vanilla pudding mix
intro
Shelf-stable homemade vanilla pudding mix, free of artificial additives, makes rich, creamy vanilla pudding in minutes for pies, parfaits, or cozy winter desserts.
Ingredients
Steps
Measure Dry Ingredients
First, confirm all tools and work surfaces are completely dry (any moisture will cause clumping and reduce shelf life). Use the stainless steel dry measuring cups and measuring spoon set to portion each ingredient into separate small clear glass ramekins: 1 cup (200g) granulated white sugar, 1/3 cup (42g) cornstarch, 1 cup (70g) nonfat dry milk powder, 1/2 teaspoon (2.5g) fine sea salt, and 2 tablespoons (14g) pure vanilla powder. Double-check measurements, as incorrect cornstarch ratios will cause runny or gummy finished pudding.
Sift All Dry Ingredients
Set the fine-mesh stainless steel sieve over the top of the medium stainless steel mixing bowl. Add each measured ingredient one at a time to the sieve, tapping the sieve edge gently to sift contents into the bowl below. This breaks up clumps in cornstarch, dry milk, and vanilla powder for a uniformly smooth mix. Discard any hard, dry clumps that remain trapped in the sieve.
Whisk Until Uniform
Lift the sieve off the mixing bowl and set it aside. Use the wire whisk to stir the sifted dry ingredients thoroughly for 45-60 seconds, scraping the bottom and sides of the bowl with the silicone spatula as needed to eliminate pockets of unblended cornstarch or vanilla powder. The finished blend should be an even pale cream color, with no darker vanilla streaks or bright white cornstarch patches visible.
Check Mix Consistency
Pinch a small amount of the blended powder between your thumb and forefinger to check for remaining clumps. If clumps are found, press them through the sieve a second time, then whisk the mix for an additional 20 seconds. The final mix should feel as fine and smooth as commercial pudding powder, with no gritty lumps.
Fill Storage Jar
Set the clean, completely dry 1L clear glass mason jar on the counter next to the mixing bowl. Hold the silicone spatula against the bowl edge to create a narrow guide, then carefully pour most of the blended pudding mix into the jar, reserving ½ cup of mix in the bowl to cook a test serving. Tap the jar gently on the counter halfway through filling to settle the powder and remove trapped air pockets.
Seal Jar Tightly
Wipe any stray powder from the jar rim with a corner of the linen tea towel to ensure an airtight seal, then screw the silver metal lid onto the jar firmly. Sealed mix will stay fresh in a cool, dark pantry for up to 6 months. To prepare pudding from the sealed jar: whisk the full jar of mix with 3 cups cold whole milk, cook over medium heat 8-10 minutes until thick, then chill 2 hours before serving for 6 half-cup servings.
Cook Test Pudding
Retrieve the 1.5L stainless steel saucepan from below the counter. Add the reserved ½ cup of dry mix to the pan, slowly whisk in 1 cup cold whole milk to prevent lumps. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly with the silicone spatula, for 8-10 minutes, until the pudding thickens to a smooth custard that coats the back of the spatula. Remove from heat and cool 10 minutes.
Chill and Serve
Pour the warm cooked test pudding into the matte cream ceramic dessert bowl, press a small piece of plastic wrap directly against the pudding surface to prevent a skin from forming, and chill for 1-2 hours until fully set. Top with a tiny sliver of dried vanilla bean for garnish before serving.
Tips
2.For extra-luxurious prepared pudding, replace 1 cup of whole milk with half-and-half, and stir in 1 tablespoon of unsalted butter immediately after removing the cooked pudding from heat for a richer, silkier texture.
3.This shelf-stable mix makes a perfect edible winter holiday gift: pair the sealed jar with a whole vanilla bean and a small bag of shortbread cookies for a thoughtful, homemade present that stores for up to 6 months.

SO good! I brought the finished pudding to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were asking me for the recipe left and right. I topped mine with fresh strawberries and a little whipped cream, total hit.
Wait, stupid question — when you store the dry mix, how long does it stay good in the pantry? I want to make a big batch for meal prep but don't want it to go bad!
Just made this for the first time using oat milk to cook the pudding, and the texture was perfect! No weird gritty bits at all, which I usually get with store bought gluten free pudding mix. Game changer for our house!
Made this last night when I realized I had no dessert for my roommate’s birthday. Cooked up in like 9 minutes, threw some crushed Oreos on top, and he thought I spent hours making it from scratch. Easy peasy, will make again.
This tastes exactly like the vanilla pudding my grandma used to make! I added a tiny extra pinch of nutmeg to my dry mix, gives it that warm cozy old fashioned flavor I remember.
How much of the dry mix do you use per batch of pudding? I followed the recipe but I think I messed up the ratio because mine came out super runny even after cooking for 12 minutes.
I love that I can make a big jar of this mix on Sunday and have quick pudding options for my kid’s school lunches all week. I portion the cooked pudding into little reusable cups and they’re perfect to grab and go.
No cap, this is so much cheaper than buying the boxed mix at the grocery store. I split a big batch of the dry mix with my three roommates and we all have pudding for late night study snacks for weeks. 10/10, no fancy ingredients needed.
Y’all, I used this mix to make my famous banana pudding for our church potluck and it turned out even better than when I use the instant box stuff. The homemade vanilla flavor really shines next to the bananas and Nilla wafers.
I cut the granulated sugar in half when I made the dry mix and it was still perfectly sweet! The vanilla flavor really comes through so you don’t need all that extra sugar, which is perfect for our family since we’re trying to cut back on added sugars.
First time making this I forgot to add the salt to the dry mix, and it still turned out pretty good! Made a second batch yesterday with the salt and wow, that little pinch makes such a big difference in making the vanilla pop.
My three boys are OBSESSED. I thought for sure they’d turn their noses up at homemade pudding vs the neon colored store bought cups, but they beg for seconds every time. Even my picky eater who refuses 90% of the food I make asks for ‘the special vanilla pudding’ after dinner.
I put this dry mix in cute mason jars with little handwritten tags for neighbor gifts last Christmas, and everyone raved about it! Way more personal than a random candle, and it’s so affordable to make in bulk.
I was so excited to make this but realized I have a corn allergy — is there a substitute for the cornstarch in this mix? I’ve heard great things and can’t wait to try it once I swap that out!
I’ve made this mix four times in the last month! My favorite add-ins so far are a handful of mini chocolate chips stirred in right after cooking, or a spoonful of peanut butter swirled on top. So versatile!
I am notoriously terrible at making homemade desserts — I burn cookies, turn out lumpy cakes, you name it. But this mix was so easy to throw together, and the cooked pudding came out perfectly smooth on the first try! I feel like a real baker now, lol.
How long does the cooked pudding stay good in the fridge? I want to make a big batch on Sunday for weekday snacks but don’t want it to get watery after a couple days.
Pro tip: Use good quality vanilla bean powder in the dry mix instead of relying on adding vanilla extract when cooking, and the flavor is next level. So rich and fragrant, with those pretty little vanilla specks that make it feel fancy.
This tastes exactly like the vanilla pudding my mom used to make for me after little league games when I was a kid. I made a bowl last night after my adult softball game and it gave me all the nostalgic feels. 10/10, will be a staple in my pantry from now on.
I did the math, and making this mix at home costs literally a third of what the name brand instant pudding mix costs at my grocery store. And it tastes better too! No weird artificial aftertaste, just pure creamy vanilla. Total no-brainer for anyone trying to cut grocery costs.