winter drinks
intro
Warm, aromatic spiced mulled cider, brimming with bright citrus and cozy winter spices, perfect for sipping by the fire on frosty Christmas evenings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Aromatic Ingredients
Set the honey maple cutting board in your work area. Use the walnut-handled paring knife to slice one navel orange into 6mm (1/4-inch) thick wheels, studding 6 of the wheels with 2 whole cloves each. Slice the second navel orange in half and set aside for juicing. Slice the Honeycrisp apple into 6mm (1/4-inch) thick rings, removing and discarding any visible seeds. Slice the unpeeled ginger into 3mm (1/8-inch) thick coins. Sort cinnamon sticks, star anise, and remaining cloves into the terracotta ramekins for quick access as you cook.
Build Cider Base
Pour all 8 cups of unfiltered apple cider into the stainless steel stock pot, set over medium-low heat. Use the matte black citrus juicer to squeeze the juice from the two reserved orange halves directly into the pot, picking out any seeds that fall into the liquid. Add the sliced clove-studded orange wheels, plain orange slices, apple rings, sliced ginger, cinnamon sticks, star anise, and remaining loose cloves to the pot. If using optional dark brown sugar for extra sweetness, stir it in now with the ladle until fully dissolved.
Simmer Spice Infusion
Heat the cider until it reaches a gentle, low simmer (small bubbles just breaking the surface, internal temperature 77°C / 170°F), then turn heat to the lowest setting to maintain the simmer. Do not allow the cider to reach a rolling boil, as high heat will destroy delicate spice essential oils and create a bitter, flat flavor. Let the cider infuse for 15 minutes, stirring once halfway through with the stainless steel ladle. The cider will turn a deeper golden amber, and the kitchen will fill with warm spice and citrus aroma when ready.
Add Optional Spirit
After the 15-minute infusion is complete, turn off the stovetop heat entirely. For a boozy batch, slowly pour in 1 cup of bourbon, stirring gently with the ladle to fully combine. Adding the spirit after turning off the heat prevents rapid alcohol evaporation, preserving its smooth, warm flavor. For a non-alcoholic batch, skip the bourbon and add 1/2 cup extra apple cider to match the volume, stirring to combine.
Strain Out Solids
Pick up the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer from its spot next to the citrus juicer. Hold the strainer directly over each clear ribbed glass mug as you ladle hot cider from the pot, catching whole spices, fruit pulp, and ginger bits in the mesh to create a smooth, silky drink. Fill each mug only 3/4 full to leave room for garnishes and avoid spills when carrying mugs to guests.
Garnish and Serve
For each filled mug, place one cinnamon stick from the clear glass jar into the cider as a stirrer, float one clove-studded orange wheel on the liquid surface, and perch one star anise pod on the mug rim. Use the stainless steel microplane to grate a light, even dusting of fresh nutmeg over the top of each drink for an extra layer of warm, nutty aroma. Set each finished mug on a cream knit coaster, and serve immediately while the cider is piping hot.
Tips
2.For a kid-friendly non-alcoholic twist, skip the bourbon and add 1/2 cup fresh cranberries and 1/4 cup pure caramel syrup to the pot while simmering. The cranberries add a bright tart pop, and the caramel adds a rich, buttery sweetness kids and adults alike will love.
3.Make this for a party with zero last-minute stress: Simmer the non-alcoholic cider and spice base 2–3 hours before guests arrive, then hold it on the 'warm' setting in a slow cooker. Stir in the bourbon (if using) right before serving to prevent alcohol from evaporating over time.

OMG I made this for our neighborhood tree lighting potluck last night and people were begging me for the recipe! So easy to throw together in 20 minutes, I didn’t even have to make a special grocery run because I already had all the spices in my pantry. 10/10 will be making this all December long.
Game changer for our post-ski hangouts this year! I usually just buy the pre-made spiced cider from the grocery store but this homemade version is next level. I added a splash of bourbon to my mug and *chef’s kiss*. The 20 minute cook time is perfect when you’re frozen and don’t want to wait hours for a warm drink.
My kids loved it! I skipped the extra cloves because my youngest is picky about strong spice flavors and it was still perfect. They kept asking for refills after we came home from picking out our Christmas tree. SO good, even without adding any alcohol for the grown-ups.
Wait, quick question—can I make this in a slow cooker instead of on the stovetop? I want to set it out for our holiday open house so people can serve themselves warm mugs all afternoon without me having to reheat it every 20 minutes.
Made this for my daughter’s basketball team snack after their Saturday morning game last weekend. All the teens were raving about it, even the ones who usually only drink soda! Super easy, no fancy steps, even a sleep-deprived dad like me can pull it off.
I’m usually not a fan of super spiced drinks because they taste like potpourri to me, but this recipe has the perfect balance! Not too much clove or allspice, just warm and cozy. I did add an extra orange slice because I love citrus, highly recommend.
Brought this to my office ugly sweater party earlier today and it was gone in 20 minutes flat! I set out a little garnish station with cinnamon sticks, orange wedges, and caramel drizzle so people could customize their mugs. So easy, so fun, will be a yearly staple for me.
Wait, stupid question—do I need to strain the spices out before serving? I’m making this for my boyfriend’s family dinner tomorrow and I don’t want anyone biting into a whole clove, lmao. Tested a small batch last night and it tasted amazing, just want to get the serving part right!
This is such a win for my tight holiday budget! I used cheap store-brand apple cider, whole spices I had leftover from last year’s cookie baking, and a couple of cuties I had in my fruit bowl, and it tasted like something from a fancy Christmas market. 20 minutes start to finish? Unbeatable.
I’ve been making mulled cider for my family every Christmas for 40 years, and I tried this recipe for a change of pace this year. It’s absolutely perfect! The spice ratios are spot on, not too overpowering, even my grandkids who turn their nose up at ‘old people drinks’ had two mugs each. Already saved this to my recipe box.
Has anyone tried saving the leftover spices to make a second batch? I hate tossing all those whole cloves and cinnamon sticks after one use, seems so wasteful!
Meal prepped a big batch of this on Sunday to sip on throughout the work week! It reheats so well in the microwave, way better than my usual boring morning coffee on cold days. I added a little pinch of nutmeg on top of each mug for extra coziness.
We tested this recipe for our little cafe’s winter drink menu last week and our customers are obsessed! We serve it with a little cinnamon stick and a candied orange peel on the rim, and we’ve already had to make three extra batches this week to keep up with demand. So easy to scale up for crowds!
Made this for our first married Christmas Eve dinner with our families last night, and it made the whole house smell like absolute holiday magic. My mother-in-law, who swears her mulled cider recipe is ‘unbeatable’, even asked for a copy! Win win.