loaded stainless steel cookie scoop to portion 24 equal 3cm dough balls, spacing them 5cm apart on the parchment (bake in two batches of 12 to avoid cookies spreading into each other). Bake each batch for 9-10 minutes, until edges are just light golden; centers will look slightly puffed and under-set, which yields soft, chewy cookies.
Cool Baked Cookies
As soon as you remove each baking sheet from the oven, use the small offset metal spatula to transfer the warm cookies to the matte black wire cooling rack. Let cookies cool for exactly 5 minutes on the rack: they need to be soft and slightly warm when you add decorations so toppings stick, but firm enough not to break when moved. Do not cool completely before decorating, or toppings will not adhere.
Prep Decorating Supplies
While cookies cool, break mini pretzel twists in half down the natural center seam to make antler shapes (each whole pretzel makes two antlers, for a total of 48 antlers, with extra pieces set aside for any breaks). Melt the 1/4 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips in the small clear glass bowl, heating in 15-second microwave bursts and stirring between bursts until completely smooth. Place the broken pretzel antlers, candy eyes, and red candy noses into the three separate terracotta ramekins for easy access.
Decorate Reindeer Faces
Working with one warm cookie at a time: dab two small dots of melted chocolate 2cm from the top edge of the cookie for antler placement, then press two pretzel half-antlers into the dots, angled slightly outward. Dab two smaller dots of chocolate 1cm below the antlers, then press two candy eyes into place. Dab one final dot of chocolate centered below the eyes, then press one red candy into place for the nose. Set decorated cookies back on the cooling rack for 5 minutes to let the chocolate set completely.
Plate Finished Cookies
Once the chocolate glue is fully set and hard to the touch, transfer all decorated reindeer cookies to the large round matte cream ceramic serving platter, arranging them in a loose, casual cluster. Serve immediately, or store in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days.
Tips
2.Add decorations while cookies are slightly warm (5 minutes out of the oven): The residual heat helps the chocolate glue set faster and keeps pretzel antlers from sliding off once cooled.
3.For nut-free batches, swap peanut butter for equal parts sunflower seed butter, and add 1 extra tablespoon of all-purpose flour to balance the softer consistency of seed butter and prevent excess spreading.

OMG these chewy reindeer cookies are a total game changer! I made them for my kid’s class holiday party and every single kid asked for seconds. The pretzel antlers and red M&M noses are so cute, and I couldn’t believe how quick they came together — 20 minutes cook time is chef’s kiss for a busy weeknight.
SO good. I’m not much of a baker and these still turned out perfect on the first try. Chewy in the middle, slightly crisp on the edges, exactly what I wanted for our office potluck. The reindeer faces were a huge conversation starter, even the grumpy guys in accounting loved them.
Wait has anyone tried making these gluten free? My nephew has celiac and I want to make a batch he can eat for our family Christmas dinner, but I don’t want to mess up that perfect chewy texture.
My kids lost their minds when they saw these after school yesterday. I let them help add the candy eyes and noses, which kept them occupied for a whole 20 minutes while the cookies baked — win win. Only thing is my first batch spread a little more than I expected, any tips?
Made these for my roommate’s ugly sweater party and they were gone in 10 minutes. People kept asking if I bought them from a fancy bakery! So easy even a college student with a tiny dorm oven can pull them off, no fancy equipment needed.
I’ve been making Christmas cookies for 60+ years and this recipe is going straight into my annual rotation. The chewy texture is perfect, not too sweet, and the little reindeer faces make my great-grandkids giggle every time. I added a tiny pinch of cinnamon to the dough for a little extra warmth and it was chef’s kiss.
Brought these to our neighborhood holiday potluck last weekend and I got so many recipe requests! Way easier than the fancy cutout sugar cookies I usually make, and the chewy texture holds up way better on a potluck table for a few hours. 10/10, will be making these every year from now on.
Quick question — can I make the dough ahead of time and freeze it for later? I do meal prep for all my holiday baking so I don’t get swamped the week of Christmas, and these are top of my list to make.
My kids loved it! I was worried the reindeer faces would be too fussy to pull off with three little kids under 5 running around, but it was so easy. Even my 3 year old could help place the red noses without making a total mess. The cookies stay chewy for days in an airtight container, which is a huge plus for us.
Wait, do these have a strong molasses taste? I love chewy gingerbread type cookies but my partner hates anything that tastes too much like molasses, so I’m trying to find a middle ground for our annual cookie plate for the neighbors.
Game changer for last minute holiday plans! I forgot I was supposed to bring cookies to my friend’s Christmas party tonight, threw these together in literally no time, and they look like I spent hours on them. The chewy center is insane, way better than any store bought cookie dough I’ve ever used.
First time baking cookies from scratch and these came out perfect! I was so nervous I’d mess them up but the instructions are super straightforward, easy difficulty is no lie. The chewy texture is exactly what I was hoping for, I’m already planning to make another batch for my family when they come into town for Christmas.