reuben dressing
intro
Creamy, tangy, and subtly spicy, this classic Reuben dressing is the essential spread for iconic deli sandwiches, balancing rich, bright, and briny flavors perfectly.
Ingredients
Steps
Measure Base Ingredients
Let refrigerated ingredients sit at room temperature for 10 minutes to encourage smooth emulsification. Using the stainless steel measuring spoons and 1-cup glass measuring cup, portion 1/2 cup full-fat mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons ketchup, and 2 tablespoons well-drained sweet dill relish into the central 1-quart clear glass mixing bowl. Scrape every last bit of mayonnaise from the measuring cup with the white silicone spatula to avoid wasting ingredients.
Add Aromatic Flavorings
Add 1 tablespoon drained prepared horseradish, 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce, 1 teaspoon raw apple cider vinegar, and 1 tablespoon finely minced yellow onion to the mixing bowl with the base ingredients. Press the minced onion against the side of the bowl with the spatula to release its juices before mixing, for deeper, more even flavor.
Add Dry Spices
Measure and add 1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika, 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder, 1/8 teaspoon flaky sea salt, and 1/8 teaspoon freshly cracked black pepper to the bowl. Hold the walnut pepper grinder 6 inches above the bowl to distribute pepper evenly across the surface of the wet ingredients.
Whisk to Combine
Pick up the stainless steel mini whisk from the bowl edge, and whisk all ingredients together in slow, steady circular motions for 45 to 60 seconds. Scrape down the sides and bottom of the bowl with the silicone spatula halfway through mixing to ensure no pockets of unblended mayonnaise or spice remain. The finished mixed dressing should be a uniform pale coral-pink color, with tiny green flecks of relish evenly distributed throughout, no streaks of ketchup or unblended spice visible.
Taste and Adjust Seasoning
Dip the tip of the small stainless steel serving spoon into the dressing to taste. If too tangy, stir in a 1/4 teaspoon extra mayonnaise; if too rich, add a 1/4 teaspoon extra apple cider vinegar; if needing more heat, add an extra 1/4 teaspoon horseradish. Add a pinch more salt if the flavors taste flat, whisking briefly to incorporate any adjustments.
Transfer to Ramekin
Use the white silicone spatula to scrape every bit of the finished dressing from the glass mixing bowl into the matte cream ceramic ramekin. Smooth the top surface of the dressing gently with the back of the serving spoon, then cover loosely and refrigerate for 30 minutes to allow flavors to meld before serving. Do not over-stir after chilling to preserve the thick, spreadable texture.
Garnish and Serve
After chilling, remove the dressing from the refrigerator, dust the top with a tiny pinch of extra smoked paprika for color, and serve alongside toasted rye bread, corned beef, sauerkraut, and melted Swiss for classic Reuben sandwiches, or use as a dip for crispy fries or soft pretzels. The dressing will stay fresh in a sealed airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 1 week.
Tips
2.Use full-fat mayonnaise for best results: low-fat or light mayo contains added water and stabilizers that create a gummy, thin texture and mute the bright, tangy, rich flavor that defines classic deli Reuben dressing.
3.Don’t skip the 30-minute chill period: mixing only combines ingredients, but resting in the fridge allows the garlic, paprika, and onion flavors to infuse evenly into the creamy base, eliminating sharp, unbalanced raw onion or spice notes.

OMG this dressing is a total game changer! I made it for our weekly Sunday family dinner to pile on corned beef Reubens and even my super picky 8 year old asked for extra. No more store bought Thousand Island for us, ever. SO good!
Brought this to our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend to serve with sliders and people would not stop asking me for the recipe! It’s so easy since there’s zero cook time, I threw it together in 5 minutes before walking over. 10/10
I make a big batch of this every Sunday for my work week lunches! It’s amazing on Reuben wraps, as a dip for sweet potato fries, even thinned out a little as a salad dressing. Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish it stayed fresh a tiny bit longer in the fridge, but that’s a me problem for making too much, ha!
Wait hold on, is this supposed to be more Russian dressing style or Thousand Island? I’ve been chasing the exact deli Reuben dressing I had on a trip to NYC as a kid and I can never get it right. Tried so many recipes that are too sweet for my taste, so I’m hesitant to buy all the ingredients before I know! Giving 3 stars for now until I test it.
I was so nervous to make homemade dressing for my first ever homemade Reuben night and this was foolproof! So easy, no cooking required, tasted exactly like what I get at my favorite local sandwich shop. Will absolutely make again.
My three teenage boys devoured their Reubens last night when I used this dressing! I had to make a second batch mid-dinner because they were putting it on everything – their burgers, their fries, even dipping their pickles in it. Total hit.
So happy this recipe is naturally gluten free as long as you use GF ketchup and relish! I’ve missed having good Reubens since going GF because all the store bought dressings have hidden wheat in them. This tastes exactly like I remember.
No cook time? Sign me up. I’m the worst at actually following recipes that require standing over the stove and this took me literally 3 minutes to stir together. Tastes insane on my leftover corned beef from St. Patrick’s Day.
Made this for our St. Patrick’s Day family feast and it got rave reviews from my in-laws, which is basically the highest possible honor, ha. Even my mother in law who swears her Reuben dressing is the best asked for the recipe. Win!
I added a heaping teaspoon of extra hot horseradish to mine and it has the perfect little kick! Cut through the richness of the corned beef and melted Swiss so well. 10/10, will make again with extra heat.
Made this in my dorm room with a bowl and a spoon, no fancy tools needed! Way cheaper than buying the pre-made bottle from the campus market and tastes 10x better. Smeared it on a toasted rye bread sandwich with deli corned beef and it slapped.
I ran a small diner in Ohio for 25 years and this Reuben dressing is spot on to what we served for decades. Saved me a trip down memory lane digging up my old recipe card, this is exactly the right ratio of creamy, tangy, and a little sweet.
Wait don’t sleep on using this as a burger sauce! I made it for Reubens but had leftovers, slathered it on a smash burger last night and it was better than any special sauce I’ve had at a fast food place. Total game changer.
Swapped the regular ketchup for no sugar added ketchup and used sugar free sweet pickle relish and this fits perfectly in my low carb diet! Tastes just like the regular version, no weird aftertaste. Can’t wait to pile it on a Reuben bowl with corned beef and sauerkraut for dinner tonight.
Okay I can barely boil water without messing it up and even I nailed this recipe! Measurements are super straightforward, no weird ingredients I had to run to three grocery stores to find. My roommate thought I ordered takeout Reubens when I served these for dinner last night. Win!