Chicken Salad Sandwich
intro
Creamy, crunchy, perfectly seasoned cold chicken salad piled on soft bread: a nostalgic, portable meal ideal for warm summer gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Poach the chicken breasts
Place 450g boneless, skinless chicken breasts in a small saucepan, cover with 5cm of cold water, bring to a gentle simmer over medium heat (85°C/185°F, no rolling boil), then reduce heat to low, cover, and cook for 12 minutes until chicken reaches an internal temperature of 74°C/165°F. Remove chicken from water and let rest 10 minutes to cool slightly.
Prep crunchy mix-ins
While the chicken cooks and cools, finely dice 100g celery stalks, 50g red onion, and 60g dill pickles into uniform 3mm pieces, then chop 6g fresh dill; set all prepped produce aside in a small bowl.
Mix creamy dressing
In a medium mixing bowl, whisk together 120ml full-fat mayonnaise, 15ml Dijon mustard, 15ml fresh lemon juice, 2.5g celery salt, and 1g freshly ground black pepper until completely smooth, with no visible lumps of mustard remaining.
Shred cooled chicken
Once the poached chicken has rested 10 minutes and is cool enough to handle, shred it into 1-2cm bite-sized pieces using two forks pulled against the grain of the meat; discard any tough white connective tissue.
Combine chicken salad
Add the shredded chicken and prepped diced vegetables and dill to the bowl of creamy dressing, fold gently with a rubber spatula until all ingredients are evenly coated. Chill the mixture in the refrigerator for 10 minutes to let flavors meld before assembling sandwiches.
Assemble the sandwiches
Lay out 8 slices of soft sandwich bread, place one butter lettuce leaf on 4 slices, scoop 120g (≈½ cup) of chilled chicken salad onto each lettuce-topped slice, spread evenly, then top with the remaining 4 bread slices. Cut each sandwich diagonally into two triangles to serve.
Tips
2.To mellow the sharp, pungent bite of raw red onion, soak diced pieces in ice water for 10 minutes, then drain thoroughly before adding to the salad for a milder, sweeter flavor.
3.For a 10-minute quick version, replace poached chicken with 450g shredded, skinless store-bought rotisserie chicken to skip the poaching step entirely, ideal for busy days.

OMG this chicken salad is SO good! I made a double batch for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and every single sandwich was gone before I even got a second one! The creaminess is perfect, not too heavy, and the little crunch from the celery is *chef's kiss*. Will be making this for every summer get together from now on.
Total game changer for my weekly meal prep! This is so easy to throw together on Sunday afternoons, I just portion it out with some whole grain bread and a side of fruit and I’ve got lunch all week. Way cheaper and tastier than the sad cafeteria chicken salad. 10/10
My kids are so picky about chicken salad and they actually ate this without complaining! I did cut the celery a little smaller so they wouldn’t pick it out, and swapped a tiny bit of mayo for plain Greek yogurt to lighten it up. Still super creamy, will definitely make again.
Taste was great but mine came out a little runny? I followed the recipe exactly, used full fat mayo, let the chicken cool completely before mixing—any idea what went wrong? Still ate it over lettuce instead of bread and it was tasty, just not sandwich worthy for me.
Made this for a quick weeknight dinner last night when I didn’t feel like cooking anything complicated. 30 minutes start to finish, exactly what the recipe said! Piled it high on toasted sourdough with a little arugula, chef’s kiss.
I’ve been making chicken salad for 40 years and this recipe is right up there with my late wife’s. Perfect balance of mayo, mustard, celery, and a little onion. Didn’t change a single thing, and my granddaughter asked for the recipe to take back to college. Win in my book.
This is so flavorful! I used gluten free sourdough for the sandwiches and it worked perfectly. Only thing is I wish there was a little more seasoning—next time I’ll add a pinch of paprika like my mom used to.
Made these for a girls’ brunch last Sunday and everyone was raving! I added halved red grapes and a handful of chopped pecans for extra texture and sweetness, and served them on mini croissants. So fancy looking for how easy they are to make!
High protein, super filling, tastes way better than the store-bought chicken salad I usually grab after the gym. I used leftover grilled chicken from last night’s cookout instead of boiling it and it added such a nice smoky flavor. Will be on regular rotation for post-gym lunches.
Wait I just made this and it’s literally the first recipe I haven’t messed up all month. It’s so easy even I can do it! I didn’t have fresh parsley so I used dried and it still slapped. 10/10 no notes.
Brought this in for our office team lunch and people were coming back for seconds and thirds. Only knock is I wish the recipe specified how much salt to add? I undersalted at first and had to adjust, but once I did it was perfect.
So happy this works with vegan mayo! I have a dairy allergy and most creamy chicken salad recipes are off limits for me, but swapping in my regular dairy free mayo didn’t change the texture or flavor at all. My whole family (who eats regular mayo) didn’t even notice a difference!
Y’all, this is the exact chicken salad my grandma used to make for Sunday lunch after church. No weird add-ins, just simple, classic flavor, creamy but not gloopy, perfect on white bread with a side of potato chips. Pure comfort food, I’m so happy I found this recipe!
Made this ahead for our weekend camping trip and it held up so well in the cooler! We ate it on sandwich thins for our first day hike and it was the perfect light but filling meal after a few miles of walking. No soggy bread, no weird texture, total win.
My toddler is going through a ‘no crunchy food’ phase so I left out the celery and onion, blended a tiny bit of the chicken to make it extra smooth, and she ate two whole mini sandwiches! I missed the crunch but it was worth it to get her to eat protein without a fight. Definitely will make it the regular way once she’s out of this phase.
Just finished whipping this up for the week and oh my gosh my kitchen smells so good! I added a little chopped fresh dill because I had it leftover from another recipe, and did half mayo half Greek yogurt to lighten it up a bit. Tasted a spoonful while I was portioning it and I already know this is going to be a new staple. Can’t wait to have it for lunch tomorrow!