Rachel Sandwich
intro
The toasty, tangy deli cousin of the Reuben: melted Swiss, savory sliced turkey, creamy coleslaw, and zesty Russian dressing griddled on marbled rye for a nostalgic, satisfying bite.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Zesty Dressing
In the small stainless steel mixing bowl, combine 1/3 cup mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons ketchup, 1 tablespoon sweet pickle relish, 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce, 1/4 teaspoon smoked paprika, 1/8 teaspoon kosher salt, and 1/8 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper. Use the small silicone whisk to stir until completely smooth, with no streaks of unincorporated mayo or ketchup remaining; the finished dressing will be a pale creamy orange-pink color. Transfer dressing to the small clear glass ramekin and set aside. This takes approximately 2 minutes.
Butter Bread Slices
Lay all 8 slices of marbled rye bread flat on the acacia wood cutting board. Use the butter knife to spread 1/2 tablespoon of softened unsalted butter evenly across one entire side of each bread slice. The butter layer should be thin enough that you can still see the dark rye marbling through it, with no thick clumps that will make the finished sandwich greasy. Set slices butter-side up as you finish each one.
Spread Dressing Layer
Flip all buttered bread slices so the buttered side faces down on the cutting board. Use the butter knife to spread 1 tablespoon of the prepared Russian dressing evenly across the unbuttered side of every bread slice, spreading all the way to the crust edges to ensure every bite has consistent flavor. Wipe excess dressing from the knife between slices if needed.
Layer Sandwich Fillings
On 4 of the dressing-topped bread slices, layer fillings in this order to prevent sogginess: first 1 slice of Swiss cheese placed directly on the dressing to create a moisture barrier, then 113g (4oz) of thin-sliced roasted turkey, loosely piled, then 1/2 cup of well-drained coleslaw, pressed lightly to remove any remaining excess moisture, then a second slice of Swiss cheese on top of the coleslaw. Top each stack with the remaining 4 bread slices, dressing-side facing down against the top cheese layer, so the buttered side of both top and bottom slices faces outward.
Preheat Cast Iron Griddle
Place the 12-inch pre-seasoned cast iron griddle on the stovetop insert over medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C). Let it preheat for 3 minutes, testing readiness by flicking a single drop of water onto the surface: the drop should dance across the griddle and evaporate slowly over 3-4 seconds. Do not use higher heat, as this will burn the rye bread before the cheese melts fully.
Grill First Sandwich Side
Use the offset metal spatula to carefully transfer 2 assembled sandwiches to the preheated griddle, leaving 2cm of space between them to allow even cooking. Cook for 3-4 minutes, until the bottom bread slice is deep golden brown and crispy to the touch, and the bottom slice of Swiss cheese starts to melt and bubble around the sandwich edges. Do not press down on the sandwiches while cooking, as this will squeeze out filling and make the bread soggy.
Flip and Finish Cooking
Slide the offset spatula fully under each sandwich to support the entire base, then flip gently in one smooth motion to avoid spilling fillings. Cook the second side for another 3-4 minutes, until golden brown and crispy, and the Swiss cheese is fully melted and oozing slightly out of the sandwich edges. Transfer cooked sandwiches to a clean spot on the cutting board, then repeat the cooking process with the remaining two uncooked sandwiches.
Rest, Cut, and Plate
Transfer all cooked sandwiches to the acacia cutting board and let rest for 1 minute to allow the cheese to set slightly, so fillings do not slide out when cut. Use the 8-inch chef knife to cut each sandwich diagonally across the middle, then transfer two halves to the matte cream ceramic dinner plate for serving. Garnish with a tiny sprig of fresh thyme from the potted plant if desired.
Tips
2.Cook over steady medium-low heat: marbled rye has a higher sugar content than white bread, so it burns quickly at high heat before the cheese has time to fully melt through the layered fillings.
3.Never press sandwiches with the spatula while griddling: this squeezes out melted cheese, dressing, and coleslaw moisture, leading to a flat, dry sandwich with uneven flavor distribution.

OMG this was SO good! Total game changer! I’ve been making Reubens for years for my husband’s game night potlucks but never tried a Rachel until now. The turkey and coleslaw combo is so much lighter than the corned beef and sauerkraut, I didn’t feel sluggish after eating two! Cook time was actually 10 minutes like the recipe said, no fancy steps, perfect for when I’m crunched for time before guests show up.
Quick question—can I prep these ahead for meal prep and reheat in the air fryer during the week? I tried a similar grilled sandwich last week and the bread got super soggy when I stored it in the fridge, would love any tips to avoid that!
My kids loved it! I cut them into little triangles and served them with sweet potato fries for our Friday family movie night and even my super picky 7 year old asked for seconds. I used a little extra Swiss cheese because we’re cheese obsessed over here, no regrets.
As someone who can barely boil water without messing up, this recipe was so easy to follow! 10 minute cook time is no joke, I made this between study sessions yesterday and it tasted like something I’d order at a fancy deli. Used store-bought coleslaw to cut down even more on prep, zero shame.
Has anyone tried making this with gluten free rye bread? I have celiac and have been craving a good melty grilled sandwich forever, just don’t want it to turn out gummy with the wrong bread.
Wait, hold up—did anyone else add a little thousand island on the side for dipping? I know the recipe says to spread it inside, but I’m a dipper and it took this from great to straight up restaurant quality. 10 minute cook time is perfect for a lazy Sunday lunch too.