muffulettas
intro
Briny, hearty New Orleans Italian-American stacked sandwich, layered with cured meats, smooth provolone, and tangy olive salad, pressed to meld flavors for perfect portable eating.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Olive Salad
In the 18cm brushed stainless steel mixing bowl, combine chopped Castelvetrano olives, kalamata olives, drained giardiniera, diced celery, minced garlic, chopped parsley, olive oil, red wine vinegar, dried oregano, and black pepper. Stir thoroughly with the spreader to coat all ingredients evenly, then let rest 10 minutes at room temperature to let flavors meld. The mixture should look chunky, glossy with oil, and smell bright and briny.
Slice Loaf Horizontally
Place the whole muffuletta loaf on the center of the acacia cutting board. Hold the top of the loaf steady with your non-dominant hand, and use the serrated bread knife to slice the loaf evenly in half horizontally, creating a 2cm thick top round and thicker bottom round. Take care not to tear the soft inner crumb; the cut surface should be flat and even across both halves.
Hollow Inner Crumb
Pull small pinches of soft inner bread crumb from the cut side of both the top and bottom loaf halves, creating a shallow 1cm deep indentation across the entire surface of each half. Reserve pulled crumbs for homemade breadcrumbs or discard. This shallow well prevents olive brine from soaking through the crust and making the sandwich soggy as it presses.
Layer Olive Salad
Use the stainless steel spreader to divide the olive salad mixture evenly between the two cut loaf halves, spreading it firmly into the shallow indentations so it covers the entire surface of both top and bottom. Press the salad gently into the bread to help it adhere; do not drain the brine, as it will soak into the bread for deep, balanced flavor.
Stack Meat and Cheese
On the bottom bread half (topped with olive salad), layer sliced meats and cheese in even, overlapping layers: first provolone, then Genoa salami, then cooked ham, then mortadella, finishing with a final layer of provolone to create a moisture barrier between the meat and top bread half. Spread layers all the way to the edge of the loaf so every bite has equal filling.
Assemble and Wrap
Place the top bread half (olive salad side down) directly onto the stacked fillings, pressing down firmly with the palm of your hand to compact the layers slightly. Tightly wrap the entire assembled loaf in two layers of plastic wrap, ensuring no gaps where brine can leak out as it presses.
Press to Meld Flavors
Place the plastic-wrapped loaf back on the center of the acacia cutting board. Set the heavy cast iron grill press directly on top of the wrapped sandwich, and place a 2kg canned good or small heavy pot on top of the press for added weight. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours (or up to 24 hours) to let flavors meld and the bread absorb olive brine evenly. The sandwich will compress to about 2/3 of its original height when fully pressed.
Slice and Serve
Remove the pressed sandwich from the refrigerator, unwrap the plastic, and transfer the loaf to the large matte cream ceramic serving platter. Use the serrated bread knife to cut the sandwich into 6 equal wedges, wiping the knife blade between cuts for clean edges. Serve chilled or at room temperature.
Tips
2.Chop olives and giardiniera by hand instead of using a food processor: hand-cut chunks stay distinct with a satisfying bite, while over-processed salad turns mushy and will make the bread soggy much faster.
3.Make the sandwich a full day ahead for picnics or potlucks: flavors deepen and meld as it rests in the fridge, and the firm pressed structure holds up perfectly for transport with no reheating required.

OMG I’ve been craving a real muffuletta since my trip to New Orleans last year and this recipe hit EVERY note! The olive salad is *chef’s kiss* — no skimping on that giardiniera, y’all. I brought this to our neighborhood block party and people were begging for the recipe before I even set the platter down. SO good.
Made this for Sunday family dinner and even my super picky 8 year old ate two whole slices! I used pre-sliced Italian meats from the deli counter to save time and it came together in literally 10 minutes. Perfect easy weekend meal when you don’t feel like turning on the oven.
Has anyone tried making this with gluten free bread? I have a GF kiddo coming to our tailgate next weekend and I want to make sure it turns out well before serving it to the group!
Game changer. I’ve been paying $18 a sandwich at the local fancy deli for muffulettas and this tastes exactly the same for a fraction of the cost. Meal prepped four of these on Sunday and they held up all week for work lunches.
Y’all, I’m born and raised in New Orleans and I was super skeptical of a random internet muffuletta recipe, but this is legit. The only thing I’d add is a little extra chopped garlic in the olive salad, but that’s just my personal preference. Tastes exactly like the ones I get from Central Grocery when I’m home.
How spicy is this as written? I love extra heat but my partner can’t handle anything above mild. Wondering if I should split the olive salad and add red pepper flakes to half.
Made this for my son’s birthday party because he’s obsessed with all things New Orleans after our family trip last summer. The kids went crazy for it! We cut it into tiny slider-sized squares and they were gone in 10 minutes flat. Will absolutely be making this again for our next cookout.
So easy to throw together with stuff I already had in the fridge! I didn’t have mortadella so I used extra salami and it still tasted amazing. No cook time is a total win for these 90 degree summer days when I refuse to turn the stove or oven on.
Brought this to my office potluck yesterday and it won “best dish” by a landslide. People kept coming up to me asking if I ordered it from a restaurant! Pro tip: wrap it tight in plastic wrap and weigh it down with a couple canned goods in the fridge for a few hours before slicing — it makes cutting so much cleaner.
Any tips for making a vegetarian version of this? My partner is vegetarian and I’d love to make this for our date night in this weekend, but I don’t want to lose that classic briny, savory flavor.
Wait, no cook time at all? That’s wild! I made this after work last night and it was on the table in 15 minutes flat. My husband said it’s one of the best things I’ve ever made. Who knew no-cook meals could be this satisfying?
I’m a little confused about the cheese — the recipe says provolone and mozzarella, but my local deli only has sliced Swiss and provolone. Will Swiss work or will it taste weird?
Making these for our road trip down to the Gulf Coast next week! How long do these stay good in the fridge? I want to prep them ahead so we don’t have to stop for fast food on the drive.
Used leftover olive salad from this recipe to top my grilled chicken salads for lunch all week and it was *chef’s kiss*. Don’t sleep on making extra olive salad, y’all — it’s good on literally everything.
First time making any kind of sandwich that isn’t just peanut butter and jelly, haha. This was so easy even I couldn’t mess it up! I think I might have added too much olive salad though, did anyone else have issues with juice dripping everywhere when they took a bite?
Served this at our boozy brunch last weekend alongside mimosas and bloody marys and it was such a hit! I added a side of pickles and chips and it was the perfect spread. 10/10 will be adding this to our regular brunch rotation.
I used my homemade spicy giardiniera for the olive salad and wow, that took this over the top. If you have a go-to giardiniera recipe, definitely use it here — it makes such a difference vs the store bought stuff.
I cut the recipe in half to make a single serving for my lunch today and it worked perfectly. I used a small round ciabatta roll from the grocery store bakery and all the ratios still worked out. Great for people who don’t need a whole giant sandwich to feed a crowd!