best potatoes for pot roast
intro
Velvety, flavor-packed mixed potatoes slow-simmered in pot roast jus, with caramelized edges and tender, non-mushy texture: the ideal cozy side for Sunday roast dinners.
Ingredients
Steps
Peel and Cut Potatoes
Scrub 1.5 lbs of mixed Yukon Gold and russet potatoes under cool running water. Use the stainless steel Y-peeler to remove skins, leaving small patches of skin for extra texture and fiber if preferred. Place potatoes on the acacia wood cutting board, and use the chef's knife to cut them into uniform 2-inch chunks—this size ensures they cook evenly without falling apart during braising. Place cut chunks in the small cream ramekin temporarily as you work. Avoid cutting chunks smaller than 1.5 inches, as this will cause them to turn mushy as they cook.
Toss with Seasonings
Transfer the cut potato chunks from the ramekin to a clear work area on the acacia cutting board. Sprinkle evenly with 1 tsp kosher salt and 1/2 tsp freshly cracked black pepper, then toss gently with clean hands to coat every chunk. Tuck the 4 lightly crushed garlic cloves and 2-inch yellow onion wedges in with the potatoes, and scatter 2 of the thyme sprigs over top. Do not over-stir, as this can break the rough potato edges and lead to mushy results.
Warm Braising Jus
Position the 6-quart forest green enameled Dutch oven in its fixed center-right spot, heating over medium-low stovetop heat (325°F if using an oven to finish the pot roast). Add the 2 tbsp of unsalted butter to the pot, and once fully melted, pour in 1 cup of reserved pot roast braising jus. Bring the liquid to a gentle simmer (not a rolling boil), which takes about 3 minutes—you will see small, steady bubbles breaking the surface. Starting with hot liquid ensures even cooking from the moment the potatoes are added.
Add Potatoes to Jus
Carefully transfer all the seasoned potato chunks, onion wedges, garlic, and thyme sprigs into the simmering jus in the Dutch oven. Arrange the chunks in a loose, even layer so each piece is partially submerged in the liquid—do not fully submerge chunks, as the exposed top edges will caramelize slightly as they cook. Use the slotted spoon to baste a small amount of jus over the top of each potato chunk to coat evenly.
Slow Simmer Until Tender
Place the lid securely on the Dutch oven, and reduce stovetop heat to low (or transfer to the preheated 325°F oven). Let the potatoes braise covered for 45 minutes, resisting the urge to stir repeatedly (stirring breaks down tender potato edges). Remove the lid after 45 minutes, turn heat up slightly to medium-low, and cook uncovered for 5 more minutes to reduce the jus to a glossy coating and caramelize exposed potato edges. Test doneness by inserting the tip of the chef's knife into the center of the largest potato chunk: the knife should slide all the way through with gentle pressure, but the chunk should hold its shape when lifted with the slotted spoon. If the knife meets hard resistance, cook for 5 more minutes before retesting.
Let Potatoes Rest
Turn off the heat, and set the lid loosely on the Dutch oven (leaving a small gap for steam to escape) to let the potatoes rest for 5 minutes. This rest period allows the potatoes to absorb remaining jus and set slightly, so they do not break apart when served. Discard the woody spent thyme sprigs before plating.
Plate and Garnish
Use the slotted spoon to lift potato chunks, onion wedges, and soft garlic from the Dutch oven, letting excess jus drip back into the pot to avoid soggy plates. Pile the potatoes gently onto the matte cream ceramic dinner plate, spoon 1 tbsp of the reduced jus over the top, and garnish with leaves picked from the remaining fresh thyme sprig. Serve immediately alongside sliced pot roast.
Tips
2.Wait to add potatoes to the pot roast until the last 50 minutes of total cook time: adding them too early causes them to overcook and dissolve into the jus, leaving you with starchy gravy and no distinct, tender potato pieces.
3.Arrange potato chunks so they are only partially submerged in jus: the exposed tops will develop a slightly firm, caramelized texture as they braise, creating a pleasant textural contrast to the soft, jus-soaked interior of each chunk.

OMG, I’ve been using the wrong potatoes for pot roast my whole adult life?! Tried these Yukon golds per the recipe last night for Sunday family dinner and they were perfectly fluffy, not mushy at all even after slow simmering with the chuck roast. Total game changer, even my super picky 7 year old asked for seconds! Cook time was spot on 50 minutes too, no guesswork.
Super easy recipe to follow, I prepped these potatoes ahead for my weekly meal prep and they held up perfectly all week when I reheated them with leftover pot roast and gravy. SO good, didn’t get that weird mushy reheated potato texture I usually deal with. Will be my go-to from now on.
Wait, quick question – I only have red potatoes on hand right now, will those work instead? I’m making pot roast for a potluck at work tomorrow and don’t have time to run to the grocery store!
Made this for my buddy’s watch party last weekend alongside the pot roast, and everyone was raving about the potatoes! I was worried they’d be underdone since I’m used to roasting potatoes for over an hour, but 50 minutes was exactly right, crispy edges, soft center, soaked up all that pot roast juice perfectly.
As someone who burns every side dish I make, this recipe was foolproof! So easy, I didn’t even have to babysit the pot, the potatoes came out perfect on the first try. My husband thought I spent hours on dinner, lol.
I added a handful of baby carrots and pearl onions in with the potatoes per the recipe’s little note at the bottom, and wow, the whole pot roast spread came out restaurant quality. The potatoes didn’t disintegrate when I stirred everything, which is usually my biggest pet peeve. 10/10.
First time ever making pot roast for my mom’s birthday dinner, and I was so stressed about the sides turning out bad. This guide to picking the right potatoes was so straightforward, I didn’t overthink it, grabbed the recommended Yukon Golds, cooked them for the 50 minutes as written, and my mom said they were the best part of the meal! So happy I found this.