sugar free butterscotch pudding
intro
Rich, velvety sugar-free butterscotch pudding with deep toasty caramel notes, no added sugar, and the same silky, nostalgic texture as the classic recipe.
Ingredients
Steps
Toast Butter and Sweetener
Place the 1.5qt heavy-bottomed stainless steel saucepan on the left induction burner over medium-low heat. Add 4 tbsp cubed unsalted butter and 1/3 cup granulated erythritol, stirring frequently with the light maple wood spoon as the butter melts. Cook for 3-4 minutes, until the mixture turns a deep golden amber color and releases a nutty, toasty aroma. Watch closely, as erythritol can scorch and turn bitter in as little as 30 seconds if heat is too high.
Whisk in Dairy Slowly
Temporarily remove the saucepan from heat. Add 1 tsp blackstrap molasses and whisk with the silicone whisk until fully incorporated, then slowly stream in the combined 1 cup whole milk and 1/2 cup heavy whipping cream while whisking constantly. The mixture will bubble vigorously at first, so pour in a thin stream to avoid hot splatters. Once fully combined, return the pan to low heat.
Temper Egg Yolks Gently
In one 3oz clear glass prep bowl, whisk 3 large egg yolks and 2 tbsp cornstarch together until completely smooth, with no remaining cornstarch lumps. Slowly ladle 1/2 cup of the warm milk-cream mixture into the egg yolk bowl, whisking nonstop as you pour to gradually raise the yolk temperature and prevent curdling. Once the warm liquid is fully mixed into the yolks, pour the tempered egg mixture back into the saucepan, whisking constantly.
Cook Until Thickened
Keep the saucepan over low heat (maintaining a temperature around 170°F/77°C, never boiling), whisking constantly for 3-4 minutes, until the pudding thickens enough to coat the back of the light maple wood spoon. Test for doneness by running your finger across the coated spoon: the line should hold cleanly without running or dripping. Remove the pan from heat immediately once thickened, as overcooking will cause curdling.
Strain for Silky Texture
Set the 6-inch fine-mesh stainless steel sieve over the 1.5qt clear glass mixing bowl. Pour the hot pudding through the sieve, using the light maple wood spoon to press the soft pudding through the mesh, catching any tiny lumps of cooked egg or cornstarch to create an ultra-smooth final texture. Stir 1 tsp pure vanilla extract and 1/4 tsp fine sea salt into the strained pudding until fully combined.
Portion Into Custard Cups
Divide the warm, smooth pudding evenly between the four 6oz clear glass custard cups, filling each to 1/4 inch below the rim. Use a corner of the unbleached paper towel to wipe any pudding drips from the outside of the cups for a clean finish.
Chill Until Fully Set
Press a small square of plastic wrap directly onto the exposed surface of each pudding (not just over the cup rim) to prevent a thick, rubbery skin from forming as it cools. Place the custard cups on a small tray and refrigerate for a minimum of 2 hours, until the pudding is completely chilled and firm, with only a slight soft jiggle in the center when tapped.
Garnish Before Serving
Remove the plastic wrap from each chilled pudding just before serving. Top each cup with a 1 tbsp dollop of unsweetened whipped cream and a light pinch of flaky sea salt to cut the richness and amplify the butterscotch flavor.
Tips
2.Always press plastic wrap directly onto the pudding surface while chilling: covering only the cup rim leaves air space above the pudding, which causes a thick, chewy skin to form on top, ruining the silky smooth texture.
3.Never let the pudding boil after adding eggs: egg yolks curdle at temperatures above 180°F (82°C), creating grainy, lumpy pudding even after straining. Keep heat on low and remove the pan from heat the second the pudding coats the back of a spoon.

OMG this sugar free butterscotch pudding is a total game changer! My kids are obsessed and had zero clue it doesn’t have any added sugar. I whipped it up last night for our post-dinner treat and even my picky 7 year old asked for seconds. 15 minute cook time? Perfect for busy school nights!
SO good. I’ve been cutting added sugar for my gym gains and was so sick of chalky, weird tasting sugar free desserts. This pudding is creamy, rich, tastes exactly like the butterscotch pudding my grandma used to make. 10/10 will be making this weekly for meal prep.
Brought this to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! Nobody believed me when I said it was sugar free. Super easy to throw together too, I didn’t even have to run to the grocery store for special ingredients — I already had everything in my pantry.
Tried this yesterday and while the flavor is amazing, mine came out a little lumpy? Did I mess up the temperature when cooking? I used a granulated erythritol blend if that makes a difference.
Wait this is so easy even I can make it in my dorm tiny kitchen? No fancy equipment needed? I’ve been craving something sweet that doesn’t make me crash during my 8am lectures.
I made this for my husband who is diabetic, and he said it’s the best dessert I’ve made in years! We used to love butterscotch pudding before he had to cut sugar, and this tastes exactly like the cooked kind from the box we had when we were first married, no weird aftertaste at all.
Can I make this dairy free? My youngest has a milk allergy and I’ve been looking for a fun treat he can eat with the rest of us for our weekly family movie night.
Just finished making a batch and it’s chilling in the fridge now! The warm pudding straight from the pan was so good I almost ate half of it before it set. Can’t wait to top it with a little sugar free whipped cream after dinner tonight.
I topped mine with a little flaky sea salt and some sugar free caramel drizzle and it tasted like something from a fancy restaurant! My coworkers kept asking where I bought it when I brought it in for lunch today. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular rotation.
I’ve tried a ton of sugar free pudding recipes and this one is hands down the best. No weird artificial aftertaste, perfectly butterscotchy, and it sets up so firm you’d swear it was the full sugar version. Brought it to a church potluck last Sunday and even the folks who hate “diet food” went back for seconds.
Quick question — can I freeze individual portions of this for grab-and-go snacks? I love having sweet treats pre-portioned so I don’t overdo it during the work week.