submarine dressing
intro
Tangy, herby, and lightly creamy, this classic sub shop dressing elevates cold cut subs, antipasto, and wraps with bright, zesty, nostalgic flavor.
Ingredients
Steps
Dice the shallot finely
Place the peeled shallot on the honey-toned beech wood cutting board. Using the 3.5-inch paring knife, dice the shallot into uniform 1/8-inch pieces, as fine as possible to avoid large, crunchy chunks in the smooth finished dressing. Pile the finished dice on the edge of the cutting board and set aside.
Combine wet base ingredients
Measure 1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil and 1/4 cup red wine vinegar into the clear glass liquid measuring cup, then pour the mixture into the center of the 1.5 quart glass mixing bowl. Add the 2 tablespoons of full-fat mayonnaise directly to the bowl with the oil and vinegar.
Whisk to emulsify base
Hold the mixing bowl steady with one hand, and use the 10-inch stainless steel whisk to beat the oil, vinegar, and mayonnaise together vigorously for 45 to 60 seconds. The mixture will transform from separated, streaky layers to a smooth, pale golden, slightly thickened uniform liquid with no visible clumps of mayonnaise remaining.
Stir in dried spices
Add the measured dried oregano, dried basil, garlic powder, granulated sugar, kosher salt, and freshly ground black pepper to the emulsified dressing base. Use the whisk to stir the spices into the liquid for 15 seconds, until they are evenly distributed throughout.
Fold in shallot and cheese
Scrape the finely diced shallot from the cutting board and add 2 tablespoons of finely grated Parmesan cheese to the spiced dressing. Use the whisk to gently fold the ingredients in for 10 seconds, taking care not to overmix—small flecks of parmesan and shallot should be evenly suspended throughout the dressing.
Taste and adjust balance
Use the stainless steel tasting spoon to dip a small amount of dressing to taste. Adjust flavor as needed: add a pinch more salt for savoriness, a tiny extra splash of vinegar for bright tang, or a pinch more sugar to cut excess acidity if the vinegar tastes overly sharp. Stir once more after any adjustments.
Chill to meld flavors
Pour the finished dressing from the mixing bowl into the 12oz clear glass storage jar, secure the glass lid tightly, and refrigerate for a minimum of 30 minutes to allow dried spices to rehydrate and flavors to meld into the signature deli-style profile. For serving, pour a 2-tablespoon portion into the cream white ceramic ramekin for drizzling. The sealed dressing will keep refrigerated for up to 2 weeks.
Tips
2.Stick to full-fat mayonnaise rather than low-fat alternatives: The small amount of mayo acts as an emulsifier to keep oil and vinegar from separating quickly, and low-fat versions often contain added sugars or stabilizers that disrupt the classic bright, tangy deli flavor.
3.Use garlic powder instead of fresh garlic for storage longevity: Fresh garlic can become harsh, bitter, and overly pungent when left to sit in acidic dressing for more than a day, while garlic powder distributes evenly and stays mild for the dressing’s full 2-week refrigerated shelf life.

OMG this is EXACTLY the dressing they use at my neighborhood deli back in Jersey! I’ve been trying to copy it for years and always missed that tangy kick. Whipped this up in 2 minutes, let it chill for 30 mins like the recipe says, and my Italian sub tasted like it came straight from the shop. Total game changer for weekend sandwich nights with the roommates!
Made this for our weekly family sub night last night and my kids went crazy for it! Even my super picky middle son who usually only eats plain turkey subs asked for extra dressing on his. I love that there’s zero cook time, I threw it together while the sandwiches were being assembled and popped it in the fridge while we set the table. SO good!
Used this on my cold cut platters for our tailgate last weekend and people were asking me for the recipe left and right! Way better than the store-bought sub dressing that’s always loaded with weird preservatives. I prepped it the night before so the flavors had extra time to meld, 10/10 would recommend.
Wait a second, no sugar? Every deli dressing I’ve had around here has a tiny hint of sweetness, I almost made it for my book club potluck next week but paused when I saw the ingredient list. Is it missing that? I’d hate for it to be too one-note tangy!
This is now a staple in my weekly meal prep! I make a big batch every Sunday and it lasts all week for my lunchtime turkey and veggie subs. No weird separation issues if you give the jar a good shake before using, way cheaper than buying the pre-made bottles at the grocery store. Obsessed!
Drizzled this over my hoagies for the football watch party on Saturday and my friends thought I ordered catering from the local sub shop. Nobody believed I made it myself! The chill time is 100% worth it, don’t skip it like I almost did when I was running late. Flavors get so much better after it sits.
I added a little sprinkle of parmesan cheese to mine like they do at the sub shop by my office and it was chef’s kiss. Super versatile recipe, easy to tweak to your own preferences without messing up the base flavor!
Wait, is there any non-vegan ingredient in this? I’m trying to find a good sub dressing for my vegan Italian subs I bring to potlucks and this looks perfect, but I wanna make sure I don’t miss anything hidden!
I’m not much of a cook, like I burn toast half the time, but this was so easy even I couldn’t mess it up. Whisked everything together in a mason jar in 90 seconds, let it chill while I played a quick 9 holes, and came back to perfect dressing for my post-round sub. Will make again for sure.
Grew up on Chicago-style subs and I’m super picky about my sub dressing—this one hits all the right notes. Tangy, herby, not too oily, exactly what I want on a loaded Italian sub with giardiniera. I’ll be keeping a jar of this in my fridge permanently from now on.
I made this for our beach picnic last weekend and it held up perfectly even in the cooler! I was worried the oil would get all weird in the heat but it stayed totally fine, just gave it a shake before drizzling on our ham and cheese subs. Only thing is I wish the recipe made more! We ran out halfway through the picnic so next time I’m doubling it for sure.
Took this to our neighborhood block party last night and had three people text me before I even got home asking for the recipe. It’s so simple but tastes so much more complex than the ingredients list makes it sound. I set it out on our build-your-own sub table and it was the most popular topping out of everything I laid out!
I added a pinch of red pepper flakes to mine for a little heat and it was chef’s kiss. Great base recipe to play around with, I’m gonna try adding a little minced garlic next time instead of garlic powder to see how that hits.
Wait, do you have to use canola oil? I only have olive oil on hand right now and I don’t feel like running to the store just for oil. Would that mess up the flavor too much?
I help make subs for the high school football team every Friday after games and I’ve been searching for a good bulk dressing recipe that’s easy to throw together and doesn’t cost a fortune. This is gonna be my new go-to! I did a test batch last night and my husband said it’s better than the dressing we get at the deli by the school.
Skipped the chill time because I was in a hurry to make lunch and it was still good, but I tried the leftovers the next day after it sat in the fridge overnight and WOW, the difference is night and day. Don’t be like me, wait the 30 minutes! It’s so much better when the herbs have time to infuse into the oil and vinegar.