reuben toastie
intro
Crisp buttered rye bread oozing with melted Swiss, tangy sauerkraut, salty corned beef, and creamy Russian dressing—this pressed Reuben toastie is quick, cozy comfort food.
Ingredients
Steps
Drain and dry sauerkraut
Place the measured sauerkraut on a double layer of paper towel, wrap tightly, and squeeze firmly to remove as much excess brine as possible—wet sauerkraut will make your toastie soggy. Fluff the dried sauerkraut lightly with a fork and set it aside in the small stainless steel mixing bowl. The sauerkraut should feel damp but not dripping when squeezed between your fingers.
Butter rye bread slices
Lay all 8 rye bread slices flat on the dark walnut cutting board. Use the natural bristle pastry brush to spread 1/2 tablespoon of softened butter evenly across one entire side of each slice, taking care to cover the edges all the way to the crust for even crisping. Sprinkle a tiny pinch of flaky sea salt over the buttered surface of each slice. The buttered sides will face outward when assembled to create a golden, crisp crust.
Spread Russian dressing
Flip all 8 of the buttered bread slices over so the unbuttered side faces up. Spread 1/2 tablespoon of Russian dressing evenly across the unbuttered side of each slice, all the way to the edges. Avoid over-spreading dressing, as excess will leak out during pressing and burn on the pan surface.
Layer toastie fillings
Top 4 of the dressing-coated bread slices with 1 slice of Swiss cheese, 56g (approx 3-4 thin slices) of corned beef, 1/4 cup of the dried sauerkraut, then place the remaining 4 dressing-coated bread slices on top, buttered side facing out, to form 4 complete sandwiches. Press down gently on each sandwich with the palm of your hand to compact the fillings slightly so they do not slide during cooking.
Preheat cast iron press
Move the seasoned cast iron sandwich press from its stored position to the inset induction burner, set to medium heat (350°F / 175°C). Let it preheat for 3 minutes, until a drop of water flicked onto the surface sizzles and evaporates in 2 seconds. Do not oil the press surface, as the butter on the bread will prevent sticking.
Press and cook toasties
Carefully place 2 sandwiches at a time on the preheated cast iron press. Close the press lid and cook for 3 minutes, until the bottom bread is deep golden brown. Use the stainless steel offset spatula to flip each sandwich, press the lid back down, and cook for a further 2-3 minutes, until the second side is equally crisp and the Swiss cheese is fully melted and stringy when you gently lift a bread edge. Transfer cooked sandwiches to a clean spot on the cutting board while you cook the remaining 2 sandwiches, adjusting heat to medium-low if the bread starts to brown too quickly before cheese melts.
Rest and slice toasties
Transfer all cooked toasties to the dark walnut cutting board and let them rest for 1 minute to allow the cheese to set slightly (this prevents fillings from pouring out when you cut them). Use the 8-inch carbon steel chef knife to slice each toastie diagonally across the middle, creating two triangular halves. Plate one sliced toastie per warm oat stoneware plate, with a dill pickle spear on the side.
Tips
2.Butter all the way to the bread crust edges: the crusts are the driest part of rye bread, and missing butter there will leave pale, tough, un-crisped edges instead of a uniform golden, crunchy crust across the entire bread surface.
3.Let cooked toasties rest for 1 full minute before slicing: this short wait lets the melted cheese set slightly, so it does not gush out the sides when you cut or bite into the sandwich, and gives the crisp crust time to firm up for the best texture.

OMG this Reuben toastie is SO good! I threw it together for a quick weeknight dinner when I didn’t feel like cooking a whole meal, and my husband went back for a second one before I even finished my first. 8 minutes cook time is no joke, it was done so fast!
Game changer for work from home lunches! I used to order Reubens from the deli down the street for $12 a pop, now I make this in less time than it takes for delivery. Tastes exactly like the classic diner version, no cap.
Took this to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! I cut them into little bite-sized squares so everyone could grab a sample, and they were gone in 10 minutes flat. Only note is I added a little extra Thousand Island because I’m a sauce fiend.
Wait, is this actually easy enough for someone who burns toast 90% of the time? I’ve been trying to learn basic cooking so I don’t live off ramen my whole senior year lol
My kids loved it! I was worried the sauerkraut would be too tangy for them, but I rinsed it just a little like my mom used to do and they ate every bite. Even my picky 7 year old asked if we could have it again this Friday.
Has anyone tried this with low-carb rye bread? I’m cutting carbs but I’ve been craving a Reuben something fierce and I don’t want to waste ingredients if it won’t hit right.
Made this before a day hike up Mount Baldy last weekend and it was the perfect trail lunch! Wrapped it in foil so it stayed warm for a couple hours, and the protein from the corned beef kept me full the whole trek. Will definitely be adding this to my regular hike meal rotation.
This tastes exactly like the Reubens my grandma used to make at her old diner in small town Ohio! The rye bread crispness, the melty Swiss, that tang from the sauerkraut and Thousand Island — total nostalgia bite for me. 10/10
Wait can you prep these ahead for the week? I do meal prep every Sunday and I’m always looking for new hot lunch options that hold up in the fridge.
Pro tip: add a little slice of dill pickle inside the toastie before you cook it. Game. Changer. The extra brininess takes it over the top, trust me.
Made these for the football watch party at my place last Sunday and they were a massive hit. Set up a little build-your-own toastie station with extra corned beef, different cheeses, and spicy mustard for people who wanted to mix it up. Zero leftovers, which is always the sign of a good recipe.
Made this for my husband for our first Saturday lunch in our new apartment and he said it’s better than any Reuben we’ve gotten at restaurants downtown. I feel like a total kitchen pro now, even though it was literally the easiest thing I’ve ever cooked. Win win!
Wait, has anyone swapped the corned beef for a plant-based alternative? I’m vegan but my partner is a diehard Reuben fan and I want to make a version we can both eat for date night.
I cooked mine on the cast iron griddle out on the patio instead of a stovetop pan and got that perfect crispy crust on both sides without even having to flip it too much. 10/10, will be making these all summer long.
I was running late for my book club meeting and needed a quick snack to bring, so I whipped up a batch of these in 15 minutes total (including prep!) and everyone raved. Nobody believed me when I said I didn’t spend hours in the kitchen. Easy, fast, delicious — the triple threat.
This is so affordable to make! I grabbed all the ingredients on sale at the grocery store this week and it came out to less than $2 per serving, which is way cheaper than getting takeout. Perfect for when you’re trying to save money but don’t want to eat boring food.
I added a slather of spicy brown mustard and a pinch of red pepper flakes to mine because I love a little heat, and wow — that’s my new go-to version. Anyone else add extra heat to their Reuben?
I work 12 hour night shifts and this is perfect for my dinner break at the hospital. I keep the ingredients in the break room fridge and it cooks up in 8 minutes flat in the break room panini press, way better than the sad cafeteria sandwiches. Total lifesaver on long shifts.
Now that the kids are off to college, my wife and I have been making more quick, easy meals for just the two of us, and this is in our regular rotation now. We pair it with a cup of tomato soup and it’s the perfect cozy dinner for cool fall evenings.
Let me preface this by saying I am terrible in the kitchen — like, I once burned boiling water terrible. But I followed this recipe exactly and it came out perfect! The instructions are so clear and straightforward, even I couldn’t mess it up. 5 stars, no notes.