Chopped Liver Sandwich
intro
Rich, umami-packed chopped liver piled high on seeded rye, balanced with sweet caramelized onion, hard-boiled egg, and a thin layer of onion jam — a classic Jewish deli sandwich full of cozy, nostalgic comfort.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Chicken Livers
Place trimmed chicken livers on the maple cutting board. Use the chef knife to cut away any remaining green bile spots or tough white connective tissue. Pat livers completely dry with a paper towel sheet, season lightly with 1/2 tsp kosher salt. Dry livers will sear evenly instead of steaming in the pan, and reduce hot fat splatter.
Caramelize Yellow Onions
Heat 2 tbsp schmaltz in the carbon steel skillet over medium-low heat (325°F pan surface). Add thinly sliced onions, stir with the beech wood turner to coat fully in fat. Cook slowly for 15 minutes, stirring every 2-3 minutes, until onions are deep golden amber, completely soft, and naturally sweet, with no crisp pale raw edges remaining. Do not turn heat too high, as this will burn the onions before they caramelize. Transfer finished caramelized onions to the stainless steel mixing bowl, set aside.
Sear Chicken Livers
Increase skillet heat to medium, add remaining 1 tbsp schmaltz. Once schmaltz shimmers, add dried, seasoned livers to the pan in a single layer, working in two batches if needed to avoid crowding. Cook 3 minutes per side, until livers develop a deep mahogany sear on the outside, with a faint blush of pink at the very center (internal temperature 160°F / 71°C). Overcooking will result in dry, grainy livers, so remove from heat promptly once seared. Transfer cooked livers to the mixing bowl with the reserved caramelized onions.
Mash Liver Mixture
Add peeled hard-boiled eggs, remaining 1/2 tsp kosher salt, and 1/2 tsp freshly ground black pepper to the mixing bowl with cooked livers and caramelized onions. Use the stainless steel potato masher to work the mixture into a coarse, spreadable consistency — stop mashing while small, rustic chunks of liver, soft onion, and crumbled egg are still visible; over-mashing to a smooth paste will result in a heavy, pasty texture. Taste and adjust salt and pepper to preference.
Toast and Prep Bread
Wipe the carbon steel skillet clean with a paper towel, then place over medium heat. Lay rye bread slices in the dry skillet in batches, toasting 1 minute per side until edges are lightly crisp and the bread is warm through, with no dark burnt spots. Transfer toasted slices to the cutting board, then spread 1/2 tbsp sweet onion jam evenly across one side of each slice. The thin, sweet jam layer balances the rich, savory depth of the chopped liver.
Assemble Sandwiches
Scoop a generous 1/2 cup of the chopped liver mixture onto the jam-coated side of 4 of the toasted rye slices, spreading the mixture evenly all the way to the bread edges. Sprinkle 1 tsp of chopped fresh parsley over the liver layer on each sandwich, then top with the remaining 4 rye slices, jam-side facing down toward the filling. Press each sandwich gently with the palm of your hand to help the layers adhere.
Cut and Plate Sandwiches
Use the serrated bread knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two equal triangular halves, using a smooth sawing motion to avoid squishing the filling out. Arrange two halves per matte cream dinner plate, leaning the halves against each other slightly, and tuck a small sprig of fresh parsley next to the sandwich as garnish. Serve immediately for best flavor and texture.
Tips
2.Avoid overcooking livers and over-mashing the mixture: livers cooked past a faint pink center turn dry, grainy, and bitter, while over-mashing to a smooth paste creates a heavy, pasty texture that lacks the rustic, satisfying mouthfeel of classic deli chopped liver.
3.Use schmaltz (rendered chicken fat) for the most authentic flavor: its rich, savory profile is the traditional fat for Jewish deli chopped liver, pairing perfectly with sweet caramelized onions. If schmaltz is unavailable, rendered duck fat is the closest substitute, followed by neutral avocado oil — avoid butter, which will burn at the high searing temperature needed for livers.

OMG this chopped liver sandwich tastes exactly like the ones my bubbe used to make when I was a kid growing up in Brooklyn! The caramelized onions are the perfect touch, not too overpowering, and the texture is so smooth, no weird grainy bits. I slathered it on rye with a little extra mustard and it was absolute perfection. Already made it twice this week for meal prep!
Brought these sandwiches cut into sliders to my neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and they were gone in 10 minutes flat! So many people asked for the recipe I lost count. I added a tiny sprinkle of paprika on top for a little color and it was chef’s kiss. Will absolutely be making these again for our next family dinner.
Tried making chopped liver for the first time ever because my partner loves it, and this recipe was super straightforward even for a medium difficulty dish! Only hiccup was I overcooked the liver a tiny bit so it was a little drier than I wanted, but still tasted great. Next time I’ll pull it off the heat a minute earlier like the recipe says, oops.
My kids are super picky and I was so nervous they’d turn their noses up at this, but they both asked for seconds! I served the sandwiches with a side of pickles and potato chips, and my husband said it’s better than the chopped liver we get at our local deli. Total weeknight win, 25 minute cook time is totally doable even with soccer practice running late.
Game changer! I’ve always hated store-bought chopped liver because it’s too salty and has a weird metallic aftertaste, but homemade with this recipe? SO good. I did swap the schmaltz for a little duck fat because I had it on hand, would that throw off the flavor too much if I keep doing that?
Wait, is there a way to lighten this up a little? I love chopped liver sandwiches but I’m trying to cut down on saturated fat, would using a light mayo or even Greek yogurt work as a mix-in instead of all the schmaltz?
Made this for my husband’s birthday since he’s been craving a proper deli-style chopped liver sandwich since we moved away from NYC, and he teared up a little when he took the first bite! Only thing is, my chopped liver came out a little chunkier than the photo shows—did I not blend it long enough?
Made these for our football watch party last Sunday and they were a huge hit with the crew! I added a slice of Swiss and some pickled red onion on each sandwich and people were raving. Who knew chopped liver would be such a hit with a bunch of guys who usually only eat wings and pizza?
I’ve only cooked liver once before and it came out totally over-salted, so I was super careful with seasoning when I made this, but I ended up under-seasoning it so it was a little bland. The recipe says salt and pepper to taste, but about how much do you usually add when you make this? I want to get it right next time because the texture was perfect, I just missed the mark on seasoning.
How long does the chopped liver stay good in the fridge for? I want to make a big batch on Sunday to have sandwiches for lunch all week, but I don’t want it to go bad before I can eat it all. Also, does it freeze well?
I run a small Jewish deli outside of Atlanta and I’ve been testing new chopped liver recipes for our menu, and this one is a home run! I adjusted the cook time just a touch to work for our big batch sizes, and our regulars have been raving about it since we added it last week. Absolute game changer for our sandwich lineup.
I am OBSESSED with garlic so I added three extra cloves when I made this, and honestly? It was so good I could’ve eaten the whole bowl of chopped liver by itself before even putting it on bread. 10/10, will be making this monthly from now on.