tea sandwiches martha stewart
intro
Delicate, crustless finger sandwiches adapted from Martha Stewart’s classic afternoon tea recipe, with light, fresh fillings perfect for spring picnics and gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Make Herb Cream Cheese
In the first of the three matte white ramekins, combine 225g softened cream cheese, 1 tbsp finely chopped dill, 1 tbsp finely snipped chives, 1 tsp fresh lemon juice, 1/4 tsp kosher salt, and 1/8 tsp black pepper. Stir with the offset spatula until completely smooth, with visible flecks of herb evenly distributed and no lumps of cream cheese remaining. Set aside at room temperature for easy spreading.
Mix Egg Salad Filling
Place 4 peeled hard-boiled eggs on the center of the maple cutting board. Using the santoku knife, chop the eggs into uniform 1/4-inch pieces. Transfer chopped eggs to the second matte white ramekin, then stir in 3 tbsp mayonnaise, 1 tsp Dijon mustard, remaining 1 tbsp snipped chives, 1/4 tsp kosher salt, and remaining 1/8 tsp black pepper. Mix until evenly combined, with a soft, spreadable consistency that holds its shape when scooped.
Slice and Dry Cucumber
Using the santoku knife, slice the English cucumber into paper-thin 1/8-inch rounds, discarding the tough stem and blossom ends. Arrange cucumber slices in a single overlapping layer on a double sheet of paper towel laid on the left edge of the marble counter, then pat firmly dry with a corner of the cornflower blue linen towel to remove all excess surface moisture. Visually check that no wet beads of cucumber juice remain on the slice surfaces, as this causes soggy bread.
Butter Bread Slices
Lay all 12 slices of thin white sandwich bread in a single even layer across the maple cutting board. Use the offset spatula to spread a paper-thin, even layer of softened unsalted butter across one entire side of every bread slice, extending all the way to the crust edges. This butter layer creates a moisture barrier to prevent fillings from soaking into the soft bread.
Build Cucumber Sandwiches
Spread 1 tbsp of herb cream cheese evenly over the buttered side of 4 bread slices. Arrange a single overlapping layer of dried cucumber slices over the cream cheese, covering the entire bread surface, then top each with a second bread slice (buttered and spread with a thin layer of cream cheese, facing down). Press gently but firmly on the top of each sandwich to adhere the layers.
Assemble Remaining Fillings
For the egg salad sandwiches: Spread 1.5 tbsp of egg salad evenly over the buttered side of 4 bread slices, taking care not to tear the soft bread, then top with a second buttered bread slice and press gently to adhere. For the smoked salmon sandwiches: Spread 1 tbsp of remaining herb cream cheese over the last 4 buttered bread slices, arrange thin folded slices of smoked salmon in a single even layer over the cream cheese, then top with a second bread slice and press gently to adhere.
Trim Sandwich Crusts
Working with 2 assembled sandwiches at a time on the center of the cutting board, use the serrated bread knife to trim off all four brown crust edges in clean, straight, even cuts. Pile trimmed crust scraps in a small pile at the top right corner of the cutting board. Apply steady, gentle pressure while cutting to avoid squishing fillings out of the sandwich edges.
Cut and Plate Sandwiches
Cut each crustless sandwich into your preferred shape: 3 equal finger-length rectangles, 2 diagonal triangles, or 4 small bite-sized squares. Line the oval white serving platter with the stacked white lace doilies, then arrange the cut sandwiches in neat rows, grouping each filling type together. Garnish with extra dill fronds and snipped chives before serving.
Tips
2.Soften cream cheese and butter to 65°F (18°C) for 30 minutes before spreading: cold spreads tear soft white bread and leave lumpy, uneven layers that make sandwiches look messy.
3.Assemble sandwiches up to 4 hours ahead, cover tightly with a damp paper towel and plastic wrap, and refrigerate until serving: this prevents the bread from drying out without trapping excess moisture that causes sogginess.

My kids loved these! I packed the crustless cucumber and egg salad ones in their school lunch this week and they came home asking for more. So easy to throw together the night before too, total meal prep win. SO good.
Brought these to our neighborhood block party potluck and people kept asking where I got the recipe! The thin bread slices and light fillings are perfect for snacking without feeling stuffed, even in 90 degree heat. No soggy bread mess, which I was worried about!
These taste exactly like the tea sandwiches we used to serve at our ladies’ church circle meetings back in the day! I did add a tiny extra dash of paprika to the egg salad for a little kick, but otherwise followed the recipe exactly. Delicious, no fuss.
Made these for my Galentine’s day brunch and they were such a hit! I did half cucumber dill and half egg salad, and even my friend who hates crusts was raving. Wait, can you use gluten free white bread for these without it falling apart?
Honestly way better than I thought tea sandwiches would be? I always thought they were too froufrou for my taste but I made these for my girlfriend’s tea themed birthday and even I ate like 6 of them. Only thing is I wish the recipe noted how much salt to add to the egg salad, I eyeballed it and almost overdid it.
Obsessed with how make-ahead friendly these are! I prepped the egg salad on Sunday, assembled the sandwiches Monday morning, and they stayed perfect in the fridge for quick work snacks all week. No soggy bread at all, which is usually my biggest pet peeve with pre-made sandwiches.
These are good, but I missed the sweet pickles my grandma always put in her egg salad tea sandwiches. The base recipe is solid though, super easy even for a beginner cook like me. I just wish I’d remembered to cut the crusts off before adding the filling, oops.
Wait a second, when you say you can make these 1 day ahead, does that include the cucumber ones? I always thought cucumber made bread soggy super fast, I don’t want to make these for my book club tomorrow and have them be mushy! The recipe looks so easy otherwise, can’t wait to try it.
I use this exact recipe for all my client bridal shower tea services! People always rave about how fresh and light they are, and the 10 minute cook time for the eggs means I don’t have to spend hours prepping for big events. Absolute staple in my catering rotation now, total game changer!
Made these for my dorm floor’s fancy tea party social and they were so easy even with my tiny dorm fridge and no fancy tools! I didn’t have a rolling pin to flatten the bread so I used a full soda can lmao, worked like a charm. Only complaint is I wish there were more filling flavor ideas.
My 8 year old daughter asked for a ‘princess tea party’ for her birthday and I was fully out of my depth trying to make fancy food, but these were so easy even I couldn’t mess them up! All the little kids at the party ate them without complaining, even the ones who refuse to eat anything with ‘green stuff’ on it. OMG, 10/10.