Potato Salad
intro
Creamy, tangy potato salad with tender potatoes, hard-boiled eggs, and crisp veggies, the iconic cold side for summer picnics and cookouts.
Ingredients
Steps
Boil potatoes and eggs
Place whole unpeeled Yukon Gold potatoes and whole eggs into the 6-quart brushed stainless steel stock pot, cover with cold water by 1 inch, add 1 tsp kosher salt. Bring to a rolling boil over high heat, then reduce heat to maintain a gentle simmer. Cook eggs for exactly 9 minutes, then remove with the slotted stainless steel spoon and plunge immediately into a bowl of ice water to stop cooking and prevent green rings around the yolk. Continue simmering potatoes for 15-18 minutes total, testing doneness by inserting the paring knife into the center of a potato: the knife should slide in easily with no resistance, but the potato should not split or fall apart when lifted.
Drain and cool potatoes
Once potatoes are fully cooked, carefully pour the entire contents of the pot into the stainless steel colander to drain off all hot water. Set the colander with drained potatoes on a clear spot on the counter, and let them cool for 15 minutes at room temperature, until they are warm to the touch but not burning hot. Do not rinse potatoes with cold water, as this washes away the surface starch that helps dressing cling to the chunks.
Mix creamy dressing
While potatoes cool, add mayonnaise, yellow mustard, apple cider vinegar, remaining 1/2 tsp kosher salt, ground black pepper, and celery seed to the large clear tempered glass mixing bowl. Stir with the pale yellow silicone spatula until completely smooth and evenly combined, then fold in finely diced celery, finely diced yellow onion, diced sweet pickles, and 1 tbsp of chopped fresh dill. Stir gently to distribute the vegetable chunks evenly throughout the dressing.
Chop potatoes and eggs
Once potatoes are cool enough to handle comfortably, use the 3.5-inch paring knife to slip off the skins—they should pull away easily with no scraping required. Cut peeled potatoes into uniform 1-inch chunks, then peel the fully cooled hard-boiled eggs. Chop 2 of the eggs into rough 1/2-inch chunks to mix into the salad, and slice the third egg into thin 1/4-inch rounds to reserve for garnish.
Toss salad gently
Add the warm potato chunks and chopped egg to the mixing bowl with the prepared dressing. Use the silicone spatula to fold the ingredients together very gently, taking care not to press down or mash the potatoes, until every chunk is evenly coated in a thin layer of dressing. Over-stirring will result in a mushy, gluey salad, so stop as soon as no dry potato chunks remain.
Chill to meld flavors
Cover the mixing bowl tightly with plastic wrap and transfer to the refrigerator to chill for a minimum of 2 hours, or up to 24 hours for make-ahead prep. Chilling allows the potatoes to absorb dressing flavor, lets the spices mellow, and ensures the salad is cold and firm for serving; skipping this step will result in runny, greasy, flat-tasting salad.
Plate and garnish
Once the salad is fully chilled, remove it from the refrigerator and give it one slow, gentle stir to redistribute any dressing that settled at the bottom. Mound the salad loosely in the center of the matte cream ceramic oval serving platter. Arrange the reserved hard-boiled egg slices across the top, sprinkle with the remaining 1 tbsp chopped fresh dill, and dust lightly with smoked paprika for a subtle smoky note and pop of color.
Tips
2.Toss potatoes with dressing while they are still slightly warm (not hot, not cold): Warm potato cells are open and receptive to absorbing dressing flavors, resulting in a more evenly seasoned salad, whereas cold potatoes repel dressing, leaving it pooled at the bottom of the bowl.
3.Resist the urge to over-stir when combining ingredients: Folding gently with a silicone spatula instead of stirring vigorously keeps potato chunks intact, so your salad has a pleasant, chunky texture instead of a gluey, mashed potato consistency.

OMG this potato salad is EXACTLY what I was missing for our weekly family cookouts! I’ve tried so many deli-style recipes that came out too tangy or too watery, but this one is perfect—creamy, just the right amount of pickle crunch, and the potatoes hold their shape so well. My kids went back for seconds before I even finished serving the burgers! 10/10, will be making this for every potluck from now on.
Game changer for weekend meal prep! I made a big batch Sunday to eat with lunches all week, and it held up way better than the store-bought stuff I usually grab. Only tweak I made was adding a little extra dill because I’m obsessed, but the base recipe is flawless. So glad I found this—saved me $10 a week on deli potato salad, no cap.
I made a test batch of this last night to try before my graduation party potluck next weekend, and it was SO good! Quick question though—if I make the full batch the night before the party and keep it covered in the fridge, will the potatoes get soggy? I don’t want to serve mushy salad to 20 guests, haha.
Bro, this is so easy even I didn’t mess it up. I live in a dorm with a tiny hot plate and a mini fridge, and I pulled this off in like 25 minutes total (only took a little longer than the recipe said because my stove is garbage). My roommates lost their minds, thought I bought it from the deli down the street. Absolute win.
I’ve made this twice now and it’s been a hit both times! My only question is—has anyone tried swapping half the mayo for plain Greek yogurt to lighten it up a little? I’m trying to cut back on a few calories but don’t want to ruin that perfect creamy texture everyone loves.
Made this for our post-hike picnic over the weekend and it was gone in 10 minutes flat. I added a little crumbled bacon and some chopped celery for extra crunch, and everyone was raving. The cook time was spot on too—20 minutes boil time for the potatoes was exactly right, no undercooked spuds, no mush. Will be in our regular picnic rotation for sure!
SO good! I added a tiny spoonful of hot sauce to the dressing for a little kick and it was chef’s kiss. This is way better than the sad grocery store potato salad I’ve been buying for work lunches. Easy to make, cheap ingredients, tastes exactly like the stuff from my favorite Jewish deli back home in Brooklyn. Obsessed.
I tried making this last night for a test run before my dinner party this weekend and it was so tasty! But I messed up and used the last of my russets, and only have red potatoes left for the party batch. Will red potatoes work okay instead? I don’t have time to run to the store before then, and I really want this to turn out for my guests!