reuben sandwich dressing
intro
Tangy, creamy, briny classic Reuben dressing: the essential flavor-packed component for iconic deli Reuben sandwiches, balancing sweet, sour, and savory notes perfectly.
Ingredients
Steps
Add Mayo to Bowl
Scoop the measured 1/2 cup full-fat mayonnaise into the clear glass mixing bowl positioned center-left on the counter. Use the deep red silicone spatula to scrape every last bit of mayonnaise from its prep cup to ensure accurate ratios, leaving no thick residue in the cup. The mayonnaise will sit as a thick, pale creamy mass at the bottom of the bowl.
Mix in Ketchup
Add the 3 tablespoons of tomato ketchup to the bowl with the mayonnaise. Hold the mixing bowl steady with one hand, and use the stainless steel whisk with matte black silicone handle to stir the two ingredients together in slow, circular motions for 30 seconds, until the mixture is a uniform pale pink color with no streaks of unblended white mayo or red ketchup remaining.
Fold in Pickle Relish
Add the 2 tablespoons of well-drained sweet dill pickle relish to the pale pink mayo-ketchup base. Use the deep red silicone spatula to fold the relish in gently, rather than whisking vigorously, to keep small, distinct bits of pickle throughout the dressing for pleasant texture. Stop folding once the relish is evenly distributed, after about 15 seconds of gentle mixing.
Add Seasonings and Horseradish
Add the 1 tablespoon prepared creamy horseradish, 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce, 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar, 1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika, 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder, 1/4 teaspoon onion powder, 1/8 teaspoon kosher salt, and 1/8 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper to the bowl. Use the ring-connected stainless steel measuring spoons to portion each ingredient carefully to avoid over-seasoning.
Whisk Until Smooth
Use the black-handled stainless steel whisk to mix all ingredients together thoroughly for 45 seconds, scraping down the sides of the bowl with the silicone spatula halfway through to ensure no unincorporated ingredients stick to the edges. The finished dressing should be creamy, with evenly distributed tiny relish flecks, a consistent pale coral-pink color, and thick enough to coat the back of a spoon without running off quickly.
Taste and Adjust Seasoning
Dip the tip of the clean small stainless steel tasting spoon into the dressing to taste. Adjust flavors as needed: add a pinch more salt for savoriness, a tiny extra splash of apple cider vinegar for brightness, or 1/4 teaspoon more horseradish if you prefer extra zing. Note that the dressing will mellow slightly as it chills, so flavors should taste bright and slightly bold right after mixing.
Chill to Meld Flavors
Use the deep red silicone spatula to transfer the fully mixed dressing from the glass mixing bowl to the matte off-white ceramic ramekin, scraping every bit of dressing from the bowl sides and bottom. Cover the ramekin with a small piece of plastic wrap, and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes to allow the flavors to meld together before using on Reuben sandwiches.
Tips
2.Stick to full-fat mayonnaise for the best results: low-fat or light mayo contains added water and stabilizers that create a bland, watery texture that cannot stand up to the bold, salty, rich flavors of classic Reuben fillings.
3.Don't skip the 30-minute chill time: resting the dressing in the fridge allows the sharp horseradish, smoky paprika, and tangy vinegar notes to mellow and meld into the creamy base, creating a far more balanced, cohesive flavor than serving it immediately after mixing.

OMG, I’ve been trying to copy the exact Reuben dressing from my favorite Jewish deli on the Upper West Side for YEARS and this is dead on! No weird ingredients, comes together in 2 minutes, and has that perfect tangy-creamy balance that doesn’t overpower the corned beef. Game changer for our weekend Reuben nights!
Made this for our annual St. Patrick’s day family dinner and everyone raved! I was tired of buying the bottled Thousand Island that tastes way too sweet, and this has that perfect horseradish kick. We even used the leftover dressing as a dip for our fries the next day, 10/10.
Super easy to make in my dorm, no cooking required which is a win because my dorm kitchen never has working stoves. Only knocked a star off because I added way too much horseradish on my first try and cleared out my whole floor, oops. Tasted great once I mixed in a little extra mayo to mellow it out though!
So happy this dressing is naturally gluten free! I’ve been missing a good Reuben since I went GF two years ago because all the store bought dressings have weird hidden wheat fillers. Paired this with GF rye bread, corned beef, sauerkraut and Swiss and my husband said it was better than the restaurant version we used to get before my diagnosis!
Brought a batch of this plus all the Reuben fixins to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were literally coming back for thirds. I set up a little build-your-own sandwich station and it was the hit of the whole party. Even the lady who brings the award-winning pecan pie asked for the recipe!
This tastes exactly like the Reuben dressing my grandma used to make back in the 60s! I was worried it would be one of those trendy updated versions that messes with the classic, but nope—perfect ratio of mayo, ketchup, horseradish, and that little splash of pickle brine that makes it sing. Made me so nostalgic taking the first bite.
I make a big batch of this every Sunday for my weekday lunches! I do turkey Reuben wraps with this dressing, sauerkraut, and Swiss and it keeps me full all afternoon. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish it was a little lower calorie, but honestly it’s so worth the extra points on my tracker.
I know Reubens are a Northern thing, but I slathered this on my smoked brisket Reubens last weekend when we had friends over to watch the game and folks were blown away. The little bit of horseradish cuts through the rich smoked meat so perfectly. Won’t ever use bottled dressing again.
No cook, no fancy tools, all stuff I already had in my mini fridge? Absolute win for a broke college student. Made a late night Reuben with deli corned beef from the campus market and it tasted like a restaurant meal. 10/10 will be making this every week.
I’ve been making Reuben dressing for 40+ years and I have to say, this recipe is spot on. I used to add a tiny bit of Worcestershire and I tried it with this recipe and it fits right in. My grandkids begged me to make extra for them to take home after Sunday dinner.
Okay, I’m mostly vegan but I cheat hardcore for a good Reuben, and this dressing is why. I’ve tried so many vegan Reuben dressings and they never get that tang right, but I just swapped the mayo for vegan mayo here and it was perfect. My vegan roommate even stole half the jar for her tempeh Reubens.
Made this for a quick weeknight dinner last night when I had zero energy to cook. Piled it on rye with leftover corned beef from St. Patty’s day, sauerkraut, and cheese, toasted it in the pan, and my kids asked for seconds! Even my picky 7 year old who hates “saucy” foods ate every bite. SO good.
Just whipped this up for my lunch today and it’s so creamy! Only thing I’ll do different next time is add a little less ketchup, I prefer my Reuben dressing a little more tangy than sweet, but that’s just personal preference. Super easy to throw together, no mess at all.
Game changer! I used this on my Reuben sliders for our tailgate last weekend and they were gone in 10 minutes. I mixed a little extra relish for people who wanted it sweeter, but the base recipe is perfect as written. Even the guys who only eat hot wings at tailgates were raving about the sliders.
Packed this in a cooler for a day hike last weekend, made little Reuben wraps ahead of time and they held up perfectly. The dressing didn’t get soggy even after 4 hours in the cooler, which is a win for trail food. Way better than the sad granola bars I usually bring.
I know people say Reubens are a cold weather food, but I make these all summer long! This dressing is so light and creamy, it doesn’t feel heavy even when it’s 80 degrees out. I serve mine with a side of coleslaw and potato chips and it’s the perfect easy weekend lunch.
Just mixed this up to put on my Reuben for lunch and I could eat this dressing by the spoonful it’s so good. The horseradish gives it just enough zing without making your eyes water, and the texture is perfectly smooth, no weird lumps. Why did I ever buy the bottled stuff?
Finally got around to making this last night after seeing all the rave reviews here, and y’all were not lying! It’s so creamy, perfectly tangy, and comes together so fast. I added a spoonful of dill relish like I saw mentioned in another comment and it was chef’s kiss. My whole family cleaned their plates, which never happens on a school night!