Tongue Sandwich
intro
Tender, slow-simmered beef tongue piled high on seeded rye with sharp mustard, crisp dill pickles, and sweet onion—rich, melt-in-your-mouth, the iconic hearty deli sandwich.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Beef Tongue
Rinse the raw beef tongue under cold running water, pat dry lightly with a corner of the fixed linen towel, and place it in the base of the 6-liter stainless steel stock pot. Use the paring knife to trim away any loose connective tissue or stray bone fragments from the surface. The tongue should sit flat in the base of the pot without propping.
Add Simmering Aromatics
Quarter both yellow onions (no peeling required, as papery skins add deep golden color to the broth), crush the 3 garlic cloves lightly with the flat of the chef knife, and add both to the pot with the tongue. Add the 2 bay leaves, 1 tablespoon whole black peppercorns, and 1 tablespoon kosher salt, then pour cold water over all contents until the tongue is fully submerged by 2cm of water.
Slow Simmer Tongue
Place the lid securely on the stock pot, bring water to a rolling boil over medium-high heat, then reduce heat to low to maintain a gentle, steady simmer (small bubbles breaking the surface every 2-3 seconds, no violent rolling). Cook for 2 hours 30 minutes, using the slotted spoon to skim any grey foamy residue from the broth surface every 30 minutes. The tongue is fully tender when a paring knife slides into the thickest section with no resistance, as easily as inserting into soft room-temperature butter.
Peel Cooked Tongue
Use the stainless steel tongs to lift the fully cooked tongue from the hot broth and transfer it to the maple cutting board. Let it rest for 10 minutes until cool enough to handle (warm, not burning to touch), then use the paring knife to loosen the thick, rough greyish outer skin from the base of the tongue. Peel the skin away in large strips, discarding all tough outer membrane until only smooth, pale pink tender meat remains. Do not let the tongue cool fully, as the skin will stick tightly.
Slice Tongue Thinly
Once fully peeled, use the chef knife to slice the tongue against the grain into uniform 3mm thick slices. Discard any tough, fatty gristle from the root end of the tongue. Pile sliced meat loosely on the cutting board as you work; properly cooked slices will bend easily when lifted without breaking.
Prep Sandwich Toppings
Thinly slice the small red onion into half-moons with the chef knife, and slice the whole dill pickles lengthwise into 5mm thick spears. Place sliced onion and pickles in the medium stainless steel mixing bowl, tossing lightly with a few torn sprigs of fresh dill. Lay all 8 slices of seeded rye bread in two neat rows on the clean section of the cutting board.
Assemble the Sandwiches
Use the butter knife to spread 1 tablespoon of spicy yellow mustard evenly across one side of every rye bread slice. Pile 120g (approximately 4-5 slices) of cooked tongue evenly across 4 of the bread slices, then top each with 3-4 thin red onion slices and 2 pickle spears. Place the remaining 4 bread slices mustard-side down on top of the fillings, pressing gently to adhere the layers.
Cut and Plate Sandwiches
Use the serrated bread knife to cut each assembled sandwich diagonally into two equal triangular halves. Arrange two halves per serving on the matte cream ceramic dinner plates, leaning the halves slightly against each other to display the layered filling. Tuck a small sprig of fresh dill next to each sandwich for a bright garnish.
Tips
2.Peel the tongue while it is still warm (10 minutes out of the broth): The thick outer membrane pulls away in large, easy strips when the meat is warm; if allowed to cool completely, the membrane will adhere tightly to the meat and require tedious, time-consuming scraping to remove.
3.Strain and reserve the tongue cooking broth: The rich, deeply savory broth makes an excellent base for beef barley soup, onion gravy, or cooking rice and grains. Store strained broth in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 5 days, or freeze for up to 3 months to cut down on food waste.

OMG, I’ve been chasing that perfect old-school deli tongue sandwich since my favorite spot in Brooklyn closed last year, and this recipe is IT. The slow simmer makes the tongue so tender it practically melts, and the tip about slicing it paper-thin against the grain? Game changer. Piled it high on rye with spicy brown mustard and a dill pickle, just like they used to make it. My roommate thought I was nuts for cooking tongue at first, then he stole half the sandwich. 10/10
Was skeptical about making deli meat at home but this turned out way better than I expected! I added a couple bay leaves and a splash of apple cider vinegar to the simmer liquid like my grandpa used to, and it gave the meat such a nice depth. Only knock is it took a little longer than 2.5 hours for mine to get fork-tender, probably because my tongue was a little on the larger side. Served it on sourdough with coleslaw for Sunday dinner and the whole family cleaned their plates.
SO good, perfect for meal prep! I made a big batch Sunday night, sliced it all up, and have been eating sandwiches all week for work lunches. Way cheaper than buying sliced tongue from the deli counter, and it tastes way fresher too. Threw a little horseradish sauce on mine today and *chef’s kiss*. Will absolutely be making this on repeat.
I’ve been making tongue sandwiches for over 50 years, and this recipe is spot-on. I brought a platter of these to our church potluck last Sunday and even the kids who turned their noses up at the idea came back for seconds. The tip to let it chill in the fridge for an hour before slicing? Genius, makes getting those thin, even slices so much easier. My husband said it’s better than the deli we used to go to when we were first married!
Flavor was great, but peeling the tongue was way more of a hassle than I expected lol. I think I waited too long to take the skin off after simmering, so it kept sticking and took forever. Still tasty once I got it all prepped, but next time I’m going to set a timer to peel it right after it cools down enough to handle. Also, I used white bread instead of rye because that’s what I had in the house, it worked fine!
Made this after a long backpacking trip as a little treat for myself, and wow. Worth every minute of cook time. I picked up a fresh tongue from the local rancher out here, simmered it with onion, garlic, and peppercorns like the recipe said, and piled it high on toasted rye with Swiss, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing for a little Reuben twist. Absolute perfection. Even my dog was begging for bites while I was slicing it.
First time ever cooking beef tongue, and I was so nervous I’d mess it up! The recipe instructions were super clear, though, and it turned out really well. My kids loved it — they kept calling it ‘mystery fancy deli meat’ and asked for seconds. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish there was a note about what size tongue to buy, because I grabbed a huge one and had to adjust the cook time a bunch. Will definitely make again!
Hosted a little deli-themed game night last weekend and made these sandwiches as the main event. Everyone was blown away! I set out a little spread with mustards, pickles, sliced onion, and Swiss cheese so people could build their own, and not a single slice of tongue was left. Multiple people asked for the recipe, which I obviously sent over. 10/10, will be my go-to for casual get-togethers from now on.
Saw this recipe on TikTok and decided to try it even though I’m a super broke college student with basically no cooking skills. Spotted the Reuben twist in the comments while I was waiting for the tongue to simmer, so I toasted mine up with Swiss and sauerkraut — so worth it! Got a tongue for super cheap at the international market near campus, simmered it in a big pot with whatever veggies I had lying around, and made sandwiches for me and my roommates. We all agreed it’s better than the sandwich shop down the street. Game changer for cheap, tasty meals.
Grew up eating tongue sandwiches at my grandpa’s deli in LA, so I’m super picky about how they’re made. This recipe is exactly how he used to make it — slow simmered with simple aromatics, sliced thin, piled high on seeded rye with yellow mustard and a pickle. Took my first bite and immediately teared up a little, it tasted just like childhood. Can’t thank you enough for posting this.