Turkey Manhattan Sandwich
intro
A nostalgic Midwestern diner classic, this cozy open-faced hot sandwich piles tender roast turkey and velvety gravy over toast, perfect for repurposing Thanksgiving leftovers.
Ingredients
Steps
Slice Turkey Thinly
Place the leftover roast turkey breast on the large maple cutting board. Using the 8-inch walnut-handled chef knife, slice the turkey against the grain into uniform 5mm (1/4-inch) thick slices, discarding any tough skin or connective tissue. Loosely cover sliced turkey to keep warm while you prep remaining components. Visual cue: Slices should be tender enough to pull apart gently with two fingers, with no ragged, stringy edges.
Toast Sourdough Slices
Lay the sourdough slices on the same cutting board. Use the 7-inch serrated bread knife to trim any overly hard, thick crust edges if desired, then toast slices in a toaster or on a dry pan over medium heat for 2 minutes per side until pale golden brown, with crisp edges and a soft chewy center. Do not over-toast, as overly dark bread will turn brittle and crumbly under gravy. Set toasted slices aside.
Make Gravy Roux Base
Place the 2-quart stainless steel saucepan on the rear of the counter over medium-low heat. Add 3 tablespoons of unsalted butter, and once fully melted and foaming subsides (about 1 minute), whisk in 3 tablespoons of all-purpose flour using the silicone whisk. Cook the roux, whisking constantly, for 2-3 minutes until it turns a pale golden, sandy color and smells faintly nutty. Do not let the roux darken to deep brown, as this will create a heavy, overly dark gravy.
Simmer Smooth Gravy
Slowly pour 2 cups of room-temperature turkey stock into the roux, whisking constantly to eliminate lumps. Increase heat to medium, bring gravy to a gentle simmer, then reduce heat to low and cook for 4-5 minutes, whisking occasionally, until gravy thickens enough to coat the back of a spoon (a clear line will remain when you run your finger across the coated spoon surface). Season with 1 teaspoon flaky sea salt, 1/2 teaspoon black pepper, and 1 tablespoon chopped parsley, then hold on the lowest heat setting to keep warm. Thin with 1-2 tablespoons extra stock if too thick, or simmer 1-2 minutes longer if too thin.
Warm Turkey and Potatoes
Nestle the sliced turkey into the warm gravy, using the slotted spatula to turn slices gently so they are fully coated and heated through, about 2 minutes. Do not boil the gravy once turkey is added, as high heat will make the turkey tough and stringy. While the turkey warms, reheat the 2 cups of mashed potatoes until steaming hot, about 2 minutes, stirring once halfway through for even heating. Visual cue: Gravy will cling to every turkey surface, and potatoes will be smooth and spreadable with no cold lumps.
Assemble Sandwich Base
Place one slice of toasted sourdough in the center of each ivory ceramic dinner plate. Divide warm mashed potatoes evenly between plates, scooping a 1/2 cup portion beside each bread slice (traditional Turkey Manhattan serves potatoes on the plate next to the sandwich, not on the bread). Use the slotted spatula to lift 1 cup of warm, gravy-coated turkey slices out of the pan, letting excess gravy drain back into the pan, then pile the turkey evenly on top of each toast slice.
Ladle Gravy and Garnish
Use the stainless steel ladle to pour 1/4 cup of warm remaining gravy evenly over each pile of turkey, letting it drip down over the bread and pool slightly on the plate around the mashed potatoes. Top each sandwich with a small parsley sprig, add a 1-tablespoon dollop of cranberry sauce to the edge of each plate next to the potatoes, and finish with a light twist of fresh black pepper. Serve immediately while hot, with extra gravy in the glass gravy boat on the side.
Tips
2.Toast sourdough only to a pale golden crisp, not dark brown. Light toast provides enough structure to hold gravy for 10-15 minutes without turning soggy; over-toasted bread becomes hard and brittle under moist gravy, leading to a crumbly, messy eating experience.
3.Warm turkey slices directly in the finished gravy instead of microwaving them separately. Submerging turkey in low-simmering gravy heats the meat gently without drying it out, and lets the slices absorb savory gravy flavor for that classic diner taste, rather than dry, plain reheated turkey.

OMG this was SO good! I threw this together last night after soccer practice with the kids when I had zero meal prep done and it only took like 12 minutes total? Total game changer. My picky 8 year old asked for a second serving, which never happens. I used leftover roasted turkey from Sunday dinner instead of deli slices and it hit even better. 10/10 will be adding this to our regular weeknight rotation!
Super easy recipe, perfect for a quick lunch when I’m working from home. I did add a little extra gravy and a sprinkle of smoked paprika on top for a tiny kick, paired it with a side of dill pickles and it was chef’s kiss. Only knock is I wish I’d made two, I was still hungry after one lol.
Brought a platter of these cut up into mini sliders for our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and they were gone in 10 minutes flat! Multiple neighbors came up to ask for the recipe, I can’t believe how simple and crowd-pleasing these are. The open-faced, gravy-topped style feels so much fancier than a regular cold turkey sandwich too, perfect for when you want something low-effort that impresses.