Sugar Cream Pie

title 1
Sugar Cream Pie
⏱️ cook time 1 hour 5 minutes
🍽️ servings 8
⚡ Difficulty easy

intro

A rich, silky, custardy Midwestern American pie with sweet vanilla-cinnamon filling, flaky buttery crust, and a warm, gently spiced finish.

Ingredients

All-butter 9-inch unbaked pie crust 1 (9-inch / 23cm) crust
Granulated sugar 1 cup (200g)
Heavy whipping cream 1 1/2 cups (360ml)
Packed light brown sugar 1/4 cup (50g)
All-purpose flour 1/4 cup (30g)
Whole milk 1/2 cup (120ml)
Unsalted butter, melted 3 tablespoons (42g)
Pure vanilla extract 1 teaspoon (5ml)
Ground cinnamon 1 1/4 teaspoons (2.5g), divided
Fine sea salt 1/4 teaspoon (1g)

Steps

1

Blind bake the crust

Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). Press the unbaked 9-inch pie crust into a 9-inch pie dish, crimp the edges as desired, line the crust with parchment paper, and fill with pie weights or dried beans. Bake for 12 minutes, then carefully lift out the parchment and weights, and bake for 3 additional minutes until the crust is pale golden and dry to the touch. Set aside to cool for 5 minutes before adding filling.

Step 1
step1:Blind bake the crust
2

Combine dry filling ingredients

In a medium mixing bowl, whisk together 1 cup (200g) granulated sugar, 1/4 cup (50g) packed light brown sugar, 1/4 cup (30g) all-purpose flour, 1 teaspoon (2g) ground cinnamon, and 1/4 teaspoon (1g) fine sea salt. Whisk for 30 seconds until fully blended, breaking up any lumps of brown sugar with the back of the whisk to create an even, uniform mixture.

Step 2
step2:Combine dry filling ingredients
3

Whisk in wet ingredients

Slowly pour 1 1/2 cups (360ml) heavy whipping cream, 1/2 cup (120ml) whole milk, 3 tablespoons (42g) melted and slightly cooled unsalted butter, and 1 teaspoon (5ml) pure vanilla extract into the dry ingredient bowl. Whisk constantly for 1 minute at a steady pace until the filling is completely smooth, with no visible flour clumps remaining.

Step 3
step3:Whisk in wet ingredients
4

Pour filling into crust

Set the par-baked pie crust (still in its dish) on a rimmed baking sheet lined with parchment paper to catch any spills. Slowly pour the smooth cream filling into the crust, stopping 1/4 inch below the crimped top edge to prevent bubbling over during baking.

Step 4
step4:Pour filling into crust
5

Bake until set

Carefully transfer the baking sheet with the pie to the middle rack of the preheated 375°F (190°C) oven. Bake for 35–40 minutes, until the outer edges of the filling are fully set and the central 2-inch circle has a soft, Jell-O-like wobble. Sprinkle the top with the remaining 1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon during the last 5 minutes of baking.

Step 5
step5:Bake until set
6

Cool and chill thoroughly

Remove the pie from the oven and transfer it to a wire cooling rack. Let it cool completely at room temperature for 2 hours, then cover loosely with plastic wrap and chill in the refrigerator for at least 2 additional hours to let the filling fully set before slicing and serving.

Step 6
step6:Cool and chill thoroughly

Tips

1.Avoid overbaking: The center 2 inches of the pie will have a soft Jell-O-like wobble when removed from the oven, and will set fully as it cools; overbaking causes rubbery, cracked filling.
2.For a traditional, extra-rich top, dot the surface of the unbaked filling with 1 tablespoon (14g) of thin cold butter slices before placing the pie in the oven, which melts into a golden, bubbly crust as it bakes.
3.Do not skip the full cooling and chilling step: Slicing the pie before it has chilled for at least 2 hours in the refrigerator will result in runny, loose filling that does not hold its shape.

✨ You May Also Like

Desserts & Baking
🍜 Italy

Creamy, coffee-kissed classic Northern Italian no-bake dessert, with layers of rum-spiked mascarpone cream, soft ladyfingers, and a rich cocoa dusting.

⏱️ 4 hours 3Desserts & Baking ★ 4.7
Desserts & Baking
🍜 France

Flaky, shatteringly crisp, buttery French croissants with golden exteriors and soft, airy layered interiors, perfect for pairing with coffee for a special morning treat.

⏱️ 12 hours Desserts & Baking ★ 4.5
Desserts & Baking
🍜 United States

Warm, spiced baked apples topped with a fluffy golden biscuit crust, this cozy dessert pairs perfectly with vanilla ice cream for cool-weather comfort.

⏱️ 55 minuteDesserts & Baking ★ 4.6
Desserts & Baking
🍜 United States

A star-spangled classic American blueberry pie with buttery flaky crust and bright sweet-tart filling, perfect for summer patriotic gatherings.

⏱️ 1 hour 25Desserts & Baking ★ 4.7
Desserts & Baking
🍜 United States

A beloved no-bake regional Maine candy with a chewy coconut-potato center coated in rich dark chocolate, a New England holiday staple since the 1870s.

⏱️ 2 hours 3Desserts & Baking ★ 4.8
Desserts & Baking
🍜 France

Luxuriously creamy, floral frozen custard made with aromatic Tahitian vanilla beans, boasting a smooth, rich texture that melts slowly on the tongue.

⏱️ 3 hours 3Desserts & Baking ★ 4.5

Sugar Cream Pie:Frequently Asked Questions

1.Why does my sugar cream pie filling turn out runny instead of the signature silky, set custard texture? ▾
Runny filling usually stems from two common missteps: unevenly mixed thickener or cutting cooling time short. Whisk your all-purpose flour fully into the granulated and brown sugar blend before stirring in heavy cream to avoid lumps that weaken thickening power. Bake until edges are set with only a faint center jiggle, then let it cool 2 full hours—filling firms up as it rests, so don’t slice early.
2.Can I use a store-bought pie crust for this recipe, and do I need to blind bake it first? ▾
A high-quality store-bought all-butter 9-inch pie crust works perfectly here if you don’t want to make homemade, with no major flavor or texture tradeoffs for that classic flaky bite. You don’t need a full blind bake for this gently cooked, creamy filling, but do dock the crust bottom with a fork and chill it 15 minutes before adding filling to reduce the risk of a soggy bottom.

Comments (6)

2 days ago

OMG this pie is exactly the one my grandma used to make for every Sunday family dinner! I was so worried I’d never get the custard texture right, but this recipe was so easy even my 10 year old helped stir the filling. Took it to our church potluck last night and people were begging for the recipe before dessert was even over. SO good, will be making this on repeat all fall!

yesterday

Wait did yours set up all the way? I tried making this last weekend and mine was a little runny in the middle, wondering if I pulled it out too early!

yesterday

So glad you loved it! Quick tip for runny filling: make sure you let it cool completely (at least 2 hours at room temp, then an hour in the fridge) before slicing—it keeps setting as it cools! If the center is still jiggly like jello when you pull it out, give it 5-10 more minutes in the oven too.

3 days ago

Super easy recipe, took barely any prep which was perfect for my weekend meal prep. I added a tiny dash of nutmeg on top because I love that warm spice, and it went over great at my neighbor’s cookout. Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish the recipe noted how long you need to let it chill before serving, I cut into it too early the first go around!

2 days ago

Thanks so much for the feedback! I just added a clear note about chill time to the recipe card—you’re totally right, that’s a key step I almost buried in the instructions. That nutmeg addition sounds delicious, I’ll have to try that next time I make it!

1 week ago

Game changer! I’d never heard of Hoosier sugar cream pie before stumbling on this recipe, but I had all the ingredients in my pantry so I gave it a shot. The sweet, creamy, cinnamon-kissed filling is insane—my roommate ate half the pie in one sitting. Way easier than pecan or apple pie for holiday meals, I’m already planning to make two for Thanksgiving this year.

5 days ago

My kids loved it!!! I was looking for a simple dessert to make for our back to school dinner and this checked every box. No fancy ingredients, no fussy steps, just sweet creamy goodness. My youngest asked if we can have this every Friday as our special weekend treat, which is the highest possible praise in our house.

3 days ago

How did you get the top so perfectly browned and cinnamon-y? Mine came out really pale on top even after baking the full time!

2 days ago

Oh I sprinkled a little extra cinnamon and a teaspoon of sugar on top right before putting it in the oven! Also I broiled it for like 1 minute at the very end, just keep a super close eye on it so it doesn’t burn!

2 weeks ago

Made this for my book club potluck and every single person asked for the recipe! I was a little nervous because cream pies can be finicky, but this was truly so straightforward. The texture was perfectly silky, not too sweet, just the right amount of vanilla. 10/10, already added this to my regular dessert rotation.

1 week ago

Wait were you the one who brought that pie to last month’s meeting??? I’ve been thinking about that slice for WEEKS, I can’t believe this is the recipe! Making it this weekend for my husband’s birthday!

yesterday

I grew up right on the Indiana border so sugar cream pie is a core childhood memory for me, and this recipe nails it. No weird additives or fancy steps, just the simple, creamy, sweet pie I remember getting at small town diners on road trips. Cook time was exactly as listed, no surprises, it turned out perfect on the first try. If you’ve never had this pie before, do yourself a favor and make it this week!