Toasted Marshmallow
intro
Golden, gooey caramelized marshmallows with a crisp sugar shell and molten fluffy center, a beloved casual outdoor sweet treat for warm-weather gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep safe heat source
Set up a low, even bed of glowing wood campfire embers or preheat a tabletop propane fire pit to medium-low heat, avoiding tall open flames that burn marshmallows instantly. Wait 5 minutes for heat to stabilize to a consistent 350°F (175°C) measured 6 inches above the heat surface, the ideal toasting height.
Prep marshmallow skewers
Lightly coat the last 3 inches of four 12-inch bamboo or metal skewers with 1/4 teaspoon of canola oil per skewer (1 teaspoon total) to prevent sticking. Thread 4 large marshmallows onto each oiled skewer, spacing pieces 1/2 inch apart to allow even heat flow around every side.
Position over steady heat
Hold each loaded skewer perfectly level, 6 inches directly above the glowing embers, keeping marshmallows completely out of direct flame. Keep your hand positioned far enough up the skewer to avoid heat discomfort, maintaining a steady hold to prevent softened marshmallows from sliding off.
Rotate for even cooking
Turn the skewer in a slow, continuous circular motion for 60 to 90 seconds, cooking every side of the marshmallows evenly. Raise the skewer to 8 inches above the heat source immediately if you notice dark, burnt black spots forming faster than the rest of the surface toasts.
Build golden caramel crust
Continue rotating the skewer for an additional 30 to 45 seconds, until each marshmallow is a deep, even golden amber color with a slightly crisp, crackly caramelized sugar shell. Marshmallows will expand to roughly 1.5 times their original size as their interior melts into a light, gooey, molten consistency.
Cool briefly and serve
Pull the skewer away from the heat source, and let the toasted marshmallows rest for 15 seconds to let the molten interior set slightly and the outer shell crisp up, preventing burns from hot oozing sugar. Slide marshmallows off the skewer to serve immediately while warm.
Tips
2.If using wooden bamboo skewers, soak them in cold tap water for 30 minutes before threading marshmallows to prevent the wood from smoldering or catching fire over the heat.
3.For a balanced flavor boost, sprinkle warm freshly toasted marshmallows with a pinch of flaky sea salt (1/8 teaspoon per serving) to cut through the rich, sweet caramelized sugar.

OMG these came out perfectly golden and gooey every single time! I’ve been burning marshmallows over my fire pit for years, total game changer. My kids begged for seconds at our backyard cookout last weekend. 10/10 no notes!
Tried this on my first ever camping trip last week and didn’t burn a single marshmallow! My whole friend group was making fun of me for looking up a marshmallow toasting tutorial but they all ended up asking for the trick by the end of the night. SO good.
I brought a s'mores bar to our neighborhood potluck and used this method for pre-toasted marshmallows so people didn’t have to mess with the tiny tabletop fire. Everyone raved about how evenly cooked they were! Will absolutely do this again.
Wait, 10 minutes total? That seems way faster than I thought it’d take? I always assumed good toasted marshmallows required forever of hovering over the fire. Excited to test this for our family movie night s'mores tray tomorrow!
Wait can you do this over a gas stove burner? My dorm doesn’t allow fire pits but I have been craving s'mores so bad mid-semester.
Finally! Every recipe or “tip” I’ve seen for toasted marshmallows just tells you to “hold it near the fire” with zero actual guidance. This gives exact distance and rotation timing, no more bitter burnt outer goop for me. Worth every star.
Made these last night with homemade hot cocoa for our first cool fall evening in Arizona. The marshmallow got all toasty and melty on top of the cocoa, literally the coziest treat I’ve had all season. 10/10 will be a weekly ritual now.
Used vegan marshmallows with this method for my gluten free/vegan s'mores platter at my friend’s birthday bonfire and they turned out identical to regular marshmallows! So happy this works for dietary alternatives too.
I teach camping skills to my scout troop and I’m definitely adding this to our first campfire night lesson. We’ve had so many kids burn their marshmallows to a crisp on their first trip, this is so easy for new learners to follow.
Wait, can you toast these ahead for meal prep? I want to pack little s'mores bites for my kid’s school lunch but I don’t want them to get all hard and weird by midday.
Took these to our annual lake bonfire last weekend and people were coming up to me all night asking how I got my marshmallows so perfectly golden without any char. Told ‘em it was the slow and low rotation trick from this recipe! Total crowd pleaser.
Am I the only one who always manages to get melted marshmallow all over my fingers when I toast these? Asking for a very sticky friend (it’s me, I’m the friend).
Made these for our weekly board game night with friends and they were the perfect mid-game snack! We set up a little tabletop fire on the coffee table and everyone took turns toasting their own using the tips here. Zero burnt marshmallows, zero arguments, 10/10.
I don’t even have a fire pit, I make these over my small tabletop soy candle when I’m craving a late night snack and it works! It takes a tiny bit longer but it’s perfect for when I don’t want to fire up the stove. So easy.
My 7 year old is super picky about marshmallow texture – he hates the charred bits and won’t eat them if they’re even a little burnt. Used this method and he ate three marshmallows in a row! He said it was the “best squishy marshmallow ever”. Total mom win.
Brought all the s'mores supplies to our college football tailgate last weekend and used these tips to toast marshmallows for the whole group. People were going crazy for them, even the guys who make fun of “fancy snacks” were coming back for seconds. So easy even a bunch of rowdy college tailgaters can pull it off.
I was so nervous to make s'mores on my first ever glamping trip because I’m terrible at anything over an open fire, but this was so easy to follow! I didn’t burn a single one, even when I was half-asleep by the fire late at night. 10/10, no fancy skill required.