Shake Shack SmokeShack
intro
The iconic Shake Shack SmokeShack: juicy smashed beef patty, melted American cheese, crisp applewood bacon, spicy cherry peppers, and tangy Shack sauce on a buttery toasted potato bun.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Tangy Shack Sauce
In the 15cm brushed stainless steel mixing bowl, combine 80g full-fat mayonnaise, 30g ketchup, 5g yellow mustard, 15ml dill pickle brine, 1/4 tsp garlic powder, and 1/4 tsp smoked paprika. Stir vigorously with a small spoon until completely smooth, with no visible streaks of spice or mustard. Transfer sauce to an 8cm clear glass ramekin, and set aside at room temperature for 15 minutes to let flavors meld.
Cook Crispy Bacon
Place the 12-inch matte black carbon steel griddle pan across two stovetop burners over medium heat (175C/350F). Lay all 8 strips of applewood smoked bacon in a single layer across one half of the preheated griddle. Cook for 3-4 minutes per side, flipping with the 12-inch silicone-tipped metal tongs, until bacon is deep golden with crisp, curled edges and all soft white fat has rendered. Transfer cooked bacon to the edge of the cutting board to drain on a small piece of paper towel. While bacon cooks, use the 9-inch walnut-handled chef knife to thinly slice 60g of pickled cherry peppers on the maple cutting board, discarding stems and excess seeds, and place slices in the second 8cm glass ramekin.
Toast Buttered Buns
Use the 1-inch natural bristle pastry brush to coat the cut sides of all 4 potato buns with melted unsalted butter from the clear glass measuring cup. Place buns cut-side down on the empty, bacon-greased half of the griddle. Toast for 1-2 minutes, until cut surfaces are evenly golden brown with slightly crisp edges, and outer crusts remain soft. Transfer toasted buns to a small stack on the cutting board, loosely tented with a small piece of foil to retain warmth.
Sear Smashed Patties
Increase griddle heat to medium-high (220C/425F). Add 2 tsp neutral canola oil to the cleared griddle surface, spreading it in a thin layer with a paper towel held by the tongs. Place all four loosely packed 113g ground beef balls on the oiled surface, spaced 5cm apart to allow for spreading. Immediately press each ball firmly flat with the metal bench scraper to form a 1cm-thick patty with irregular, lacy edges. Season the top of each patty generously with flaky sea salt and freshly ground black pepper. Cook undisturbed for 2 minutes, until patty edges are deep mahogany brown and fat bubbles actively around the perimeter.
Flip and Melt Cheese
Slide the thin flexible stainless steel spatula fully under each patty, scraping to lift all crisp browned edges from the griddle, then flip each patty in one smooth, quick motion. Immediately top each flipped patty with one slice of deli American cheese, centered so it melts evenly over the patty surface. Cook for 1 additional minute, until cheese is fully melted and drapes slightly over the patty edges, and beef reaches an internal temperature of 71C/160F for medium doneness.
Layer Burger Fillings
Spread 1 tablespoon of prepared Shack sauce evenly across the toasted cut side of each bottom bun. Place one cheese-topped beef patty on each sauced bun, followed by two strips of crisp bacon arranged in a crisscross to cover the patty, then 15g of sliced cherry peppers scattered evenly over the bacon. Spread 1 teaspoon of Shack sauce across the toasted cut side of each top bun.
Press and Serve Hot
Place the sauced top bun on each stacked burger, pressing down gently on the crown to compress the layers slightly, so a small amount of sauce and cheese oozes out the sides of the bun. Transfer each finished burger to a matte white ceramic dinner plate, and serve immediately while hot, with crinkle-cut fries if desired.
Tips
2.Wait the full 2 minutes before flipping patties: moving the patties too early will tear the crispy, flavor-packed maillard crust from the griddle, leaving you with pale, bland patties. The crust releases naturally from the griddle once it is fully seared, making flipping easy.
3.Let the Shack sauce rest for 15 minutes at room temperature before using: this short rest allows the garlic powder and smoked paprika to hydrate in the mayonnaise base, mellowing harsh raw spice notes and creating the balanced, tangy signature flavor instead of a flat, mayo-heavy spread.

OMG this is spot on to the actual SmokeShack I get at the Shake Shack downtown! I made these for my Sunday family dinner and everyone went back for seconds, even my super picky 10 year old. The cherry pepper bacon jam is a total game changer, I could eat that stuff straight out of the pan. 10/10 will make every other burger night from now on.
Made these for my kid’s soccer team potluck last weekend and every single parent asked for the recipe! Super easy to throw together even for a crowd, cook time was actually only 15 minutes like the recipe said no extra faff. Only note is I added a tiny extra splash of pickle brine to the sauce because my crew loves extra tang.
SO good. I prepped the sauce and bacon jam ahead for meal prep this week and threw these together after a long hike last night, hit the spot perfectly. Didn’t even miss driving across town to wait in the Shake Shack drive thru line.
Okay I was skeptical a copycat could measure up but wow, this delivered. Cooked the patties smash-style on my cast iron like the recipe said, got that perfect crispy edge, the smoke from the bacon with the cherry peppers? *Chef’s kiss* My only complaint is I wish I made double the patties because my brother-in-law ate three of them. Only giving 4 stars because I slightly burned the first batch of jam because I walked away for 2 minutes, totally my bad though. Definitely a new regular in our rotation.
Made these for date night in with my partner last night and we both agreed they’re better than takeout! We paired them with crinkle cut fries and chocolate shakes, felt like we had our own little Shake Shack on our patio. Will absolutely be making these again for our next cookout.
Quick, easy, tasty. I swapped the regular buns for potato rolls because that’s what I had in my pantry and it worked perfectly. Great weeknight dinner option when you don’t feel like putting a ton of effort in but still want something that tastes indulgent.
Wait, has anyone tried this with a plant-based patty? I’m trying to cut back on red meat but I’ve been craving a SmokeShack for weeks now and this recipe looks too good to pass up. Would the sauce and jam still work with a veggie burger?
Game changer for tailgates! I made a big batch of the bacon jam ahead of time and kept it in a slow cooker on warm, set out all the toppings and let people build their own burgers. People were raving the whole game, even the guy who brings his own fancy gourmet burgers to every tailgate asked for the recipe.
My kids loved it!!! They’ve been begging me to take them to Shake Shack ever since we went on our last beach trip, but the closest one is 45 minutes from our house. I made these for dinner last night and they both said it tasted exactly like what they got on vacation, no 45 minute drive required. Win for mom!
As someone who’s eaten literally dozens of SmokeShacks from the original Manhattan location, I can confirm this copycat is legit. The sauce ratio is perfect, the cherry pepper kick is exactly right, the only thing missing is the crinkle cut fries but that’s on me for not making those too. 10/10 no notes.
Took me 15 minutes total start to finish, no lie. I was running late to my friend’s backyard BBQ and needed something to bring, threw these together and everyone thought I spent an hour prepping. Only thing I messed up was I forgot to toast the buns, I’m sure that would’ve made it even better.
Made this in my tiny dorm kitchen with just a countertop griddle and it came out amazing! Super cheap to make too, split the cost with my roommates and we had enough for 4 big burgers for less than the cost of two SmokeShacks from the location near campus. Will be making this every Sunday for our watch parties.
Perfect quick dinner after a 12 hour shift. I keep pre-portioned burger patties in my freezer so I just thawed one, made the quick sauce, heated up some leftover bacon jam I had from the last time I made this, and had a restaurant quality burger in 10 minutes flat. No elaborate steps, no fancy equipment, exactly what I need on busy weeks.
Solid recipe! I added a little extra smoked paprika to the patty seasoning to give it a little more smoke flavor since I was cooking these on a camp stove on a camping trip, and it worked like a charm. Way better than the boring freeze-dried camp meals I usually bring.
Wait, can I make the bacon jam a couple days ahead? I’m hosting a big backyard BBQ this Saturday and want to get as much prep done earlier in the week as possible so I’m not rushing around day of. This burger is on the menu for sure, just need to plan my prep timeline!
I’m usually a diehard cheeseburger purist, no fancy toppings for me, but my wife convinced me to try this recipe and I’m a convert. The cherry pepper bacon jam adds just the right amount of heat and sweetness without overpowering the burger, I don’t know if I can go back to plain cheeseburgers now.
Added this to my weekly meal prep rotation! I make 4 patties, a batch of the jam, and portion out the sauce on Sunday, then assemble for lunches all week. It holds up way better than I expected, even when I take it to work and reheat the patty in the office microwave. Way better than the sad office cafeteria burgers.
Made these for my teenage son’s birthday party over the weekend and the teens demolished 12 burgers in 20 minutes flat. A couple of them said it was better than the Shake Shack they go to after football practice, which is the highest possible praise you can get from a 16 year old tbh. Only thing is I ran out of cheese halfway through because I underestimated how many they’d eat, oops.