Seafood Newburg Casserole
intro
Rich, velvety Seafood Newburg Casserole loaded with tender shrimp, scallops, and lobster, baked under a buttery cracker crust for a cozy, nostalgic coastal family meal.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Seafood and Oven
Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C). Pat shrimp and scallops completely dry with paper towels, trim any tough side muscles from scallops, and cut large scallops in half horizontally to create uniform 2cm pieces. Place prepped shrimp, scallops, and chunked lobster meat in the stainless steel colander set over a small bowl to drain excess moisture. Use the pastry brush to coat the bottom and sides of the cream ceramic baking dish with 1 tablespoon of softened butter, then set the greased dish on the cork trivet at center counter.
Sear Seafood Briefly
Melt 1 tablespoon of butter in the 3-quart stainless steel saucepan over medium heat on the induction cooktop. Add drained shrimp and scallops in a single layer, cooking for exactly 1 minute per side just until edges turn opaque (seafood will be undercooked at this stage, as it will finish cooking in the oven). Use the slotted stainless steel spoon to transfer par-cooked shrimp and scallops to the greased baking dish, then scatter lobster chunks evenly over top. Do not wipe out the saucepan—residual butter and seafood drippings will form the base of the sauce.
Build Light Roux
Return the saucepan with seafood drippings to medium-low heat on the induction burner, add the remaining 4 tablespoons of butter, and melt until foaming subsides. Add all-purpose flour, whisking constantly with the silicone whisk for 2 full minutes, until the roux is pale golden, smooth, and smells faintly nutty. Do not let the roux darken to a brown color—this light roux creates the pale, delicate base for Newburg sauce.
Simmer Newburg Sauce
Slowly pour half-and-half into the roux while whisking constantly to prevent lumps from forming. Bring the sauce to a gentle simmer, cooking for 3-4 minutes until it thickens enough to firmly coat the back of a spoon (a finger drawn across the coated spoon will leave a clean line that does not run). Stir in dry sherry, sweet paprika, freshly grated nutmeg, kosher salt, and black pepper, then taste and adjust seasoning if needed. The finished sauce will be a smooth, velvety pale golden color.
Assemble Casserole Layers
Pour the finished Newburg sauce evenly over the seafood in the baking dish, then use the slotted spoon to gently stir until every piece of seafood is fully coated in sauce, spreading the mixture into a flat, even layer. In the small stainless steel mixing bowl, toss crushed cracker crumbs with 2 tablespoons of melted butter until all crumbs are evenly moistened. Sprinkle the buttered crumbs in a uniform layer over the top of the casserole, covering the sauce completely.
Bake Until Bubbly
Carefully transfer the assembled casserole to the middle rack of the preheated 375°F (190°C) oven. Bake for 22-25 minutes, until the sauce bubbles vigorously around the edges of the dish and the cracker crumb topping is deep golden and toasted. Remove the casserole from the oven and place it back on the center cork trivet to rest.
Garnish and Serve
Let the casserole rest for 5 minutes to allow the sauce to set slightly (this prevents runny portions when scooping). Sprinkle the top evenly with chopped fresh flat-leaf parsley. Serve hot, with lemon wedges on the side for squeezing over individual portions.
Tips
2.Do not overcook the seafood during the initial sear: The shrimp, scallops, and lobster will continue to cook for 25 minutes in the hot oven, so searing for just 1 minute per side ensures the final seafood is tender, not rubbery or tough.
3.Let the casserole rest for 5 full minutes after baking: Just like rested meat, this pause allows the hot cream sauce to thicken and set, so portions hold their shape instead of running across the plate, and the flavors meld together smoothly.

OMG this Seafood Newburg Casserole was the star of our Sunday family dinner last night! I used a mix of shrimp and lump crab because I couldn’t find lobster at my grocery store, and even my pickiest kid who hates all fish asked for seconds. SO good, will absolutely be adding this to our monthly rotation.
Brought this to my neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were literally scraping the dish clean! I was a little nervous because it’s medium difficulty and I’m usually a dump-and-bake kind of cook, but the steps were way easier to follow than I expected. Only note: I added a little extra paprika on top for a tiny kick, chef’s kiss.
Has anyone tried making this gluten free? My husband has celiac so I have to swap out the regular flour and breadcrumbs, and I don’t want to mess up the sauce consistency — it looks so creamy and dreamy!
Game changer. I’ve never successfully made a seafood dish that didn’t come out rubbery or bland before, and this had my wife asking if I ordered takeout from that fancy seafood place downtown. The only mistake I made was forgetting to thaw the shrimp all the way, so it added a little extra water to the sauce — still slapped though.
This tastes just like the Seafood Newburg they used to serve at the country club when I was a girl! I was worried modern recipes cut corners on the sherry and cream, but this is spot on. I added a handful of sautéed mushrooms because that’s how we always made it back in the day, and it was perfect.
Wait, 40 minute cook time for a seafood casserole that tastes this fancy? Sign me up! I prepped all the ingredients on Sunday during my meal prep session, and it came together in 10 minutes on a random Tuesday when I got home late from work. Absolute weeknight win.
I was skeptical about a baked seafood casserole because I usually do all my seafood on the grill, but my wife begged me to try this for our anniversary dinner. Holy cow, that sherry cream sauce is insane. I added a little sprinkle of Old Bay because I put that on everything, and it was chef’s kiss.
I’ve made a lot of Seafood Newburg in my 30 years cooking for the Navy, and this recipe is right up there with the best of them. Pro tip: don’t skimp on the fresh nutmeg in the sauce, it makes all the difference. The pre-ground stuff just doesn’t hit the same.
Made this for our office lunch last week and I got no less than 8 people asking for the recipe. The only issue was that it was gone in 10 minutes flat, next time I’m making a double batch! The buttery breadcrumb topping is *chef’s kiss*.
First time making any kind of casserole ever, and I only messed up one thing: I burned the breadcrumb topping a little because I got distracted playing video games while it was in the oven. Even with the slightly charred top, it was still SO good. Will definitely pay better attention next time!
This was way more budget friendly than I thought it would be! I used frozen seafood mix (shrimp, scallops, imitation crab) from the grocery store freezer section instead of fresh lobster, and it still tasted super luxurious. Perfect for when you want a fancy meal without the fancy price tag.
My kids loved it! I was worried the sherry flavor would be too strong for their little palates, but they ate two helpings each and asked if we could have it for their birthday dinner next month. Win for mom!
I swapped the lobster for fresh Dungeness crab that my cousin brought back from the coast, and it was absolute perfection. The rich sauce pairs so well with the sweet, briny crab. Will be making this every time we get a fresh crab haul!
Took this to my friend’s dinner party and everyone thought I spent hours in the kitchen. Little did they know I followed the recipe step by step and it was so straightforward! The sauce is so rich and velvety, I wanted to lick the bowl. 10/10.
This is our new go-to Sunday dinner casserole. It’s fancy enough for when we have guests over, but cozy enough for just me and my partner on a lazy night. I paired it with a crisp green salad and some crusty bread to soak up the extra sauce, perfection.
Made this in my tiny dorm kitchen with a toaster oven and it still turned out amazing! I used canned crab and pre-cooked frozen shrimp to keep it easy, and my dorm mates are already begging me to make it again. Way better than the dining hall food, that’s for sure.
I’ve tried so many Seafood Newburg recipes over the years, and this one is hands down the best. The sauce ratio is perfect — not too thick, not too runny, and the seafood cooks perfectly without getting rubbery. No more curdled sauce for me! This is my new go-to.
This was so good, but I wish I’d added a little more heat! Next time I’m throwing in a pinch of cayenne or a dash of hot sauce to cut through the richness a little. Even without it, though, it was a hit at my house. The cook time was exactly 40 minutes like the recipe said, which I appreciate because I hate when recipes lie about timelines.