Shaker Lemon Pie (Ohio)

title 1
Shaker Lemon Pie (Ohio)
⏱️ cook time 5 hours (30 minutes active prep, including passive maceration and cooling)
🍽️ servings 8
⚡ Difficulty medium

intro

A tangy-sweet iconic Ohio Shaker dessert featuring macerated whole lemon slices baked in a flaky double crust, balancing bright citrus and buttery pastry.

Ingredients

Thin-skinned fresh lemons 2 medium (≈225g, scrubbed, seeds removed)
Granulated white sugar 2 cups (400g)
Large eggs 4 (≈200g, lightly beaten)
All-purpose flour 2 ½ cups + 1 tbsp (323g)
Cold unsalted butter 1 cup (226g, cut into ½-inch cubes)
Fine sea salt 1 tsp (5g, divided)
Ice-cold water 6–8 tbsp (90–120ml)
Heavy cream 1 tbsp (15ml, for crust wash)
Coarse sanding sugar 1 tsp (4g, for crust topping)

Steps

1

Prep and macerate lemons

Scrub lemons thoroughly, pat dry, and slice paper-thin (1–2mm thick) with a sharp knife or mandoline, discarding all seeds. Toss lemon slices (including rind and pith) with 2 cups (400g) granulated sugar and ¼ tsp fine sea salt in a non-reactive glass bowl. Cover tightly and let rest at room temperature for 2 hours, stirring every 30 minutes, until sugar dissolves and lemon rinds soften and release their juice.

Step 1
step1:Prep and macerate lemons
2

Prepare flaky pie crust

After lemons have macerated for 1.5 hours, combine 2 ½ cups (315g) all-purpose flour and remaining ¾ tsp fine sea salt in a large mixing bowl. Cut in cold cubed butter with a pastry blender or your fingertips until the mixture forms uneven crumbs with pea-sized and lima-bean-sized butter clumps. Drizzle in 6 tbsp (90ml) ice water, tossing gently, adding up to 2 extra tbsp (30ml) water if needed, until the dough just holds together when squeezed. Split dough into two equal discs, wrap tightly in plastic wrap, and chill in the refrigerator for 30 minutes while lemons finish macerating.

Step 2
step2:Prepare flaky pie crust
3

Roll out bottom crust

Preheat oven to 425°F (220°C). On a lightly floured work surface, roll one chilled dough disc into a 12-inch (30cm) circle that is ⅛-inch (3mm) thick. Gently lay the rolled dough into a 9-inch (23cm) glass pie plate, pressing it firmly against the bottom and up the sides, leaving a 1-inch (2.5cm) overhang around the plate edge. Trim any ragged excess dough beyond the overhang with kitchen shears.

Step 3
step3:Roll out bottom crust
4

Mix lemon filling

Add the remaining 1 tbsp (8g) all-purpose flour to the finished macerated lemon-sugar mixture, stirring to fully dissolve any flour lumps. Fold in the 4 lightly beaten large eggs, mixing until completely combined into a uniform, loose filling with evenly suspended lemon slices. Pour the entire filling mixture into the dough-lined pie plate, spreading lemon slices in an even layer across the bottom.

Step 4
step4:Mix lemon filling
5

Seal top pie crust

Roll the second chilled dough disc into an 11-inch (28cm) circle that is ⅛-inch (3mm) thick. Drape the rolled dough evenly over the top of the lemon filling. Trim the top crust to match the 1-inch overhang of the bottom crust, then fold the bottom crust edge up and over the top crust edge, crimping tightly with your fingers or a fork to create a fully sealed edge. Cut 4 evenly spaced 1-inch slits in the top crust to allow steam to escape during baking.

Step 5
step5:Seal top pie crust
6

Bake and set pie

Brush the top crust evenly with 1 tbsp (15ml) heavy cream, then sprinkle with 1 tsp (4g) coarse sanding sugar. Bake at 425°F (220°C) for 25 minutes, then reduce oven temperature to 375°F (190°C), wrap the crust edges with a strip of aluminum foil to prevent over-browning, and bake for an additional 20–25 minutes, until the crust is deep golden brown and filling bubbles steadily through the top slits. Transfer the pie to a wire rack and let cool completely for 2 full hours at room temperature before slicing, to allow the filling to set firmly.

Step 6
step6:Bake and set pie

Tips

1.Choose thin-skinned lemons (preferably Meyer lemons, if available) for this recipe: thick, rough-skinned grocery store lemons have dense, bitter white pith that will not fully soften even after 2 hours of maceration.
2.Do not rush the cooling step: slicing the pie before it cools for 2 full hours will result in a runny, loose filling, as the egg-based custard needs time to set as it comes to room temperature.
3.Keep all butter and water for the pie crust ice-cold: warm butter melts too quickly in the oven, leading to a tough, dense crust instead of the light, flaky layers that define this classic pie.

✨ You May Also Like

Desserts & Baking
🍜 Italy

Creamy, coffee-kissed classic Northern Italian no-bake dessert, with layers of rum-spiked mascarpone cream, soft ladyfingers, and a rich cocoa dusting.

⏱️ 4 hours 3Desserts & Baking ★ 4.7
Desserts & Baking
🍜 France

Flaky, shatteringly crisp, buttery French croissants with golden exteriors and soft, airy layered interiors, perfect for pairing with coffee for a special morning treat.

⏱️ 12 hours Desserts & Baking ★ 4.5
Desserts & Baking
🍜 United States

Warm, spiced baked apples topped with a fluffy golden biscuit crust, this cozy dessert pairs perfectly with vanilla ice cream for cool-weather comfort.

⏱️ 55 minuteDesserts & Baking ★ 4.6
Desserts & Baking
🍜 United States

A star-spangled classic American blueberry pie with buttery flaky crust and bright sweet-tart filling, perfect for summer patriotic gatherings.

⏱️ 1 hour 25Desserts & Baking ★ 4.7
Desserts & Baking
🍜 United States

A beloved no-bake regional Maine candy with a chewy coconut-potato center coated in rich dark chocolate, a New England holiday staple since the 1870s.

⏱️ 2 hours 3Desserts & Baking ★ 4.8
Desserts & Baking
🍜 France

Luxuriously creamy, floral frozen custard made with aromatic Tahitian vanilla beans, boasting a smooth, rich texture that melts slowly on the tongue.

⏱️ 3 hours 3Desserts & Baking ★ 4.5

Shaker Lemon Pie (Ohio):Frequently Asked Questions

1.What makes Shaker Lemon Pie different from standard lemon meringue pie? ▾
Great question! Unlike creamy, meringue-topped lemon pie, this traditional Ohio Shaker recipe uses zero-waste, thinly sliced whole lemons (peel and all) macerated in sugar, baked in a flaky double crust with no meringue. It delivers a bright, balanced tangy-sweet bite with subtle, pleasant depth from the tender lemon rind.
2.Do I really use the entire lemon, including the peel, for this pie? ▾
You absolutely do—that’s the signature Shaker zero-waste touch! Just be sure to use thin-skinned fresh lemons, slice them paper-thin, and pick out all seeds before macerating. The thin, tender rind softens as it rests in sugar, so you won’t get tough, unpleasantly bitter bites in the finished filling.
3.How long do I need to macerate the lemon slices before baking? ▾
For the best texture and flavor, toss your thinly sliced lemons with measured granulated white sugar and rest them for a minimum of 4 hours, or ideally overnight in the fridge. This resting time draws out bright lemon juices, softens the rind, and dissolves sugar so the filling sets smoothly without any gritty texture.
4.Can I use thick-skinned grocery store lemons if that’s all I have on hand? ▾
I don’t recommend it for an authentic result—thick, pithy rinds add unpleasantly bitter, tough bites even after long maceration. If that’s all you can find, carefully peel off and discard ⅔ of the white pith from each slice before macerating, and add 30 minutes of resting time to soften the remaining rind.
5.Why is cold unsalted butter so important for the double crust? ▾
Cold unsalted butter is the secret to that signature flaky Shaker pie crust! As cold butter melts in the hot oven, it creates tiny steam pockets that puff the pastry into light, crisp layers. If your butter warms up before baking, the crust will turn out dense, tough, and greasy instead of tender and flaky.
6.Do I need to blind bake the bottom crust for this pie? ▾
You don’t need a full blind bake for this traditional recipe! The dense, egg-thickened filling cooks at a steady moderate temperature, and the double crust traps enough heat to set the bottom pastry evenly. Just crimp edges tightly and cut a few small steam vents in the top crust before baking.
7.How do I keep my Shaker Lemon Pie filling from turning out runny? ▾
First, don’t skip the full maceration time for lemons, so excess moisture is drawn out and balanced with granulated sugar. Stick to the measured amount of all-purpose flour to thicken the egg and lemon base, and let the pie cool completely (2 to 3 hours at room temp) before slicing, since filling continues to set as it cools.
8.Can I make this pie ahead of time for a potluck or holiday gathering? ▾
Absolutely! This pie holds up beautifully, which is why it’s been a staple at Ohio potlucks and holiday meals for generations. Bake it 1 to 2 days ahead, let it cool fully, cover loosely with foil, and store it in the fridge. Let it sit at room temp for 20 minutes before serving to amp up the bright lemon flavor.
9.Why do the large eggs need to be well-beaten before adding to the lemon mixture? ▾
Large eggs act as the main structural binder for the filling, holding the macerated lemons, sugar, and all-purpose flour into a cohesive, perfectly sliceable set. Beating them well before mixing ensures they combine evenly with other ingredients, so you don’t end up with streaks of cooked egg or uneven texture in the finished pie.
10.My macerated lemon slices still taste bitter—what went wrong? ▾
That almost always comes down to either using thick, overly pithy lemons, or cutting the maceration time too short. The white pith is the source of most harsh bitter flavor, so stick to thin-skinned lemons, and don’t rush the resting step. If you spot extra-thick pith on slices, trim a bit off before adding sugar.
11.Can I use store-bought pie crust instead of making it from scratch? ▾
No judgment here—good quality store-bought all-butter crust works perfectly for this recipe if you’re short on time! Just be sure to grab a double crust set, keep it cold until you’re ready to fill it, and crimp the edges tightly to seal in the tangy lemon filling as it bakes.
12.What’s the best way to get paper-thin lemon slices for the filling? ▾
A very sharp, thin-bladed serrated knife works well, but a mandoline set to 1/8-inch thickness is the most foolproof tool for even, ultra-thin slices. No matter what tool you use, pause to pick out any visible seeds as you slice, since those can add unwanted bitter notes to the finished pie.
13.How do I keep the top crust from getting too dark while the pie bakes? ▾
If you notice the top crust browning faster than the filling cooks (usually around the 30-minute mark), loosely tent a strip of aluminum foil over the edges and top of the pie. This blocks excess direct heat so the crust turns a perfect golden brown without burning before the filling is fully set.
14.Is it normal for the pie to jiggle a little right when I pull it out of the oven? ▾
That’s totally normal! The center of the pie should have a slight, Jell-O-like jiggle when you remove it from the oven—remember, the egg and flour thickeners will continue to set as the pie cools completely on a wire rack. If the whole pie sloshes loosely, it needs 5 to 10 more minutes of bake time.

Comments (15)

2 weeks ago

Grew up outside Cleveland eating my grandma’s Shaker lemon pie every Thanksgiving and I swear this recipe tastes exactly like hers! I was worried the long maceration step would be a pain but the 4 hour wait for the lemons to soften is 100% worth it – no weird bitter rind bite at all. Brought it to my office potluck last week and every single slice was gone in 10 minutes. SO good.

3 days ago

Made this for our Sunday family dinner and my kids loved it – my picky 7 year old even asked for a second slice before he even finished his first! I did cut the sugar by 2 tbsp because our family likes tarter lemon desserts, and it came out perfect. The crust was flaky, the filling was perfectly set, no runny mess when we sliced it. Total win in our house!

5 days ago

Tried this for the first time ever after hearing about Shaker lemon pie on a food podcast. I’m usually a key lime pie stan but this is a total game changer! The combination of the bright lemon and that buttery crust is unreal. My only note is make sure you slice the lemons paper thin – I rushed that step on my first test batch and some of the rind was a little chewy. Still delicious though!

1 week ago

Made this for a pie contest at my local community garden and got second place! The judges kept commenting on how unique and bright the flavor was compared to all the standard apple and cherry pies entered. Will definitely be making this on repeat all summer long.

2 hours ago

I’m so excited to make this for my dad’s birthday dinner this weekend, quick question – do I have to use Meyer lemons for this? My grocery store only had regular Eureka lemons in stock this week and I don’t feel like driving across town to a specialty market. Would that throw the whole recipe off?

30 minutes ago

Great question! Regular Eureka lemons work totally fine here – you just might want to add an extra 1-2 tbsp of sugar if you prefer a less tart filling, since Eureka lemons have a brighter, more acidic bite than Meyers. Just make sure to slice them extra thin and let them macerate the full time to soften the rind, and you’ll be all set!

yesterday

Has anyone tried making this with a gluten free all purpose flour crust? My partner has celiac and I’d love to make this for our anniversary dinner next weekend but don’t want to waste ingredients if the texture gets weird.

2 hours ago

I made it last weekend with a gluten free crust (used the Cup4Cup brand flour for my go-to crust recipe) and it turned out incredible! No weird texture issues at all, just make sure you blind bake the crust for 10 minutes first so it doesn’t get soggy from the filling.

2 days ago

OMG this pie is insane! I’m from Georgia so I take my fruit desserts very seriously, and this lemon pie just jumped to the top of my go-to list. I served it with a dollop of freshly whipped cream and a tiny sprinkle of lemon zest on top and my guests were raving about it all night.

yesterday

So glad you and your guests loved it! The fresh whipped cream pairing is such a perfect call – it cuts through the bright tartness of the lemon so nicely. Thanks for giving the recipe a try!

3 days ago

I followed the recipe exactly but my filling came out a little runny even after letting it cool the full 2 hours. Did I do something wrong? It still tasted amazing, just didn’t hold its slice shape as well as I wanted.

2 days ago

I had that happen my first time making it too! Turns out I didn’t let the eggs come fully to room temp before mixing them into the filling, and I also pulled it out of the oven 5 minutes too early. Next time I baked it until the center was just barely jiggly (like Jell-O, not sloshy) and it set perfectly while cooling!

5 days ago

How well does this pie hold up in the fridge? I want to make it ahead for a camping trip next weekend and don’t want it to get soggy or go bad before we get to eat it.

3 days ago

This pie holds up great in the fridge for up to 4 days! Just keep it tightly covered with plastic wrap, and wait to add any whipped cream or toppings until right before you serve it. It’s actually even better the second day, once the flavors have extra time to meld together. Perfect for make-ahead trips!

1 week ago

Full transparency: I’m a diehard chocolate dessert person and only made this because my husband begged me for lemon pie. I went back for a second slice. Oops. The balance of sweet and tart is so perfect, even a chocolate snob like me is obsessed. 10/10, no notes.

5 days ago

Same! I only ever make chocolate cream pie normally but my book club asked for something fruity this month and this was such a hit. I’m already making it again for my mom’s birthday next week!

2 weeks ago

Wait, hold up – I’ve been making Shaker lemon pie for 30 years and I never thought to macerate the lemons for 4 whole hours? I’ve always done 2 hours max. Gave this recipe a shot last weekend and wow, that extra time makes such a huge difference in how tender the rind is. Total game changer, can’t believe I slept on that trick for so long.

1 week ago

Right?! My grandma used to macerate her lemons overnight for Shaker pie, I always thought that was overkill until I tried it too. The rind gets so soft and almost candy-like, no bitter bite at all. Worth planning ahead for!

5 days ago

So happy that trick worked for you! The long maceration time is really the secret to getting that perfect, non-bitter texture that traditional Shaker pie is known for. It takes a little extra patience, but the payoff is so worth it.

2 days ago

Disaster alert! I was so excited to make this for my partner’s birthday and I accidentally sliced the lemons way too thick, and now they’re macerating but I’m worried they’re gonna be chewy and bitter. Is there any way to save this, or do I need to run to the store for more lemons and start over?

yesterday

Don’t panic! I did the exact same thing last month. I just dumped the lemon slices and sugar into my food processor and pulsed them a couple times to break up the thicker rind pieces, then let them macerate for another hour before mixing up the filling. It turned out totally fine, no one even noticed!

2 hours ago

Totally agree with that tip! If your slices are too thick, a quick few pulses in the food processor (don’t puree them, you still want some texture!) will save the day. You can also let them macerate an extra 30-60 minutes to help soften the thicker rind if you don’t have a food processor. Hope the birthday pie turns out great!

3 days ago

Brought this pie to my neighborhood block party over the weekend and I swear people were coming up to me for the recipe an hour after the last slice was gone. Multiple people said it was the best lemon dessert they’d ever had. Who knew such a simple, old fashioned recipe would be such a showstopper?!

2 days ago

Ugh I need to remember this for our next block party! I always bring the same old chocolate chip cookies and they’re fine, but this sounds like it would steal the show. Do you serve it cold or room temp?

yesterday

I served it cold right out of the cooler and it was perfect on a hot day! I bet it’s great room temp too, but cold was chef’s kiss for 90 degree Florida weather.

5 days ago

I was so intimidated to try this because I’m still pretty new to baking and the difficulty says medium, but it was way easier than I thought! The active prep really is only 30 minutes, and most of the time is just waiting for the lemons to macerate and the pie to cool. My crust wasn’t the prettiest (my crimping needs work lol) but it tasted incredible. My whole family was impressed!

3 days ago

Oh this makes me feel so much better! I’ve been eyeing this recipe for weeks but was scared I’d mess it up since I’ve never made a pie with fresh lemon slices before, only the lemon curd kind. Your comment is making me hit the grocery store for lemons tonight!

2 days ago

So proud of you for giving it a try! The medium difficulty rating mostly comes from the wait time, not the actual active steps – it’s totally doable for beginner bakers, I promise. If your crimping is messy, just cover the edge with a little extra whipped cream, no one will ever know 😉

1 week ago

I moved from Columbus to LA 8 years ago and I haven’t had a proper Shaker lemon pie since I left. I made this last night and I almost cried when I took the first bite – it tastes exactly like the pie my great aunt used to bring to every family reunion when I was a kid. Thank you so much for sharing this authentic recipe, it made me feel so close to home.

5 days ago

Fellow Ohio expat here (moved to Seattle 5 years ago) and I had the exact same experience! I made this for my roommates who had never even heard of Shaker lemon pie and they were blown away. Nothing hits like the food you grew up with, right?

3 days ago

This comment means so much to me! I developed this recipe after testing it with my own grandma who grew up in the Shaker Heights area, so it’s so special to hear it’s bringing back fond family memories for people. Thanks for giving it a taste of home out in LA!