Pastrami Reuben Grilled Cheese
intro
Crispy buttered rye stacked with smoky pastrami, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss, and zesty Russian dressing—this elevated grilled cheese is warm, satisfying deli comfort in every bite.
Ingredients
Steps
Drain Sauerkraut Well
Measure 1 cup of sauerkraut and place it on a double layer of paper towels set on the maple cutting board. Gently press down with additional paper towels to squeeze out all excess brine, until the sauerkraut is damp but not dripping wet—this takes about 2 minutes, and is critical to avoid soggy sandwiches. Transfer the fully drained sauerkraut to one of the small clear glass ramekins and set aside.
Butter Rye Bread Slices
Lay all 8 slices of marbled rye bread flat across the maple cutting board. Use the charcoal silicone spatula to spread 1/2 tablespoon of softened unsalted butter evenly across one full side of each bread slice, spreading all the way to the crust edges to ensure even crisping. If using optional caraway seeds, sprinkle a tiny pinch over the buttered side of each slice and press gently to help them stick during cooking. Aim for a thin, uniform butter layer, rather than a thick coat that will pool and make the bread greasy.
Layer Sandwich Fillings
Flip 4 of the bread slices over so their unbuttered sides face up. Spread 1 tablespoon of Russian dressing evenly across the unbuttered side of each of these 4 base slices. Top each base with 1 slice of Swiss cheese, 55g (roughly 2 thin slices) of pastrami, 1/4 cup of drained sauerkraut spread in a thin even layer, and a second slice of Swiss cheese. Spread 1 tablespoon of remaining Russian dressing across the unbuttered side of the remaining 4 bread slices, then place them dressing-side down on top of the fillings to form 4 complete sandwiches, with buttered sides facing outward on both top and bottom. Press down gently on each sandwich top to help the layers adhere.
Preheat Cooking Skillet
Retrieve the 12-inch matte black carbon steel skillet from below the counter and place it on the stovetop burner set to medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C for electric cooktops). Let the pan preheat for 3 full minutes—do not use high heat, as this will burn the bread crust before the cheese has time to melt through. No extra butter is needed in the pan, as the bread slices are already evenly buttered.
Grill First Sandwich Side
Carefully place 2 of the assembled sandwiches in the preheated skillet, leaving 2cm of space between them to allow even cooking. Cook for 4 to 5 minutes without moving, until the bottom bread slice is deep golden brown and crispy, and the bottom layer of Swiss cheese has started to melt and bubble slightly around the sandwich edges. Do not press down hard on the sandwiches with the spatula while cooking, as this will squeeze out fillings and press butter into the pan, leading to greasy, unevenly cooked bread.
Flip and Finish Cooking
Use the slotted stainless steel turner spatula to carefully flip each sandwich in one smooth motion. Cook for an additional 3 to 4 minutes on the second side, until the bread is equally golden and crispy, and all cheese is fully melted through the center—you will see soft, melted cheese oozing gently from all sides of the sandwich when it is ready. Transfer the first two cooked sandwiches to an off-white ceramic dinner plate, then repeat the cooking process with the remaining two sandwiches.
Rest and Slice Sandwiches
Once all sandwiches are fully cooked, transfer them back to the maple cutting board and let rest for 1 full minute to allow the melted cheese to set slightly—this prevents fillings from sliding out when cut. Use the 8-inch chef knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two triangular halves, wiping the knife blade between cuts if needed for clean slices.
Tips
2.Stick to medium-low heat for grilling: high heat will burn the buttered bread crust in 1 to 2 minutes, long before the cheese has a chance to fully melt and bind the fillings together, resulting in a burnt exterior and cold, un-melted center. Low and slow is key for perfect grilled cheese.
3.Let sandwiches rest for 1 minute before slicing: this short rest allows the melted cheese to firm up slightly, so it won’t gush out the sides when you cut into the sandwich, and keeps all the pastrami, sauerkraut, and cheese neatly layered in every bite.

OMG this is the closest I’ve gotten to a NYC deli Reuben without trekking 45 minutes into Manhattan! I used seeded rye like my grandpa always did and added an extra dollop of Thousand Island, total game changer for quick weeknight dinners. My roommate already asked me to make it again tomorrow.
Made these for my three kids after soccer practice last night and they DEVOURED them! I was worried the sauerkraut would be too tangy for the little ones but they didn’t even complain. Served with a side of dill pickles and potato chips, total comfort food win.
This was so easy to throw together for meal prep! I pre-portioned the pastrami, cheese, and drained sauerkraut into containers so I could assemble and grill these in 5 minutes for lunch all week. Only knock is I wish I’d bought better Swiss, the cheap pre-sliced stuff didn’t melt as nicely.
Threw these on the flat top griddle for our Sunday football watch party and people were lined up for seconds! I added a little extra pastrami (because duh, more meat = better) and sprinkled a tiny bit of caraway seed on the buttered bread for extra rye flavor. Absolute crowd pleaser.
As a broke college student with only a tiny dorm pan, I was shocked how easy this was to make! I didn’t have Thousand Island so I mixed mayo and ketchup with a little pickle brine and it worked perfectly. 10/10, will be making this every week instead of ordering takeout.
I’ve always hated sauerkraut but my partner begged me to make this so I caved… and I’m a convert? I guess when it’s melted with cheese and pastrami and that tangy dressing it’s actually incredible? Who knew. 10/10 even for sauerkraut haters.
I’ve been making Reubens for my husband for 50 years and I never thought to turn it into a grilled cheese! He said this was the best version I’ve ever made. I used homemade rye bread from my neighbor and it was chef’s kiss.
Wait why did I never think to combine my two favorite sandwiches?? This is genius. I had it for lunch today with a side of coleslaw and I’m already craving another one. So quick to make even on my busiest work from home days.
Just made this for a late lunch and OMG. The cheese pull was insane. I used extra sharp Swiss and piled the pastrami high, no regrets. 15 minutes is no joke, this came together faster than delivery would have showed up.
Brought a big batch of these cut into bite-sized squares to our neighborhood potluck and they were the first thing gone! Everyone was asking for the recipe, I told them I found my new go-to party food. So easy to scale for a crowd too.
Made this for my wife while she’s on maternity leave and she said it’s the best thing I’ve cooked since we brought the baby home! I accidentally forgot the sauerkraut on mine though, oops, still tasted great even without it.
I swapped the rye for gluten-free sourdough and used certified gluten-free pastrami and Thousand Island, and this turned out perfectly! I’ve missed Reubens since going GF and this hit every single craving. Thank you for such a flexible recipe!
Made this as a late night snack after a night out and I swear it’s the best thing I’ve ever eaten. No notes, 10/10, would burn my tongue on molten cheese again a million times over.
Made these as a post-hike refuel meal last weekend and they hit SO hard. Only change I made was adding a little spicy brown mustard to the spread for an extra kick. Will definitely be adding this to our regular camp meal rotation.
Super solid recipe! I used turkey pastrami because that’s what I had in the fridge and it was still really tasty. Next time I’ll splurge on the real beef pastrami though, I bet it’s even better.
I didn’t feel like standing over the stove so I made these in my air fryer at 375 for 6 minutes, flipping halfway, and the bread got perfectly crispy and the cheese was fully melted. Game changer for no-mess cooking!
Made these for me and my partner for our anniversary lunch at home (we didn’t feel like fighting restaurant crowds) and it felt so fancy for how little effort it took! We paired it with a couple of local IPAs and it was the perfect low-key date.
Used leftover pastrami from our weekend brisket smoke to make these and holy cow, it was next level. The smoky homemade pastrami paired so well with the tangy sauerkraut and melty Swiss, I’ll be making extra pastrami just for these sandwiches from now on.
This is the first recipe I’ve ever made that didn’t turn out burnt or weird! The instructions were so easy to follow even for someone who can barely boil water. My roommate thought I ordered it from a deli, I felt so proud of myself.