best egg salad sandwich
intro
Chunky, creamy egg salad piled high on soft lightly toasted sourdough, with bright dill and crisp celery for crunch. This nostalgic, perfectly seasoned deli classic is ideal for picnics and quick lunches.
Ingredients
Steps
Hard Boil the Eggs
Fill the 3-quart brushed stainless steel saucepan with 4 inches of cold tap water, lower the 8 large eggs into the water in a single layer so they are fully submerged. Place over medium-high heat and bring to a full rolling boil, visible as large bubbles breaking continuously at the surface. As soon as the water reaches a rolling boil, cover the pan with the lid, remove from heat, and set a timer for 9 minutes. This method produces tender, not rubbery, egg whites and fully set, creamy golden yolks with no unappetizing green ring around the edge.
Shock Eggs in Ice Bath
When the 9-minute timer goes off, use the slotted stainless steel spoon to immediately transfer all eggs from the hot water to the prepared ice bath. Let eggs chill fully submerged for 5 minutes: this stops the cooking process instantly to prevent overcooked yolks, and contracts the egg white away from the shell to make peeling fast and easy with no torn egg whites.
Peel and Chop Eggs
Lift cooled eggs from the ice bath one at a time, tap firmly against the birch cutting board to crack the shell across the entire surface, then peel away the shell, using a quick rinse under cool water to wash away any tiny stuck shell fragments. Pat peeled eggs dry with the corner of the indigo linen towel, then use the chef knife to chop eggs into rough 1/4-inch chunks. Leave some pieces slightly larger for texture, rather than mashing to a smooth paste, for the best mouthfeel.
Mix Creamy Dressing Base
In the 2-quart stainless steel mixing bowl, combine the 1/2 cup full-fat mayonnaise, 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard, 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar, 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt, and 1/4 teaspoon freshly cracked black pepper. Stir with the light blue silicone spatula until completely smooth, with no streaks of mustard remaining. Fold in the finely diced celery and 2 tablespoons chopped fresh dill, stirring just enough to distribute the vegetables and herbs evenly through the dressing.
Fold Eggs Into Dressing
Scrape the chopped egg chunks from the cutting board into the mixing bowl with the prepared dressing. Use the light blue silicone spatula to fold the eggs gently into the dressing, lifting from the bottom of the bowl and turning over, just until all egg pieces are evenly coated. Do not overmix, as this will mash the eggs and turn the salad mushy. Taste a small bite, and add extra salt or pepper if desired.
Lightly Toast Bread
Let the mixed egg salad rest for 5 minutes at room temperature to let flavors meld. While it rests, lay the 8 sourdough slices in a single layer and toast to a pale golden brown—do not toast until dark and crispy, as the bread should be soft enough to bite without squishing the egg salad out the sides. Let toast cool for 1 minute before assembling, so residual heat does not melt the mayonnaise and make the sandwich soggy.
Assemble the Sandwiches
Scoop a generous 1/2 cup of egg salad onto 4 of the toasted bread slices, spreading evenly almost to the edges of the bread. Top each with a second slice of toast, pressing down very gently to set the filling. Cut each sandwich diagonally into two triangles for easier eating and serving.
Tips
2.Avoid overchopping or mashing the eggs: a mix of rough 1/4-inch chunks and slightly smaller pieces creates a satisfying, textured bite, while fully mashed eggs turn the salad into a dense, paste-like spread that feels heavy and masks the delicate, creamy egg flavor.
3.Toast bread only to a pale golden brown, not fully crispy: overly crunchy toast will squish egg salad out the sides of the sandwich when you bite into it, while light toasting adds just enough structure to prevent sogginess without losing the soft, pillowy bread texture that pairs perfectly with creamy egg salad.

OMG this egg salad is EXACTLY what I grew up getting at our neighborhood deli back in Cleveland! I made it for my kids’ after-school snack yesterday and they both begged for seconds, even my super picky 7-year-old. The little touch of dill and paprika? Game changer. No more sad, watery egg salad for us!
Threw this together last minute for a backyard cookout over the weekend and it was gone in 10 minutes flat. Everyone kept asking where I got the recipe, I felt like a total kitchen hero. SO good on sourdough with a couple extra pickle slices, trust me.
This is my new go-to Sunday meal prep staple! It takes barely any time to whip up a big batch, and it stays good in the fridge all work week for quick lunches. 12 minute cook time for the eggs is spot on, no weird gray rings around the yolks at all.
As someone who barely knows how to boil water, this recipe was so easy to follow! I didn’t have fresh dill so I used dried, and it still slapped. Way cheaper than buying egg salad from the campus deli every week, saved me so much money already.
Brought this to our office potluck last week and I swear people were hovering over the platter. The only thing I changed was adding a tiny bit of diced celery for extra crunch, just how my grandma used to make it. 10/10, will be making this for every potluck from now on.
I’ve been making egg salad for over 60 years and I have to say, this recipe got the ratios exactly right. Not too much mayo, not too mustard-heavy, perfectly seasoned. My granddaughter said it tastes just like the ones we used to get at the downtown deli when she was little. Made my whole week.
Lightened this up a little by swapping half the mayo for plain Greek yogurt and it was still incredible! So much protein, perfect to eat after my morning gym sessions on whole grain toast. I was worried it would taste tangy but you couldn’t even tell the difference.
Worked at a New York deli for 7 years making sandwiches, and let me tell you — this recipe is legit. The secret is a tiny splash of pickle brine right? I saw someone in the comments mention extra pickles, yeah that brine is what gives it that authentic tang people chase. Don’t skip it!
Made this for a lazy Sunday brunch with my roommates and we all ate way too much. We served it on croissants with a side of potato chips and mimosas, felt like we were at a fancy little cafe instead of our tiny apartment. Zero effort, maximum payoff.
Added extra dill pickles, a sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning on top, and served it on an everything bagel instead of sliced bread. Absolute perfection. I ate two sandwiches back to back, no regrets.
Made these for my team during our lunch meeting yesterday and everyone was raving. So much better than the sad catered sandwiches we usually get. One of my coworkers is gluten free so I served hers on a gluten free wrap and she said it was the best egg salad she’s ever had.
This recipe is so easy to make gluten free, just use your favorite GF bread or wrap! I also added a little bit of yellow mustard because I love that extra tang, and it came out perfect. No weird textures, no runny mess, just perfect egg salad.
Got home late from work last night, had almost nothing in the fridge except eggs, mayo, and a couple random spices, and this recipe came together in literally 15 minutes total. No fancy ingredients, no complicated steps, just a really solid, tasty sandwich. Exactly what I needed after a long day.
Made this for my bridal shower brunch last weekend and it was a total hit! I cut the sandwiches into little tea-sized triangles and served them with fruit and mini quiches, and so many guests asked for the recipe. Felt so fancy but it was so easy to make a huge batch.
Made a double batch of this for our family camping trip over the long weekend and it held up perfectly in the cooler. No sogginess, no weird off flavors even after two days, everyone ate it for quick lunches between hikes. 10/10 for easy camping food.
I ate this for a midnight snack last night straight out of the bowl with a spoon, no bread even. It’s that good. Don’t judge me, sometimes you don’t want to deal with toasting bread at 1am, you just want really good egg salad.