Tomato Pie

title 1
Tomato Pie
⏱️ cook time 1 hour 30 minutes
🍽️ servings 6
⚡ Difficulty medium

intro

A creamy, cheesy savory pie loaded with ripe summer tomatoes and fresh herbs in a flaky crust, a beloved Southern American comfort food staple.

Ingredients

Unbaked 9-inch pie crust 225g (1 standard 9-inch crust)
Ripe heirloom tomatoes 900g (about 4 large, sliced 1/4-inch thick)
Kosher salt 1 tablespoon plus 1/2 teaspoon
Shredded sharp cheddar cheese 225g (2 packed cups)
Full-fat mayonnaise 170g (3/4 cup)
Fresh sweet basil 2 tablespoons, chopped (plus extra for garnish)
Fresh thyme leaves 1 tablespoon
Ground black pepper 1/2 teaspoon
Garlic powder 1/4 teaspoon
Thinly sliced sweet onion 60g (1/2 cup)
All-purpose flour 1 tablespoon (7.5g)

Steps

1

Prep and drain tomatoes

Lay the 900g 1/4-inch thick sliced heirloom tomatoes in a single, non-overlapping layer on paper towel-lined rimmed baking sheets. Sprinkle the tomato slices evenly with 1 tablespoon of kosher salt, and let rest for 20 minutes at room temperature to draw out excess watery juice. After resting, pat the top surface of every tomato slice thoroughly with fresh paper towels to remove all remaining surface moisture before use.

Step 1
step1:Prep and drain tomatoes
2

Blind bake pie crust

Preheat oven to 190°C (375°F). Press the 225g unbaked 9-inch pie crust into a standard 9-inch (23cm) pie dish, crimp the outer edges decoratively, prick the bottom of the crust all over with the tines of a fork to prevent bubbling, line the crust with parchment paper and fill with pie weights or dried beans to cover the bottom completely. Bake for 12 minutes, then carefully lift out the parchment and weights, and bake for 3 more minutes until the crust base is pale golden and dry to the touch. Remove from oven and set aside to cool slightly.

Step 2
step2:Blind bake pie crust
3

Mix cheese filling

In a medium mixing bowl, combine 225g packed shredded sharp cheddar cheese, 170g full-fat mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons chopped fresh basil, 1 tablespoon fresh thyme leaves, 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt, 1/2 teaspoon ground black pepper, and 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder. Stir with a rubber spatula until all ingredients are fully incorporated into a thick, uniform, spreadable mixture.

Step 3
step3:Mix cheese filling
4

Layer pie components

Sprinkle the full 1 tablespoon (7.5g) of all-purpose flour evenly over the bottom of the slightly cooled blind-baked crust to absorb any remaining tomato juice and prevent sogginess. Layer half of the dried tomato slices in a slightly overlapping pattern over the flour, top with all 60g thinly sliced sweet onion in an even layer, then spread half the cheese mixture gently over the onions. Add the remaining tomato slices in a neat even layer, then top with the remaining cheese mixture, spreading it gently to cover all tomato slices completely.

Step 4
step4:Layer pie components
5

Bake the tomato pie

Reduce oven temperature to 175°C (350°F). Place the assembled pie on the middle oven rack, and bake for 35 to 40 minutes, until the top cheese layer is deep golden brown and bubbling around the crust edges, and the filling is fully set with no jiggly center. If the crust edges begin to brown too quickly, wrap them in narrow strips of aluminum foil halfway through baking to prevent burning.

Step 5
step5:Bake the tomato pie
6

Cool and serve

Transfer the baked pie to a wire cooling rack and let it rest for 15 minutes at room temperature to allow the filling to firm up fully before slicing. Garnish with extra fresh basil leaves if desired, and serve warm or at room temperature.

Step 6
step6:Cool and serve

Tips

1.Never skip salting and draining the tomatoes: excess tomato moisture is the number one cause of a soggy, water-logged crust and runny filling, so take the full 20 minutes to draw out juice and pat slices completely dry.
2.For the creamiest, most flavorful filling, shred cheddar cheese fresh from a block; pre-shredded packaged cheese is coated in anti-caking potato starch that creates a grainy, less smooth filling texture.
3.This pie holds up well at room temperature for up to 2 hours, making it a versatile option for potlucks and picnics in addition to family Sunday dinners.

✨ You May Also Like

Side Dishes
🍜 India

Velvety, aromatic all-purpose curry sauce perfect for tossing with roasted veggies, grilled protein, or rice for fast, cozy, flavorful meals.

⏱️ 25 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.8
Side Dishes
🍜 Spain

Tender, starchy boiled yuca tossed in bright, garlicky citrus mojo sauce—an iconic, zesty side that pairs beautifully with roasted pork, grilled meats, and rice and beans.

⏱️ 40 minuteSide Dishes ★ 5
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Tender, paper-thin potato flatbread, a beloved Norwegian-American Minnesota Christmas staple, griddled until softly spotted and served warm with butter.

⏱️ 1 hour 30Side Dishes ★ 4.6
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Rich, deeply savory cured salt pork, a long-lasting kitchen staple perfect for frying crispy as a side or adding umami to stews, beans, and chowders.

⏱️ 7 days (2Side Dishes ★ 4.9
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Crispy, tangy classic Southern fried green tomatoes with a crunchy cornmeal crust, served hot for a nostalgic, comforting summery bite.

⏱️ 25 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.9
Side Dishes
🍜 United States

Moist, golden-crusted savory muffins with sweet corn, zesty jalapeño, and melted cheddar, perfect for pairing with smoky summer grilled fare.

⏱️ 30 minuteSide Dishes ★ 4.9

Tomato Pie:Frequently Asked Questions

1.My tomato pie always turns out soggy—how do I prevent that common issue? ▾
Sogginess is the most common misstep with this savory pie! Start by slicing your heirloom tomatoes ¼-inch thick, toss them with kosher salt, and let them drain in a colander for 30 minutes. Pat every slice completely dry with paper towels, and blind bake your unbaked 9-inch pie crust for 10 minutes at 375°F before adding fillings to lock out excess moisture.
2.Do I have to use full-fat mayonnaise, or can I swap in low-fat mayo or a substitute? ▾
I strongly recommend sticking with full-fat mayonnaise for the authentic, rich, creamy texture this classic pie is known for. Low-fat mayo, light mayo, or substitutes like plain Greek yogurt have higher water content that can make your filling runny, mute the signature savory tang, and lead to a watery, less cohesive final slice.
3.What tomatoes work best if I don’t have heirloom varieties on hand? ▾
Ripe in-season beefsteak tomatoes are the closest swap for heirlooms, as they have that same deep, sweet-savory flavor and firm, meaty flesh that holds up well during baking. Skip mealy, out-of-season hothouse grocery store tomatoes if you can—they have very little flavor and excess watery pulp that causes sogginess even after salting and draining.
4.Can I use a pre-made store-bought pie crust, or do I need to make crust from scratch? ▾
A store-bought unbaked 9-inch pie crust works perfectly here for a quick, easy take on this classic, and I won’t tell a soul if you use it! Opt for a refrigerated all-butter crust for the flakiest, most buttery flavor, and be sure to crimp edges securely and blind bake it as directed to avoid a soggy bottom, just like you would with homemade crust.
5.Why does this recipe call for sharp cheddar instead of a milder cheese variety? ▾
Sharp cheddar has a bold, tangy, nutty flavor that cuts through the richness of the mayo and bright sweetness of ripe tomatoes to create that perfectly balanced Southern comfort food taste. Milder cheddar or softer cheeses like mozzarella get lost next to the other strong flavors, leading to a bland, one-note, overly creamy pie.
6.How long should I let the pie cool before slicing into it? ▾
I know it’s tempting to dig in right out of the oven, but you need to let your tomato pie rest for a full 20 to 25 minutes on a wire rack before slicing. This rest time lets the hot, creamy cheese and mayo filling set up fully, so slices hold their shape instead of oozing apart, and the flavors meld together beautifully as it cools slightly.
7.What fresh herbs work best in classic Southern tomato pie? ▾
This pie shines with bright, earthy fresh herbs that complement ripe tomatoes perfectly—my go-tos are chopped fresh basil, a little bit of fresh thyme, and a pinch of chopped fresh chives. Stir half the herbs into the cheese and mayo mixture, and sprinkle the rest over the top during the last 5 minutes of baking for a fresh pop of flavor that doesn’t cook off.
8.Can I make this pie ahead of time for a potluck or summer cookout? ▾
This pie is ideal for make-ahead meals and casual gatherings! You can assemble the entire uncooked pie, cover it tightly, and store it in the fridge for up to 24 hours before baking, or bake it fully, let it cool, and keep it covered in the fridge for up to 3 days. It tastes great slightly warm, at room temperature, or even chilled for easy serving.
9.Do I need to peel the tomatoes before adding them to the pie filling? ▾
Peeling your tomatoes is totally optional, and I usually skip it for quicker prep! If you dislike the texture of tomato skin, blanch slices in boiling water for 30 seconds, then shock them in ice water to slip skins off easily before salting and draining. Just note peeled tomatoes release more juice, so be extra thorough patting them dry before assembly.
10.What are the best side dishes to serve with classic Southern tomato pie? ▾
This rich, savory pie pairs perfectly with lighter, bright Southern sides to balance out its creamy texture. Try serving it with a simple tossed green salad with tangy vinaigrette, crispy fried okra, buttered corn on the cob, cold cucumber salad, or a side of tangy dill pickles to cut through the richness of the cheese and mayo filling for a well-rounded meal.
11.My crust edges always burn before the filling finishes baking—how do I fix that? ▾
Burnt crust edges are a super easy problem to solve! About halfway through the total bake time, wrap a thin strip of aluminum foil around the crimped outer edge of the pie crust, or use a reusable silicone pie crust shield. This blocks the outer edge from too much direct oven heat while the center cooks, so you get a perfectly golden, flaky crust with no bitter charred bits.

Comments (15)

2 days ago

OMG this tomato pie tastes exactly like my grandma used to make every Sunday after church! I brought it to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and every single person asked for the recipe. The buttery crust paired with the juicy ripe tomatoes and that cheesy mayo topping? *Chef’s kiss* I used homegrown tomatoes from my backyard garden and it made all the difference. SO good, will be making this on repeat all summer long!

yesterday

That makes my day to hear, Liz! There’s nothing quite like the flavor of homegrown tomatoes in this pie—so glad it was a hit at your potluck, thanks for leaving such a sweet review!

1 week ago

Made this for our weekly family dinner last night and my two picky toddlers ate two slices each! I was worried the onion would be too strong for them but I sautéed it a little extra long like the recipe tips suggested and it was perfect. Only note: I added a sprinkle of crispy bacon on top because everything’s better with bacon, right? Total game changer for weeknight meals when you have too many summer tomatoes lying around.

5 days ago

Oh the bacon addition sounds brilliant! I’m making this for our Fourth of July cookout next week and will definitely be stealing that hack, thanks for the idea!

3 days ago

I was able to swap the regular mayo for vegan mayo and used dairy-free cheddar to make this work for my dairy allergy, and it still turned out amazing! The fresh basil and tomato flavor really shines through, you don’t even miss the dairy. Great base recipe that’s super easy to tweak for dietary needs.

5 days ago

Wait, I followed the recipe exactly but my pie came out super watery? I used ripe beefsteak tomatoes like it said, but after baking there was a pool of liquid at the bottom of the crust that made it all soggy. Did I do something wrong? Flavor was great but the texture was off for me, so I’m giving it 3 stars for now until I can figure out how to fix the sogginess.

3 days ago

So sorry to hear your pie turned out soggy, Mia! The #1 trick to avoid watery tomato pie is to salt your sliced tomatoes and let them drain on paper towels for 30-45 minutes before assembling—this pulls out all the excess moisture. You can also sprinkle a thin layer of breadcrumbs or parmesan on the bottom of the crust before adding the tomatoes to catch any leftover liquid. Give that a try next time!

2 days ago

Second the salting trick! I let my tomatoes drain for an hour last time I made this and the crust was perfectly flaky, no sogginess at all. It’s an extra step but so worth it!

2 weeks ago

Y’all, I have made this three times in the last two weeks! First for my book club, then for my office lunch, then for my son’s baseball team cookout, and every single time people beg me for the recipe. The combination of ripe tomatoes, tangy mayo, sharp cheddar, and that hint of hot sauce? It’s the perfect summer side that feels special without being fussy. 10/10, no notes.

1 week ago

Wow, three times in two weeks is the ultimate compliment! So glad this has become your go-to dish for gatherings, Carol—thanks so much for sharing how much everyone loves it!

2 hours ago

Has anyone tried making this ahead of time for meal prep? I want to make it on Sunday to eat for lunches throughout the week, but I’m worried the crust will get mushy if it sits in the fridge for a few days. Would love to hear any tips!

30 minutes ago

I made this last Sunday and ate slices for lunch all week! I stored it in an airtight glass container and reheated slices in the toaster oven for 5 minutes to crisp the crust back up, and it held up perfectly. Way better than I expected!

5 minutes ago

Great question, Jess! Leo’s tip about reheating in the toaster oven is spot on. If you want to prep even further ahead, you can assemble the whole pie (unbaked) and freeze it for up to 3 months, then bake straight from frozen adding 15-20 minutes to the cook time. Works like a charm!

30 minutes ago

I added a extra dash of cayenne and a handful of pickled jalapeños to the cheese layer and it gave this pie the perfect little kick! If you like a bit of heat with your savory pies, do not sleep on that addition. The creamy cheese balances the spice so well, it’s become my go-to version now.

1 week ago

I’ve been making Southern tomato pie for over 40 years, and this recipe is hands down the best version I’ve ever tried. The ratio of cheese to mayo is perfect—not too gloopy, not too dry—and the addition of fresh basil instead of dried makes such a huge difference. My husband said it’s even better than the one I’ve been making for decades, ha! Guess it’s never too late to learn a new recipe trick.

5 days ago

Pat, that is the highest possible praise coming from someone who’s been making this pie for 40 years! So glad the fresh basil swap worked for you, and that your husband approves. Thanks so much for the kind words!

yesterday

I made this with a store-bought gluten-free pie crust to accommodate my celiac disease, and it turned out absolutely delicious! I was worried the crust would be crumbly or weird but it held up perfectly, even with all the tomato filling. This is going to be a staple at our summer cookouts from now on, since so many of our friends are gluten free too.

2 hours ago

So glad the gluten-free crust worked! I’ve been hesitant to try that swap because I’ve had bad GF crust experiences in the past, but I’ll definitely give it a go now. What brand of crust did you use, if you don’t mind me asking?

30 minutes ago

I used the Wholly Gluten Free frozen pie crust, it’s flaky and buttery just like regular crust! Just make sure to blind bake it for 10 minutes before adding the filling so it doesn’t get soggy.

5 minutes ago

I’m a college student still learning to cook, and I was able to pull this off even with my tiny dorm oven! I used pre-made crust to save time and it still tasted so fancy, my roommates thought I ordered it from a fancy Southern restaurant down the street. Way easier than I expected for a medium difficulty recipe, 10/10.

3 days ago

I served this at my weekend brunch last weekend alongside cheesy grits and fried green tomatoes, and it was the star of the whole spread! Even my friend who swears he hates tomatoes went back for a second slice. The only thing I did differently was add a sprinkle of smoked paprika on top for a little smoky flavor, which paired so nicely with the cheesy topping.

2 days ago

That brunch spread sounds like a dream! I’m hosting a brunch for my mom’s birthday next month and I was looking for a good savory dish, this is going on the menu for sure. Thanks for the paprika tip!

2 weeks ago

We grow 12 different varieties of heirloom tomatoes on our small farm, and this is the absolute best recipe to use up a big bumper crop. I love that it lets the tomato flavor be the star instead of covering it up with too many extra ingredients. I’ve already passed this recipe along to all our CSA members this year!

30 minutes ago

Quick question—would this work with pepper jack cheese instead of sharp cheddar? I have a huge block of pepper jack in my fridge that I need to use up, and I don’t want to run to the store just for cheddar if I don’t have to. Any thoughts?

5 minutes ago

Absolutely, Max! Pepper jack works beautifully in this recipe—it adds a nice subtle heat that pairs perfectly with the sweet tomatoes and creamy mayo. Just keep an eye on it while baking since pepper jack can melt a little faster than sharp cheddar!

just now

I made this with pepper jack last week and it was insane! Added a little extra garlic powder too, and my whole family raved about it. Highly recommend giving it a shot!

2 days ago

Packed this for our family hike and picnic in the mountains last weekend, and it was even better cold than it was fresh out of the oven! The flavors meld together so nicely after it sits in the fridge for a few hours, it’s the perfect portable picnic food. No messy drips, easy to slice, and everyone loved it.

yesterday

I moved from Boston to Georgia last year and have been trying to learn all the classic Southern dishes, and this tomato pie was my first big win! I was intimidated at first because I’d never had anything like it before, but the instructions were so clear and easy to follow. My neighbor who’s lived here her whole life said it tasted like the real deal, so I’m calling that a massive win. Can’t wait to make it for my family when they come visit next month!

2 hours ago

Welcome to the South, Sam! That’s so awesome to hear your tomato pie got a local seal of approval—nothing beats that. I hope your family loves it when they come to visit, thanks for giving the recipe a try!