macaroni pie

title 1
macaroni pie
⏱️ cook time 45 minutes
🍽️ servings 8
⚡ Difficulty easy

intro

Creamy, perfectly sliceable baked macaroni pie with a crisp golden cheddar top and rich, savory custard center—the ultimate comforting Southern staple for relaxed family meals.

Ingredients

Dry elbow macaroni 340g (12oz)
Sharp cheddar cheese 450g (1lb)
Whole milk 480ml (2 cups)
Large eggs 3
Unsalted butter 4 tbsp (57g), melted, plus extra for greasing
All-purpose flour 2 tbsp
Garlic powder 1 tsp
Onion powder 1 tsp
Smoked paprika 1/2 tsp
Kosher salt 1.5 tsp, plus 1 tbsp for pasta water
Freshly ground black pepper 1/2 tsp
Fresh curly parsley 2 tbsp, chopped

Steps

1

Cook Elbow Macaroni

Fill the 5L stainless steel stock pot with 4L of water, add 1 tbsp kosher salt, and bring to a rolling boil over high heat. Add 340g dry elbow macaroni, stir with the stainless steel slotted spoon to prevent sticking, and cook for 6 minutes (2 minutes less than the package’s al dente directions, as pasta will finish cooking in the oven). Drain pasta in the stainless steel colander, do not rinse, and set aside. Rinsing removes surface starch that helps the custard cling to noodles for a cohesive texture.

2

Grate Sharp Cheddar

Place the stainless steel box grater on the maple cutting board. Grate all 450g of sharp cheddar using the large grating holes, separating 115g (1 cup) of grated cheese to reserve for the top topping. Avoid pre-shredded cheese, as it contains anti-caking agents that create a grainy finished texture.

Step 2
step2:Grate Sharp Cheddar
3

Mix Cheese Custard

Melt the 4 tbsp of unsalted butter in the 3L stainless steel saucepan over low heat, then set aside to cool slightly. Crack 3 large eggs into the 4L clear glass mixing bowl, whisk lightly with the stainless steel wire whisk until yolks and whites are fully combined. Pour in the whole milk, cooled melted butter, all-purpose flour, garlic powder, onion powder, smoked paprika, remaining 1/2 tsp kosher salt, and black pepper. Whisk vigorously for 30 seconds until no flour lumps remain, then stir in 3/4 of the non-reserved grated cheddar until evenly distributed.

Step 3
step3:Mix Cheese Custard
Step 3
step3:Mix Cheese Custard
4

Combine Pasta and Custard

Add the drained, slightly undercooked elbow macaroni to the mixing bowl with the cheese custard. Use the matte cream silicone spatula to fold gently for 1 minute, ensuring every pasta noodle is fully coated in the custard mixture, with no dry pasta patches visible at the bottom of the bowl.

Step 4
step4:Combine Pasta and Custard
5

Prep Baking Dish

Preheat oven to 175C (350F). Use a small piece of leftover butter wrapper or 1 tsp of softened butter to grease the entire interior surface of the 9x13 inch matte white ceramic baking dish, making sure to coat the corners and sides fully to prevent sticking. Avoid cooking spray, as it can leave a chemical aftertaste on the crust.

Step 5
step5:Prep Baking Dish
6

Assemble Macaroni Pie

Pour the entire pasta and custard mixture into the greased baking dish, spread evenly with the silicone spatula to create a flat, level surface. Sprinkle the remaining reserved grated cheddar evenly across the top, covering the entire surface for a uniform crisp crust. Do not press the cheese down into the pasta, as this will prevent a light, crisp top layer.

Step 6
step6:Assemble Macaroni Pie
Step 6
step6:Assemble Macaroni Pie
7

Bake Until Set

Place the baking dish on the middle rack of the preheated 175C (350F) oven. Bake for 40-45 minutes, until the edges are bubbling vigorously, the top cheese is deep golden brown and crisp, and the center of the pie jiggles only slightly (like firm Jell-O) when the dish is gently shaken; a loose, sloshy jiggle means the custard needs more time, while no movement at all means it is overbaked. Remove from the oven and place on the chrome wire cooling rack.

Step 7
step7:Bake Until Set
8

Rest Before Serving

Let the macaroni pie rest for 15 full minutes on the cooling rack before slicing. This rest time allows the custard to set fully, creating clean, neat slices that hold their shape instead of oozing when cut. Slice into 8 equal squares, lift each slice with the stainless steel slotted serving spatula, and plate on the matte cream ceramic dinner plate, garnished with a light sprinkle of chopped fresh parsley.

Step 8
step8:Rest Before Serving

Tips

1.Cook pasta 2 minutes shorter than the package’s al dente direction: Pasta continues to absorb liquid and cook while baking in the custard, and undercooking it initially prevents mushy, over-soft noodles in the finished pie.
2.Grate cheese fresh from a block instead of using pre-shredded packaged cheese: Pre-shredded cheese is coated in anti-caking potato starch that prevents smooth melting, leading to a grainy, uneven custard instead of a silky, cohesive texture.
3.Let the baked pie rest a full 15 minutes before slicing: Hot custard is thin and runny straight from the oven, and the rest time allows it to set fully so slices hold their clean, neat shape without oozing.

✨ You May Also Like

Side Dishes
🍜 India

Velvety, aromatic all-purpose curry sauce perfect for tossing with roasted veggies, grilled protein, or rice for fast, cozy, flavorful meals.

⏱️ 25 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.8
Side Dishes
🍜 Spain

Tender, starchy boiled yuca tossed in bright, garlicky citrus mojo sauce—an iconic, zesty side that pairs beautifully with roasted pork, grilled meats, and rice and beans.

⏱️ 40 minuteSide Dishes ★ 5
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Tender, paper-thin potato flatbread, a beloved Norwegian-American Minnesota Christmas staple, griddled until softly spotted and served warm with butter.

⏱️ 1 hour 30Side Dishes ★ 4.6
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Rich, deeply savory cured salt pork, a long-lasting kitchen staple perfect for frying crispy as a side or adding umami to stews, beans, and chowders.

⏱️ 7 days (2Side Dishes ★ 4.9
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Crispy, tangy classic Southern fried green tomatoes with a crunchy cornmeal crust, served hot for a nostalgic, comforting summery bite.

⏱️ 25 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.9
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Moist, golden-crusted savory muffins with sweet corn, zesty jalapeño, and melted cheddar, perfect for pairing with smoky summer grilled fare.

⏱️ 30 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.9

macaroni pie:Frequently Asked Questions

1.Why does my baked macaroni pie turn out runny instead of holding clean, neat slices? ▾
Runny pie usually traces back to three easy fixes: First, don’t skip or cut back on the large eggs—those are what set the rich custard base to hold solid slices. Second, don’t add extra milk beyond the recipe ratio. Third, bake until the center jiggles just slightly, then rest 15 minutes before slicing to let the custard fully set.
2.Can I use pre-shredded sharp cheddar instead of shredding my own block cheese? ▾
You can in a total pinch, but I strongly recommend shredding your own sharp cheddar. Pre-shredded cheese is coated with anti-caking potato starch that keeps it from melting smoothly, which can leave your filling grainy and your crisp top less evenly golden. It only takes 2 extra minutes, and the creamier melt is well worth the effort.
3.Do I have to use whole milk, or can I swap in a lower-fat milk option? ▾
Whole milk gives the custard that luxe, rich texture that makes this Southern staple feel like true comfort food, but you can swap in 2% milk if that’s what you have on hand. Skip skim or thin non-dairy milks for the traditional version—they make the filling watery, less flavorful, and prevent the custard from setting cleanly.
4.How do I get that perfectly crisp, golden cheddar top without burning it? ▾
For that ideal bubbly, crisp golden top, spread your final layer of shredded sharp cheddar evenly over the filling right before baking. If you notice the top browning too fast before the center is set, tent a loose piece of aluminum foil over the dish for the last 10 to 15 minutes of bake time to prevent scorching while the custard finishes cooking.
5.Should I rinse my cooked elbow macaroni before mixing it into the pie filling? ▾
Skip rinsing your cooked dry elbow macaroni for this recipe! Instead, toss hot drained noodles with the recipe’s unsalted butter to keep them from sticking. The light starchy coating on unrinsed pasta helps the egg and milk custard cling to every noodle, creating a cohesive filling that slices cleanly, while rinsing causes separated, slippery noodles.
6.Can I make this macaroni pie ahead of time for a family meal or potluck? ▾
Absolutely! You can assemble the full pie, cover it tightly, and refrigerate it for up to 24 hours before baking. Let it sit on the counter for 20 minutes to take the chill off while your oven preheats, then bake as directed, adding 5 to 10 minutes of extra time if the center is still overly jiggly. It reheats beautifully for leftovers too.

Comments (20)

2 days ago

OMG this baked mac pie was the star of our Sunday family dinner! My picky 7 year old asked for thirds, even my husband who swears only his grandma’s mac counts said this was a close second. So creamy, not dry at all—game changer for weeknight meals too!

yesterday

So happy your whole family loved it! Nothing beats a mac and cheese that wins over the picky eaters and the grandma’s recipe loyalists 😊

3 days ago

Brought this to my office potluck yesterday and people were literally scraping the pan! I added a little extra sharp cheddar on top because I’m a cheese fiend, and it was *chef’s kiss*. 10/10 will be making this for every cookout this summer.

2 days ago

Ooh extra sharp cheddar is such a good call! Did you mix any panko on top too for crunch?

2 days ago

Love the extra cheese hack! Adding panko for crunch is a fantastic optional add-on too, totally customizable to your taste.

1 week ago

Made a big batch of this for my weekly meal prep and it held up perfectly all week! No weird sogginess when reheated, which is my biggest pet peeve with baked pasta. Super easy to throw together on Sunday too, even for a cooking newbie like me.

5 days ago

Wait, I’m used to macaroni pie being a little sweeter like my aunt makes it for holidays—does this have any sugar in it? I don’t see it in the ingredient list but want to make sure before I make it for our Easter gathering.

3 days ago

Great question! This classic savory version doesn’t include added sugar, but you can absolutely stir in a teaspoon or two if you prefer that sweeter, old-school macaroni pie profile your aunt makes!

1 week ago

Okay as someone who burns toast 50% of the time, this was so easy! 45 minutes total, no fancy steps, and my roommates thought I was a professional chef. Only thing I messed up was under-salting the pasta water, but even then it was SO good.

5 days ago

Same! I’m a total beginner too, this is the first pasta dish I’ve made that didn’t come out a gluey mess. Pro tip: salt the water until it tastes like sea water, trust me!

3 days ago

So awesome that this worked out for you new cooks! The pasta water salt tip is 100% correct—it’s the easiest way to make sure every bite is flavorful, no bland pasta here.

2 weeks ago

Has anyone tried making this with gluten free elbow macaroni? My kid has celiac and I’m always hunting for baked mac recipes that don’t turn grainy with GF pasta.

1 week ago

I made it with brown rice GF elbows last week! Just cook the pasta a minute less than the package says so it doesn’t get mushy when it bakes, turned out amazing.

1 week ago

Made this for our football tailgate last weekend and it was gone before the national anthem ended. Warm, hearty, travels really well in a foil pan—definitely adding this to my regular tailgate rotation.

2 weeks ago

This tastes just like the macaroni pie my grandma used to make for church suppers! The creamy egg-custard base is exactly what I’ve been missing in all the fancy gourmet mac and cheese recipes online. No weird truffle oil or lobster, just straight up comfort food.

1 week ago

Right?! All the fancy mac recipes are fine but nothing hits like the classic baked custard-style mac pie. I added a tiny dash of nutmeg like my nana did, chef’s kiss.

5 days ago

We’re all about no-fuss classic comfort food here! That little dash of nutmeg is a brilliant old-school touch, it adds such a warm, cozy depth of flavor without being noticeable.

30 minutes ago

Wait how well does this keep? I’m cooking for just me and don’t want to waste half a pan if it goes bad fast.

5 minutes ago

Great question! It will keep tightly covered in the fridge for up to 4 days, and reheats great in the microwave or oven. I recommend slicing individual portions so you don’t have to reheat the whole pan every time!

5 days ago

I swapped half the cheddar for pepper jack because we love a little kick in our house, and wow—total game changer. It’s not too spicy, just enough zing to keep you coming back for more bites.

3 days ago

Oh that sounds incredible! Do you think adding a diced jalapeño would be too much, or would that pair well?

2 days ago

I added diced pickled jalapeños last time I made this and it was chef’s kiss! Not too hot, adds a nice tang too.

yesterday

Can I assemble this the night before and bake it the next day? We have back to back soccer practices on Thursdays and I’d love to just pop it in the oven when we get home.

2 hours ago

Absolutely! Assemble it fully, cover it tightly, and keep it in the fridge overnight. You may need to add 5-10 minutes to the bake time since it’ll be cold going into the oven, but it turns out just as delicious.

2 weeks ago

Made this for my first ever hosted Friendsgiving last year and everyone asked for the recipe. I was so stressed about cooking for my friends but this was foolproof, even when I accidentally used whole milk instead of evaporated. Still turned out creamy and perfect.

1 week ago

This is the perfect side for smoked brisket! I smoked my brisket on Saturday and made this mac pie to go with it, and the combo was unbeatable. The creamy pasta cuts right through the smoky, salty meat so well.

5 days ago

Dude that combo sounds insane! I’m making ribs this weekend, this is definitely going to be the side now.

3 days ago

There’s no better side for BBQ than creamy baked macaroni pie! It pairs so perfectly with all those smoky, savory grilled and smoked meats, total match made in heaven.

2 days ago

Any tips for making this dairy free? My daughter is allergic to dairy so I’m always looking for swaps that don’t taste weird or coconut-y.

yesterday

I used dairy free sharp cheddar shreds and oat milk for the custard base last month! Didn’t taste coconutty at all, my dairy-eating husband didn’t even notice it was DF.

3 days ago

The 45 minute cook time is no joke! I timed it from when I pulled out the ingredients to when it was out of the oven, and it was exactly 42 minutes for me. Perfect for when you don’t want to spend half your evening in the kitchen on a school night.

30 minutes ago

Okay who else leaves it in the oven an extra 5 minutes so the top cheese gets all crispy and bubbly with those little browned edges? That’s non-negotiable for me, no soft top mac allowed in my house.

5 minutes ago

ME. Those burnt cheese edges are the best part of the whole pan, I will fight anyone who says otherwise. I even sprinkle a little extra cheese right on top at the 40 minute mark to get it extra crispy.

just now

We fully support the crispy top agenda! Leaving it in a few extra minutes for that golden, bubbly cheese crust is 100% allowed, no recipe police here.

2 hours ago

Can I cut this recipe in half? I live alone and don’t need a whole 9x13 pan of mac, even though I would absolutely eat it all if I made it, ha.

30 minutes ago

Totally! Just cut all the ingredients exactly in half and bake it in an 8x8 inch pan, check for doneness around the 30-35 minute mark since it’ll be a smaller batch. No judgement if you eat the whole thing anyway, we’ve all been there.

3 days ago

Tired of bringing the same old potato salad to every summer cookout so I gave this a shot last weekend, and I got so many more compliments than I ever do on potato salad. Consider this my new go-to potluck contribution from now on.

1 week ago

I’ve been making macaroni pie for 60 years and I have to say, this recipe is dead on for the classic version. No unnecessary frills, just good, simple ingredients that taste like home. I added a pinch of paprika on top like I always do, and it was perfect.

5 days ago

That means the world coming from someone who’s been making this classic for decades! That pinch of paprika on top is such a timeless, delicious touch.

yesterday

I know this is supposed to be a comfort food side but I ate a whole slice of this for lunch after my long run on Saturday and zero regrets. Carbs and cheese are the best recovery food, fight me. It was so filling and tasty, 10/10.