Pimento Cheese Grilled Cheese
intro
Crispy buttery sourdough encasing tangy, creamy homemade pimento cheese, this elevated grilled cheese is nostalgic, fast, and the ultimate cozy comfort food.
Ingredients
Steps
Grate Sharp Cheddar
Set the box grater on top of the acacia wood cutting board, with the medium stainless steel mixing bowl positioned below the grating surface to catch shreds. Hold the block of sharp orange cheddar against the coarse grating side, applying firm, even pressure to shred all 8oz of cheese into light, fluffy, separate shreds. Discard any small, hard end pieces of cheese, and set the bowl of grated cheddar aside temporarily. Do not use pre-shredded bagged cheese for this step, as it contains anti-caking agents that create a grainy melt.
Mix Pimento Spread
Add the softened 4oz cream cheese, 1/3 cup mayonnaise, 1/4 tsp garlic powder, 1/4 tsp smoked paprika, and 1/8 tsp flaky sea salt to the mixing bowl with the grated cheddar. Use the silicone spatula to stir the mixture for 1-2 minutes until fully combined, with no visible streaks of plain cream cheese or mayonnaise remaining. Gently fold in the fully drained diced pimentos and 1 tbsp chopped chives, taking care not to over-mash the pimentos so small, bright red chunks stay visible throughout the thick, spreadable mixture.
Prep Bread Slices
Use the serrated bread knife to cut the sourdough loaf into 8 even slices, each exactly 1/2-inch thick, discarding the thin end crust pieces if desired. Lay all 8 slices flat on the acacia wood cutting board. Use the small maple butter knife from the butter crock to spread 1/2 tbsp of softened salted butter evenly across one full side of every bread slice, spreading all the way to the crust edges to ensure even, crisp toasting. The buttered sides will form the outer crispy surface of the sandwiches.
Assemble Sandwiches
Flip 4 of the bread slices so their buttered sides face down on the cutting board. Scoop 1/2 cup of prepared pimento cheese onto each of these 4 slices, using the silicone spatula to spread the cheese evenly all the way to the bread edges (this eliminates dry, un-filled bites at the crusts). Top each base slice with a second bread slice, positioned so its buttered side faces up, pressing gently on the top of each sandwich to help the layers adhere. Both outer surfaces of every assembled sandwich should be fully buttered.
Preheat Cooking Skillet
Bring the 12-inch matte black carbon steel skillet to the center of the work surface, set over medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C for electric burners). Allow the skillet to preheat for 3 full minutes. Test the temperature by sprinkling a single drop of water onto the pan surface: the pan is ready when the drop sizzles immediately and dances across the surface without evaporating in under 2 seconds. Do not use high heat, as this will burn the bread before the cheese melts.
Cook First Side
Carefully place 2 assembled sandwiches into the preheated skillet, leaving 1 inch of space between them to allow even air flow. Cook undisturbed for 3-4 minutes, until the bottom bread slice is a deep, even golden brown and crispy to the touch, and the cheese closest to the pan has started to soften and melt. Do not press down on the sandwiches with the turner during cooking, as this will squeeze melted cheese out into the pan.
Flip and Cook Through
Use the slotted metal turner to carefully flip each sandwich in one smooth motion. Cook the second side for another 3-4 minutes, until it matches the first side’s deep golden crispness, and the pimento cheese in the center is fully melted, with small amounts oozing gently from the sandwich edges. If the bread browns faster than 3 minutes, reduce heat to low to give the cheese time to melt fully before the crust burns. Transfer cooked sandwiches to a clean spot on the cutting board, and repeat the cooking process with the remaining 2 sandwiches.
Rest and Plate
Once all sandwiches are cooked, let them rest on the cutting board for 1 full minute. This short rest allows the melted cheese to set slightly, so it stretches cleanly when bitten instead of running out immediately when cut. Use the serrated bread knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two equal triangles. Arrange two triangles per serving on the matte cream ceramic lunch plates, adding a few dill pickle slices on the side if desired.
Tips
2.Spread butter all the way to the crust edges of every bread slice: unbuttered bread edges will turn dry and pale instead of crisping up to a golden, buttery finish, leaving less flavorful, tough crusts on your finished sandwich.
3.Resist the urge to press down on sandwiches with the turner while cooking: pressing squeezes melted cheese out of the bread seams into the hot pan, which burns and reduces the amount of creamy filling left inside your sandwich.

OMG y’all, this pimento cheese grilled cheese is a total game changer! I made it for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging me for the recipe. The creamy pimento paired with that crispy buttery bread? *Chef’s kiss* I added a little extra dash of cayenne for a tiny kick and it was perfect. My kids even asked for seconds before they finished their first! 10/10 will be making this on repeat for quick weeknight dinners.
Super easy to make in my dorm room! Only took me like 10 minutes total in my tiny sandwich press, way better than the sad dining hall grilled cheese. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I didn’t have any pimentos on hand so I used roasted red peppers from a jar — still slapped, though. Will grab actual pimentos next time I run to the bodega.
This is our new go-to Friday night movie night dinner! I serve it with tomato soup for dipping, just like my mom used to make when I was little, but the pimento cheese makes it feel so much more special than regular grilled cheese. My 7 year old who hates “fancy food” devoured his, no complaints at all. SO good.
Meal prep win! I made a big batch of the pimento cheese on Sunday, then whipped these up for lunch all week long. Holds up great in the fridge, and the sandwich gets perfectly crispy even when I reheat it in the office toaster oven. Coworkers kept stopping by my desk to ask what smelled so good lmao
I’ve been making pimento cheese for family cookouts for 40 years, and I never thought to put it in a grilled cheese! Where has this recipe been all my life? I added a couple slices of crispy bacon to mine and it was out of this world. My grandkids are already asking when I’ll make it again.
Made this on my camp stove last weekend on a car camping trip and it hit so hard after a long hike. Only wish I’d brought extra cheese mix to make more — we were fighting over the last bite. Next time I’m packing pickles to add on top, I bet that brininess would cut the richness perfectly.
Just made this for lunch and I’m literally mad at how easy and good it is? I’ve been paying $12 for pimento grilled cheese at the café down the street when I can make it in 12 minutes at home for a fraction of the cost. Total game changer for my work from home lunch rotation.
Made these for my book club potluck tonight and they were the first thing gone! I cut them into little triangle bite-sized pieces so they were easy to grab, and everyone was raving. Even my friend who swears she hates pimento cheese went back for three servings lmao. Pro tip: slather a little mayo on the outside of the bread instead of butter for extra crisp, trust me.
Wow, this is so simple but so flavorful! I was skeptical that pimento cheese would work for grilled cheese but it’s so much creamier than regular sliced cheese. I added a little handful of pickled jalapeños to mine for a tangy kick and it was chef’s kiss. Perfect for a quick weeknight meal when I don’t feel like putting a ton of effort into cooking.