Reverse Sear
intro
The reverse sear method delivers evenly cooked, juicy thick-cut steak with a shatteringly crisp caramelized crust, more consistent than traditional high-heat searing.
Ingredients
Steps
Season the steaks
Pat all 4 ribeye steaks completely dry with paper towels. Evenly coat all sides (including thick edges) with 1.5 tablespoons kosher salt, 1 tablespoon cracked black pepper, and 1 teaspoon garlic powder, pressing seasoning gently to adhere. Let steaks rest at room temperature for 30 minutes before cooking to promote even doneness.
Set up two-zone grill
Preheat a charcoal or gas grill to 120°C (250°F) for two-zone indirect cooking: bank fully lit, ashed-over charcoal to one side of the grill bed, or ignite only half the burners on a gas grill, leaving the opposite side unlit. Clip a grill thermometer to the cool zone grate to maintain consistent temperature during slow cooking, preheating the grill while the steaks rest to save time.
Slow-cook the steaks
Place seasoned steaks on the unheated, indirect cool side of the grill, positioned at least 5cm away from the direct heat source. Close the grill lid and cook for 30–38 minutes, flipping steaks once at the 18-minute mark, until the internal temperature at the thickest part of the steak reaches 52°C (125°F) for medium-rare doneness; cook 3°C longer for medium, 3°C less for rare.
Sear for crisp crust
Move the temperature-stabilized steaks directly over the high-heat zone of the grill, where grate temperature reaches 260°C (500°F). Drizzle 2 tablespoons canola oil across the hot grate first to prevent sticking. Sear each flat side for 1.5–2 minutes, then hold steaks vertically with tongs to sear all thick edges for 30 seconds per edge, until a deep mahogany caramelized crust forms.
Baste with herb butter
Move seared steaks back to the cool grill zone to avoid burning the low-smoke-point butter. Top each steak with 1 tablespoon (14g) unsalted butter, 1 crushed garlic clove, and 1 fresh rosemary sprig. Once butter melts, repeatedly spoon the fragrant, garlic-rosemary butter over the steaks for 1 full minute to coat every surface.
Rest before serving
Transfer basted steaks to a clean wooden cutting board, tent loosely with a sheet of aluminum foil (do not wrap tightly, as this will steam the crust), and let rest for 10 full minutes to allow muscle fibers to relax and redistribute juices. Slice against the grain into 1.25cm thick slices to serve.
Tips
2.Use a calibrated instant-read or leave-in meat thermometer to check doneness instead of relying solely on cook time; steak thickness, outdoor temperature, and wind can all alter cooking speed.
3.Never wrap steaks tightly in foil during the rest period; loose tenting prevents steaming that will soften the crisp seared crust, while still keeping steaks warm enough to serve.

OMG, this reverse sear method is a total game changer! I’ve been overcooking ribeyes on direct heat for years, always ending up with that charred outside and raw middle or well done gray mess. Made these for our Sunday family dinner last night and my wife and kids actually cheered when they cut into them. Perfect medium rare all the way through, that crust was insane. 10/10 will be my go-to steak method from now on!
Made this for my husband’s birthday cookout and he said it was better than the $60 steak we got at the fancy steakhouse downtown for our anniversary! Only thing is I didn’t have a grill with two zones, so I used my oven for the low temp part then seared on my cast iron on the patio, worked like a charm. SO good.
First time I’ve ever made a steak that didn’t turn out tough or chewy! Followed the timing exactly even though I was convinced 45 minutes on low heat would dry it out, nope, it was juicy as anything. Roommate ate half my steak lmao, will be making a double batch next time for meal prep.
Took this recipe for a test run before our big neighborhood potluck next weekend, and wow. The dry rub ratio is spot on, I didn’t even need extra steak sauce! My only note is that my thick-cut ribeyes were almost 2 inches thick, so they took about 10 minutes longer on the indirect heat than the recipe said.
So happy this recipe is just simple seasoning, no weird marinades with hidden gluten! Made these for a date night in with my partner and we both agreed it’s the best steak we’ve ever made at home. Paired it with roasted garlic mashed potatoes and grilled asparagus, chef’s kiss.
I was skeptical about the reverse sear because I’ve always done the hot-and-fast method, but this converted me. The even cook all the way through is unreal, no more weird gray band under the crust. My teen son who’s super picky about steak ate two whole ribeyes, I couldn’t believe it.
Got my first ever charcoal grill last month and have been so nervous to make steaks on it because I kept messing up the heat. This recipe walked me through every single step, even how to set up the two-zone fire! My steaks came out perfectly medium rare, my roommates thought I ordered takeout lmao.
Made a batch of these on Sunday to slice up for weekday salads and wraps, and they held up so well even after 3 days in the fridge! Usually grilled steak gets tough when you reheat it, but because it was cooked so evenly low and slow, it was still tender. Game changer for my work lunches.
Added a little extra smoked paprika to the dry rub like I do for all my grilled meats, and it paired so perfectly with the fatty ribeye. We had these for our Fourth of July small gathering and everyone was asking for the recipe. Even my 72-year-old dad who swears only his steak method works said this was top tier.
Gave this 3 stars because the cook time was way off for me. I followed the directions exactly for 1.5 inch ribeyes, and after 45 minutes on indirect they were already at 135 internal, so when I seared them they ended up medium well instead of medium rare. Bummed because the flavor was great.
Made this last night for our weekly at-home date night, and we paired it with a cabernet sauvignon like the recipe notes suggested, chef’s kiss. The crust you get from that high heat sear after the low cook is literally better than any steakhouse we’ve been to in the city. Worth every minute of cook time!
Made these for my son’s end-of-soccer-season team dinner, and even the kids who say they ‘hate steak’ ate every bite. I was worried cooking for 10 people would be a hassle, but the reverse sear method let me cook all the steaks low and slow first then sear them all quick right when we were ready to eat, no frantic timing. So good!
I make ribeyes at least once a week and I’m kicking myself for not trying reverse sear sooner. I used a little compound garlic butter on top right after searing like I usually do, and it melted perfectly into all the little crevices of the crust. 10/10, this is my new permanent method.
I don’t have a big backyard grill, so I did the reverse sear entirely in my oven and cast iron, just like some other commenters mentioned. It worked flawlessly! I was worried I’d set off my smoke alarm from the high heat sear, but I opened my window and turned the range hood on high, no issues. Perfect date night meal even in a tiny city apartment.
Made these after a long day hike with my partner last weekend, we were ravenous and they hit so hard. The seasoning is simple enough that it doesn’t overpower the actual steak flavor, which I love—so many steak recipes dump way too much seasoning on and you can’t even taste the beef. Will be making these on every camping trip from now on.
Y’all, I have a reputation for burning literally everything I grill. I’ve burned hot dogs, I’ve burned burgers, I even burned grilled corn once. I followed this recipe step by step, set timers, used a meat thermometer, and my steaks came out PERFECT. My husband took one bite and asked if I secretly ordered from the steakhouse down the street. I’m never using another steak recipe again.
Been grilling steaks for over 40 years, and I’ll admit I thought reverse sear was just some fancy internet food trend. My grandson made me try this method when he visited last weekend, and I’ve got to eat my words. The even doneness is unbeatable, and that crust is just as good as the hot sear method I’ve used my whole life. Old dogs can learn new tricks, I guess!
Perfect for my low carb lifestyle! No sugary marinades, no weird additives, just good quality steak and simple seasoning. I paired it with grilled broccoli and a side of chimichurri, and it was so filling I didn’t even crave my usual post-dinner snack. This is going into my regular weekly dinner rotation for sure.
Made this for a first date a couple nights ago, and I fully credit this recipe for getting me a second date lmao. I was panicking the whole time because I’ve never made steak for someone else, but the steps were so easy to follow, the date said it was the best steak they’d ever had. Total win!