best potatoes for potato bake
intro
Silky, tender creamy potato bake with a crisp golden cheesy top, made with the ideal potato mix to avoid soggy slices and deliver perfect cozy comfort food flavor.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Potatoes, Preheat Oven
Preheat your oven to 180°C (350°F) with a rack positioned in the middle. Scrub Russet and Yukon Gold potatoes under cool running water to remove all surface dirt, then pat completely dry with the faded indigo cotton kitchen towel. Peel potatoes if you prefer a smooth, uniform texture; leaving thin, clean skins on adds a subtle rustic bite.
Slice Potatoes Evenly
Use the matte white mandoline slicer (or sharp 7-inch chef’s knife) to cut potatoes into uniform 3mm (1/8 inch) thick slices. Consistent thickness ensures every slice cooks at the same rate, preventing undercooked crunchy bits or overcooked mushy slices. Do not soak potato slices in water, as this removes the starch needed to thicken the cream sauce naturally.
Sauté Aromatic Base
Melt 30g unsalted butter in the 3-quart stainless steel saucepan over medium-low heat. Finely dice the yellow onion, mince the 3 garlic cloves, and add to the melted butter. Sauté for 4-5 minutes until onion is soft and translucent (not browned), stirring occasionally with the pale grey silicone spatula. Browning onion will add a bitter, dark flavor that overwhelms the delicate potato taste.
Warm Cream Seasoning
Pour 300ml heavy cream into the saucepan with the sautéed onion and garlic. Add 1 tsp kosher salt, 1/2 tsp freshly ground black pepper, 1/4 tsp freshly grated nutmeg, and leaves stripped from 3 fresh thyme sprigs. Stir gently with the silicone spatula, and heat until the cream just starts to simmer around the edges (do not bring to a rolling boil, as this can cause cream to split during baking). Remove from heat immediately once small bubbles appear.
Layer Potatoes and Cream
Arrange 1/3 of the sliced potatoes in overlapping, shingled rows across the bottom of the matte white ceramic baking dish. Season lightly with a pinch of the remaining 0.5 tsp kosher salt, then pour 1/3 of the warm cream mixture over the potatoes, and sprinkle with 1/4 of the grated sharp cheddar. Repeat this layering process two more times, finishing with a final neat layer of potatoes, and pour any remaining cream over the top to ensure all slices are moistened.
Bake Covered First
Sprinkle 3/4 of the remaining grated cheddar cheese evenly over the top layer of potatoes. Cover the baking dish tightly with aluminum foil, ensuring the foil does not touch the cheese surface to prevent sticking. Place in the preheated 180°C (350°F) oven and bake for 45 minutes, until potatoes are almost tender when pierced with a knife through the foil.
Crisp Top and Rest
Carefully remove the aluminum foil from the baking dish (watch for escaping hot steam). Increase oven temperature to 200°C (400°F), and bake uncovered for an additional 20-25 minutes, until the top cheese is bubbly, deep golden brown in spots, and a knife slides through potato layers with no resistance. Remove from oven and let rest 10 minutes before serving to allow the cream to set, so slices hold their shape when plated.
Tips
2.Never soak sliced potatoes in water: the thin starchy coating on cut potato slices is what naturally thickens the cream as it bakes, creating a cohesive, non-runny texture. Soaking washes this starch away and results in separated, watery cream that pools at the bottom of the dish.
3.Always bake covered for the first 45 minutes: trapped steam cooks potatoes evenly from all sides, preventing the top cheese layer from burning before the center potatoes are tender. Removing foil for the final 20-25 minutes creates a perfectly crisp, golden cheese top without overcooking the layers.

OMG this creamy potato bake was the star of our Sunday family dinner! My kids loved it, they went back for seconds AND thirds—even my super picky 7 year old cleaned his plate. It was so easy to throw together too, perfect for when I don’t feel like fussing with a million ingredients. SO good, I’m already making it again for our neighborhood potluck next weekend!
Game changer for weeknight sides! I was worried it’d be too heavy but the cream balance is perfect, not gloppy at all. Cook time was exactly as listed, came out bubbly and golden on top right at 70 minutes. 10/10, will be a regular in our meal prep rotation.
This was super tasty! I added a handful of shredded cheddar and a sprinkle of crispy bacon on top the last 10 minutes of baking and it was chef’s kiss. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish the recipe noted you should slice the potatoes super thin for the best texture, mine were a little chunky on the first try.
Just pulled this out of the oven for our office potluck and the whole break room smells insane. I snuck a tiny bite before bringing it in and WOW, that creamy garlic flavor is unreal. Already got three people asking me for the recipe before I even set the dish down!
I’ve tried so many creamy potato bake recipes that end up watery or bland, and this one is NONE of that. The garlic and hint of nutmeg? *Chef’s kiss* My husband said it’s better than the one his grandma used to make, which is the highest possible compliment in our house.
Super easy even for a total beginner like me! I barely know how to boil water and this turned out perfect first try. I didn’t have heavy cream so I used half and half and it still came out creamy and delicious, no issues at all.
Made this to go with our baked ham for Easter dinner and every single person at the table raved about it. My sister in law is gluten free and I was so happy this recipe doesn’t use any weird thickeners or flour, she could eat it no problem! Will be our go-to potato side for every holiday from now on.
Just prepped this ahead for next week’s dinners and I’m already obsessed. It assembled in like 15 minutes flat, I popped it in the fridge and I’ll just bake it when I get home from work on Monday. No fuss, no mess, exactly the kind of recipe I need for busy school nights. The recipe says it reheats great so I’m stoked to have easy sides all week.
Flavor is 10/10 but the top didn’t get that golden crispy edge I was hoping for. Next time I’ll crank the broiler for the last 2 minutes to get that crunchy top I love, otherwise it was perfect, super creamy and the potatoes were cooked all the way through.
I mixed in a handful of thinly sliced sweet onion with the potato layers and it added the best little sweet, savory kick. This recipe is so versatile, you can add whatever little mix-ins you love and it still turns out perfect. Even my teenager who hates all vegetables ate two full servings!
I’ve never made a potato bake before in my life and this was so straightforward! No fancy skills needed, no weird equipment, just simple ingredients and clear instructions. It came out so creamy and delicious, my roommate thought I ordered it from a fancy steakhouse. Total win for a first try!
I cut this recipe in half since it’s just me and my partner, and it worked perfectly! Baked in a smaller casserole dish for about 55 minutes instead of the full 70 and it came out exactly right, no dry spots, no undercooked potatoes. Will be making this at least once a month.
Wait a second, this is better than any scalloped potato recipe I’ve ever made! The cream is so flavorful, not just bland cream and potatoes. I brought it to a friend’s BBQ last weekend and people were scraping the dish clean, no leftovers at all. 100% adding this to my permanent recipe box.