Witches' Brew Punch
intro
Fizzy, neon-green Halloween punch with bright citrus and tropical flavors, topped with frothy sherbet and spooky edible garnishes for a festive, kid-friendly party treat.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep spooky garnishes
First, make floating 'eyeball' garnishes by pushing 1 fresh blueberry into the hollow center of each drained canned lychee, making 15-20 eyeballs total; set aside on a small plate at room temperature. This prep takes 5 minutes, and you do not need to rinse lychees, as their subtle sweet flavor complements the punch.
Mix chilled punch base
In a 5-liter (1.3 gallon) clear punch bowl, combine 1440 ml chilled unsweetened pineapple juice, 355 ml thawed frozen limeade concentrate, and 1/4 teaspoon neon green gel food coloring. Stir slowly with a long-handled spoon for 30 seconds until the mixture is a uniform vivid neon green with no streaks of concentrated food coloring. Do not add carbonated soda at this stage to preserve fizz.
Add fizzy lemon-lime soda
Slowly pour 2000 ml of well-chilled lemon-lime soda down the inner side of the punch bowl to reduce fizz loss, then stir the mixture extremely gently for 10 seconds to combine. Avoid fast, aggressive stirring, as this will flatten the carbonation and ruin the punch’s bubbly texture.
Top with lime sherbet
Use a standard 60-ml (1/4 cup) ice cream scoop to drop even scoops of the slightly softened 900 grams of lime sherbet across the punch surface, spacing scoops 5 cm apart. The sherbet will fizz and create a frothy, murky pale green top layer as it reacts with the carbonated soda; let it sit for 2 minutes to partially melt into the punch.
Add floating garnishes
Scatter the pre-made lychee eyeballs and 150 grams of gummy worm candies across the punch surface, draping 4-5 gummy worms over the punch bowl rim for a creepy, crawly effect. Position half the garnishes to be half-submerged and half to float fully on top for maximum visual appeal.
Add optional smoky effect
If using food-grade dry ice, use heavy metal tongs to drop 100-gram chunks of dry ice into the punch (never touch dry ice with bare hands, as it causes instant frostbite). The dry ice will create thick, billowing white smoke that spills over the bowl edges for 5-7 minutes as it sublimates. Wait until all dry ice is fully dissolved before serving, or nestle a small dry ice-filled cauldron inside the punch bowl to avoid direct contact with servings.
Tips
2.For an adult-only version, replace 720 ml (3 cups) of the pineapple juice with coconut rum or citrus vodka, keeping all other measurements and steps identical.
3.Only use food-grade dry ice for the smoky effect; never use industrial dry ice, and supervise children closely around dry ice to prevent accidental frostbite or ingestion of un-melted chunks.

OMG this punch was the star of our annual Halloween block party! I was scrambling for a last-minute easy drink since our old punch recipe called for like a million weird ingredients, and this came together in 12 minutes flat. I added a little extra dry ice for the smoky effect and every single parent asked me for the recipe. SO good, will make every year from now on!
Made this for my office potluck last week and it went over really well! Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I thought the sweetness was a little overpowering for my taste, so I added an extra cup of sparkling water to cut it. Would definitely make again, just adjust the sugar next time.
Game changer for my kid’s classroom Halloween party! I was worried it would be too messy or complicated to make before dropping them off at school, but 15 minutes start to finish? No way. My kids loved it, and had a blast helping me drop in the gummy worm garnishes — they thought it was the coolest thing ever. 10/10 no notes.
Made this for my dorm Halloween pre-game last night and everyone went feral for it lmao. I added a splash of vodka for the 21+ crowd (kept a non-alcoholic batch separate for the freshmen) and it was chef’s kiss. So easy I could make it half-asleep between midterms, will be back for more holiday recipes for sure!
Told my kids I was making ‘witches’ brew’ for dinner and they spent 20 minutes cackling about how I must’ve stolen it from a real witch. Jokes aside, this is the easiest punch recipe I’ve ever tried, no weird fancy syrups or anything. We paired it with mummy hot dogs for our family dinner and Halloween movie night and it was perfect.
It was fine? I don’t know, I followed the recipe exactly but it just tasted like regular fruit punch to me. Maybe I was expecting more of a fun unique flavor? The dry ice effect was cool for my Halloween party though, so it gets points for presentation.
I’ve been making a version of this for years but never thought to add the lime sherbet scoop on top! That little addition was a total game changer, it makes it so creamy and fun. I prepped the base the night before for my friend’s costume party (meal prep win!) and just added the fizz and sherbet right before guests arrived. People were going back for thirds, no cap.
Was in charge of drinks for our annual neighborhood bonfire and Halloween costume contest, picked this recipe because it looked easy and fed a crowd. Let me tell you, people were lined up to fill their cups! I added a few drops of green food coloring to make it extra neon and spooky, looked straight out of a cauldron. Zero leftovers, that’s how you know it’s good.
Obsessed!!! I needed a super easy punch for my 7 year old’s witch-themed birthday party and this checked every single box. It’s sweet, fizzy, looks so cool with the dry ice, and didn’t require a trip to the specialty grocery store. All the moms were asking for the link, already sent it to our class parent group.