muffuletta sandwich
intro
Hearty New Orleans Italian-American muffuletta, stacked with briny chunky olive salad, layered cured meats, and creamy provolone on crusty sesame bread, pressed for deep, melded flavor.
Ingredients
Steps
Chop Olive Salad Ingredients
Place the pitted Castelvetrano olives, kalamata olives, drained giardiniera, pickled cauliflower, celery stalk, and peeled garlic clove on the acacia cutting board. Using the chef's knife, chop all ingredients into rough 1/4-inch pieces, stopping before the mixture turns into a smooth paste (textural chunks are desired). Transfer all chopped ingredients to the large clear glass mixing bowl.
Season Olive Salad Mix
Add 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil, 1 teaspoon dried oregano, and 1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper to the chopped mixture in the glass bowl. Stir thoroughly to combine, then let the salad rest for 10 minutes at room temperature to allow flavors to meld. Taste and add a tiny pinch of salt only if needed—olives and pickled vegetables are already high in sodium, so over-salting is a common mistake.
Split Sesame Bread Loaf
Place the 10-inch sesame seed Italian loaf on the acacia cutting board. Using the serrated bread knife, slice the loaf horizontally into two even round halves, either fully separated or left attached with a small hinge if preferred. Gently pull out 1/2 inch of the soft inner crumb from the cut side of each half to create a shallow well that will hold filling and prevent sogginess.
Spread Olive Salad Evenly
Spoon half of the seasoned olive salad onto the cut side of the bottom bread half, spreading it all the way to the loaf edges. Spoon the remaining olive salad onto the cut side of the top bread half, spreading evenly. The light coating of olive oil from the salad will soak slightly into the exposed bread crumb, creating a moisture barrier for the fillings.
Layer Cured Meats, Cheese
Layer the sliced provolone evenly over the olive salad on the bottom bread half, followed by alternating, evenly spread layers of mortadella, Genoa salami, and capicola, all the way to the loaf edges. Avoid piling fillings high in the center, as this will create an uneven sandwich that is hard to press and slice. Once all fillings are layered, place the top bread half (olive salad side down) firmly onto the stack.
Press to Meld Flavors
Tear a sheet of unbleached parchment paper large enough to fully wrap the assembled sandwich, and wrap it tightly around the loaf. Set the wrapped sandwich on the matte cream ceramic serving platter, then place the heavy cast iron grill press squarely on top of the sandwich to apply even pressure. Transfer the platter to the refrigerator and chill for a minimum of 2 hours (up to 12 hours) to compress the loaf and let flavors meld.
Slice into Wedges, Serve
Remove the chilled, pressed sandwich from the refrigerator, unwrap the parchment, and return the loaf to the acacia cutting board. Using the serrated bread knife, cut the muffuletta into 6 even wedge-shaped pieces, similar to slicing a pie. Arrange the wedges on the matte cream serving platter, fanning them slightly to show the layered cross-section, and serve chilled or at cool room temperature.
Tips
2.Spread olive salad on both cut sides of the bread: the oil and brine create a natural moisture barrier that stops meat and cheese juices from soaking into the soft crumb, keeping the sandwich sturdy even after hours of chilling.
3.Assemble the muffuletta 4–12 hours ahead of serving: the long chilled press time allows briny olive flavors to infuse into the meats and cheese, and the compressed loaf holds together cleanly when sliced, with no loose filling spilling out during transport.

OMG I made this for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were literally begging me for the recipe! I was worried the olive salad would be too briny for my picky kids but they went back for SECONDS. Pro tip: don’t skip the 2 hour press, it makes all the flavors meld so perfectly, no soggy bread at all. SO good, 10/10 will be making this for every game day get together from now on.
Total game changer for my weekly meal prep! I made a batch on Sunday, pressed it overnight, sliced it into individual portions, and it held up perfectly all week for work lunches. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish it had a little more guidance on what kind of cured meats to pick — I grabbed a spicy soppressata and it was chef’s kiss, but I almost got plain boiled ham that would’ve been totally boring. Super easy otherwise, zero cook time is perfect for my busy schedule.
As someone who grew up eating muffulettas on trips to New Orleans, I was skeptical a home recipe could live up to the ones from Central Grocery. Y’all. This is SPOT ON. I brought it to my family dinner last night and my dad who’s from NOLA said it tasted exactly like the ones he ate as a kid. The olive salad ratio is perfect, not too much, not too little, and the press time makes the bread soak up just enough flavor without getting mushy.
Wait, has anyone tried making this with gluten free bread? I have celiac and have been craving a good muffuletta forever but haven’t found a GF bread that holds up to the press and the olive salad brine. Would love any tips!
Made this for my college football watch party yesterday and it was gone in 15 minutes flat. I added a little extra hot capicola for a kick and it slapped. So easy to throw together, didn’t have to turn the oven on at all which is perfect when it’s still 90 degrees out here. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular game day rotation.
I’m literally the worst at making sandwiches, they always fall apart or have weird ratios of fillings, but this recipe was so foolproof! I was worried the 2 hour chill press time would be a hassle but I threw it together right before I ran errands, stuck it in the fridge with my heavy cast iron skillet on top to press it, and came home to the perfect sandwich. My roommate thought I ordered it from a fancy local deli!
This recipe is so easy to tweak for vegetarians! I swapped the assorted cold cuts for marinated roasted red peppers, oil-packed artichoke hearts, and extra sliced provolone, kept the olive salad exactly as written, pressed it for two hours, and it was insane. My meat-eating husband didn’t even miss the salami — he went back for two whole slices!