best roast beef sandwich
intro
Juicy, paper-thin medium-rare roast beef piled on crusty sourdough with zesty horseradish cream, caramelized onions, and peppery arugula—this is the ultimate, flavor-packed roast beef sandwich.
Ingredients
Steps
Season the Beef Roast
Pat the 680g eye of round roast completely dry with paper towels (use the corner of the indigo kitchen towel if needed). Rub the entire surface with 1 tablespoon olive oil, then coat evenly with 1 tablespoon kosher salt, 1 teaspoon black pepper, and 1 teaspoon garlic powder, pressing the seasonings firmly into the meat to adhere. Let the roast rest at room temperature for 20 minutes to take the chill off, which ensures even cooking.
Roast to Medium-Rare
Place the wire cooling rack inside the stainless steel baking sheet, then set the seasoned roast directly on the rack. Roast in a preheated 190C (375F) oven for 40–45 minutes, until the instant-read thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the roast reads 57C (135F) for perfect medium-rare, with a rosy pink center. Do not overcook, as eye of round is lean and will become tough if cooked past medium.
Rest the Roasted Beef
Transfer the baking sheet with the roast back to the counter, and tent the beef loosely with a small piece of aluminum foil. Let it rest for a full 15 minutes to allow the muscle fibers to relax and redistribute juices, so every slice stays juicy instead of leaking juice when cut. Do not skip this step—rushing slicing will result in dry, wasted beef.
Caramelize Yellow Onions
While the roast rests, heat 1 tablespoon unsalted butter in the 20cm carbon steel skillet over medium-low heat. Add the thinly sliced yellow onion, and cook slowly for 12–15 minutes, stirring occasionally, until the onions are soft, deep golden brown, and sweet. Do not turn the heat too high, as this will burn the onions instead of caramelizing them.
Slice Beef Paper-Thin
After the 15-minute rest, transfer the roast to the light oak cutting board. Using the sharp 8-inch chef’s knife, slice the beef against the grain into paper-thin slices, roughly 3mm (1/8 inch) thick. Thin slicing ensures the beef is tender, even with the lean eye of round cut. Collect any accumulated beef jus from the cutting board and baking sheet to drizzle over sandwiches later.
Mix Horseradish Cream
In the small stainless steel mixing bowl, combine 1/2 cup full-fat sour cream, 2 tablespoons well-drained prepared horseradish, and 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard. Stir with a small spoon until completely smooth, then season with a tiny pinch of salt and pepper to taste. Drain the horseradish well to avoid a watery sauce that makes bread soggy.
Toast Sourdough Slices
Lay the 8 thick sourdough slices on a clean section of the counter, then spread a thin layer of soft butter on one side of each slice. Toast the slices butter-side down in the same carbon steel skillet used for onions over medium heat for 2 minutes per side, until golden and crisp on the surface, but still soft in the center. Crisp toast prevents the sandwich from getting soggy from sauce and beef jus.
Layer and Serve Sandwiches
Lay 4 toasted sourdough slices toasted-side down on the clean work surface. Spread a thick layer of horseradish cream on each slice, then pile 4–5 thin slices of roast beef on top, drizzle with a tiny spoonful of reserved beef jus, add a heaping 1/2 cup of fresh arugula and a spoonful of caramelized onions. Top with the second toasted bread slice, spread with a thin extra layer of horseradish cream, then cut each sandwich diagonally in half. Transfer to the cream white ceramic oval plate to serve.
Tips
2.Drain prepared horseradish thoroughly before mixing into the cream sauce: excess vinegar and watery brine from the jar will seep into the bread and make sandwiches soggy within minutes, especially if packing them for a picnic or potluck.
3.Let the beef rest a full 15 minutes before slicing: cutting hot beef straight out of the oven causes all the flavorful, juicy liquid to run out onto the cutting board, leaving you with dry, bland meat and no rich jus to drizzle over the finished sandwich.

OMG this roast beef sandwich is a total game changer! I made it for our Sunday family dinner and everyone went back for seconds. The horseradish mayo is chef’s kiss, I didn’t even change a single thing. Total cook time was right around 50 minutes like the recipe said, no annoying surprises. 10/10 will be making this for our next neighborhood potluck too!
This was SO good, though I will say the difficulty felt a little higher than medium for me? I overcooked the roast a touch on my first try because my oven runs hot, but even slightly well done the sandwiches were a hit with my kids. I added a little extra sharp cheddar and some pickled red onions on top, highly recommend that easy tweak!
Absolute meal prep win! I made a full batch on Sunday, wrapped the sandwiches individually, and had easy work lunches all week long. The side au jus is chef’s kiss — I felt like I was eating a restaurant-quality sandwich at my desk for $2 a serving instead of dropping $15 at the deli down the street. This is going on regular meal rotation for sure!
Made these for my husband’s birthday cookout and every single guest asked for the recipe! I was worried 50 minutes of cook time would be too long for a party, but I roasted the beef ahead of time and assembled the sandwiches right before serving, and it worked perfectly. The crispy fried onions on top? Unreal. Can’t say enough good things about this recipe!
Solid roast beef sandwich recipe, though I had to make a couple swaps because my grocery store was totally out of horseradish. I mixed spicy brown mustard and a splash of hot sauce into the mayo instead, and it still turned out pretty tasty. Next time I’ll plan ahead and grab horseradish for the real deal, I bet it’s even better.
Just finished making these and OMG, my whole house smells incredible. I snuck a bite before my partner got home and it’s even better than the roast beef sandwiches we get at our favorite local pub. The garlic butter spread on the toasted buns? Game. Changer. Already know this is going to be a regular weekend staple for us.