copycat arby's beef and cheddar
intro
Tender thinly sliced roast beef, tangy red ranch, and gooey melted cheddar piled on a soft onion roll—this spot-on copycat tastes exactly like the classic Arby’s favorite you crave.
Ingredients
Steps
Shred Cheddar Cheese
Place the block of sharp orange cheddar on the light birch wood cutting board. Use the coarse side of the stainless steel four-sided box grater to shred the cheese into fine, even pieces. Toss shredded cheese with 1 teaspoon cornstarch until every piece is lightly coated; this coating prevents the finished cheese sauce from separating and turning grainy. Set the coated shredded cheese aside in one of the light grey ceramic ramekins.
Make Smooth Cheddar Sauce
Place the 2-quart stainless steel saucepan on the center-back of the counter over low heat (stovetop setting 2, approximately 300°F). Pour in 1/2 cup evaporated milk, and warm for 2 minutes until tiny, pinprick-sized bubbles form around the pan edge; do not bring to a rolling boil, as scalded milk will make the sauce grainy. Whisk in 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder, 1/4 teaspoon onion powder, 1/4 teaspoon sweet paprika, and 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt. Gradually add the cornstarch-coated shredded cheddar, 1/4 cup at a time, whisking constantly with the small red-handled silicone whisk until fully melted and smooth, about 3 minutes total. The finished sauce should be thick enough to evenly coat the back of a spoon, with no visible lumps. Turn heat to the lowest setting to keep the sauce warm while prepping other components.
Warm Thin Roast Beef
Slide the saucepan of warm cheddar sauce to the cool side of the counter, covering it loosely with a small piece of aluminum foil to retain heat. Return the empty (no need to wash) 2-quart stainless steel saucepan to the heat, add 1 tablespoon of water, then pile in all 450g of thinly sliced deli roast beef. Cover the pan and warm over the lowest heat setting for 2-3 minutes, tossing gently halfway through with the off-white silicone spatula, until the beef is heated through and soft. Do not overcook the beef, as thin deli slices will turn tough and rubbery if exposed to high heat or cooked too long.
Toast Soft Onion Rolls
Transfer the warm roast beef from the saucepan to a clean ramekin, and set aside covered. Take the serrated bread knife with the walnut handle, and split each onion roll horizontally if not pre-sliced. Place rolls cut-side down in the still-warm empty saucepan (residual heat is enough, no extra oil needed) for 30-45 seconds, until the cut surface is lightly golden and soft to the touch, not crispy or browned. The goal is a warm, slightly sealed bread surface that holds sauce without getting soggy, not a crunchy toasted texture.
Layer Sandwich Components
Set one warm toasted onion roll bottom on the clean section of the birch cutting board. Spread 1 tablespoon of red ranch sauce evenly across the cut surface of the bottom bun. Pile 1/4 of the warm thin roast beef onto the sauced bun, arranging slices loosely so the sandwich is light, not tightly packed. Ladle 2 tablespoons of warm cheddar sauce over the top of the roast beef, letting a small amount drip down the sides of the meat pile. Spread 1/2 tablespoon of remaining red ranch on the cut side of the top bun, then set it loosely on top of the cheese-covered beef. Repeat for all 4 sandwiches.
Plate and Serve Warm
Carefully transfer one fully assembled sandwich to the off-white matte ceramic round dinner plate. Cut the sandwich diagonally in half with the serrated bread knife, leaning one half against the other to show the distinct layers of bun, ranch, roast beef, and melted cheddar. Serve immediately while the cheese is gooey and the beef and buns are still warm.
Tips
2.Keep cheese sauce on the lowest possible heat while prepping other components; high heat will cause the cheese proteins to separate, resulting in a grainy, greasy sauce instead of the smooth, gooey texture of the original.
3.Skip crispy, crusty rolls and use soft, pillowy onion rolls — crusty bread will absorb too much sauce and become soggy, and will not match the soft, tender bite of the classic Arby’s sandwich.

OMG this is such a dead ringer for the actual Arby's sandwich! I made these for my kid's after-practice dinner last night and they all asked for seconds, even my super picky 10 year old. The cheddar sauce is *chef's kiss* no weird processed aftertaste at all. Total game changer for busy weeknights since it only takes 10 minutes!
SO good, I added a little extra horseradish to the cheddar sauce to give it that tiny kick I love from Arby's. Meal prepped a whole batch of the beef and sauce for the week and it held up perfectly for quick lunches. Way cheaper than hitting the drive thru every day!
Made these for our church potluck last Sunday and people were hounding me for the recipe all night! I doubled the batch and still ran out in 20 minutes. Who knew copycat fast food could be such a crowd pleaser?
Wait this is actually easier than I thought it would be? I was intimidated to make copycat fast food but 10 minutes total? No fancy ingredients? I'm making this for my roommates tonight for our movie night, fingers crossed it turns out!
Took the kids to Arby's last weekend and they complained the sandwich was skimpy on the meat. Made this copycat version last night and piled the beef high, they said it was way better than the real thing. Win for dad!
I swapped the regular onion bun for a gluten free sesame bun and it worked perfectly! The cheddar sauce is naturally gluten free too which was such a win, I haven't had a beef and cheddar in years since my celiac diagnosis. Thank you for this easy recipe!
Taste tested this side by side with an actual Arby's beef and cheddar today and honestly? This one is better. The cheese sauce is creamier and the beef tastes fresher, no weird rubbery texture. I did add a tiny drizzle of Arby's sauce on top though, just for that extra tang.
Uh, help? I tried making the cheese sauce and it got all lumpy? Did I do something wrong? It still tasted good but the texture was off, not smooth like the pictures.
The cheddar sauce recipe alone is worth saving! I've used it on burgers, on top of fries, even dipped pretzels in it this week. It's so rich and cheesy, not that weird neon orange goop you get at the fast food place. Obsessed.
10 minute cook time is no lie! I got home late from work, pulled the ingredients out of the fridge, and had dinner on the table before my kid even finished their homework. No fancy steps, no weird ingredients, total weeknight staple now.
Calculated the cost per sandwich and it's like $1.30 each? Compare that to almost $6 at the Arby's down the street, I'm never driving through again. I bought a whole pound of thin sliced roast beef when it was on sale at the deli and stocked up on buns, this is going to be a regular in our rotation.
Made sliders out of this recipe for our game watch party last weekend, used mini onion rolls and cut the cheese sauce a little thicker so it didn't run. Absolute home run, even my friend who swears by only takeout Arby's said he was converted. Will be making these again for the next party for sure.
Added a couple slices of pickled jalapeno to my sandwich and a dash of hot sauce in the cheese sauce, and it was chef's kiss. Perfect little kick to cut through the richness of the beef and cheese. 10/10, will make again, probably tomorrow tbh.