sub roll
intro
Soft, chewy sub rolls with a thin, crisp golden crust, sturdy enough to pile high with grilled fillings, cold cuts, or meatballs for summer gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Activate the Yeast
Pour 320ml lukewarm water (100°F/38°C, warm to the touch but not hot enough to sting) into the stand mixing bowl. Stir in 8g granulated sugar until fully dissolved, then sprinkle 7g active dry yeast evenly over the water surface. Let rest for 5-7 minutes at room temperature, until the mixture forms a 1/4-inch thick foamy, creamy layer on top, confirming the yeast is active. If no foam forms after 7 minutes, the yeast is expired and should be replaced to avoid dense, flat rolls.
Knead the Dough
Add 500g bread flour, 10g fine sea salt, and 30ml extra virgin olive oil to the foamy activated yeast mixture in the mixing bowl. Attach the dough hook to the stand mixer, and mix on low speed (speed 2) for 8 full minutes, stopping once to scrape down the bowl sides with the dough scraper. The finished dough will pull away cleanly from the bowl sides, form a smooth, taut elastic ball, and spring back halfway when poked 1/2 inch deep with a finger. If kneading by hand, turn the shaggy dough out onto the lightly floured cutting board and knead for 12 minutes, until the same smooth, elastic texture is achieved.
First Dough Rise
Lightly coat the inside of the mixing bowl with a thin swipe of olive oil to prevent sticking. Turn the dough ball to coat its entire surface in oil, then cover the bowl tightly with the oatmeal linen kitchen towel taken from its front left resting spot. Let rise in a warm, draft-free spot on the counter for 1 full hour, until the dough has doubled in volume, and a finger poked 1 inch into the center leaves an indent that does not spring back at all.
Shape Sub Rolls
Once doubled in size, uncover the dough and return the linen towel to its front left resting position. Turn the risen, puffy dough out onto the lightly floured beech wood cutting board, pressing gently to deflate large air bubbles. Use the white plastic dough scraper to divide the dough evenly into 8 equal pieces, each weighing roughly 105g. Working one piece at a time, pat each dough portion into a 4x6 inch flat oval, then fold the long edges in toward the center, pinching the seam tightly to seal. Roll the sealed log back and forth under your palms to form a 6-inch long, evenly thick roll with slightly tapered ends. Place shaped rolls seam-side down on the parchment-lined aluminum baking sheet, leaving 2 inches of space between each roll to allow for expansion.
Proof Shaped Rolls
Lightly drape the oatmeal linen towel over the shaped rolls on the baking sheet, and let rise in a draft-free spot for 20-25 minutes, until the rolls have puffed to 1.5 times their original size, and hold a slow, partial indent when gently poked on the side. While the rolls proof, preheat the oven to 425°F (220°C), with an oven rack positioned in the exact center.
Score and Bake Rolls
Uncover the fully proofed rolls and return the linen towel to its front left resting position. Use the serrated bread knife to make one shallow 1/4-inch deep diagonal score across the top of each roll, to allow for even expansion in the oven. Use the boar bristle pastry brush to lightly coat the top of each roll with a thin layer of olive oil, for a crisp, golden crust. Place the baking sheet on the center oven rack, and bake for 18-20 minutes at 425°F (220°C), until the rolls are deep golden brown on top, sound hollow when tapped on the bottom, and reach an internal temperature of 190°F (88°C).
Cool Before Serving
Once fully baked, use oven mitts to carefully remove the baking sheet from the oven. Immediately transfer the golden rolls to the unglazed terracotta cooling rack at back right, and let cool for a minimum of 15 minutes before slicing or filling. This cooling step allows the internal crumb to set fully, preventing squished, doughy interiors when you add sandwich fillings. Once cooled, transfer rolls to the cream ceramic bread basket for serving.
Tips
2.Do not rush the cooling step: cutting rolls straight from the oven causes trapped steam to escape too quickly, leading to a gummy, dense crumb instead of the light, airy interior that makes restaurant-style sub rolls so appealing.
3.Add steam for extra crust crispness: place a small metal baking pan on the lower oven rack while preheating, and pour 1/2 cup hot water into the pan right as you put the rolls in to bake. The released steam helps the crust expand fully in the first 5 minutes of baking, creating a delicate, shatteringly crisp outer layer.

OMG, these rolls are a total game changer! I’ve been buying sad grocery store sub rolls for years for our Sunday Italian sub nights, and these taste exactly like the ones from my favorite corner deli back in Jersey. The crust is perfectly chewy, the inside is soft and fluffy enough to hold all the cold cuts, oil, and vinegar without getting soggy for hours. My kids devoured their meatball subs on these last night and asked if we can make them every week from now on. 10/10, will be doubling the batch for meal prep this weekend!
Okay, I’m super new to bread baking and was nervous this would be too hard since the difficulty is listed as medium, but I followed the directions step by step and they actually turned out! I messed up the first rise a little because my kitchen is freezing right now, so I stuck the dough in the oven with the light on for an extra 20 minutes and that did the trick. Only thing is my rolls came out a little lopsided when I shaped them, but my roommates said they tasted so good they didn’t care at all. SO good with toasted garlic butter on the side too!
Made these for our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and people were asking me for the recipe before I even finished setting up my table! I made 18 rolls, sliced them, set out cold cuts, cheese, pickles, onions, and all the fixings so people could build their own subs, and every single roll was gone in 45 minutes. The only complaint was that I didn’t make enough! I will say, I added a little sprinkle of sesame seeds to the top before baking per my husband’s request, and that was chef’s kiss level.
These rolls hold up so good for meal prep! I baked a batch on Sunday, sliced them, and stuffed them with turkey, provolone, and roasted veggies for work lunches all week, and they didn’t get soggy at all even with the pesto I spread on them. Way better than the sad sandwich bread I usually buy, and way cheaper than grabbing a sub from the shop by my office every day. Saved me like $40 this week already!
Wait a second, can I use these rolls to make garlic bread too? I had a couple leftover after making meatball subs the other night, sliced them open, slathered them with garlic butter, sprinkled parm on top, and broiled them for 3 minutes and it was the best garlic bread I’ve ever had. The chewy crust gets all crispy and the inside soaks up the butter perfectly. Why have I never thought to do that with sub rolls before?
Tried making these at 6,000 feet elevation yesterday and they rose way too fast then collapsed right when I put them in the oven! So sad, I was really looking forward to good sub rolls. Any tips for high altitude adjustments?
Worked at an Italian deli in Boston for 6 years in college, and let me tell you — these rolls are legit. The texture is spot on, that slight crisp on the bottom, the soft crumb inside, that tiny hint of sweetness that classic Italian-American sub rolls have. I was skeptical a homemade recipe could nail it, but this is exactly what we used to get delivered from the local bakery every morning. Absolute home run.
Made these with my 8 year old daughter for our family movie night last week, we used them to make pizza subs with pepperoni and mozzarella, and she had an absolute blast helping knead the dough and shape the rolls. She was so proud to tell everyone at school that she made the bread for our dinner! The rolls came out perfect, even with her very enthusiastic dough punching.
SO good! I added a little Italian seasoning and parmesan to the dough when I was mixing it, and it gave the rolls such a nice herby kick that paired perfectly with the spicy capicola and hot peppers I piled on my sub. Will absolutely be adding that to my regular rotation. The 20 minute cook time is no joke either, they baked up perfectly golden in exactly that time, no guesswork needed.
I was shocked how cheap these were to make! I already had all the ingredients in my pantry — flour, yeast, salt, sugar, a little olive oil — so I didn’t even have to run to the store. Way better value than the $4 for a 4 pack of sub rolls at the grocery store, and they taste a million times better. I already sent the recipe to my whole family group chat.
Really solid recipe, the flavor was great, but my crust came out a little thicker and crispier than I prefer for sub rolls. Next time I’ll probably roll them a little thinner and maybe add a pan of water to the oven while they bake to get a softer, chewier crust. Still way better than store bought though, will definitely make again with those small tweaks.
Swapped the honey for maple syrup and used a plant-based egg wash (oat milk + a little maple syrup) on top, and these still came out absolutely perfect! I made vegan meatball marinara subs for my partner’s birthday dinner, and he said they were better than the non-vegan subs we get at our local sandwich shop. So happy I found this recipe, it’s a new staple in our house.