Smoked Old Fashioned Cocktails
intro
A rich, aromatic twist on the classic bourbon cocktail, with smooth wood smoke notes balancing sweet sugar, bitter orange, and warm bourbon for a luxurious, slow-sipping experience.
Ingredients
Steps
Muddle Sugar and Bitters
Place 1 demerara sugar cube in the bottom of each lowball rocks glass. Add 4 dashes of aromatic bitters directly on top of each sugar cube. Use the walnut muddler to gently press and twist the sugar cubes 3-4 times until the sugar is partially crushed and saturated with bitters, forming a coarse wet paste at the bottom of the glass. Do not over-muddle to a fine powder, as small sugar granules add pleasant texture.
Measure Bourbon Into Mixer
Set the prepared rocks glasses temporarily to the left of the work area. Place the clear crystal mixing glass in the center of the counter. Use the double-sided stainless steel jigger to measure 60ml (2oz) of bourbon per serving, for a total of 120ml (4oz), pouring it into the mixing glass. Wipe any small bourbon drips from the jigger with the edge of the linen towel between pours for a clean work surface.
Stir Cocktail to Chill
Use the polished stainless steel ice tongs to transfer 4 standard stirring ice cubes from the small glass cup on the slate coaster to the mixing glass with the bourbon. Hold the mixing glass steady with one hand, insert the twisted-handle bar spoon, and stir slowly and steadily for 25-30 seconds, until the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty to the touch and the bourbon is chilled to approximately 4°C (40°F). Do not shake, as this will cloud the bourbon and create unwanted over-dilution.
Prepare Smoke Infuser
Open the matte silver applewood chip tin, and scoop 1 tablespoon of fine applewood smoking chips into the mesh burn chamber of the matte black handheld smoke infuser. Ensure the chips are loosely packed so air can flow through them evenly. Hold the infuser nozzle 5cm above the counter, and use the long-reach butane lighter to ignite the top of the wood chips. Turn the infuser on to the lowest airflow setting until thin, pale grey, sweet-smelling smoke begins to flow steadily from the nozzle. Extinguish any small open flames on the chips before using; stop immediately if you see thick black smoke, as this indicates over-burned chips that will create a bitter, ashy flavor.
Strain and Smoke Cocktail
Place the polished stainless steel julep strainer over the top of the frosty, chilled mixing glass, and pour equal amounts of the chilled bourbon evenly into the two prepared rocks glasses, straining out the stirring ice as you pour. Do not add the large serving ice yet. Place the clear borosilicate glass cloche over one of the filled glasses, insert the infuser nozzle under the edge of the cloche, and fill the cloche with thick pale applewood smoke for 3 seconds. Remove the nozzle, let the smoke sit trapped over the drink for 10 seconds to allow the smoke compounds to bond with the cold bourbon surface, then repeat the smoking process for the second glass.
Add Ice and Garnish
After smoking both drinks, lift the cloche off the second glass, allowing the remaining trapped smoke to curl gently upward toward the window. Use the ice tongs to place one large 5cm clear serving ice cube into each glass. Take the fresh whole orange, and use the Y-shaped vegetable peeler to remove a 5cm long strip of orange peel, taking care to cut only the thin bright orange zest and avoid the bitter white pith. Hold the peel 5cm above the drink, skin-side down, and squeeze gently to express the citrus oils over the surface of the bourbon, then rub the peel along the outer rim of the glass before resting it on the edge of the ice cube as garnish. Serve immediately while the drink is cold and smoke aroma is bright.
Tips
2.Never shake an Old Fashioned: stirring slowly for 25-30 seconds chills the drink to the ideal serving temperature with just 20% dilution from melted ice, while shaking creates tiny air bubbles that cloud the bourbon and muddle the delicate smoke and citrus notes.
3.Avoid cutting into the white pith when prepping your orange garnish: the pith has a harsh, bitter flavor that will overpower the smooth bourbon and subtle smoke; only peel the thin, bright orange outer zest layer to get sweet, aromatic citrus oil for expression.

OMG, this smoked old fashioned is an absolute game changer! I made these for my guys’ poker night last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe. The smoke adds such a cozy, deep flavor that makes regular old fashioneds taste boring by comparison. 10/10, will be making these for every backyard hang from now on.
Made these for my anniversary dinner with my husband yesterday and we both felt like we were at a fancy downtown cocktail bar! The only thing I messed up at first was holding the smoke too long, it got a little bitter, but the second round was perfect. SO good, way easier than I thought it would be for a medium difficulty recipe.
I was nervous to try a smoked cocktail at home but this recipe was so straightforward! I made a batch for our family dinner to celebrate my dad’s birthday and he said it was better than the old fashioneds he orders at his favorite steakhouse. Total win!
Just got a cocktail smoker as a housewarming gift and this was the first recipe I tested out. Quick question — has anyone tried this with rye instead of bourbon? I have a bottle of rye I’ve been wanting to use up but don’t want to mess it up!
Made these for my fall brunch get together with the girls and they were such a hit! I garnished each with a cinnamon stick and a little orange twist and they looked so fancy. Everyone kept asking how I learned to make smoked cocktails at home, I felt like a total pro!
I’ve tried a handful of smoked old fashioned recipes online and this one is by far the best. The ratio of simple syrup to bitters is perfect — not too sweet, not too sharp. Cook time is no joke too, I whipped up 6 of these in under 10 minutes total for my cookout crew.
I don’t even love whiskey usually but these are so smooth! The smoke cuts the harshness I usually taste in bourbon, I ended up drinking two of these when I thought I’d just have a sip. Who knew I was a fancy cocktail person now?
Quick heads up for anyone making this in a small apartment like me — open a window! I set off my smoke alarm the first time I tried to make these lmao. Once I got the window cracked and figured out how much smoke to trap under the glass, it turned out incredible, though. Worth the minor chaos.
I spent 20 years behind the bar and I’m impressed with how well this recipe nails the classic smoked old fashioned you’d get at a high end craft cocktail spot. No weird fancy ingredients, just solid technique and perfect ratios. I’ve already shared this with a bunch of my old regulars.
Made these on my last camping trip with a portable smoke infuser and they were the perfect nightcap around the campfire. Used mesquite chips for extra woodsy campfire vibe and it was chef’s kiss. Way easier to pull off at the campsite than I thought it would be, no fancy bar tools needed!