Pumpernickel Reuben Grilled Cheese

title 1
Pumpernickel Reuben Grilled Cheese
⏱️ cook time 10 minutes
🍽️ servings 4
⚡ Difficulty easy

intro

Toasted dark pumpernickel loaded with salty corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss, and zesty Russian dressing: the elevated deli classic grilled cheese for cozy, quick meals.

Ingredients

Dark pumpernickel bread (sliced 1cm thick) 8 slices
Thinly sliced deli corned beef 340g
Sliced Swiss cheese 160g (8 slices)
Sauerkraut (drained, squeezed very dry) 1 cup
Creamy Russian dressing 1/2 cup
Unsalted butter (softened) 4 tbsp

Steps

1

Squeeze Sauerkraut Dry

Place the measured sauerkraut in the corner of the fixed linen kitchen towel and squeeze firmly over the nearby sink to remove as much excess brine as possible, squeezing for 1 full minute. The finished sauerkraut should feel damp but not dripping, with no pooled liquid when pressed; leftover brine will cause soggy bread. Transfer squeezed sauerkraut to the small stainless steel mixing bowl temporarily.

Step 1
step1:Squeeze Sauerkraut Dry
2

Butter Bread Slices Evenly

Lay all 8 pumpernickel slices flat on the maple cutting board. Use the silicone basting brush to spread 1/2 tbsp of softened butter evenly across one entire side of each bread slice, spreading all the way to the crust edges. The butter layer should be thin and uniform, not clumped, to ensure even toasting without burnt spots.

Step 2
step2:Butter Bread Slices Evenly
3

Layer Sandwich Fillings

Flip 4 of the buttered bread slices so the buttered side faces down on the cutting board. Spread 1 tbsp of Russian dressing evenly across the unbuttered side of each of these 4 base slices. Top each base with 1 slice of Swiss cheese, 85g of corned beef fanned slightly for even coverage, 1/4 cup of squeezed dry sauerkraut, then a second slice of Swiss cheese. Spread the remaining 1 tbsp of Russian dressing on the unbuttered side of the remaining 4 bread slices, and place dressing-side down on top of each stack to form 4 complete sandwiches, with buttered sides facing out on both top and bottom.

Step 3
step3:Layer Sandwich Fillings
Step 3
step3:Layer Sandwich Fillings
4

Preheat Cooking Skillet

Place the 12-inch carbon steel skillet on the integrated stovetop burner at the back of the counter over medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C). Let the pan preheat for 3 minutes, until a drop of water flicked onto the surface dances and evaporates slowly over 3-4 seconds; if water vanishes instantly, the pan is too hot and will burn the pumpernickel before the cheese melts.

Step 4
step4:Preheat Cooking Skillet
5

Toast First Sandwich Side

Carefully place 2 sandwiches in the preheated skillet, leaving 2cm of space between them for even air flow. Cook for 3-4 minutes, until the bottom bread slice is deep golden brown and crisp to the touch, and the cheese on the bottom layer starts to melt around the edges. Do not press down on the sandwiches with the spatula during cooking, as this will squeeze out filling and compress the soft bread.

Step 5
step5:Toast First Sandwich Side
6

Flip and Cook Second Side

Slide the offset spatula fully under each sandwich and flip carefully in one smooth motion to avoid tearing the bread. Cook the second side for another 3-4 minutes, until the bread is equally deep golden and crisp, and all the Swiss cheese is fully melted and oozing slightly out of the sandwich edges. Transfer cooked sandwiches to the cream ceramic dinner plate temporarily while you cook the remaining 2 sandwiches, repeating the same toasting time and temperature for the second batch.

Step 6
step6:Flip and Cook Second Side
Step 6
step6:Flip and Cook Second Side
7

Rest, Slice, and Plate

Once all 4 sandwiches are cooked, transfer them back to the maple cutting board and let rest for 1 minute to allow the cheese to set slightly, so filling does not slide out when cut. Use the serrated bread knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two equal triangles. Arrange 2 triangles per serving on the matte cream ceramic dinner plate, and serve with a dill pickle spear on the side.

Step 7
step7:Rest, Slice, and Plate

Tips

1.Squeeze sauerkraut completely dry before assembling sandwiches: Excess sauerkraut brine will soak through the buttered bread and turn your crispy grilled cheese soggy, even with perfect toasting. For extra dry sauerkraut, pat it with paper towels after squeezing in the linen towel to remove every last drop of excess liquid.
2.Cook over steady medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C), not high heat: Pumpernickel bread contains molasses and rye flour that caramelize and burn very quickly at high temperatures; lower heat ensures the bread toasts to a deep golden, crisp crust without charring, while giving the Swiss cheese enough time to fully melt all the way through the sandwich layers.
3.Let cooked sandwiches rest for 1 full minute before slicing: Cutting into a piping hot grilled cheese immediately causes all the runny melted cheese to slide out the sides of the sandwich; a short rest lets the cheese set slightly, so every bite has even, balanced layers of bread, corned beef, sauerkraut, and cheese with no lost filling.

✨ You May Also Like

Lunch
🍜 United States

Creamy, salty, tangy nostalgic Midwestern sandwich pairing rich peanut butter with crisp briny dill pickles for a fast, satisfying no-cook meal.

⏱️ 5 minutesLunch ★ 4.6
Lunch
🍜 United States

Crispy, melty pressed sandwich layered with savory roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and tangy mustard: a beloved Cuban-American comfort classic.

⏱️ 25 minuteLunch ★ 4.9
Lunch
🍜 United States

Hearty, briny New Orleans pressed sandwich stacked with cured Italian meats, provolone, and zesty olive salad, served cold for bold, portable flavor.

⏱️ 1 hour 20Lunch ★ 4.7
Lunch
🍜 United States

A tangy, creamy Southern American staple, this no-cook cheesy sandwich is packed with sharp cheddar and sweet pimentos for a satisfying, portable bite.

⏱️ 1 hour 15Lunch ★ 4.8
Lunch
🍜 United States

Crispy Cajun-spiced fried shrimp piled on crusty French bread with tangy remoulade and fresh toppings, the iconic Louisiana street food sandwich.

⏱️ 35 minuteLunch ★ 4.4
Lunch
🍜 United States

Stacked, savory deli-style corned beef sandwich with melted Swiss, tangy mustard, and crisp griddled rye— a fast, hearty, satisfying classic.

⏱️ 15 minuteLunch ★ 4.9

Pumpernickel Reuben Grilled Cheese:Frequently Asked Questions

1.Why do I have to squeeze the sauerkraut completely dry for this sandwich? ▾
Skipping this step leaves excess brine that will turn your crisp pumpernickel soggy mid-toast, no matter how well you cook it. Squeeze handfuls firmly over the sink until no more liquid drips out, or press sauerkraut between layers of paper towel for 30 seconds. You keep all the bright tang without the mushy, wet texture.
2.Can I use rye bread instead of dark pumpernickel if that’s what I have on hand? ▾
Absolutely! Traditional dark pumpernickel has a deeper, earthier, slightly sweet molasses note that pairs beautifully with salty corned beef, but light or dark rye works as a perfect 1:1 swap. Just stick to the 1cm slice thickness so your bread toasts evenly without getting too brittle or falling apart under fillings.
3.What’s the best way to get the Swiss cheese fully melted without burning the pumpernickel? ▾
Cook your sandwich over medium-low heat, not high. High heat will char the dark pumpernickel before the cheese has time to melt through the corned beef and sauerkraut layers. I also recommend placing one slice of Swiss directly against each bread slice to create a moisture barrier and encourage even melting.
4.Can I use Thousand Island dressing instead of Russian dressing? ▾
You can, but note the key flavor difference! Russian dressing is spicier and zestier, with a hint of horseradish and chili sauce, while Thousand Island is sweeter with added pickle relish. If you swap, stir a tiny pinch of prepared horseradish into your Thousand Island to get closer to that classic Reuben zing.
5.How do I keep the corned beef from sliding out of the sandwich while I cook it? ▾
Layer your fillings strategically! Start with a slice of Swiss on the bottom bread, then a thin, even layer of corned beef pressed gently flat, followed by squeezed sauerkraut, a thin spread of dressing, then a second Swiss slice and top bread. Melted cheese acts as glue to hold all fillings in place as you flip.
6.Should I butter the outside of the bread for this grilled cheese? ▾
Yes, absolutely! Spread a thin, even layer of softened unsalted butter all the way to the edges of each pumpernickel slice’s outer side before cooking. This creates that perfectly golden, shatteringly crisp crust, and adds a rich, buttery note that balances the tangy, salty fillings. Skip neutral oil here for the best classic flavor.
7.Can I make this sandwich ahead for weekly meal prep? ▾
This sandwich is best eaten fresh off the griddle for optimal crispness, but you can prep components ahead to cut down on cook time. Pre-squeeze your sauerkraut, portion your corned beef, and portion your dressing up to 3 days in advance in airtight fridge containers. Don’t assemble fully ahead, as the bread will turn soggy.
8.What if I don’t eat beef—can I swap the corned beef for another protein? ▾
Definitely! Thinly sliced deli turkey pastrami makes a great lighter swap that still pairs perfectly with the sauerkraut, Swiss, and Russian dressing. For a vegetarian version, use sliced roasted portobello or marinated tempeh, patted very dry, to get that savory, salty bite without the meat.
9.How long should I cook each side of the sandwich for ideal results? ▾
Cook the first side for 3 to 4 minutes over medium-low heat, until the buttered bread is deep golden brown and the bottom cheese layer starts to bubble. Flip carefully with a spatula, then cook the second side for another 2 to 3 minutes, until the second side is crisp and all cheese is fully melted through.
10.Is it okay to use pre-sliced packaged Swiss cheese instead of fresh deli-sliced? ▾
Pre-sliced packaged Swiss works perfectly here, as long as you pick a regular full-moisture variety. Skip low-fat Swiss, which gets rubbery and won’t melt smoothly when heated. Use two slices per sandwich, positioned against the bread to create that melt barrier, just like you would with fresh deli-sliced cheese.
11.My sauerkraut is really mild—how can I add extra flavor to it? ▾
Of course you can amp it up! After squeezing it dry, toss the sauerkraut with a tiny pinch of caraway seed, a light sprinkle of black pepper, or even a 1/4 teaspoon of apple cider vinegar to boost its tang. Just don’t add extra liquid, and keep additions light so they don’t overpower other fillings or cause sogginess.
12.Can I cook this in an air fryer instead of a stovetop skillet? ▾
You can! Assemble the sandwich as directed, butter the outsides, and cook at 375°F for 4 minutes, flip carefully, then cook for another 3 to 4 minutes until the bread is crisp and cheese is melted. Keep a close eye on it, as air fryer heat varies, and dark pumpernickel can burn faster than lighter breads.
13.Why does the recipe call for 1cm thick pumpernickel slices specifically? ▾
1cm (roughly 3/8 inch) is the perfect thickness to hold up to hearty, moist fillings without getting soggy, while still getting crisp all the way through. Thinner slices will tear or get mushy under corned beef and sauerkraut, and thicker slices won’t let heat reach the cheese to melt it evenly before the bread burns.
14.What are good side dishes to serve with this grilled cheese? ▾
This rich, tangy sandwich pairs perfectly with bright, light sides to cut through the richness. Classic deli picks include crisp dill pickle spears, tangy vinegar-based coleslaw, a simple side salad with light vinaigrette, or a cup of hot tomato soup. For a true deli vibe, serve extra Russian dressing for dipping.
15.Can I add extra fillings like dill pickles to the sandwich? ▾
You can absolutely customize it, but add extras sparingly and pat them very dry first! Thin slices of dill pickle, a sprinkle of caramelized onions, or a thin swipe of spicy brown mustard all work great, but too many wet add-ins will make the sandwich soggy and throw off the classic Reuben flavor balance.
16.My sandwich always falls apart when I flip it—what am I doing wrong? ▾
First, don’t overstuff it! Piling on too much corned beef or sauerkraut makes the sandwich unstable. Second, press the assembled sandwich gently with your palm before putting it in the pan to help the layers stick together. Use a wide, thin spatula to support the full sandwich when you flip, and move slowly.

Comments (13)

1 week ago

OMG this was SO good! I threw this together for a quick weeknight dinner when I forgot to meal prep, and my whole family devoured it. The pumpernickel adds such a perfect nutty depth that regular sourdough just can’t match. 10/10 will be making this again for our next block party potluck and game night spread!

just now

Made this on my cast iron after a long day on the trails last weekend and it hit every single spot. I used a little extra Swiss cheese because who doesn’t love more cheese, and it was perfectly melty. Only note is I’d toast the caraway seeds a tiny bit first next time for extra crunch, but that’s just personal preference.

yesterday

My kids loved it! I was worried the pumpernickel flavor would be too strong for them, but they dipped theirs in thousand island and didn’t even complain. Super easy to throw together on school nights when we’re running between soccer practice and piano lessons. Added a side of dill pickles and it was a full meal.

2 weeks ago

Tastes exactly like the grilled Reubens I used to get at my favorite old diner back in Brooklyn! I swapped the regular corned beef for leftover pastrami from our weekend deli run and it worked perfectly. Easy enough for a lazy Sunday lunch, fancy enough to serve to guests when they stop by.

30 minutes ago

Wait, has anyone tried making this with vegan corned beef and dairy-free Swiss? My partner is dairy free and I’d love to make this for our date night in, but I don’t want it to turn out all rubbery!

5 minutes ago

Great question! We’ve tested this with a good quality meltable vegan Swiss and plant-based corned beef, and it works beautifully — just make sure to cook it on medium-low heat a minute or two longer to make sure the vegan cheese fully melts without burning the bread.

2 days ago

Made these for our football watch party last Sunday and they were gone before halftime! Cut them into little sliders with a toothpick and they were the perfect handheld snack. Only thing I’ll do different next time is double the batch, because we ran out way too fast.

yesterday

Oh the slider idea is genius! I was planning to make these for our next tailgate and I was worried they’d be too messy, but cutting them small is perfect. Thanks for the tip!

2 hours ago

How well do these hold up if I make them ahead for work lunches? I’m always looking for easy hot lunches I can pack and reheat in the office microwave without them getting soggy.

30 minutes ago

These reheat really well if you store the components separately and assemble right before microwaving! If you build it fully ahead, the sauerkraut can make the pumpernickel a little soggy, so packing the bread, cheese, corned beef, and kraut in separate containers makes meal prep super easy.

3 days ago

Added a dash of hot honey to mine and oh my gosh, that sweet-spicy kick with the salty corned beef and tangy sauerkraut? Unreal. If you love a little heat, do not sleep on that addition. Total flavor bomb.

2 days ago

Hot honey?! That’s such a good call, I’m making this for dinner tonight and I’ve got a jar of that in my pantry right now. Can’t wait to try that twist!

5 days ago

This was so affordable to make! I already had pumpernickel and cheese in the fridge, picked up a pack of deli corned beef and a jar of sauerkraut for under $5, and got three full meals out of it. Way cheaper than ordering Reubens from the sandwich shop down the street.

3 days ago

So glad to hear it worked out on a budget! Using pre-sliced deli meat and pantry staples is exactly why we love this recipe for quick, low-cost weeknight meals.

1 week ago

Wait, is there a good gluten free pumpernickel bread you’d recommend for this? I have celiac and I’ve been craving a good Reuben so bad, but most GF breads get super crumbly when you grill them.

5 days ago

I’ve had really good luck with the GF pumpernickel from my local Trader Joe’s! It holds up great on the grill, doesn’t fall apart, and the flavor is almost exactly like regular pumpernickel.

3 days ago

Great recommendation from Cindy! We also recommend toasting the GF bread lightly on both sides before adding fillings to help it hold up even better and prevent sogginess when grilling.

30 minutes ago

First time making a grilled cheese that didn’t burn! The easy difficulty rating was totally accurate, and the 10 minute cook time was spot on. I didn’t even mess it up even though I’m usually terrible at stovetop sandwiches. Used extra thousand island because I’m a sauce fiend, and it was perfect.

5 minutes ago

Same here! I burn every single grilled cheese I make, but the tip to cook it on medium low instead of high was a total game changer. No more charred bread with unmelted cheese in the middle!

just now

So proud of you both! Medium-low heat is the secret to perfect grilled cheese every time — it gives the cheese time to fully melt while the bread gets that perfect crispy, buttery crust.

2 weeks ago

Made this for brunch last weekend with a side of loaded hash browns and mimosas, and my guests are still talking about it! I added a little layer of coleslaw on half of them for extra crunch, and people went back and forth on which version they liked better.

1 week ago

The coleslaw addition sounds chef’s kiss! I’m hosting a brunch next month and this is going straight on the menu. Did you use creamy coleslaw or vinegar based?

5 days ago

I used creamy coleslaw, and I squeezed out all the extra moisture first so it didn’t make the bread soggy! Worked like a charm.

5 days ago

I thought this was good, but it was missing a little something for me. I added a sprinkle of caraway seeds and a thin slice of pastrami along with the corned beef, and that pushed it over the top for me. Still super easy to make, just needed a little extra oomph to match my local deli’s version.

3 days ago

Love that tweak! Adding pastrami and extra caraway is such a classic deli move, it sounds absolutely delicious. We’re big fans of customizing this recipe to match your favorite deli order.

2 days ago

I did the exact same thing! I also buttered the outside of the bread with a little garlic butter instead of plain butter, and the crust was so flavorful. Highly recommend that too.