Thanksgiving Leftover Sandwich
intro
Stacked high with all your favorite Thanksgiving leftovers, this hearty, nostalgic sandwich turns post-holiday scraps into the most anticipated bite of the long weekend.
Ingredients
Steps
Make Cranberry-Gravy Mayo
In the small stainless steel mixing bowl, combine 1/4 cup full-fat mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons leftover turkey gravy, 1 tablespoon whole berry cranberry sauce, 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt, and 1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper. Use the small silicone whisk to stir the mixture until fully smooth, with faint flecks of cranberry visible throughout. Set the bowl aside on the cutting board for sandwich assembly.
Butter and Toast Bread
Use the metal pastry brush to spread 1/2 teaspoon of softened unsalted butter across one side of each of the 8 sourdough slices. Place the 10-inch matte charcoal non-stick skillet on the counter over medium heat (350°F / 175°C). Add bread slices butter-side down in batches of 4, toasting for 2 minutes per side until deep golden brown with crisp, darker crust edges. Use the stainless steel offset spatula to flip slices once during toasting, then transfer toasted bread to the edge of the cutting board as finished.
Warm Leftover Fillings
Reduce skillet heat to low (250°F / 120°C). Add the sliced roasted turkey and leftover herbed sage stuffing to the same skillet used for toasting, warming for 3 minutes and turning gently with the offset spatula until heated through to a food-safe internal temperature of 165°F / 74°C. Avoid overcooking, as high heat will dry out the tender turkey meat.
Spread Bread with Sauce
Arrange 4 of the toasted sourdough slices on the center of the cutting board, toasted side facing down. Use the offset spatula to spread 1 tablespoon of the prepared cranberry-gravy mayo evenly across the un-toasted side of each bottom slice, spreading all the way to the bread edges to create a moisture barrier against wet fillings.
Stack Sandwich Layers
Divide the warm sliced turkey evenly between the 4 sauced bread slices, pressing lightly to create a flat, stable base. Top each turkey layer with 1/2 cup of warm stuffing, followed by 2 tablespoons of whole berry cranberry sauce, a light 1-teaspoon drizzle of warm gravy, and 1/4 cup of loosely packed fresh arugula. Add one light crack of fresh black pepper over the arugula for brightness.
Top and Press Sandwiches
Take the remaining 4 toasted sourdough slices, spreading 1 teaspoon of plain leftover gravy across the un-toasted side of each. Place the slices gravy-side down on top of the filled stacks, pressing down firmly with the palm of your hand to compact the layers slightly, which helps the sandwich hold together when picked up and eaten.
Cut and Plate Sandwiches
Use the 7-inch walnut-handled santoku knife to cut each sandwich diagonally across the middle, creating two equal triangular halves. Place two halves per serving on the matte cream stoneware dinner plates, leaning one half against the other to display the layered cross-section. Tuck one fresh sage leaf next to each sandwich for garnish, and serve with a small cream stoneware ramekin of extra warm gravy for dipping.
Tips
2.Warm leftover turkey and stuffing over low heat only: high heat will dry out the delicate turkey meat and turn soft stuffing crispy and crumbly, ruining the soft, cozy texture people love in leftover sandwiches.
3.Avoid overpacking fillings: stick to the measured 1/2 cup of stuffing per sandwich, and press layers firmly after adding the top slice to help fillings adhere, so ingredients don’t fall out onto your lap when you take the first bite.

OMG this is SUCH a game changer! I’ve been piling Thanksgiving leftovers on bread for years but never thought to add that little layer of cranberry cream cheese spread? My kids loved it, they devoured two each after our family dinner last night, zero complaints even from my super picky 8 year old. That 10 minute cook time is no joke, I threw these together while the post-dinner football game was on commercial break. Total win!
Super easy to throw together, but honestly I thought it was missing a little crunch? I added some crispy fried onions from the green bean casserole on top and it took it right over the top. Will definitely be making this every year now instead of just eating sad cold leftover plates straight from the Tupperware.
Made these for my roommate potluck after we all went home for Thanksgiving break, everyone went back for seconds! We had a random assortment of leftovers from everyone’s family dinners and this recipe worked perfectly to mash them all together. No fancy ingredients, zero stress, 10/10.
Meal prepped a bunch of these for my post-hike lunches this week after Thanksgiving, they hold up way better than I thought they would! I toasted the sourdough a little extra so it doesn’t get soggy from the gravy, pro tip right there.
Wait quick question — does this have any nuts in the base recipe? My son has a severe peanut/tree nut allergy and I want to make sure I don’t accidentally use something that will trigger a reaction for our post-Thanksgiving lunch.
SO good. I put a runny fried egg on mine because I put an egg on literally everything, and it was like the best day-after Thanksgiving brunch I’ve ever made. No cleanup, super fast, tasted better than the actual Thanksgiving dinner tbh.
I’ve been making leftover turkey sandwiches for 40+ years and I can’t believe I never thought to layer the leftover mashed potatoes right in the sandwich! I was skeptical at first but it is so creamy and delicious, my bridge club friends asked for the recipe when I brought them to our meeting last week.
Tried this after our Friendsgiving hangout yesterday, we were all too full to eat much at the actual dinner so we made these when we got the late night munchies. Absolute perfection, even when you’re half asleep and slightly buzzed on spiced cider. 10/10 no notes.
Wait can you make these ahead and freeze them? I always have way too many leftovers and I’d love to stock a few in the freezer for busy work days next month.
I swapped the regular turkey for my smoked turkey leftover from our Thanksgiving smoke session, added a little drizzle of hot honey, and holy cow. This might be my new go-to sandwich year round, not just for Thanksgiving leftovers. So easy even I can’t mess it up, and I burn toast half the time.
Love how easy this is! I was expecting to have to make a bunch of special sauces or something but no, it just uses all the stuff you already have sitting in your fridge after Thanksgiving. I made it for my little brother who’s in high school and he took three to school for his lunch the next day, said all his friends were jealous.
Wait does this work with vegetarian Thanksgiving leftovers? I do a tofurkey roast every year and have all the same sides — cranberry sauce, stuffing, mashed potatoes, green beans — just no actual turkey. Would love to not miss out on the leftover sandwich fun!
Made these for our Thanksgiving weekend tailgate before the Bucs game, they were so easy to pass out and everyone raved about them. Way better than boring burgers and hot dogs, and I didn’t have to do any extra cooking after spending all day Thursday in the kitchen. Win win!
I used leftover Hawaiian rolls instead of sliced bread to make little slider versions of these for our post-Thanksgiving movie night, and they were gone in 10 minutes flat. The sweet rolls pair so good with the savory turkey and tangy cranberry, I will never make them on regular bread again. Such a versatile, easy recipe!