Egg & Cream Milkshake
intro
Velvety old-fashioned egg and cream milkshake, thick enough to hold a spoon upright, with warm vanilla and nutmeg notes and a frosty, luxuriously creamy finish.
Ingredients
Steps
Whisk Egg Yolk Base
Separate the 2 pasteurized egg yolks from their whites (reserve whites for another use, such as meringue or omelets) and place yolks in the small stainless steel mixing bowl. Add 2 tablespoons granulated sugar and 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract to the bowl. Use the small wire whisk to beat the mixture continuously for 90 seconds, until it turns pale creamy yellow, thickens slightly, and no gritty sugar texture remains when you rub a drop between your fingers.
Measure Cold Dairy
Use the clear glass 1-cup measuring cup to measure 1/3 cup cold heavy whipping cream and 2/3 cup cold whole milk, keeping both liquids chilled to 4°C (39°F) to slow ice cream melt during blending. Do not let the dairy come to room temperature, as this will result in a thin, watery final shake.
Add Base to Blender
Set the clear blender jar onto its matte silver base in its fixed center-counter position, then remove the black lid and set it on the counter beside the base. Pour the whisked egg yolk mixture first into the bottom of the blender jar, then pour in the measured cold milk and cream. Scrape the sides of the mixing bowl with the whisk to capture every drop of the sweetened yolk mixture, so no flavor is left behind.
Scoop in Ice Cream
Use the spring-loaded matte aluminum ice cream scoop to add 2.5 cups of slightly softened vanilla bean ice cream to the blender jar, packing scoops gently. For the thickest texture, ice cream should give slightly when pressed but still hold its rounded shape when scooped, not drip liquid.
Blend to Thickness
Secure the black lid tightly on the blender jar. Blend on medium-low speed for 20 to 25 seconds, pausing once to scrape down the sides of the jar with the long-handled stainless steel milkshake spoon if any ice cream sticks above the liquid line. Do not over-blend: the final mixture should be thick, smooth, and thick enough to coat the back of a spoon.
Add Fresh Nutmeg
Turn off the blender and remove the lid. Use the small beech wood nutmeg grater to grate 1/4 teaspoon of whole nutmeg directly into the blender jar. Stir the nutmeg into the milkshake with the long-handled spoon using 2 to 3 quick turns, just to distribute the spice evenly without over-mixing.
Pour and Garnish
Pour the thick milkshake evenly between the two clear diner-style milkshake cups, letting the shake mound slightly above the rim of each glass. Grate a light extra dusting of nutmeg over the top of each shake, insert one red-and-white striped paper straw into each cup, and tuck a single small mint leaf plucked from the potted terracotta plant into the froth for a fresh garnish. Serve immediately, before the shake starts to melt.
Tips
2.Chill all dairy ingredients and serving glasses ahead of time: keep cream, milk, and ice cream at refrigerator/freezer temperature until ready to use, and stick milkshake cups in the freezer for 10 minutes before pouring. Warm ingredients melt ice cream rapidly, resulting in a thin, watery shake instead of the thick, spoonable diner consistency.
3.Blend on low speed for no more than 25 seconds: over-blending breaks down ice cream crystals too much and incorporates excess air, turning the dense, creamy texture light and slushy. Stop blending as soon as no large ice cream lumps remain, even if the mixture looks slightly swirled—it will combine fully as you pour.

OMG this is so easy to throw together on busy school mornings! My kids devoured it before the bus even got here, I added a dash of cinnamon on top and it was chef’s kiss. 10/10 will be making this every week now.
Game changer. I was sick of my boring protein shakes after workouts so I swapped my usual powder for this recipe, added a scoop of vanilla protein and it tastes like an old fashioned soda shop shake. No weird raw egg aftertaste at all!
Made this for my book club potluck last weekend and everyone asked for the recipe! It’s so rich and creamy, people couldn’t believe it only took a minute to make. I served it in little mason jars with whipped cream on top, so cute.
Wait hold on, is the raw egg actually safe in this? I’ve always been nervous about no-cook egg recipes, especially since my partner is pregnant.
SO good. I was skeptical at first because egg in a milkshake sounded weird but it makes it so much frothier and richer than a regular vanilla shake. My teenager said it’s better than the fast food version down the street.
Perfect quick treat for my Sunday meal prep! I make a big batch on Sunday and portion it into to-go cups for my midday sweet treat during the work week. It holds up way better than I thought it would in the fridge, just give it a quick stir before drinking.
This tastes exactly like the egg creams my dad used to make me when I was a kid in Brooklyn! I haven’t had one in probably 40 years, this recipe is spot on. I didn’t change a single thing, it’s perfect as written.
Tried making this with plant based cream and a flax egg and it totally flopped, don’t do what I did lmao. Gonna run to the store for real eggs and heavy cream tomorrow and try again because the photos look so good.
Made these for our tailgate before the college football game last weekend and they were a hit! I added a splash of bourbon to the adult versions and everyone was coming back for seconds. So quick to whip up right in the parking lot with a portable blender.
My super picky 7 year old who refuses almost every new food asked for SECONDS of this. I’m in shock. I didn’t even add any extra sugar because the cream and little vanilla was sweet enough for him. Game changer for after school snacks.
Wait this only needs like 3 ingredients? I have eggs, milk, and cream in my dorm fridge right now from the dining hall, I’m making this tonight instead of spending money on boba. Genius.
I added a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream to mine and it was literally the creamiest milkshake I’ve ever had in my life. I don’t think I can ever go back to regular milkshakes again, the egg adds such a nice silky texture.
Worked in a 50s style diner all through high school and we made these exact milkshakes for the regulars every Saturday. This recipe is 100% authentic, no weird additives or extra stuff, just pure creamy goodness. Don’t skip the fresh nutmeg on top!
Wait I made this this morning and it was way thinner than I expected? Did I do something wrong? I blended it for like 30 seconds, used whole milk and heavy cream and a pasteurized egg.
Served these at my family brunch last Sunday instead of mimosas for the non-drinkers and everyone raved. I set up a little topping bar with sprinkles, chocolate syrup, caramel, and whipped cream so people could customize theirs. So fun!
I’m lactose intolerant so I used lactose free whole milk and lactose free heavy cream, and it worked perfectly! No tummy ache afterwards, and it tasted just as rich and creamy as the regular version I remember as a kid.
Added a tablespoon of chocolate syrup to mine and it tasted like a frosty chocolate egg cream straight from a NYC bodega. So quick, so delicious, I’ve already made it three times this week. 10/10.