Leftover Turkey Reuben
intro
A crispy, tangy twist on the classic deli Reuben, repurposing leftover Thanksgiving turkey with melted Swiss, zesty sauerkraut, and creamy Russian dressing on butter-grilled rye.
Ingredients
Steps
Squeeze Sauerkraut Dry
Place drained sauerkraut on a double layer of plain white paper towel. Gather the towel edges and squeeze firmly over the adjacent sink to remove all excess brine, until sauerkraut feels damp but not drippy (this takes about 1 minute). Excess brine causes soggy bread, so do not skip this step. If using caraway seeds, toss them with the dried sauerkraut in a small pile on the bamboo cutting board.
Butter Rye Bread Slices
Lay all 8 marbled rye bread slices flat on the bamboo cutting board. Use the matte charcoal silicone spatula to spread 1/2 tablespoon of softened unsalted butter evenly across one full side of each slice, spreading all the way to the crust edges. The buttered sides will face outward against the hot skillet to create a crisp, golden crust.
Layer Sandwich Fillings
Flip 4 bread slices so buttered sides face down against the cutting board. Spread 1 tablespoon of Russian dressing across the unbuttered side of each base slice, using the silicone spatula. Top each base with 1 slice Swiss cheese, 85g (3oz) thinly sliced leftover turkey, 55g (1/4 cup) dried sauerkraut, and a second slice of Swiss cheese. Spread 1 tablespoon of Russian dressing on the unbuttered side of the remaining 4 bread slices, then place them on top of the fillings, buttered side facing up, to form 4 complete sandwiches.
Preheat Cooking Skillet
Place the 12-inch matte black carbon steel skillet on the stovetop over medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C). Preheat for 2 minutes, until a drop of water flicked onto the pan surface dances across the metal and evaporates slowly over 3-4 seconds. Avoid high heat, which will burn the bread before cheese melts.
Grill First Sandwich Side
Use the metal turner spatula to carefully transfer 2 assembled sandwiches to the preheated skillet. Cook for 3-4 minutes without pressing down on the bread, until the bottom crust is deep golden brown and crispy, and the lower cheese layer begins to bubble softly at the sandwich edges. Pressing sandwiches squeezes out filling and creates soggy bread.
Flip Sandwiches Evenly
Slide the thin metal turner fully under each sandwich to support the entire bottom, then flip gently to avoid spilling filling. Cook the second side for 3-4 minutes, until golden crispy, and all cheese is fully melted with no solid slices visible at the center. Transfer cooked sandwiches to the off-white ceramic plate, then repeat cooking with the remaining two sandwiches.
Rest and Slice Sandwiches
Transfer all cooked sandwiches to the bamboo cutting board and let rest for 1 minute to allow cheese and fillings to set, so layers do not slide apart when cut. Use the 7-inch serrated sandwich knife to cut each sandwich diagonally across the middle into two equal triangular halves.
Tips
2.Cook over medium-low heat, not high: high heat will burn the buttered bread crust before the Swiss cheese fully melts to bind the fillings together, leading to a bitter, un-melted sandwich.
3.Never press down on sandwiches with the spatula while grilling: this squeezes out melted cheese, dressing, and turkey juices, resulting in a dry, flat sandwich with far less flavor.

OMG this is the best leftover turkey recipe I’ve ever made! I had a mountain of Thanksgiving turkey left and was sick of the usual turkey sandwiches, this was a total game changer. The thousand island + rye + sauerkraut combo works so perfectly with turkey instead of corned beef? Who knew! Cook time was literally 8 minutes like it said, no fuss at all.
Made this for a quick post-Thanksgiving lunch for me and my roommates, we all went back for seconds! I did add a little extra Swiss cheese because who doesn’t love more cheese, right? Only thing is I burned the first slice of rye because I got distracted by the football game lmao. 10/10 will make again next year.
My kids DEVOURED these! I was worried the sauerkraut would be too tangy for them but they didn’t even complain, asked if we could have them again next week. Even my picky 7 year old ate his whole sandwich without picking anything out. Total weeknight win.
Wait, has anyone tried making these ahead for meal prep? I usually prep my lunches for the week on Sundays and I have a ton of leftover turkey from our Friendsgiving potluck, would these hold up if I assemble them the night before?
I swapped the regular thousand island for a spicy version I had in the fridge and tossed a little coleslaw on top for extra crunch, holy cow that was good. Easy recipe to tweak to your taste, no fancy skills needed which is great for a guy who usually only cooks burgers and brats.
SO good! I used leftover smoked turkey from our weekend BBQ instead of roasted Thanksgiving turkey and the flavor was insane. I never thought to use turkey for Reubens, I always thought you had to use corned beef or pastrami. This is going to be a regular in our dinner rotation now, not just for leftovers!
I brought a platter of these cut into sliders (used mini rye slices!) to my office potluck yesterday and they were gone in 10 minutes flat. Everyone was asking for the recipe, I sent them all this link! Even the people who say they hate sauerkraut liked them, the flavor is so balanced.
Super easy even for someone who can barely boil water like me! The only question I have — do you guys butter the outside of the bread like you do for grilled cheese? I didn’t see that in the instructions so I just used a dry pan, it was good but I bet it would be even better with a little butter.
Made these for dinner last night, told my kids it was ‘turkey reuben’ and they thought it was ‘rude turkey’ and wouldn’t stop laughing the whole meal. Jokes aside, these slapped. Used my cast iron to toast them and the bread got perfectly crispy. 10/10, will make again, will definitely make the bad joke again too.
Anyone try this with gluten free rye? I have celiac so regular rye is out for me, but I found a really good GF rye loaf at my grocery store and I’m dying to make these with my leftover Christmas turkey (yes, we did turkey for Christmas too, don’t judge).
8 minute cook time is no joke! I got home late from work last night, pulled leftover turkey out of the fridge, and had a hot, delicious dinner on the table before my partner even finished setting the table. No fancy ingredients, no complicated steps, exactly what I need on busy weeknights.
I skipped the sauerkraut because my husband hates it and used pickled red onions instead, it was so bright and tasty! The rest of the recipe I followed exactly, even used thousand island like the recipe said. The pickled onions were chef’s kiss. Great flexible recipe!
Made these for our Sunday football watch party, cut them into quarters as appetizers and they were the most popular snack on the table! Even better than the pizza we ordered, tbh. I made a little extra thousand island for dipping and people were drizzling it on everything else too lmao.
Wait, is it weird that I used provolone instead of Swiss? I didn’t have Swiss in the fridge and provolone was all I had, it still tasted amazing. I thought the nuttiness of Swiss was required but provolone melted so smooth, I might actually prefer it now?
I always get stuck with so much turkey after holidays and end up freezing half of it for soup later, but this recipe is going to make me look forward to leftovers now! It’s so much more exciting than the plain cold turkey sandwiches I usually make. The tang from the sauerkraut cuts through the richness of the cheese and dressing perfectly.
Made this in my dorm room with a tiny countertop griddle! My roommate and I split a turkey breast we cooked for our little Friendsgiving in the dorm, and we had all the fixings for these. It was better than any sandwich we’ve gotten from the campus dining hall, no cap. Super easy even with super limited cooking equipment.
I added a slice of crispy bacon to mine because I put bacon on literally everything, and let me tell you — that salty crunch paired with the tangy sauerkraut and creamy dressing? Life changing. Also, the cook time is spot on, 4 minutes per side on medium heat and everything was perfectly melted and toasty.
I grew up eating Reubens at delis in Cleveland and was super skeptical that a turkey version made at home with leftovers could measure up, but I stand corrected! It’s got all the classic Reuben flavor, just lighter, and it’s so quick to throw together. My grandma even approved, which is the highest possible seal of approval if you ask me.