Potato Filling

title 1
Potato Filling
⏱️ cook time 55 minutes
🍽️ servings 6
⚡ Difficulty easy

intro

Creamy, savory baked potato filling with buttery herbs and soft bread, a hearty Pennsylvania Dutch Thanksgiving side with German roots, perfect alongside roasted turkey.

Ingredients

Russet potatoes 900 grams (about 4 medium, peeled, cut into 1-inch cubes)
Unsalted butter 113 grams (1 stick, divided)
Yellow onion 150 grams (1 medium, finely diced)
Celery 100 grams (2 stalks, finely diced)
Garlic 9 grams (3 cloves, minced)
Day-old white bread 120 grams (4 slices, cut into ½-inch cubes)
Whole milk 180 ml (¾ cup)
Low-sodium chicken broth 120 ml (½ cup)
Cold water 2 liters (for boiling potatoes)
Dried sage 1 teaspoon (1 gram)
Dried thyme ½ teaspoon (0.5 grams)
Kosher salt 1 tablespoon (18 grams, divided)
Ground black pepper ½ teaspoon (1 gram)
Fresh flat-leaf parsley 6 grams (2 tablespoons, chopped, divided)
Large egg 50 grams (1, lightly beaten)

Steps

1

Cook the potatoes

Place 900g peeled, 1-inch cubed russet potatoes in a large stockpot, cover with 2 liters of cold water mixed with 9g (1.5 tsp) kosher salt, bring to a rolling boil over medium-high heat, then reduce to medium heat to maintain a gentle simmer. Cook for 12-15 minutes until fork-tender, when a paring knife slides through a potato cube with no resistance. Drain fully in a colander and set aside.

Step 1
step1:Cook the potatoes
2

Sauté aromatic vegetables

Heat 80g (≈5.5 tbsp) unsalted butter in a 10-inch skillet over medium heat. Once the butter melts and foaming subsides, add 150g finely diced yellow onion and 100g finely diced celery. Cook for 7-8 minutes, stirring occasionally with a wooden spoon, until vegetables are soft and translucent. Add 9g minced garlic, 1g dried sage, and 0.5g dried thyme, stir constantly for 30 seconds until fragrant (do not let garlic burn), then remove the pan from heat.

Step 2
step2:Sauté aromatic vegetables
3

Combine filling base

Transfer the drained cooked potatoes to a 3-liter large mixing bowl, add the sautéed aromatic butter and vegetable mixture, 180ml whole milk, 120ml low-sodium chicken broth, 50g lightly beaten large egg, remaining 9g (1.5 tsp) kosher salt, and 1g ground black pepper. Mash with a potato masher until mostly smooth, leaving a few small soft potato chunks for texture. Fold in 120g ½-inch cubed day-old white bread and 4g chopped fresh parsley until all ingredients are evenly distributed.

Step 3
step3:Combine filling base
4

Assemble baking dish

Preheat your oven to 190°C (375°F). Use 5g (1 tsp) of the remaining unsalted butter to grease the bottom and sides of a 23x23cm (9x9 inch) square baking dish evenly. Scoop the entire potato filling mixture into the prepared dish, spreading it into a smooth, even layer with a silicone spatula.

Step 4
step4:Assemble baking dish
5

Bake until golden

Melt the remaining 28g (2 tbsp) unsalted butter, then drizzle it evenly over the top of the unbaked filling. Place the dish on the middle rack of the preheated oven, bake uncovered for 30-35 minutes, until the top is lightly golden brown and the edges are actively bubbling. Remove from the oven, let the filling rest for 5 minutes at room temperature, then garnish with the remaining 2g chopped fresh parsley before serving.

Step 5
step5:Bake until golden

Tips

1.Use day-old (slightly stale) white bread instead of fresh bread for this recipe: fresh bread will turn mushy and make the filling soggy, while stale bread holds its shape and absorbs savory butter and herb flavors beautifully.
2.This dish is very make-ahead friendly: assemble the unbaked filling in the greased dish, cover tightly with plastic wrap, and refrigerate for up to 24 hours. Add 10 minutes to the baking time when cooking straight from the refrigerator.
3.Customize the filling to your taste: swap chicken broth for vegetable broth to make it vegetarian, add 60g crumbled cooked breakfast sausage for extra savoriness, or top with 30g toasted breadcrumbs for a crunchier top.

✨ You May Also Like

Side Dishes
🍜 India

Velvety, aromatic all-purpose curry sauce perfect for tossing with roasted veggies, grilled protein, or rice for fast, cozy, flavorful meals.

⏱️ 25 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.8
Side Dishes
🍜 Spain

Tender, starchy boiled yuca tossed in bright, garlicky citrus mojo sauce—an iconic, zesty side that pairs beautifully with roasted pork, grilled meats, and rice and beans.

⏱️ 40 minuteSide Dishes ★ 5
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Tender, paper-thin potato flatbread, a beloved Norwegian-American Minnesota Christmas staple, griddled until softly spotted and served warm with butter.

⏱️ 1 hour 30Side Dishes ★ 4.6
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Rich, deeply savory cured salt pork, a long-lasting kitchen staple perfect for frying crispy as a side or adding umami to stews, beans, and chowders.

⏱️ 7 days (2Side Dishes ★ 4.9
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Crispy, tangy classic Southern fried green tomatoes with a crunchy cornmeal crust, served hot for a nostalgic, comforting summery bite.

⏱️ 25 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.9
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Moist, golden-crusted savory muffins with sweet corn, zesty jalapeño, and melted cheddar, perfect for pairing with smoky summer grilled fare.

⏱️ 30 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.9

Potato Filling:Frequently Asked Questions

1.How is this classic baked potato filling different from regular mashed potatoes? ▾
Great question! Unlike smooth, dairy-forward mashed potatoes that are often light on mix-ins, this Pennsylvania Dutch staple with deep German roots incorporates butter-soaked soft bread and sautéed aromatics for a heartier, textured, savory bite that’s perfectly designed to soak up roasted turkey gravy at Thanksgiving and other holiday meals.
2.Can I use a potato variety other than Russets for this recipe? ▾
I strongly recommend sticking with Russet potatoes for the best results. Their high starch content breaks down into that signature fluffy, light base when cooked; waxy options like red potatoes or Yukon Golds will turn dense, gummy, and overly firm, throwing off the filling’s classic soft, creamy, melt-in-your-mouth consistency.
3.Do I have to bake the potatoes first, or can I boil them to save prep time? ▾
Baking whole, pricked Russets at 400°F for about an hour delivers the best deep, earthy, dry fluffy texture, but if you’re crunched for time on a holiday, you can cube and boil them for 12–15 minutes until fork-tender. Just drain them extremely well first—excess water will make your filling soggy instead of rich and creamy.
4.What type of bread works best for the soft bread component in this filling? ▾
Plain, soft white sandwich bread is the traditional, most reliable pick for this recipe. Tear it into 1-inch pieces (remove crusts for an ultra-smooth texture) so it absorbs melted butter and potato starch evenly. Skip crusty sourdough or dense whole-grain loaves, which create tough, chewy bits in the final dish.
5.Can I make this baked potato filling a day ahead to cut down on Thanksgiving day work? ▾
Absolutely! Assemble the filling fully, transfer it to a greased, buttered baking dish, let it cool completely to room temperature, then cover tightly with foil and refrigerate for up to 24 hours. When ready to serve, bake covered at 375°F for 30 minutes, then uncover for 10 minutes to crisp the top slightly.
6.My filling turned out too dry when I tested the recipe—how do I fix that? ▾
Dry filling usually happens if potatoes were over-drained, your bread was overly stale, or you skimped on melted butter during prep. Fix it immediately by stirring in 2 tablespoons of warm low-sodium chicken broth or melted butter at a time, mixing gently, until you reach that soft, creamy, spreadable consistency. Don’t overmix, or it will turn gummy!
7.How can I add extra flavor to the filling without making it too heavy? ▾
Stir in 1 teaspoon of dried rubbed sage or 2 tablespoons of chopped fresh parsley and thyme right before baking for a bright herby kick, or add ¼ cup of finely chopped cooked bacon for salty, smoky depth. Skip heavy mix-ins like loads of cheddar or sour cream, which weigh down the filling’s light, classic texture.
8.Do I need to sauté the onion, celery, and garlic first, or can I mix them in raw? ▾
Always sauté those aromatics first in melted butter over medium-low heat for 5–7 minutes, until the onion is soft and translucent and the garlic is fragrant (don’t let the garlic burn!). Raw veggies will stay crunchy and release harsh, sharp flavors as the filling bakes, ruining the dish’s signature mellow, savory profile.
9.What main dishes pair well with this filling besides roasted Thanksgiving turkey? ▾
While it’s a natural match for roasted Thanksgiving turkey, this hearty side also pairs beautifully with baked glazed ham, whole roast chicken, pan-seared pork chops, or braised bratwurst for cozy cold-weather weeknight meals. Serve it with tangy green beans or pickled beets to cut through the richness, just like traditional PA Dutch spreads do.
10.Can I adapt this recipe to be dairy-free for guests with dietary restrictions? ▾
Yes, this is a really easy recipe to adapt for dairy-free guests! Swap the unsalted butter for a high-quality neutral plant-based butter (skip olive oil, which will alter the classic buttery flavor), use soft dairy-free white bread, and confirm any broth you use for moisture adjustments is also dairy-free for full compliance.

Comments (19)

2 days ago

OMG this baked potato filling is a total game changer for our weekly family dinners! My picky 4 year old asked for seconds, which never happens. I added a little extra shredded cheddar and a sprinkle of bacon bits, chef’s kiss. 10/10 will make again for our next neighborhood potluck too.

yesterday

Wait I brought this to my church potluck last month and people were begging for the recipe! The leftovers even hold up great for lunch the next day.

yesterday

So glad your whole family loved it! Adding extra cheddar and bacon is such a tasty twist, we love when folks customize the recipe to their tastes.

3 days ago

Super easy to whip up, even for a guy who burns toast half the time. Cook time was spot on at 55 minutes, the filling came out creamy and perfectly seasoned. I meal prepped a batch on Sunday and ate it for lunch all week, no sogginess at all!

2 days ago

Thrilled this worked out for your meal prep! So many people don’t realize how well this filling stores in the fridge for quick weekday meals, that’s such a smart use for it.

1 week ago

I swapped the sour cream for plain Greek yogurt to lighten it up a bit and added some steamed broccoli, and it was SO good. Perfect easy weeknight side when I don’t feel like putting a ton of effort into cooking.

5 days ago

Made these to go with my smoked ribs last weekend for the game watch party, and everyone raved. I did add a dollop of garlic butter on top right before serving, highly recommend that little hack.

3 days ago

Oh the garlic butter addition sounds insane! I’m making these for our college football tailgate next weekend, definitely stealing that tip.

1 week ago

Wait this was so much easier than I thought it would be! I’m in a dorm with a tiny toaster oven, and I was able to make this without any fancy equipment. Only thing is I think I over-salted mine a little, oops. Still tasty though!

5 days ago

Pro tip: Taste as you add salt! I did the same thing my first time making this, now I add a pinch at a time and it comes out perfect every time.

5 days ago

We’re so impressed you pulled this off in a dorm toaster oven! Next time, hold off on adding extra salt until you’ve mixed in all the fillings, since ingredients like cheese and butter already have natural saltiness that can sneak up on you.

2 weeks ago

Solid, classic baked potato filling, no weird fancy ingredients which I love. It’s exactly what I want when I’m craving a cozy, no-fuss baked potato on a cold night. Will be adding this to my regular rotation.

2 hours ago

Why did I ever buy those pre-made frozen potato fillings? This is 100x better, cheaper too. I added some chopped chives from my windowsill planter and it tasted like something you’d get at a fancy steakhouse.

30 minutes ago

Nothing beats homemade! Fresh chives are such a bright, delicious addition, we love that you used homegrown herbs too.

2 days ago

Made this last night with the kids, they had a blast helping mash the filling and mix in the cheese. It was the perfect easy activity for a rainy school night, and dinner was done right when my husband got home from work.

yesterday

Oh my kids love helping with this too! I let them pick their own mix-ins (one does olives, one does extra cheese, weirdos) and it makes dinner way less of a fight.

1 week ago

So happy this recipe is naturally gluten free! I brought it to a friend’s BBQ where a few of us have celiac, and everyone felt safe eating it and loved how creamy it was. No weird fillers, just simple, real food.

5 days ago

Right?! I’m always hunting for potluck recipes that don’t require 100 special GF substitutes, and this one fits the bill perfectly. My non-GF husband didn’t even notice a difference.

5 days ago

We love that this recipe works for so many different dietary needs right out of the gate! It makes us so happy to hear it was a hit at your BBQ.

30 minutes ago

Followed the recipe exactly and it turned out great! I was really nervous I’d mess up baked potatoes for my first time hosting friends, but everyone said they were perfect. Easy to follow steps, no confusing jargon.

3 days ago

I made this when I was home sick last week, and it was the coziest thing ever. Warm, creamy, salty, exactly what my sore throat needed. I added a little extra black pepper and it was perfect.

2 days ago

So sorry you were under the weather, but we’re glad this cozy recipe hit the spot! Extra black pepper is always a good call in our book.

2 weeks ago

Wait this is perfect for bulk meal prep! I made 8 potatoes worth of filling on Sunday, portioned it out into containers, and just reheat for 90 seconds at work. Way cheaper and tastier than getting takeout for lunch every day.

1 week ago

Same! I started doing this last month and I’ve saved like $50 a week on lunch. Pro tip: don’t add the green onions until right before you eat, otherwise they get a little mushy when reheated.

5 days ago

I thought classic baked potato filling was just… sour cream and butter? But this recipe levels it up with the little bit of garlic powder and cream cheese, wow. I was a hater at first but my wife made it and I’m converted. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish there was a little more guidance on how to pick the best potatoes for baking.

3 days ago

Russet potatoes all the way! Their skin gets crispy and the inside gets super fluffy, perfect for scooping out and mixing with the filling. I learned that the hard way after using red potatoes once, they were too waxy.

3 days ago

So glad we converted you! Great tip on the russet potatoes, too. We recommend starchy russet potatoes for the fluffiest filling, and we’ll add that note to the recipe card right away to help other folks out.

5 minutes ago

Made this for a casual date night in with my partner, paired with steak and a side salad, and he said it was better than the baked potatoes we get at our favorite steakhouse. Win for me! Super easy to make even when you’re trying to impress someone without slaving over the stove all night.

1 week ago

I’ve been making baked potatoes for 40+ years, and I have to say, this recipe is the best version I’ve tried. The touch of cream cheese makes the filling so velvety without being heavy. My grandkids begged me to make it again when they visited last weekend.

5 days ago

Wow, coming from someone with 40 years of potato-making experience, that means the world to us! We’re so glad the grandkids loved it too—those are the best reviews.

2 hours ago

I tossed in a handful of pickled jalapeños and a sprinkle of cajun seasoning to give this a little kick, and it was insane. Great base recipe that you can tweak however you want without messing it up, which is perfect for people who like to experiment.

30 minutes ago

Oh the pickled jalapeño addition sounds chef’s kiss. I’m gonna add a drizzle of hot honey on top too when I make this this weekend, that sweet and spicy combo is gonna slap.

yesterday

Made this for our office potluck yesterday, and the pan was scraped clean in 10 minutes. Multiple coworkers asked for the recipe, so I sent them the link. The only tiny issue was that my potatoes took a little longer than 55 minutes to cook through, but that’s probably just my old oven being finicky.

2 hours ago

Same! My oven runs 25 degrees cold, so I had to add an extra 10 minutes. Next time I’ll just test them with a fork earlier to make sure they’re soft all the way through before I scoop them out.

30 minutes ago

We love that it was such a hit at your office potluck! Oven temperatures can vary so much, so we always recommend testing potatoes with a fork to make sure they’re tender all the way through—if they need a few extra minutes, that’s totally normal! We’ll add a note about that to the recipe to help folks with finicky ovens.

just now

I used dairy free cream cheese and oat milk sour cream to make this vegan for my sister when she visited, and even the dairy lovers in my family went back for seconds. You couldn’t even tell it was dairy free, the texture was still super creamy!

3 days ago

Made these for our Super Bowl party back in February and they were such a hit, I’m making them again for our season opener watch party this weekend. Easy to make a big batch, handheld if you stuff the filling back in the skins, perfect for game day snacking.