grilled pimento cheese sandwich
intro
Crispy buttery sourdough oozing with tangy, creamy pimento cheese, grilled to golden melty perfection—this nostalgic Southern staple delivers quick, cozy comfort.
Ingredients
Steps
Grate Sharp Cheddar
Place the stainless steel box grater on the center of the light maple cutting board. Hold the block of sharp yellow cheddar against the large holes of the grater, and grate into even, fine shreds, collecting all shreds directly into the clear glass mixing bowl positioned under the grater. Stop grating when you have a 1cm nub of cheese left to avoid scraping your knuckles; reserve the nub for another use. You will end up with approximately 1.25 cups of loosely packed shredded cheddar.
Mix Pimento Filling
Add the softened cream cheese, mayonnaise, thoroughly drained diced pimentos, garlic powder, cayenne pepper, kosher salt, and black pepper to the clear glass mixing bowl with the shredded cheddar. Stir with a sturdy spoon until all ingredients are fully combined, with no streaks of unblended cream cheese or mayonnaise remaining. The finished filling should be thick and spreadable, evenly flecked with bright red pimento pieces, with visible cheddar shreds throughout; do not overmix to a smooth paste.
Assemble Sandwich Layers
Lay 4 slices of sourdough bread flat on the maple cutting board. Divide the pimento cheese filling evenly between the 4 slices, spreading it in a 1cm (1/2 inch) thick layer all the way to the very edges of the bread—this prevents dry, un-filled crust edges when grilling. Top each filled slice with the remaining 4 slices of sourdough to form 4 complete sandwiches, pressing gently on the top slice to adhere the layers together.
Preheat Cast Iron Skillet
Retrieve the seasoned cast iron skillet and place it directly in front of the maple cutting board on the soapstone counter. Set the cream butter dish to the left of the skillet, rest the silicone basting brush on the butter dish edge, and set the stainless steel turner spatula on the folded linen towel at top right. Heat the skillet over medium-low heat (160°C / 325°F) for 3 full minutes. Test the temperature by dropping a single bead of water onto the pan: it is ready when the water sizzles immediately and dances across the surface without evaporating in under 2 seconds.
Butter Sandwich Exteriors
Pick up one assembled sandwich at a time. Use the silicone basting brush to spread 1/4 tablespoon of softened butter evenly across the top surface of the bread, covering every corner all the way to the edges. A thin, uniform butter layer creates a perfectly crisp, golden crust rather than patchy, soggy, or burnt spots. Set buttered sandwiches aside on the edge of the cutting board until the pan is fully preheated.
Grill First Sandwich Side
Use the metal turner spatula to carefully lift 2 of the buttered sandwiches and place them butter-side down in the preheated cast iron skillet. Cook for 3 to 4 minutes, resisting the urge to press down on the sandwiches with the spatula (pressing squeezes out melted cheese and leads to dry sandwiches). The first side is done when it is a deep, even golden brown and crisp to the touch, with cheese at the edges just starting to soften and melt.
Flip and Finish Cooking
Slide the metal turner spatula under each sandwich and flip carefully to the second side. Immediately spread 1/4 tablespoon of softened butter across the now-exposed top bread surface with the basting brush. Cook for another 3 to 4 minutes, until the second side is equally deep golden and crisp, and the pimento cheese filling is fully melted, with small bubbles of cheese oozing gently from the sandwich seams. Transfer cooked sandwiches to the matte cream ceramic plate, then repeat the grilling process with the remaining 2 sandwiches.
Rest, Cut, and Serve
Once all 4 sandwiches are cooked, transfer them back to the maple cutting board and let rest for 1 full minute. This short rest allows the melted cheese to set slightly, so it stretches nicely instead of running out when cut. Use the santoku knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two triangular halves, then arrange on the matte cream ceramic dinner plate. Serve with one dill pickle spear per sandwich.
Tips
2.Keep the skillet at a steady medium-low temperature for the full cook time: high heat will burn the butter and bread crust long before the thick cheese filling has a chance to melt all the way through to the center of the sandwich.
3.Always spread filling all the way to the bread edges and butter every corner of the bread exterior: this eliminates dry, untoasted bread spots and ensures every bite has the perfect ratio of crisp crust to melted cheese.

OMG this grilled pimento cheese is a total game changer! I made it for last night’s family dinner and even my super picky 7 year old asked for seconds. The crispy buttery bread paired with that creamy, tangy filling? *Chef’s kiss* SO good, I’ll be making this every week for meal prep!
Made these for our neighborhood potluck this past weekend and they were gone in 10 minutes flat! I did add a little crumbled bacon to the pimento cheese mix because, well, bacon makes everything better. Will absolutely be making this again for our next cookout.
This was so quick and easy to throw together for a lazy Saturday lunch! 8 minutes cook time is no joke, I had a hot, melty sandwich on my plate before my show even came back from commercial break. 10/10, no notes.
Wait, I’ve been making pimento cheese wrong my whole life? I always used pre-shredded cheese and it never got that creamy, melt-in-your-mouth texture this recipe gives. Grating your own sharp cheddar makes all the difference, wow.
My kids are obsessed! I cut these into little triangle dippers and served them with tomato soup for dinner last night, and they ate every single bite without complaining about veggies for once. Win for mom!
Super easy recipe, but I burned the first sandwich because I had the heat too high! Medium-low is definitely the move so the bread gets crispy without burning before the cheese melts all the way through.
I brought these on our day hike last weekend and they held up perfectly! I wrapped them in foil right off the grill and they were still warm and melty by the time we got to our overlook spot. Way better than packing boring PB&J.
I was skeptical about grilled pimento cheese at first because I always thought pimento was just for party dip, but wow. This converted me. The little bit of garlic powder in the spread is such a nice subtle touch, I never would have thought to add that.
Meal prep win! I made a batch of the pimento cheese spread on Sunday and have been making a quick grilled sandwich for lunch all week. It stays so good in the fridge for up to 5 days, total time saver for busy work days.
Made these for my partner who’s from Georgia and swears no one makes pimento cheese as good as his grandma’s. He said this recipe is a close second! High praise coming from him, let me tell you.
I added a few slices of pickled jalapeno to mine for a little kick and it was *chef’s kiss*. The heat pairs so perfectly with the creamy, tangy cheese, I’ll never make it without jalapenos now.
This recipe is so easy even I couldn’t mess it up, and I burn toast 90% of the time. 8 minutes total, minimal ingredients, maximum flavor. My new go-to late night snack when I get home from work.
Wait, can I make this on a panini press instead of a stovetop pan? I don’t have a good nonstick skillet right now and I’m craving this so bad for lunch today!
I used sourdough bread instead of plain white and it elevated the whole sandwich! The tang from the sourdough pairs so well with the creamy pimento cheese, 10/10 swap if you have it on hand.
I made these for my book club meeting last night and everyone asked for the recipe! I served them with a little side of spicy honey for dipping and everyone went crazy for it. Such a crowd pleaser.
Great base recipe! I swapped the mayo for Greek yogurt to lighten it up a little and it still tasted so creamy and delicious, I didn’t even miss the extra calories. Perfect for when I’m trying to eat a little lighter but still want comfort food.
I can’t believe how fast this comes together! I got home from a long day at work, had zero meal prep done, and had a hot, delicious dinner on the table in 10 minutes total (including prep). Absolute weeknight lifesaver.