Shoofly Pie
intro
A classic Pennsylvania Dutch spiced molasses pie with a gooey wet bottom, crisp cinnamon crumb top, and warm, cozy sweetness perfect for cool autumn days.
Ingredients
Steps
Fit Crust into Dish
Preheat oven to 400°F (200°C). Unroll the unbaked all-butter pie crust and gently press it into the 9-inch matte white ceramic pie dish, pressing firmly against the bottom and fluted sides. Trim any overhang to 1 inch, fold the edge under, and crimp decoratively. Prick the bottom of the crust all over with a fork 8-10 times to prevent air bubbles from lifting the crust during baking. Chill the crust in the refrigerator for 10 minutes while you prepare the crumb topping.
Mix Crumb Topping
In the 2-quart brushed stainless steel medium mixing bowl, combine 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour, 1 cup packed light brown sugar, 1 tsp ground cinnamon, and 1/4 tsp fine sea salt. Add the 6 tbsp cold cubed unsalted butter. Use the stainless steel pastry blender to cut the butter into the dry ingredients until the mixture forms coarse, uneven crumbs ranging from pea-sized to small walnut-sized clumps. Do not overmix into a smooth paste, as this will make the topping dense instead of crisp.
Combine Molasses Base
In the 1-quart brushed stainless steel small mixing bowl, pour 3/4 cup unsulphured light molasses. Sprinkle 1 tsp baking soda and the remaining 1/4 tsp fine sea salt over the molasses, then carefully pour 3/4 cup boiling water over the top. Whisk constantly with the stainless steel wire whisk until the baking soda fully dissolves and the mixture foams lightly, about 30 seconds. Set aside to cool for 5 minutes, until it is just warm to the touch (not hot, to prevent curdling the egg later).
Temper Egg into Filling
Once the molasses mixture has cooled to warm (approximately 120°F / 49°C), slowly drizzle 2 tablespoons of the warm molasses liquid into the lightly beaten egg while whisking constantly to gently warm (temper) the egg and prevent curdling. Pour the tempered egg mixture back into the small mixing bowl with the remaining molasses, add 1 tsp pure vanilla extract, and whisk until fully smooth, with no visible streaks of egg.
Layer Pie Components
Remove the chilled pie crust from the refrigerator. Sprinkle 1/3 of the finished crumb topping evenly across the bottom of the unbaked crust. Slowly pour the smooth molasses filling over the bottom crumb layer, pouring gently to avoid disturbing the crumbs. Sprinkle the remaining 2/3 of the crumb topping evenly over the top of the molasses filling, covering the entire liquid surface with loose crumbs – do not press the crumbs down into the filling.
Bake Until Set
Place the assembled pie on the middle oven rack in the preheated 400°F (200°C) oven. After 15 minutes, reduce the oven temperature to 350°F (175°C), place the adjustable aluminum pie crust shield over the crimped edges to prevent over-browning, and bake for an additional 30-35 minutes. The pie is done when the center jiggles slightly like firm Jell-O (not sloshing like loose liquid) and the top crumbs are deep golden brown.
Cool Completely Before Serving
Transfer the baked pie directly to the matte black wire cooling rack on the counter. Remove the pie crust shield. Let the pie cool completely for 2 full hours at room temperature before slicing – this allows the gooey molasses layer to set properly so slices hold their clean shape. Do not refrigerate during cooling, as this will make the crust soggy.
Tips
2.Always temper the egg before adding it fully to the warm molasses: pouring cold beaten egg directly into hot liquid will cause the egg proteins to curdle instantly, creating lumpy, uneven filling instead of the smooth, silky gooey bottom layer that defines wet-bottom shoofly pie.
3.Resist the urge to slice the pie early: the molasses filling will be thin and runny straight out of the oven, and the full 2-hour cooling time allows the egg and starch from the crumbs to set into the perfect sliceable, gooey texture without being runny.

OMG I’ve been hunting for a proper wet-bottom shoofly pie recipe for YEARS after my grandma’s recipe card got lost in a move. This tasted exactly like I remembered! The crumb top is perfectly spiced and that gooey molasses bottom? *Chef’s kiss* Baked it for our Sunday family dinner and everyone went back for seconds. SO good.
Made this for my weekly meal prep to have as a little sweet treat after dinners all week. It held up really well in the fridge! I cut the sugar a tiny bit because I don’t love super sweet desserts and it still turned out great. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish the instructions for the wet vs dry layer were a little more clear for new bakers, but I figured it out.
Game changer! I’ve made dry-bottom shoofly pie a dozen times but never nailed the wet version until now. Cooked mine for exactly 47 minutes and the bottom was that perfect gooey, almost custardy texture everyone raves about. Brought half of it to my office potluck and people were begging for the recipe before I even left.
My kids loved it! I let my 8 year old help mix the crumb topping and she was so proud of how it turned out. We had it with a dollop of whipped cream after our taco night last Friday and there were zero leftovers. Will absolutely be adding this to our regular dessert rotation.
Help! I followed the recipe exactly but my bottom came out totally set, not gooey at all. I baked it for 50 minutes like the high end of the time said, did I overdo it? It still tastes good, just not the wet-bottom I was hoping for.
Brought this to our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and it was the first dessert gone! I had three people knock on my door the next day asking for the recipe. The spice balance is perfect, not too heavy on the molasses which I love.
I used sorghum molasses from our local farm stand instead of regular store-bought and wow, that depth of flavor is unreal. This recipe is so forgiving, I even messed up the crumb topping ratio a little and it still came out perfect.
First time ever making any kind of pie from scratch, and this was way easier than I thought it would be for a medium difficulty recipe! I messed up the store-bought crust a little when I was laying it in the pan, but no one even noticed once it was baked. Tastes amazing with vanilla ice cream on top.
I’ve been making shoofly pie for over 60 years, and this recipe is better than the one I got from my own mother! The wet bottom is exactly how it should be, not runny but not dry, and the crumb topping has just the right amount of cinnamon. My grandkids ate two slices each after Sunday supper.
Made this for my partner’s birthday because he grew up eating shoofly pie on trips to Lancaster, and he said it tasted just like the ones he got from the roadside stands there! I only knocked off a star because I wish the recipe noted what type of molasses works best — I used light and it was great, but I’m curious if dark would be too strong.
OMG y’all, I was so nervous to make this because I’ve only ever eaten shoofly pie at Amish markets when we go camping, but this was so straightforward! Cooked for 46 minutes, let it cool completely like the recipe said, and that wet bottom was perfect. My teenage boys ate half the pie in one sitting after football practice.
Made this as the dessert for our weekend BBQ spread and it was a total hit! Everyone expects cookies or brownies at a cookout, so this was such a fun, unexpected surprise. Paired so good with the smoked brisket we made, who knew molasses pie went that well with savory BBQ?
This was SO good, but I had a little issue with my crust getting a bit too dark around the edges before the center was set. Any tips for that next time? I covered the edges with foil halfway through but maybe I should do it earlier?
Wait a second, this is the exact wet-bottom shoofly pie recipe my great-aunt used to make for our family reunions every summer! I can’t believe I found it online. The secret is definitely not overbaking it, which so many other recipes get wrong. I made it last night and cried a little when I took the first bite, it was so nostalgic.