Pimento Cheese Grilled Cheese

title 1
Pimento Cheese Grilled Cheese
⏱️ cook time 12 minutes
🍽️ servings 4
⚡ Difficulty easy

intro

Crispy buttery sourdough encasing tangy, creamy homemade pimento cheese, this elevated grilled cheese is nostalgic, fast, and the ultimate cozy comfort food.

Ingredients

Crusty sourdough bread 8 slices (1/2-inch thick)
Sharp orange cheddar cheese 8oz (225g)
Full-fat cream cheese, softened 4oz (113g)
Diced pimentos, drained 1 (4oz/113g) jar
Full-fat mayonnaise 1/3 cup (75g)
Salted butter, softened 4 tbsp (56g)
Garlic powder 1/4 tsp
Smoked paprika 1/4 tsp
Flaky sea salt 1/8 tsp
Fresh chives, finely chopped 1 tbsp

Steps

1

Grate Sharp Cheddar

Set the box grater on top of the acacia wood cutting board, with the medium stainless steel mixing bowl positioned below the grating surface to catch shreds. Hold the block of sharp orange cheddar against the coarse grating side, applying firm, even pressure to shred all 8oz of cheese into light, fluffy, separate shreds. Discard any small, hard end pieces of cheese, and set the bowl of grated cheddar aside temporarily. Do not use pre-shredded bagged cheese for this step, as it contains anti-caking agents that create a grainy melt.

Step 1
step1:Grate Sharp Cheddar
2

Mix Pimento Spread

Add the softened 4oz cream cheese, 1/3 cup mayonnaise, 1/4 tsp garlic powder, 1/4 tsp smoked paprika, and 1/8 tsp flaky sea salt to the mixing bowl with the grated cheddar. Use the silicone spatula to stir the mixture for 1-2 minutes until fully combined, with no visible streaks of plain cream cheese or mayonnaise remaining. Gently fold in the fully drained diced pimentos and 1 tbsp chopped chives, taking care not to over-mash the pimentos so small, bright red chunks stay visible throughout the thick, spreadable mixture.

Step 2
step2:Mix Pimento Spread
Step 2
step2:Mix Pimento Spread
3

Prep Bread Slices

Use the serrated bread knife to cut the sourdough loaf into 8 even slices, each exactly 1/2-inch thick, discarding the thin end crust pieces if desired. Lay all 8 slices flat on the acacia wood cutting board. Use the small maple butter knife from the butter crock to spread 1/2 tbsp of softened salted butter evenly across one full side of every bread slice, spreading all the way to the crust edges to ensure even, crisp toasting. The buttered sides will form the outer crispy surface of the sandwiches.

Step 3
step3:Prep Bread Slices
4

Assemble Sandwiches

Flip 4 of the bread slices so their buttered sides face down on the cutting board. Scoop 1/2 cup of prepared pimento cheese onto each of these 4 slices, using the silicone spatula to spread the cheese evenly all the way to the bread edges (this eliminates dry, un-filled bites at the crusts). Top each base slice with a second bread slice, positioned so its buttered side faces up, pressing gently on the top of each sandwich to help the layers adhere. Both outer surfaces of every assembled sandwich should be fully buttered.

Step 4
step4:Assemble Sandwiches
5

Preheat Cooking Skillet

Bring the 12-inch matte black carbon steel skillet to the center of the work surface, set over medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C for electric burners). Allow the skillet to preheat for 3 full minutes. Test the temperature by sprinkling a single drop of water onto the pan surface: the pan is ready when the drop sizzles immediately and dances across the surface without evaporating in under 2 seconds. Do not use high heat, as this will burn the bread before the cheese melts.

Step 5
step5:Preheat Cooking Skillet
6

Cook First Side

Carefully place 2 assembled sandwiches into the preheated skillet, leaving 1 inch of space between them to allow even air flow. Cook undisturbed for 3-4 minutes, until the bottom bread slice is a deep, even golden brown and crispy to the touch, and the cheese closest to the pan has started to soften and melt. Do not press down on the sandwiches with the turner during cooking, as this will squeeze melted cheese out into the pan.

Step 6
step6:Cook First Side
Step 6
step6:Cook First Side
7

Flip and Cook Through

Use the slotted metal turner to carefully flip each sandwich in one smooth motion. Cook the second side for another 3-4 minutes, until it matches the first side’s deep golden crispness, and the pimento cheese in the center is fully melted, with small amounts oozing gently from the sandwich edges. If the bread browns faster than 3 minutes, reduce heat to low to give the cheese time to melt fully before the crust burns. Transfer cooked sandwiches to a clean spot on the cutting board, and repeat the cooking process with the remaining 2 sandwiches.

Step 7
step7:Flip and Cook Through
8

Rest and Plate

Once all sandwiches are cooked, let them rest on the cutting board for 1 full minute. This short rest allows the melted cheese to set slightly, so it stretches cleanly when bitten instead of running out immediately when cut. Use the serrated bread knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two equal triangles. Arrange two triangles per serving on the matte cream ceramic lunch plates, adding a few dill pickle slices on the side if desired.

Step 8
step8:Rest and Plate

Tips

1.Grate your own cheddar cheese instead of using pre-shredded bagged cheese: pre-shredded cheese is coated in potato starch and anti-mold preservatives that prevent smooth melting, resulting in a grainy, separated pimento cheese texture instead of a creamy, cohesive melt.
2.Spread butter all the way to the crust edges of every bread slice: unbuttered bread edges will turn dry and pale instead of crisping up to a golden, buttery finish, leaving less flavorful, tough crusts on your finished sandwich.
3.Resist the urge to press down on sandwiches with the turner while cooking: pressing squeezes melted cheese out of the bread seams into the hot pan, which burns and reduces the amount of creamy filling left inside your sandwich.

✨ You May Also Like

Lunch
🍜 United States

Creamy, salty, tangy nostalgic Midwestern sandwich pairing rich peanut butter with crisp briny dill pickles for a fast, satisfying no-cook meal.

⏱️ 5 minutesLunch ★ 4.6
Lunch
🍜 United States

Crispy, melty pressed sandwich layered with savory roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and tangy mustard: a beloved Cuban-American comfort classic.

⏱️ 25 minuteLunch ★ 4.9
Lunch
🍜 United States

Hearty, briny New Orleans pressed sandwich stacked with cured Italian meats, provolone, and zesty olive salad, served cold for bold, portable flavor.

⏱️ 1 hour 20Lunch ★ 4.7
Lunch
🍜 United States

A tangy, creamy Southern American staple, this no-cook cheesy sandwich is packed with sharp cheddar and sweet pimentos for a satisfying, portable bite.

⏱️ 1 hour 15Lunch ★ 4.8
Lunch
🍜 United States

Crispy Cajun-spiced fried shrimp piled on crusty French bread with tangy remoulade and fresh toppings, the iconic Louisiana street food sandwich.

⏱️ 35 minuteLunch ★ 4.4
Lunch
🍜 United States

Stacked, savory deli-style corned beef sandwich with melted Swiss, tangy mustard, and crisp griddled rye— a fast, hearty, satisfying classic.

⏱️ 15 minuteLunch ★ 4.9

Pimento Cheese Grilled Cheese:Frequently Asked Questions

1.Do I have to use sourdough bread for this recipe, or can I swap it for another bread? ▾
Sourdough’s tangy, crisp crust and chewy crumb pairs perfectly with rich, creamy pimento cheese, but you can absolutely swap it if you prefer! Sturdy picks like thick-cut white sandwich bread, country loaf, or light rye work great—just avoid super soft, thin-sliced bread that will get soggy or fall apart while cooking.
2.Why do you recommend full-fat cream cheese and mayo instead of low-fat versions? ▾
Full-fat dairy and mayo create that luxuriously creamy, smooth pimento cheese texture home cooks love, plus they melt evenly without separating as the sandwich cooks. Low-fat versions often have added stabilizers and extra water that can make your filling runny, grainy, or bland when heated, so skip them for the best possible result.
3.How do I keep my grilled cheese from getting soggy while cooking? ▾
Start by making sure your diced pimentos are fully drained—pat them dry with a paper towel if they’re extra juicy straight from the jar! Cook over medium-low heat instead of high, spread softened (not melted) butter evenly on the outer bread slices, and don’t overstuff the sandwich to avoid filling seepage.
4.Can I make the pimento cheese filling ahead of time? ▾
Absolutely! Homemade pimento cheese stays fresh in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 5 days. In fact, making it a day ahead lets the tangy, savory flavors meld together even better. Just let it sit at room temp for 10 minutes before assembling sandwiches so it spreads easily.
5.What kind of pimentos should I use for this recipe? ▾
Jarred, diced roasted red pimentos are the classic, nostalgic pick for this recipe—just make sure you drain them really well, as excess brine will make your filling watery. If you don’t have jarred pimentos, you can swap in finely diced roasted red peppers for a nearly identical, slightly smoky flavor.
6.Why is my pimento cheese filling grainy instead of smooth? ▾
Grainy filling almost always comes from using cold, straight-from-the-fridge cream cheese, pre-shredded cheddar coated in anti-caking starch, or not mixing the filling long enough. Make sure your cream cheese is fully softened to room temp, shred your own cheddar fresh, and mix until all ingredients are completely combined.
7.What heat setting should I use so the bread crisps up before the cheese melts out? ▾
Stick to medium-low heat, no higher! If your pan is too hot, the butter will burn and the bread will turn dark and crispy long before the pimento cheese filling is fully melted and gooey. Cook 3-4 minutes per side, until bread is golden and filling oozes slightly at the edges.
8.Can I add extra mix-ins to the pimento cheese filling? ▾
Of course! This recipe is super customizable. Popular add-ins include a pinch of cayenne for gentle heat, a dash of Worcestershire sauce for umami, finely diced pickled jalapeños for zing, or a sprinkle of smoked paprika for depth. Just don’t add so many extras that the filling loses its creamy, spreadable texture.
9.Do I have to use sharp orange cheddar, or can I use a different cheese? ▾
Sharp orange cheddar gives the filling that classic bold, tangy flavor and iconic bright orange hue, but you can swap in other melty cheeses if you prefer. White sharp cheddar, gouda, Monterey Jack, or a little crumbled pepper jack work beautifully—just avoid hard, non-melting cheeses like parmesan as your main base.
10.Can I make this recipe dairy-free? ▾
You can absolutely adapt this recipe for dairy-free diets! Swap the sharp cheddar for your favorite melty dairy-free sharp cheddar shreds, use dairy-free cream cheese, and pick a vegan full-fat mayonnaise. Just note that some dairy-free cheeses melt slower, so you may need an extra minute of cook time per side.
11.How much butter should I use on the bread for that perfect crispy crust? ▾
Use about 1 teaspoon of softened, unsalted butter per slice of bread, spread in a thin, even layer all the way to the edges. Don’t douse the bread in butter—that will make it greasy instead of crisp. If you prefer, swap half the butter for full-fat mayo for an extra tangy, ultra-crisp crust.
12.Can I freeze assembled pimento cheese grilled cheeses for quick meals later? ▾
I don’t recommend freezing fully assembled, cooked sandwiches, as the bread will get mushy when you reheat them. You can, however, freeze the prepared pimento cheese filling for up to 3 months, then thaw it in the fridge overnight when you’re ready to assemble and cook fresh sandwiches for the best texture.
13.What are good side dishes to serve with this grilled cheese? ▾
This rich, tangy sandwich pairs perfectly with bright, fresh sides to cut through the heavy creaminess of the filling. Classic picks include creamy tomato soup, dill pickle spears, a simple arugula salad with lemon vinaigrette, crispy potato chips, or tangy coleslaw for that perfect cozy, nostalgic meal vibe.
14.My cheese isn’t fully melted by the time the bread is golden—what did I do wrong? ▾
This usually happens if you spread the pimento cheese too thick, or used ice-cold filling straight from the fridge. If you notice the bread browning too fast, turn the heat down to low, cover the pan with a lid for 1-2 minutes, and trapped steam will melt the cheese all the way through without burning the bread.
15.Is it okay to use light mayonnaise if that’s all I have on hand? ▾
Light mayo will work in a pinch, but be aware it has a higher water content than full-fat mayo, which can make your filling a little runnier and less rich. If you use light mayo, pat your pimentos extra dry, and add an extra ounce of softened cream cheese to thicken the filling and balance the texture.
16.Can I cook these in an air fryer instead of on the stovetop? ▾
Definitely! Assemble the sandwiches as directed, butter the outer sides of the bread, and cook in a 375°F air fryer for 4-5 minutes, flipping halfway through, until the bread is crispy and golden and the filling is melted. Keep a close eye on them, as air fryer temperatures vary widely between models.
17.How do I keep the pimento cheese from oozing out of the sandwich while it cooks? ▾
First, don’t overstuff the sandwich—about ⅓ cup of pimento cheese per sandwich is the perfect amount. Make sure you spread the filling all the way to the edges of the bread, and press the top slice down firmly before cooking. Cooking over medium-low heat also helps cheese melt gradually instead of bubbling out fast.
18.Can I add meat or other fillings to make this a more hearty sandwich? ▾
Absolutely! If you want to bulk this up into a heartier meal, thin slices of crispy bacon, smoked turkey, caramelized onions, or sliced tomato (patted very dry to avoid sogginess) all pair beautifully with tangy pimento cheese. Just don’t add too many thick layers, or the filling won’t heat through evenly.

Comments (9)

2 days ago

OMG y’all, this pimento cheese grilled cheese is a total game changer! I made it for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging me for the recipe. The creamy pimento paired with that crispy buttery bread? *Chef’s kiss* I added a little extra dash of cayenne for a tiny kick and it was perfect. My kids even asked for seconds before they finished their first! 10/10 will be making this on repeat for quick weeknight dinners.

yesterday

Wait the cayenne add is genius! I made this plain last night and thought it was missing a little zing, definitely trying that next time. Did you use sharp cheddar or the mild stuff?

yesterday

So glad it was a hit at the potluck! Love the cayenne addition — a little heat pairs so perfectly with the creamy pimento. We recommend sharp cheddar for the deepest flavor, but mild works great if that’s what your family prefers!

5 minutes ago

Super easy to make in my dorm room! Only took me like 10 minutes total in my tiny sandwich press, way better than the sad dining hall grilled cheese. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I didn’t have any pimentos on hand so I used roasted red peppers from a jar — still slapped, though. Will grab actual pimentos next time I run to the bodega.

just now

Roasted red peppers are such a great swap when you don’t have pimentos handy! So happy this worked out for your dorm cooking setup — 10 minutes flat is totally doable even without a full kitchen.

1 week ago

This is our new go-to Friday night movie night dinner! I serve it with tomato soup for dipping, just like my mom used to make when I was little, but the pimento cheese makes it feel so much more special than regular grilled cheese. My 7 year old who hates “fancy food” devoured his, no complaints at all. SO good.

yesterday

Meal prep win! I made a big batch of the pimento cheese on Sunday, then whipped these up for lunch all week long. Holds up great in the fridge, and the sandwich gets perfectly crispy even when I reheat it in the office toaster oven. Coworkers kept stopping by my desk to ask what smelled so good lmao

2 hours ago

Wait how long does the pimento cheese last in the fridge? I’ve been looking for easy make-ahead lunch ideas that don’t get soggy!

30 minutes ago

Love that you prepped the cheese ahead — that’s such a smart time saver! The homemade pimento cheese will stay fresh for up to a week in an airtight container in the fridge, perfect for quick lunches all week long.

3 days ago

I’ve been making pimento cheese for family cookouts for 40 years, and I never thought to put it in a grilled cheese! Where has this recipe been all my life? I added a couple slices of crispy bacon to mine and it was out of this world. My grandkids are already asking when I’ll make it again.

2 days ago

The bacon addition sounds insane! I’m making these for our family cookout this weekend and I’m absolutely throwing bacon on half of them for the meat lovers in my crew. Thanks for the tip!

2 weeks ago

Made this on my camp stove last weekend on a car camping trip and it hit so hard after a long hike. Only wish I’d brought extra cheese mix to make more — we were fighting over the last bite. Next time I’m packing pickles to add on top, I bet that brininess would cut the richness perfectly.

2 hours ago

Just made this for lunch and I’m literally mad at how easy and good it is? I’ve been paying $12 for pimento grilled cheese at the café down the street when I can make it in 12 minutes at home for a fraction of the cost. Total game changer for my work from home lunch rotation.

30 minutes ago

So happy this is saving you lunch money! Nothing beats a homemade version that comes together faster than you can wait for takeout delivery. Enjoy!

30 minutes ago

Made these for my book club potluck tonight and they were the first thing gone! I cut them into little triangle bite-sized pieces so they were easy to grab, and everyone was raving. Even my friend who swears she hates pimento cheese went back for three servings lmao. Pro tip: slather a little mayo on the outside of the bread instead of butter for extra crisp, trust me.

5 minutes ago

The mayo on the outside trick is chef’s kiss! I started doing that for all my grilled cheeses a couple years ago and I’ll never go back to butter. Makes the crust so perfectly crunchy without burning!

just now

The bite-sized cut is such a smart potluck hack! And the mayo crust tip is 100% approved — it gives such an amazing golden, crispy exterior that’s hard to beat. So glad your book club loved them!

5 days ago

Wow, this is so simple but so flavorful! I was skeptical that pimento cheese would work for grilled cheese but it’s so much creamier than regular sliced cheese. I added a little handful of pickled jalapeños to mine for a tangy kick and it was chef’s kiss. Perfect for a quick weeknight meal when I don’t feel like putting a ton of effort into cooking.