bbq side
intro
Tender hickory-smoked potatoes, crispy bacon, and tangy creamy dressing come together in this iconic Southern BBQ side, perfect for feeding a crowd at summer cookouts.
Ingredients
Steps
Cut Uniform Potato Chunks
Place 2lbs unpeeled, washed Yukon Gold potatoes on the center acacia cutting board. Use the 8-inch stainless steel chef knife to cut potatoes into even 1.5-inch chunks, cutting around and discarding any dark eyes or bruised spots. Uniform size ensures every piece cooks at the same rate on the grill, so you won’t end up with half mushy, half raw potatoes.
Smoke Seasoned Potatoes
Toss the cut potato chunks with 1 tablespoon olive oil from the glass bottle and 1 teaspoon kosher salt until every piece is lightly coated. Spread potatoes in a single layer on the perforated grill tray, then place on the preheated 225°F (107°C) charcoal grill. Add 2 small hickory wood chunks to the hot coals for smoke, close the lid, and cook for 30 minutes. Test for doneness by piercing a chunk with a fork: it should slide in easily with no hard center, with faint golden smoky browning on the edges. Remove from grill and let cool 15 minutes to room temperature.
Cook Crispy Bacon
While potatoes smoke, place 6 thick-cut bacon strips in the 20cm stainless steel skillet on the side burner set to medium heat. Cook for 8-10 minutes, flipping once with the slotted spoon, until bacon is deep golden and fully crispy, with no remaining rubbery white fat. Transfer cooked bacon to a paper-towel lined spot on the edge of the cutting board to drain, and reserve 1 tablespoon of rendered bacon fat for the dressing.
Mix Creamy Dressing
In the now-empty matte white mixing bowl (wiped clean of potato residue), combine ½ cup full-fat mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons apple cider vinegar, 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard, 1 tablespoon reserved pickle brine, 1 teaspoon reserved bacon fat, ½ teaspoon kosher salt, ½ teaspoon black pepper, and 1 teaspoon smoked paprika. Stir with the slotted spoon until completely smooth, with no streaks of mustard or paprika left. The dressing should be thick but pourable, with a pale tan color from the paprika.
Chop Mix-In Ingredients
While potatoes cool, use the chef knife on the acacia cutting board to finely chop 3 dill pickles, 2 peeled hard-boiled eggs, 2 tablespoons fresh dill, and 1 tablespoon fresh chives. Crumble the cooled crispy bacon into small, bite-sized bits. Set all chopped mix-ins aside in a small pile on the edge of the cutting board, keeping 1 tablespoon of chives and 2 tablespoons of bacon bits aside for garnish.
Combine Salad Components
Add the cooled smoked potato chunks to the bowl of creamy dressing, followed by the chopped pickles, eggs, dill, and all but 2 tablespoons of the crumbled bacon. Gently fold with the slotted spoon until every potato chunk is evenly coated in dressing, taking care not to mash the tender potatoes as you mix. Visible flecks of dill, pickle, and egg should be evenly distributed throughout the salad.
Chill and Plate Salad
Cover the mixing bowl and refrigerate for 20 minutes to let flavors meld (this can be made up to 24 hours ahead for deeper, more balanced flavor). When ready to serve, scoop the chilled salad onto the matte cream stoneware oval serving platter, mounding it gently in the center. Top with the reserved crumbled bacon, sliced chives, a pinch of fresh dill, and a light dusting of smoked paprika for a pop of color.
Tips
2.Let smoked potatoes cool for 15 minutes to room temperature before tossing with dressing: warm potatoes will melt mayonnaise, leading to a greasy, separated dressing instead of a thick, creamy, evenly coated salad.
3.Reserve 2 tablespoons of crumbled bacon and 1 tablespoon of fresh chives to top the salad right before serving: mixing all bacon into the salad causes it to soften as it chills, and the fresh crispy garnish adds a welcome textural contrast for every bite.

Made this for our neighborhood Memorial Day cookout and everyone asked for the recipe!!! The smoky bacon takes regular potato salad from boring to next level. The creamy dressing isn’t too tangy, which is perfect for picky eaters. 10/10 will be making this all summer long.
Quick question — can I make this a day ahead for a work potluck? I don’t want the potatoes to get all mushy or the dressing to get weird overnight.
OMG my kids DEVOURED this at dinner last night! My kids loved it so much they asked me to make it again this weekend. I was worried the smoky bacon would be too strong for my 7 year old who hates “smoky tasting stuff” but he went back for seconds. Game changer for our weekly Sunday dinner rotation.
Added this to my weekly meal prep rotation! It stays good in the fridge for 4 days, is super filling, and doesn’t get all soggy like other potato salads I’ve tried. I added a little extra dill because I’m obsessed with dill, and it slapped.
Took this to my buddy’s backyard bonfire last weekend and people were literally scraping the bowl clean. Only note: I’d recommend boiling the potatoes with a little salt in the water, it makes such a difference in flavor instead of salting later.
As someone who can barely boil water without messing it up, this was SO easy to make! Cook time was exactly 40 minutes like the recipe said, no fancy ingredients needed. My roommates thought I ordered it from the deli down the street lmao.
I’ve been making potato salad for 60 years and this recipe is now my go-to. The balance of creamy mayo, a touch of mustard, and that crispy smoked bacon is just perfect. I added a handful of chopped sweet pickles like I always do, and it turned out divine.
Made this for Father’s Day dinner with my dad who’s a total potato salad snob, and he said it’s the best he’s ever had. Wild. I used hickory smoked bacon instead of regular and it gave it such a deep, rich flavor. 10/10.
Wait, has anyone tried making this with Greek yogurt instead of half the mayo to cut a few calories? I’m trying to lighten up my summer cookout sides but don’t want to ruin the texture.
This potato salad is a potluck all-star. I’ve brought it to three different gatherings in the last month and every single time people are begging for the recipe. Pro move: save a little bacon to crumble on top for presentation, it looks so fancy for zero extra effort.
I messed up and bought russet potatoes instead of Yukon gold, will this still turn out okay? I don’t have time to run back to the store before my dinner party tonight!
Paired this with my slow smoked brisket over the weekend and it was the perfect combo. The creaminess cuts right through the smoky brisket, and the bacon bits add an extra little punch of smoke that pairs so well. Absolute banger of a side dish.
Added a little dash of smoked paprika and some chopped hard boiled eggs because that’s how my family always does potato salad, and it turned out incredible. The base recipe is so solid, it’s easy to tweak to your own taste without messing it up. Will make again for sure.
How long does this take to make total? The recipe says 40 minutes cook time but I’m wondering if prep time adds a ton more? I have exactly an hour between getting home from work and needing to leave for my kid’s baseball team dinner.
So excited to try this! Is this recipe gluten free? I have celiac and have to be super careful about hidden gluten in dressings and pre-packaged ingredients.
I’m not usually a potato salad guy but this one converted me. The bacon adds so much flavor that regular potato salad is missing, it’s SO good, and the dressing isn’t gloppy like the grocery store stuff. My wife said this is the only side I’m allowed to bring to cookouts from now on lmao.
Can I freeze this? I made a double batch for meal prep and have way more than I can eat in 4 days, don’t want it to go to waste.
Made this for our family reunion last weekend and it was a total hit! My cousin who is a professional chef even asked me for the recipe, that’s how good it is. I added a little sprinkle of celery seed on top for extra crunch and flavor, highly recommend.
Help! I overcooked my potatoes a little, are they going to be totally ruined? They’re a little softer than I wanted but not total mush yet.