best tuna fish sandwich
intro
Creamy, briny, perfectly seasoned tuna salad piled high on crisp toasted sourdough with cool lettuce and juicy tomato—this nostalgic, balanced sandwich is ideal for summer lunches and picnics.
Ingredients
Steps
Drain and Flake Tuna
Use the stainless steel can opener to open both 5oz cans of albacore tuna. Hold each can tilted over the sink, pressing the lid gently against the tuna to drain every drop of excess water—any leftover water will make tuna salad watery. Transfer fully drained tuna to the clear glass mixing bowl, then use the stainless steel fork to flake tuna into fine, even pieces, breaking up large clumps until no chunks larger than a pea remain. Do not over-mash into a paste; the salad should have light, distinct texture.
Dice Crunchy Vegetables
Place the two celery stalks and small section of red onion on the maple cutting board. Use the 8-inch chef’s knife to dice celery into uniform 3mm pieces (tiny, so they add subtle crunch without creating large, overwhelming bites) and mince red onion even finer, to about 1mm pieces, to avoid harsh, sharp raw onion bites that overpower the tuna. Pluck fresh dill fronds from the potted plant on the back counter, discarding thick tough stems, then chop 1 tablespoon of the fronds. Transfer each prepped vegetable to its own small white ceramic ramekin to keep ingredients organized.
Combine Salad Ingredients
Add the diced celery, minced red onion, chopped dill, 1/3 cup full-fat mayonnaise, 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard, and 1 teaspoon freshly squeezed lemon juice (squeezed from the whole lemon on the counter, seeds strained out) to the bowl of flaked tuna. Season with 1/4 teaspoon flaky sea salt from the glass salt cellar and 1/8 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper, ground directly from the matte black wood pepper mill. Use the stainless steel fork to fold all ingredients together gently, until every bit of tuna is evenly coated in creamy dressing. Taste and adjust seasoning if needed—add a pinch more salt or tiny extra squeeze of lemon if the salad tastes flat. Do not over-stir, which will turn the salad mushy.
Toast Bread Slices
Spread a thin, even layer of softened unsalted butter on one side of each of the 8 sourdough slices. Place two buttered slices at a time into the matte silver 2-slice toaster, and toast on medium heat for 1.5 to 2 minutes, until the surface is golden crisp with light tan edges, but not dark brown or burnt. Remove toasted slices from the toaster and set them on the edge of the maple cutting board to cool for 30 seconds—spreading cold tuna salad on piping hot bread will melt mayonnaise and create soggy bread.
Layer Sandwich Fillings
Lay 4 of the toasted sourdough slices flat on the maple cutting board, toasted side facing up. Divide the creamy tuna salad evenly between the 4 slices, spreading it in a 1.5cm thick even layer all the way to the edges of the bread. Before adding tomato slices, pat each slice lightly with the cream linen towel to remove excess juicy seeds and surface moisture—this is critical to prevent soggy bread. Top the tuna salad with one dried thick slice of ripe beefsteak tomato and one crisp leaf of iceberg lettuce, torn to fit the bread size so it does not hang over edges. Place the remaining 4 toasted sourdough slices on top, toasted side facing down against the fillings, to form 4 full, evenly layered sandwiches.
Cut and Plate Servings
Use the 8-inch chef’s knife to cut each assembled sandwich diagonally into two equal triangles, pressing straight down through the layers in one smooth motion (do not saw back and forth through the bread, which will squeeze tuna filling out the sides). Transfer two sandwich halves (one full sandwich) to the top matte white stoneware dinner plate from the stack, arranging triangles so the cut cross-section faces outward to show distinct layers of toast, tuna, tomato, and lettuce. Tuck two small dill pickle spears next to the sandwich on the plate for serving, and garnish with a single tiny dill frond on top. If packing for a picnic, wrap each sandwich tightly in uncoated parchment paper to hold layers together.
Tips
2.Skip sweet pickle relish in classic deli tuna salad if you want a balanced, non-cloying flavor. The tiny, crisp dice of celery and bright, herbaceous note from fresh dill adds far better texture and brightness without the sugary aftertaste that masks the delicate flavor of the tuna. If you love pickles, serve them as a crunchy side instead of mixing them into the salad.
3.Two small steps prevent soggy sandwiches every time: pat tomato slices dry to remove excess juice, and let toasted bread cool for 30 seconds before assembling. These steps keep your sandwich crisp and intact for up to 4 hours, making it perfect for packing for picnics, hikes, or work lunches without ending up with a mushy mess.

OMG this is the exact tuna sandwich I used to get from my corner deli in Brooklyn growing up! I never could get the ratio of mayo to relish right before, but this recipe nailed it. Threw in a little extra dill because I’m obsessed, and my husband ate two in one sitting. 10/10, will be making this for weekly meal prep for work lunches!
Super easy to throw together between meetings! I only had chunk light tuna instead of solid white albacore, and it still came out SO good. Skipped the red onion because I have a big client call later, no ragrets. Would make again for a quick lunch.
Made this before a day hike up in the Rockies last weekend, wrapped it tight in parchment paper and it held up perfectly in my pack! The little squeeze of lemon makes all the difference, I never used to add that before. Total game changer for quick trail lunches
Wait this takes literally 2 minutes? I’m a senior in college with basically no kitchen supplies besides a bowl and a butter knife, and I made this last night with tuna packets I had stashed in my dorm! So much better than the sad premade sandwiches at the campus market, only complaint is I wish I had pickles to add on top.
My kids are so picky about tuna salad—usually they pick out all the onion and complain it’s “too fishy”. Tried this recipe yesterday for lunch and all three of them asked for seconds! My kids loved it so much they asked me to make it again for their school lunches next week. Even my husband who swears he “doesn’t do tuna sandwiches” ate half of mine. Wild.
I make this every Sunday for post-gym lunches during the week! I swap half the mayo for plain Greek yogurt to bump up the protein, and it’s still so creamy and delicious. Piled high with tomato and spinach on whole wheat, hits every time.
Brought these to our office potluck last week, cut them into little slider sized bites on Hawaiian rolls, and they were gone in 10 minutes! Multiple people asked me for the recipe, I told ‘em I found it here. Only thing I added was a sprinkle of Old Bay on top, *chef’s kiss*
Has anyone tried this on gluten free bread? I have celiac and have been chasing that good deli tuna sandwich vibe forever, but most gluten free bread gets so soggy if I don’t eat it immediately. Any tips?
Look, I’m a simple guy. I don’t need no fancy truffle oil or artisanal whatever in my tuna sandwich. This recipe uses stuff I already had in my pantry, takes 2 whole minutes, and tastes like it came from the fancy deli downtown that charges $12 a sandwich. Absolute banger.
Made these for a casual brunch with my girlfriends last weekend, served them alongside pickles and potato chips, and everyone raved! I added a little chopped celery for extra crunch, which was chef’s kiss. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular rotation.
Wait I messed up and used sweet relish instead of dill pickle relish when I made this earlier! I was panicking it would be ruined, but it actually was really good? My date didn’t even notice a difference, he said it was the best tuna sandwich he’s ever had. Wild win for kitchen mistakes!
I’ve been making tuna salad for 40 years, and I have to say, this recipe is the best one I’ve ever tried! The little bit of Dijon mustard is the secret ingredient I was missing all these years. My grandkids go crazy for it when they come to visit.
Made a batch of these before our cross-country road trip from Chicago to Phoenix last week, stored ‘em in the cooler, and they were perfect for quick stops so we didn’t have to eat fast food the whole time. Held up great for 3 days, no sogginess, tasted amazing.
I’ve been trying to eat less meat lately, and this tuna sandwich is the perfect go-to for quick lunches! I used a little less mayo and added some diced avocado on top, it was so creamy and satisfying. Even my meat-loving roommate stole a bite and asked for the recipe.
Fun fact: I worked at a Jewish deli in Manhattan for 6 years during college, and this recipe is dead on for what we served. The only thing missing is the half-sour pickle on the side, and rye bread toasted with a schmear of cream cheese. Trust me, try the cream cheese, it’s life changing.