Grilled Cheese with Butternut Squash

title 1
Grilled Cheese with Butternut Squash
⏱️ cook time 25 minutes
🍽️ servings 4
⚡ Difficulty easy

intro

Crispy golden sourdough grilled cheese oozing with melted sharp cheddar, layered with sweet caramelized butternut squash and earthy sage—cozy autumn comfort ready in under 45 minutes.

Ingredients

Butternut squash 350g
Sourdough bread 8 thick slices (1.5cm thick)
Sharp white cheddar cheese 180g
Unsalted butter 32g, melted
Fresh sage leaves 12 leaves (8 for cooking, 4 for garnish)
Extra virgin olive oil 1 tablespoon
Flaky sea salt 1/2 teaspoon
Freshly ground black pepper 1/4 teaspoon

Steps

1

Prep Butternut Squash

Preheat oven to 200C (400F). Place the whole butternut squash on the maple cutting board. Use the chef knife to trim 1cm off the top and bottom of the squash, then carefully peel away the tough outer skin, scoop out seeds and stringy pulp with a spoon, and slice the firm orange flesh into uniform 5mm thick half-moon slices. Transfer sliced squash to the stainless steel mixing bowl, setting peels and seeds aside for compost.

Step 1
step1:Prep Butternut Squash
2

Season Squash Slices

Drizzle the 1 tablespoon of olive oil over the squash slices in the mixing bowl, add 1/4 teaspoon flaky sea salt, 1/8 teaspoon black pepper, and 4 chopped fresh sage leaves. Toss gently with your hands until every slice is lightly and evenly coated in oil and seasoning. Line the aluminum baking sheet with the cut parchment paper sheet.

Step 2
step2:Season Squash Slices
3

Roast Squash Slices

Arrange the seasoned squash slices in a single even layer on the parchment-lined baking sheet, ensuring no slices overlap to promote even caramelization. Place the baking sheet on the middle oven rack, roast for 18-20 minutes until squash is fork-tender with lightly golden, caramelized edges. Remove from oven and set aside to cool slightly for 2 minutes.

Step 3
step3:Roast Squash Slices
Step 3
step3:Roast Squash Slices
4

Grate Sharp Cheddar

While the squash roasts, place the box grater on the maple cutting board. Grate all 180g of sharp white cheddar using the large coarse holes of the grater, collecting the grated cheese in a fluffy pile on the cutting board. Discard any small leftover bits of cheese rind. Avoid pre-grated cheese, as anti-caking additives prevent smooth, even melting.

Step 4
step4:Grate Sharp Cheddar
5

Butter Bread Slices

Lay all 8 sourdough slices flat on the maple cutting board. Use the silicone basting brush to spread a thin, even layer of melted unsalted butter across one entire side of each bread slice. Ensure full butter coverage right to the bread edges for even, golden toasting on the sandwich exterior.

Step 5
step5:Butter Bread Slices
6

Assemble Sandwiches

Place the cork trivet in the center of the counter work zone, then set the carbon steel skillet on top of the trivet to preheat over medium heat for 2 minutes (a drop of water should dance and evaporate in 2 seconds when the pan is ready). While the skillet heats, flip 4 bread slices so buttered sides face down, top each with half of the grated cheddar (divided evenly), an even single layer of roasted squash slices, 1 fresh sage leaf, a pinch of black pepper, then the remaining half of the grated cheddar. Top each stack with a second bread slice, buttered side facing up.

Step 6
step6:Assemble Sandwiches
Step 6
step6:Assemble Sandwiches
7

Grill First Sandwich Side

Carefully place 2 assembled sandwiches into the preheated skillet, leaving 2cm of space between them. Cook for 3-4 minutes over medium heat, resisting the urge to press down on the sandwiches, until the bottom bread slice is deep golden brown and crispy, and cheese along the edges has started to melt and bubble.

Step 7
step7:Grill First Sandwich Side
8

Flip and Cook Until Golden

Use the slotted metal turner spatula to carefully flip each sandwich in one smooth motion. Cook the second side for another 2-3 minutes, until equally golden and crispy, and all cheese inside is fully melted and gooey. Transfer cooked sandwiches to the cutting board to rest for 1 minute, then repeat the cooking process with the remaining 2 assembled sandwiches.

Step 8
step8:Flip and Cook Until Golden
9

Slice and Plate Sandwiches

Once all sandwiches are cooked and rested for 1 minute, use the chef knife to slice each sandwich diagonally into two triangular halves. Sprinkle the top of each sandwich with a tiny pinch of flaky sea salt, and garnish with a small fresh sage leaf. Serve immediately while warm and oozing.

Step 9
step9:Slice and Plate Sandwiches

Tips

1.Slice butternut squash to a uniform 5mm thickness: Thicker slices will not fully tenderize during the 20-minute roast and will create lumpy, hard-to-bite sandwiches, while thinner slices caramelize evenly and lay flat between bread layers for even cheese distribution.
2.Never press down on sandwiches with the spatula while grilling: Pressing squeezes melted cheese out of the bread seams and compresses the sourdough, leading to a greasy, flat sandwich instead of a light, crisp exterior with a gooey, fully contained cheese filling.
3.Let cooked sandwiches rest for 1 full minute before slicing: This short rest allows the molten cheese to set slightly, so it does not run out completely when cut, and lets trapped steam escape so the bread stays crispy instead of turning soggy.

✨ You May Also Like

Lunch
🍜 United States

Creamy, salty, tangy nostalgic Midwestern sandwich pairing rich peanut butter with crisp briny dill pickles for a fast, satisfying no-cook meal.

⏱️ 5 minutesLunch ★ 4.6
Lunch
🍜 United States

Crispy, melty pressed sandwich layered with savory roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and tangy mustard: a beloved Cuban-American comfort classic.

⏱️ 25 minuteLunch ★ 4.9
Lunch
🍜 United States

Hearty, briny New Orleans pressed sandwich stacked with cured Italian meats, provolone, and zesty olive salad, served cold for bold, portable flavor.

⏱️ 1 hour 20Lunch ★ 4.7
Lunch
🍜 United States

A tangy, creamy Southern American staple, this no-cook cheesy sandwich is packed with sharp cheddar and sweet pimentos for a satisfying, portable bite.

⏱️ 1 hour 15Lunch ★ 4.8
Lunch
🍜 United States

Crispy Cajun-spiced fried shrimp piled on crusty French bread with tangy remoulade and fresh toppings, the iconic Louisiana street food sandwich.

⏱️ 35 minuteLunch ★ 4.4
Lunch
🍜 United States

Stacked, savory deli-style corned beef sandwich with melted Swiss, tangy mustard, and crisp griddled rye— a fast, hearty, satisfying classic.

⏱️ 15 minuteLunch ★ 4.9

Grilled Cheese with Butternut Squash:Frequently Asked Questions

1.Can I use pre-cut butternut squash instead of chopping a whole one for this recipe? ▾
Absolutely—pre-cut butternut squash is a fantastic time-saver for this recipe. Just double-check that cubes are cut to a uniform ½-inch size so they roast evenly, and pat them thoroughly dry with paper towels before seasoning to prevent soggy, steamed squash instead of sweet, caramelized roasted pieces.
2.Why does my grilled cheese always turn out soggy instead of crispy on the outside? ▾
Sogginess usually comes from two common culprits: too-high heat that burns bread before cheese fully melts, or excess moisture from the roasted squash. Cook sandwiches over steady medium-low heat, and pat roasted squash pieces completely dry with a paper towel before layering to keep that sourdough perfectly crisp and golden.
3.Can I substitute a different cheese if I don’t have sharp white cheddar? ▾
Absolutely! Sharp white cheddar pairs perfectly with sweet squash, but you can swap it for gruyère for a nuttier profile, fontina for extra luxe meltiness, or smoked gouda for a cozy, warm smoky note. Just skip super soft, high-moisture cheeses like fresh mozzarella, which can make the bread soggy.
4.Do I have to use sourdough bread for this recipe, or will other bread types work? ▾
Sourdough’s tangy, sturdy crumb is ideal for holding up to heavy fillings and getting ultra-crispy, but you can swap it for other thick-cut, hearty breads. Try crusty country white, whole grain, or even rye for an earthy twist—just avoid thin, soft sandwich bread, which will get mushy under the squash and cheese.
5.How do I get the sage leaves crispy without burning them? ▾
Crispy sage is super easy to nail if you watch it closely. Melt a small pat of butter in a pan over medium heat, drop in whole sage leaves, and cook for 15 to 20 seconds per side until they’re bright and crisp. Pull them immediately—they burn in seconds, and burnt sage adds a bitter, unpleasant flavor to the sandwich.
6.Can I roast the butternut squash ahead of time to cut down on weeknight prep? ▾
Definitely! Roast the squash up to 3 days in advance and store it in an airtight container in the fridge. When you’re ready to make sandwiches, let the squash come to room temperature for 10 minutes, and pat off any excess collected moisture before layering it to keep your bread crisp instead of soggy.
7.What’s the best way to get the cheese fully melted without burning the bread? ▾
The trick is low, slow cooking over medium-low heat, with a lid on the pan. After assembling your sandwich, cook it covered for 3 to 4 minutes per side: the trapped heat melts the cheddar all the way through to the center, while buttered bread slowly toasts to a deep, even golden crisp without burning.
8.Can I make this recipe vegan or dairy-free? ▾
You absolutely can! Swap the sharp cheddar for your favorite high-melting dairy-free sharp cheddar alternative, use plant-based butter in place of unsalted butter, and double-check that your sourdough is made without dairy (most traditional loaves are!). The roasted squash and crispy sage will still carry that cozy, warm autumn flavor perfectly.
9.My butternut squash isn’t getting caramelized when I roast it—what am I doing wrong? ▾
Lack of caramelization almost always traces back to an overcrowded pan or wet squash. Spread cubed squash in a single, even layer on a sheet pan (use two pans if you need to!) and pat pieces totally dry before tossing with olive oil and salt. Roast at 400°F, flipping halfway, for deep, sweet golden edges.
10.Should I butter both sides of the bread for extra crispiness? ▾
Buttering the outer sides of both bread slices is non-negotiable for that signature shatteringly crisp crust, but you don’t need to butter the inner sides facing the fillings. For extra flavor, mix a tiny pinch of garlic powder or smoked paprika into the softened butter before spreading for a subtle, tasty boost.
11.Can I add extra fillings to this sandwich without ruining the texture? ▾
You can, just stick to low-moisture add-ins to avoid sogginess. Thin slices of crisp apple, a sprinkle of cooked crumbled bacon, a thin spread of whole-grain mustard, or a handful of caramelized onions all work beautifully. Skip wet fillings like tomato slices or runny spreads, which will make bread turn mushy fast.
12.How long do I need to roast the butternut squash for this recipe? ▾
Roast ½-inch cubed butternut squash at 400°F for 20 to 25 minutes total, flipping the cubes halfway through cooking, until they’re fork-tender with deep golden, caramelized edges. That timing lines up perfectly to let you prep bread, cheese, and crispy sage while the squash cooks for a total meal time under 45 minutes.
13.Can I cook these sandwiches in an air fryer instead of on the stovetop? ▾
You absolutely can! Assemble the sandwiches as directed, butter the outer bread sides, and air fry at 370°F for 4 to 5 minutes per side, until the bread is golden crisp and the cheese is fully melted. Keep a close eye on them, as air fryer heat varies, to avoid burning the delicate bread edges.
14.What’s the best way to store and reheat leftover grilled cheese? ▾
Leftover sandwiches will keep in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 2 days, but they’re best reheated to bring back that signature crispness. Skip the microwave (it makes bread soggy!) and reheat in a dry skillet over medium-low heat for 2 to 3 minutes per side, until cheese re-melts and bread crisps back up.
15.Do I need to peel the butternut squash before roasting it for this sandwich? ▾
Yes, you’ll want to peel the butternut squash before cubing and roasting it. The outer skin is tough, fibrous, and doesn’t soften enough during roasting to be pleasant in a grilled cheese sandwich. A sharp Y-shaped vegetable peeler works great for removing skin quickly, especially if you cut the squash into smaller sections first.
16.Can I use dried sage instead of fresh sage leaves for this recipe? ▾
Fresh sage is preferred for that bright, earthy flavor and crispy texture, but you can use dried sage in a pinch. Toss ½ teaspoon of dried sage with the butternut squash before roasting to let the flavor bloom, and skip the crispy fried sage step—dried sage won’t crisp up the same way fresh whole leaves do.
17.Why use sharp cheddar instead of mild cheddar for this recipe? ▾
Sharp cheddar has a deeper, tangier, more concentrated cheese flavor that stands up perfectly to the sweet, caramelized squash and earthy sage, so no single flavor overpowers the others. Mild cheddar has a much softer, blander flavor that will get lost next to the bold, sweet squash filling.
18.Can I make this recipe gluten-free for friends with gluten sensitivities? ▾
Absolutely! Swap the regular sourdough for a thick-cut, hearty gluten-free sourdough or crusty gluten-free country bread—look for a loaf with a tight, sturdy crumb that will hold up to fillings and crisp up well. All other core ingredients (squash, cheddar, butter, sage) are naturally gluten-free, so no other swaps are needed.

Comments (15)

2 days ago

OMG this was SO good! My 7 and 9 year old are super picky about veggies but they devoured this. The crispy bread paired with the sweet roasted squash and melty cheese? Total game changer for weeknight dinners. Will be adding this to our regular rotation for sure!

yesterday

So happy your picky eaters loved it! Pro tip: you can roast a big batch of butternut squash ahead of time on Sunday to make this come together even faster on busy weeknights.

1 week ago

Wait, grilled cheese with squash? I was skeptical at first but my wife begged me to try it. Used sourdough like the recipe said, added a little sprinkle of red pepper flakes for kick, and wow. The sweetness of the squash cuts the richness of the cheese perfectly. Made this for our football watch party last weekend and everyone asked for the recipe.

5 days ago

Adding red pepper flakes is such a good call! I did that too last time I made it and it took the whole thing up a notch.

3 days ago

Love the red pepper flake addition! That little hint of heat pairs so beautifully with the caramelized squash, I’m definitely going to try that next time I make it.

3 days ago

Super easy to make in my tiny dorm toaster oven! I used pre-cut butternut squash from the grocery store to save time, and it still turned out perfect. Way fancier than the plain grilled cheese I usually survive on, and it only took me like 25 minutes total like the recipe said. 10/10

5 days ago

Made this for our church potluck last Sunday and it was gone in 10 minutes flat! I cut the sandwiches into little bite-sized squares so people could grab them as appetizers, and so many people came up to ask what was in them. The crispy buttery crust is *chef’s kiss*

3 days ago

Bite-sized appetizer portions are such a smart idea for potlucks! I’m so glad it was a hit with your church group.

1 week ago

Obsessed with how meal prep friendly this is! I roasted the squash at the start of the week, kept it in an airtight container, and was able to throw these sandwiches together in 5 minutes flat for lunch all week. Even reheated in the air fryer the bread gets crispy again, no sogginess at all!

5 days ago

Wait how do you reheat them in the air fryer? Temp and time? I tried microwaving leftover grilled cheese once and it was a sad soggy mess lol

2 weeks ago

I veganized this super easily! Used dairy-free cheddar and vegan butter on sourdough, and followed the rest of the recipe exactly. The roasted squash adds so much depth that I didn’t even miss the dairy cheese. Would 100% make this again, even for my non-vegan friends!

1 week ago

Ooh what brand of dairy-free cheddar did you use? I’ve tried a couple that don’t melt right and I want to make this for my vegan cousin next month!

5 days ago

Love that you adapted this for a vegan diet! Thanks for sharing that swap, I’m sure lots of other readers will appreciate the tip.

30 minutes ago

Tried this last night after seeing it pop up on my feed. Cooked the sandwiches on my cast iron skillet outside on the patio to keep the house from smelling like grilled cheese (no judgment but my roommate hates the smell lmao). Turned out perfectly crispy, the squash was caramelized just right. Solid recipe, no notes.

yesterday

I was worried this would be too sweet for my husband who hates sweet-savory combos, but he went back for a second sandwich! I used a sharp white cheddar instead of American like the recipe suggested, and the tangy cheese balanced the squash really well. So happy I gave this a shot!

2 hours ago

Sharp white cheddar is such a great swap! The tang definitely helps balance the natural sweetness of the roasted squash, I’ll have to note that variation in the recipe card. Thanks for sharing!

2 hours ago

Eh, this was just okay for me. I think I roasted my squash a little too long so it got mushy, made the sandwich a little soggy. The flavor combo was good but texture was off for me. Might try again and keep a closer eye on the squash next time.

2 weeks ago

Made this over the campfire on our last camping trip! Wrapped the sandwiches in foil and cooked them over the coals, roasted the squash ahead of time at home so we just had to assemble at the campsite. Best camp meal we’ve ever had, way better than hot dogs!

1 week ago

Campfire version? That is genius! We’re going camping next month and I’m absolutely adding this to our meal plan now.

5 days ago

Campfire grilled cheese is next level! What a fun idea to pre-roast the squash ahead for easy camping cooking, I’m totally stealing that for my next trip.

1 week ago

My granddaughter showed me this recipe and we made it together last weekend. She loved mashing the roasted squash and helping butter the bread. Turned out real crispy, just like the name says. Reminds me of the grilled cheese my mom used to make, but fancier. Great recipe for cooking with the grandkids.

5 days ago

This makes my day! Cooking with grandkids is the best, and I’m so glad you two got to make this together. The little ones always love mashing veggies, right?

5 minutes ago

Pro tip from someone who has made this three times already: use a mix of provolone and sharp cheddar for the cheese, and spread a thin layer of mayo on the outside of the bread instead of butter for extra crisp. Trust me, it’s life changing. The squash gets all caramelized and sweet, it’s the perfect fall sandwich.

yesterday

Finally got around to making this last night after seeing all the rave reviews, and wow, it did not disappoint! I don’t have a lot of time to cook on weeknights between work and picking the kids up from soccer practice, but 25 minutes was totally doable. My kids asked if we can have it again tonight, that’s the highest praise possible in this house!

30 minutes ago

Right?! My kids are the exact same way, they request this at least once a week now. It’s the only way I can get them to eat winter squash without complaining!

just now

I added a little drizzle of hot honey on mine after reading the red pepper flake suggestion in another comment, and oh my gosh. Sweet, spicy, cheesy, crispy? Absolute perfection. This is going to be my go-to lunch all fall and winter long, no question.

3 days ago

I made this for a cozy fall girls’ night in with tomato soup on the side, and we all agreed it’s the best grilled cheese we’ve ever had. The roasted butternut squash adds such a nice creamy, sweet element that regular grilled cheese is missing. I used brioche bread instead of sourdough because that’s what I had on hand, and it was insanely good.

2 days ago

Brioche? That sounds so decadent and delicious! I bet the buttery brioche pairs so well with the squash. I need to try that next time instead of sourdough.

yesterday

Serving this with tomato soup is such a classic, perfect combo! Brioche is a fantastic swap, that soft buttery bread crisps up so nicely. So glad you and your friends loved it!